BACKGROUND: Little is known about the advice fourth-year medical students receive from their advisors as they prepare to apply for residency training. OBJECTIVE: We collected information on recommendations given to medical students preparing to apply to internal medicine residencies regarding fourth-year schedules and application strategies. METHODS: Clerkship Directors in Internal Medicine conducted its annual member survey in June 2013. We analyzed responses on student advising using descriptive and comparative statistics, and free-text responses using content analysis. RESULTS: Of 124 members, 94 (76%) responded, and 83 (88%) advised fourth-year medical students. Nearly half (45%) advised an average of more than 20 students a year. Advisors encouraged students to take a medicine subinternship (Likert scale mean 4.84 [1, strongly discourage, to 5, strongly encourage], SD = 0.61); a critical care rotation (4.38, SD = 0.79); and a medicine specialty clinical rotation (4.01, SD = 0.80). Advisors reported they thought fourth-year students should spend a mean of 6.5 months doing clinical rotations (range 1-10, SD = 1.91). They recommended highest academic quartile students apply to a median of 10 programs (range 1-30) and lowest quartile students apply to 15 programs (range 3-100). Top recommendations involved maximizing student competitiveness, valuing program fit over reputation, and recognizing key decision points in the application process. CONCLUSIONS: Undergraduate medical advisors recommended specific strategies to enhance students' competitiveness in the Match and to prepare them for residency. The results can inform program directors and encourage dialogue between undergraduate medical education and graduate medical education on how to best utilize the fourth year.
BACKGROUND: Little is known about the advice fourth-year medical students receive from their advisors as they prepare to apply for residency training. OBJECTIVE: We collected information on recommendations given to medical students preparing to apply to internal medicine residencies regarding fourth-year schedules and application strategies. METHODS: Clerkship Directors in Internal Medicine conducted its annual member survey in June 2013. We analyzed responses on student advising using descriptive and comparative statistics, and free-text responses using content analysis. RESULTS: Of 124 members, 94 (76%) responded, and 83 (88%) advised fourth-year medical students. Nearly half (45%) advised an average of more than 20 students a year. Advisors encouraged students to take a medicine subinternship (Likert scale mean 4.84 [1, strongly discourage, to 5, strongly encourage], SD = 0.61); a critical care rotation (4.38, SD = 0.79); and a medicine specialty clinical rotation (4.01, SD = 0.80). Advisors reported they thought fourth-year students should spend a mean of 6.5 months doing clinical rotations (range 1-10, SD = 1.91). They recommended highest academic quartile students apply to a median of 10 programs (range 1-30) and lowest quartile students apply to 15 programs (range 3-100). Top recommendations involved maximizing student competitiveness, valuing program fit over reputation, and recognizing key decision points in the application process. CONCLUSIONS: Undergraduate medical advisors recommended specific strategies to enhance students' competitiveness in the Match and to prepare them for residency. The results can inform program directors and encourage dialogue between undergraduate medical education and graduate medical education on how to best utilize the fourth year.
Authors: Pamela Lyss-Lerman; Arianne Teherani; Eva Aagaard; Helen Loeser; Molly Cooke; G Michael Harper Journal: Acad Med Date: 2009-07 Impact factor: 6.893
Authors: Shalini T Reddy; Jason Chao; Jonathan L Carter; Robert Drucker; Nadine T Katz; Robert Nesbit; Brenda Roman; Joshua Wallenstein; Gary L Beck Journal: Teach Learn Med Date: 2014 Impact factor: 2.414
Authors: D Michael Elnicki; Meenakshy K Aiyer; Maria L Cannarozzi; Alexander Carbo; Paul R Chelminski; Shobhina G Chheda; Saumil M Chudgar; Heather E Harrell; L Chad Hood; Michelle Horn; Karnjit Johl; Gregory C Kane; Diana B McNeill; Marty D Muntz; Anne G Pereira; Emily Stewart; Heather Tarantino; T Robert Vu Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2017-06-20 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: T Robert Vu; Allison H Ferris; Michelle L Sweet; Steven V Angus; Nadia J Ismail; Emily Stewart; Jonathan S Appelbaum; Brian Kwan Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2019-07 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: John C Ray; Laura R Hopson; William Peterson; Sally A Santen; Sorabh Khandelwal; Fiona E Gallahue; Melissa White; John C Burkhardt Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-05-09 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Celeste S Royce; Elise N Everett; LaTasha B Craig; Angela Fleming; David A Forstein; Scott C Graziano; B Star Hampton; Laura Hopkins; Margaret L McKenzie; Helen K Morgan; Shireen Madani Sims; Christopher Morosky Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2020-10-07 Impact factor: 8.661