Literature DB >> 26401954

Local and International Implications of Schistosomiasis Acquired in Corsica, France.

Philippe Gautret, Frank P Mockenhaupt, Frank von Sonnenburg, Camilla Rothe, Michael Libman, Kristina Van De Winkel, Emmanuel Bottieau, Martin P Grobusch, Davidson H Hamer, Douglas H Esposito, Philippe Parola, Patricia Schlagenhauf.   

Abstract

We report 11 cases of schistosomiasis in international travelers who had bathed in rivers in Corsica, France, during 2012-2014. The infections were diagnosed in 2014 and reported to the GeoSentinel Surveillance Network and European Travel Medicine Network. Travelers can be sentinels for emerging infections; thus, this situation warrants a concerted human and veterinary epidemiologic response.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Bulinus truncatus snail; Corsica; France; One Health; Schistosoma haematobium; epidemiology; freshwater rivers; host; intermediate host; outbreak; parasites; schistosomiasis; snail; surveillance; travelers; trematode; urinary schistosomiasis

Mesh:

Year:  2015        PMID: 26401954      PMCID: PMC4593456          DOI: 10.3201/eid2110.150881

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis        ISSN: 1080-6040            Impact factor:   6.883


In 2014, reports were received of several cases of Schistosoma haematobium trematode infection acquired in Corsica, a Mediterranean French island. The first patient was a child from Germany who had traveled to southern Corsica in August 2013 and had no other known exposures. Medical examination showed that the child had gross hematuria; he received a diagnosis of urinary schistosomiasis (). Serologic test results were positive for 4 of 5 asymptomatic family members who had also traveled to Corsica and bathed in the Cavu River, near Porto-Vecchio. Eleven additional cases of urinary schistosomiasis were reported among mainland French tourists who bathed in the Cavu River during August 2011–August 2013 (–). All cases were identified during the chronic phase of the disease. Following a national screening campaign in France, ≈100 additional schistosomiasis cases were described over 2 years among Corsica residents and visitors from other parts of France. In addition, a competent intermediate host snail, Bulinus truncatus, was identified in rivers in Corsica (Technical Appendix Table 1). To elucidate the epidemiologic characteristics of schistosomiasis in Corsica, we determined the number of and clinical findings for urinary schistosomiasis cases among international travelers to Corsica.

The Patients

To find cases, we searched the GeoSentinel Surveillance Network database () for urinary schistosomiasis diagnoses for international travelers with freshwater (river) exposure in Corsica during 1996 through March 2015. We also informally extended the search to members of the European Travel Medicine Network (EuroTravNet, http://www.istm.org/eurotravnet). GeoSentinel’s data-collection protocol is for public health surveillance, so human subjects’ review board clearance was not needed. According to local institutional review boards at sites in Berlin and Munich, Germany, our use of supplemental data not available in the GeoSentinel database conforms to the human subject protection guidelines at these sites. Individual patient consent was obtained at sites in Hamburg, Germany; Ghent, Belgium; and Montreal, Quebec, Canada. We identified 11 records with diagnoses of schistosomiasis acquired in Corsica during 1996–March 2015 (Table). Patients resided in Germany, Belgium, or Canada and had traveled to Corsica during 2012–2014; some had also traveled to Corsica before 2012. No patients reported other exposure to freshwater in any other country where schistosomiasis is known to be endemic. All 11 patients reported bathing in rivers in Corsica: 7 persons (6 from Germany, 1 from Canada) bathed in the Cavu River; a familial cluster of 3 persons from Berlin bathed in the Gaglioli, Solenzara, and Restonica Rivers; and a Belgian tourist bathed in the Osu River.
Table

Characteristics for 11 international travelers with urinary schistosomiasis diagnosed in 2014 and acquired in Corsica, France*

