Secondary failure to oral hypoglycaemic agents in non-obese patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes is related to reduced insulin release.

The frequency of secondary failure to oral hypoglycaemic agents (OHA) in patients with non-insulin dependent diabetes (NIDDM) is still unknown, despite more than 30 years of use of OHA. The term secondary failure should be limited to patients who, despite maximal dosages of OHA and despite full compliance with diet and therapy, are no longer controlled and require insulin to obtain an acceptable glucose metabolism. We evaluated 248 out-patients, either on OHA, or on insulin because of poor metabolic control with OHA, in order to assess duration of treatment with OHA since diagnosis, by means of actuarial curves (Mantel-Cox test). Patients with low relative body weight (RBW less than or equal to 100) experienced secondary failure earlier and more often than obese patients (RBW greater than 120) or overweight (RBW 101-120) patients. In 66 of the above out-patients, 33 OHA-treated and 33 insulin-treated, matched for age at onset and duration of disease, islet-cell-antibodies (ICA) and C-peptide release at fasting, 6 min after i.v. glucagon and post prandially were evaluated. Only among lean and overweight patients, was C-peptide release significantly lower in insulin-treated than in OHA-treated patients; differences disappeared in obese patients. ICA were found in only 7 patients (10.6%). HLA phenotype was different from that of healthy blood donors for the loci HLA B5, B13, CW4, with no differences between OHA-treated and insulin-treated patients. These data indicate that secondary failure is more frequent in lean patients with NIDDM, and is related to reduced insulin release.