Joel L Cohen1, Alastair Carruthers, Derek H Jones, Vic A Narurkar, Martin Wong, Lisa N Cheskin, J Richard Trout, David J Howell. 1. *AboutSkin Dermatology and DermSurgery, Englewood, Colorado, and Department of Dermatology, University of Colorado, Aurora, Colorado; †Department of Dermatology and Skin Science, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada; ‡Skin Care and Laser Physicians of Beverly Hills, Los Angeles, California; §Bay Area Laser Institute, San Francisco, California; ‖Merz North America, Raleigh, North Carolina; ¶Yardley, Pennsylvania; #San Francisco, California.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The Merz Hand Grading Scale (MHGS) is a 5-point scale used to grade appearance of the dorsum of the hand. The MHGS has been previously validated for assessment of photographed hands but not for live assessment. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this randomized, blinded study was to validate the MHGS for live assessment of the hands in the clinical setting. METHODS: Three physician raters completed a scale qualification program that included MHGS training, ratings of standardized hand photographs, and statistical analysis for reliability. Eighty-four subjects (28 males, 30% Fitzpatrick skin Types IV-VI, mean age of 42 years), randomized to 2 live assessment sessions for independent and blinded observation of dorsa of their right hands, completed the study. RESULTS:Overall MHGS intrarater weighted Kappa value was 0.74 (0.68-0.79 [CI 95%]). First- and second-time hand-rating agreement scores ranged from 64% to 75%. Interrater weighed Kappa values ranged from 0.59 to 0.71, representing between-rater paired results of each combination of raters. CONCLUSION: High-weighted Kappa values and agreements demonstrate that consistency at different time points can be achieved individually and by different raters for live assessments. The MHGS is a suitable instrument for live assessment in the clinical setting.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: The Merz Hand Grading Scale (MHGS) is a 5-point scale used to grade appearance of the dorsum of the hand. The MHGS has been previously validated for assessment of photographed hands but not for live assessment. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this randomized, blinded study was to validate the MHGS for live assessment of the hands in the clinical setting. METHODS: Three physician raters completed a scale qualification program that included MHGS training, ratings of standardized hand photographs, and statistical analysis for reliability. Eighty-four subjects (28 males, 30% Fitzpatrick skin Types IV-VI, mean age of 42 years), randomized to 2 live assessment sessions for independent and blinded observation of dorsa of their right hands, completed the study. RESULTS: Overall MHGS intrarater weighted Kappa value was 0.74 (0.68-0.79 [CI 95%]). First- and second-time hand-rating agreement scores ranged from 64% to 75%. Interrater weighed Kappa values ranged from 0.59 to 0.71, representing between-rater paired results of each combination of raters. CONCLUSION: High-weighted Kappa values and agreements demonstrate that consistency at different time points can be achieved individually and by different raters for live assessments. The MHGS is a suitable instrument for live assessment in the clinical setting.
Authors: Amir Moradi; Shawn Allen; David Bank; Ellen Marmur; Steven Fagien; Dee Anna Glaser; Courtney Maguire; Joel L Cohen Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Date: 2019-10 Impact factor: 4.730
Authors: Christine E Wamsley; Nicole Vingan; Jennifer Barillas; Abby Culver; David M Turer; Jeffrey M Kenkel Journal: Aesthet Surg J Open Forum Date: 2022-02-17
Authors: Nicolas Vermeersch; Maxime De Fré; Veronique Verhoeven; Judith E Hunter; Thierry Tondu; Filip E F Thiessen Journal: JPRAS Open Date: 2022-03-11
Authors: Derek Jones; Lisa Donofrio; Bhushan Hardas; Diane K Murphy; Jean Carruthers; Alastair Carruthers; Jonathan M Sykes; Lela Creutz; Ann Marx; Sara Dill Journal: Dermatol Surg Date: 2016-10 Impact factor: 3.398