Patient age, y/sexReporting siteTravel to Corsica
First clinic visit, 2014Eosinophils, cells/μLSerologic test result
Eggs in urine Infection status†
2014Before 2014First-line (antibody titer, IU)Second-line
7/MBerlin, GermanyNone2013Jun 51,415Pos (26.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegProbable
52/MBerlinNone2012Jul 18192Borderline (11.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegSuspected
29/FGhent, BelgiumNone2013Aug 29560Pos (1.1)¶IHA Neg#NegProbable
17/FHamburg, GermanyJuly–AugustNoneSep 845Weak Pos**IIFT NegNTProbable
11/MMunich, GermanyNone2013Sep 22770Pos††IIFT PosPosConfirmed
35/F‡‡BerlinJuly2011–2013Sep 23202Pos (17.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegProbable
35/M‡‡BerlinJuly-August2012–2013Oct 7359Pos (29.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegProbable
11/M‡‡BerlinJuly–August2012–2013Oct 7152Borderline (9.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegSuspected
41/FMunichMay–June2007, 2009–2011Oct 10344Pos††IIFT PosNegConfirmed
45/FMontreal, Quebec, CanadaJulyNoneDec 50Pos (0.37)§§NDNegSuspected
6/FBerlinNone2011–2012Dec 22950Pos (32.0)‡ELISA and IHA Neg§NegProbable

*All patients were detected through a search of the GeoSentinel Surveillance Network (). The patient from Montreal had microscopic hematuria; none of the other patients showed signs or symptoms of disease, and their infections were found during screening. IHA, indirect hemagglutination assay; IIFT, indirect immunofluorescence test; Neg, negative; ND, not done; NT, not tested; Pos, positive.
†Suspected, borderline result from 1 serologic testing method; probable, positive result from 1 serologic testing method; confirmed, positive result from 2 serologic testing methods and/or parasite eggs in urine.
‡As determined by using a Schistosoma mansoni IgG ELISA (DRG Diagnostics, Marburg, Germany); negative, <9; borderline, 9–11; positive, >11.
§As determined by using an S. mansoni adult or egg IgG ELISA; IHA, Cellognost Schistosomiasis H (Siemens, Erlangen, Germany).
¶As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni IgG ELISA using egg antigen extract mixed with S. mansoni adult worm extract imported from Egypt (positive at an optical density >1).
#As determined by using an in-house IHA with an S. mansoni adult worm extract (Fumouze SA, Levallois-Perret, France), with titration and cut-off set at 1/80 (positive at >1/160).
**As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni cercariae IgG ELISA.
††As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni IgG ELISA.
‡‡Familial cluster.
§§As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni–S. haematobium combined IgG ELISA (negative, <0.3; borderline, 0.3–0.35; positive, >0.35).

*All patients were detected through a search of the GeoSentinel Surveillance Network (). The patient from Montreal had microscopic hematuria; none of the other patients showed signs or symptoms of disease, and their infections were found during screening. IHA, indirect hemagglutination assay; IIFT, indirect immunofluorescence test; Neg, negative; ND, not done; NT, not tested; Pos, positive.
†Suspected, borderline result from 1 serologic testing method; probable, positive result from 1 serologic testing method; confirmed, positive result from 2 serologic testing methods and/or parasite eggs in urine.
‡As determined by using a Schistosoma mansoni IgG ELISA (DRG Diagnostics, Marburg, Germany); negative, <9; borderline, 9–11; positive, >11.
§As determined by using an S. mansoni adult or egg IgG ELISA; IHA, Cellognost Schistosomiasis H (Siemens, Erlangen, Germany).
¶As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni IgG ELISA using egg antigen extract mixed with S. mansoni adult worm extract imported from Egypt (positive at an optical density >1).
#As determined by using an in-house IHA with an S. mansoni adult worm extract (Fumouze SA, Levallois-Perret, France), with titration and cut-off set at 1/80 (positive at >1/160).
**As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni cercariae IgG ELISA.
††As determined by using an in-house S. mansoni IgG ELISA.
‡‡Familial cluster.
§§As determined by using an in-house S. mansoniS. haematobium combined IgG ELISA (negative, <0.3; borderline, 0.3–0.35; positive, >0.35). All infections were in asymptomatic persons who sought screening in 2014 after seeing/hearing public health warnings regarding the risk for acquiring schistosomiasis after freshwater exposure in Corsica. Four cases were in children <15 years of age; 1 was in a 17-year-old girl. Two recent infections were acquired after exposure in July or August 2014. Eosinophilia was recorded for 4 patients (Table). Most diagnoses relied on serologic testing, including the diagnoses for 2 patients who were suspected to have schistosomiasis because of repeated borderline seropositive test results or borderline results plus being part of a familial cluster. Parasite eggs were identified in only 1 patient.

Conclusions

We document 11 cases of schistosomiasis in international travelers who had freshwater river exposure in Corsica during 2012–2014. Of note, 4 of the persons did not report bathing in the Cavu River (the source of all cases of S. haematobium trematode infection among French patients so far), but they did bathe in other Corsica rivers. Corsica has a population of 316,000 persons, but in 2012, the island was visited by 2.7 million tourists, primarily from mainland France, followed by Italy, Belgium, Germany, and Switzerland (Technical Appendix Table 2). Local data from the Porto-Vecchio community (≈10,000 inhabitants) confirm the predominance of French nationals among the ≈100,000 tourists who visited the area in 2011; much smaller numbers of tourists visited from other parts of Europe and North America (Technical Appendix Table 2). Because tourists outnumber residents, it is not surprising that most persons who acquired urinary schistosomiasis in Corsica were tourists (Technical Appendix Figure). French travelers are not represented in GeoSentinel data because travel across an international border is required for inclusion in the database (). The predominance of German travelers in our cohort may reflect the high proportion of Germans among international travelers to Corsica and the strong representation of German travelers in the GeoSentinel database. Our report has limitations. All patients identified through the Surveillance Network were asymptomatic at the time of diagnosis. Only 1 traveler had parasitologic proof of infection. In these patients, a diagnosis of schistosomiasis was made on the basis of only 1 positive serologic test result; in some cases, the results were borderline or weakly positive. Serum samples were examined by using in-house or commercial assays and were not tested side by side in 1 reference laboratory or confirmed by Western blot. We cannot completely exclude that the case definition in our study generated false-positive cases; diagnosis of schistosomiasis in a setting where the disease is not endemic is extremely challenging (). Symptoms of acute schistosomiasis (corresponding to larval migration) may be absent (as in our cases) or nonspecific, but chronic infection (presence of adult worms) due to S. haematobium is symptomatic in ≈66% of cases with detectable egg excretion (often of light intensity however) (). In acute and chronic infections in travelers, sensitivity of egg detection is notoriously poor, and serologic test performance is far from optimal. Schistosomiasis has never been established in Europe. However, sporadic autochthonous cases of human urinary schistosomiasis were reported in Greece, Cyprus, Spain, and Portugal in the 1920s (); the last cases were reported in Portugal in 1965 (). Autochthonous transmission of urinary schistosomiasis to humans has only recently been described in France (). The intermediate host snail, B. truncatus, is widely distributed in Africa, the Middle East, and the Mediterranean Basin as far north as Portugal, Spain, Sardinia, and Corsica (). Because the intermediate host is present and climatic conditions are suitable, the risk for autochthonous transmission of S. haematobium in the region of Porto-Vecchio was predicted as early as 1928 (). Animal schistosomiasis caused by S. bovis was described in cattle in Corsica in 1929; B. truncatus snails were identified as the intermediate host. The last cases of animal schistosomiasis in Corsica were documented in 1966 (). The discovery of human cases of schistosomiasis proves that a humanBulinus parasitic cycle exists in Corsica and suggests that a cattleBulinus cycle may also exist (). Furthermore, hybridization between schistosome species can occur, specifically hybridization of S. bovis and S. haematobium, as described in Senegal and elsewhere (). Hybridization results in heterosis, thereby producing offspring that have higher fecundity, faster maturation, and a wider intermediate host spectrum. The situation in Corsica is of significance for One Health medicine and disease epidemiology and, thus, requires a concerted public health and veterinary epidemiologic response. Because a competent intermediate host is present and schistosomes can be imported by migrants and travelers returning (primarily) from sub-Saharan Africa, autochthonous foci of schistosomiasis could become established throughout susceptible Mediterranean areas in southern Europe. The latest data from EuroTravNet indicate that among the >32,000 travelers who returned home ill during 2008–2012, schistosomiasis ranked twelth among all diagnoses (), and travelers were infected almost exclusively in Africa; none were infected in Europe. We hypothesize that the schistosomiasis outbreak in Corsica began with importation of S. haematobium trematodes and subsequent establishment of an autochthonous transmission cycle.

Technical Appendix

Public health measures in France regarding the emergence of schistosomiasis in Corsica, tourism statistics for Corsica, and tracking of schistosomiasis cases linked to Corsica.
  12 in total

1.  [Human bilharziasis in the Near-East Mediterranean countries. Historical aspects and current distribution].

Authors:  J P Nozais
Journal:  Bull Soc Pathol Exot       Date:  1990

Review 2.  New diagnostic tools in schistosomiasis.

Authors:  J Utzinger; S L Becker; L van Lieshout; G J van Dam; S Knopp
Journal:  Clin Microbiol Infect       Date:  2015-04-03       Impact factor: 8.067

3.  [Urinary schistosomiasis contracted in a child in Corsica].

Authors:  P-M Patard; C Debuisson; S Mouttalib; A Berry; A Garnier; P Galinier; O Abbo
Journal:  Arch Pediatr       Date:  2015-01-20       Impact factor: 1.180

Review 4.  [Parasitic diseases in Europe].

Authors:  A Fain
Journal:  Ann Soc Belg Med Trop       Date:  1980-03

5.  Schistosoma haematobium infections acquired in Corsica, France, August 2013.

Authors:  M C Holtfreter; H Moné; I Müller-Stöver; G Mouahid; J Richter
Journal:  Euro Surveill       Date:  2014-06-05

6.  Travel-associated infection presenting in Europe (2008-12): an analysis of EuroTravNet longitudinal, surveillance data, and evaluation of the effect of the pre-travel consultation.

Authors:  Patricia Schlagenhauf; Leisa Weld; Abraham Goorhuis; Philippe Gautret; Rainer Weber; Frank von Sonnenburg; Rogelio Lopez-Vélez; Mogens Jensenius; Jakob P Cramer; Vanessa K Field; Silvia Odolini; Effrossyni Gkrania-Klotsas; Francois Chappuis; Denis Malvy; Perry J J van Genderen; Frank Mockenhaupt; Stéphane Jauréguiberry; Catherine Smith; Nicholas J Beeching; Johan Ursing; Christophe Rapp; Philippe Parola; Martin P Grobusch
Journal:  Lancet Infect Dis       Date:  2014-12-02       Impact factor: 25.071

7.  Surveillance for travel-related disease--GeoSentinel Surveillance System, United States, 1997-2011.

Authors:  Kira Harvey; Douglas H Esposito; Pauline Han; Phyllis Kozarsky; David O Freedman; D Adam Plier; Mark J Sotir
Journal:  MMWR Surveill Summ       Date:  2013-07-19

8.  Schistosomiasis haematobium, Corsica, France.

Authors:  Antoine Berry; Hélène Moné; Xavier Iriart; Gabriel Mouahid; Olivier Aboo; Jérôme Boissier; Judith Fillaux; Sophie Cassaing; Cécile Debuisson; Alexis Valentin; Guillaume Mitta; André Théron; Jean-François Magnaval
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2014-09       Impact factor: 6.883

9.  Schistosomiasis in cattle in Corsica, France.

Authors:  Didier Calavas; Paul M V Martin
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2014-12       Impact factor: 6.883

10.  Bidirectional introgressive hybridization between a cattle and human schistosome species.

Authors:  Tine Huyse; Bonnie L Webster; Sarah Geldof; J Russell Stothard; Oumar T Diaw; Katja Polman; David Rollinson
Journal:  PLoS Pathog       Date:  2009-09-04       Impact factor: 6.823

View more
  13 in total

1.  Introgressive hybridizations of Schistosoma haematobium by Schistosoma bovis at the origin of the first case report of schistosomiasis in Corsica (France, Europe).

Authors:  Hélène Moné; Martha C Holtfreter; Jean-François Allienne; Rodrigue Mintsa-Nguéma; Moudachirou Ibikounlé; Jérôme Boissier; Antoine Berry; Guillaume Mitta; Joachim Richter; Gabriel Mouahid
Journal:  Parasitol Res       Date:  2015-08-14       Impact factor: 2.289

2.  Schistosomiasis Screening of Travelers to Corsica, France.

Authors:  Antoine Berry; Luc Paris; Jérôme Boissier; Eric Caumes
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2016-01       Impact factor: 6.883

3.  Difficulties in Schistosomiasis Assessment, Corsica, France.

Authors:  Hélène Moné; Martha C Holtfreter; Gabriel Mouahid; Joachim Richter
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2016-04       Impact factor: 6.883

4.  Refined stratified-worm-burden models that incorporate specific biological features of human and snail hosts provide better estimates of Schistosoma diagnosis, transmission, and control.

Authors:  David Gurarie; Charles H King; Nara Yoon; Emily Li
Journal:  Parasit Vectors       Date:  2016-08-04       Impact factor: 3.876

5.  Schistosomiasis Screening of Travelers to Corsica, France.

Authors:  Philippe Gautret; Frank P Mockenhaupt; Frank von Sonnenburg; Camilla Rothe; Michael Libman; Kristina Van De Winkel; Emmanuel Bottieau; Martin P Grobusch; Davidson H Hamer; Douglas H Esposito; Philippe Parola; Patricia Schlagenhauf
Journal:  Emerg Infect Dis       Date:  2016-01       Impact factor: 6.883

6.  Infections and cancer: the "fifty shades of immunity" hypothesis.

Authors:  Camille Jacqueline; Aurélie Tasiemski; Gabriele Sorci; Beata Ujvari; Fatima Maachi; Dorothée Missé; François Renaud; Paul Ewald; Frédéric Thomas; Benjamin Roche
Journal:  BMC Cancer       Date:  2017-04-12       Impact factor: 4.430

7.  The human-snail transmission environment shapes long term schistosomiasis control outcomes: Implications for improving the accuracy of predictive modeling.

Authors:  David Gurarie; Nathan C Lo; Martial L Ndeffo-Mbah; David P Durham; Charles H King
Journal:  PLoS Negl Trop Dis       Date:  2018-05-21

Review 8.  Mobile populations across the Mediterranean Sea and beyond: travel medicine, mass gathering medicine and homeless health.

Authors:  P Gautret; B Pradines; Z A Memish; C Sokhna; P Parola
Journal:  New Microbes New Infect       Date:  2018-05-31

9.  Persistence of schistosomal transmission linked to the Cavu river in southern Corsica since 2013.

Authors:  Lauriane Ramalli; Stephen Mulero; Harold Noël; Jean-Dominique Chiappini; Josselin Vincent; Hélène Barré-Cardi; Philippe Malfait; Guillaume Normand; Florian Busato; Vincent Gendrin; Jean-François Allienne; Judith Fillaux; Jérôme Boissier; Antoine Berry
Journal:  Euro Surveill       Date:  2018-01

10.  Imported Schistosomiasis: A New Public Health Challenge for China.

Authors:  Lei Wang; Xiaoying Wu; Xiaoli Li; Xiaoyan Zheng; Fei Wang; Zhiqun Qi; Minjun Huang; Yang Zou
Journal:  Front Med (Lausanne)       Date:  2020-10-22
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.