Samuel H Preston1, Ezra Fishman1, Andrew Stokes2. 1. Population Studies Center, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. 2. Department of Global Health, Boston University, Boston, MA. Electronic address: acstokes@bu.edu.
Abstract
PURPOSE: The health consequences of obesity are often assessed using categorical, self-reported data on body mass index (BMI). This article investigates the combined effects of categorization and self-report bias on the estimated association between obesity and mortality. METHODS: We used the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (1988-2008) linked to death records through 2011. Cox models and age-standardized death rates were used to evaluate the effects of categorization and self-report bias on the mortality risks and percent of deaths attributable to obesity. RESULTS: Despite a correlation between measured and self-reported BMI of 0.96, self-reports miscategorized 20% of adults. Hazard ratios using self-reports were overstated for the obese 1 (BMI, 30-35 kg/m(2)) and obese 2 (BMI ≥ 35 kg/m(2)) categories. The bias was much smaller using a continuous measure of BMI. In contrast, the percent of deaths attributable to excess weight was lower using self-reported versus measured data because self-reports led to systematic downward bias in the BMI distribution. CONCLUSIONS: Categorization of BMI and self-report bias combine to produce substantial error in the estimated hazard ratios and percent of deaths attributable to obesity. Future studies should use caution when estimating the association between obesity and mortality using categorical self-reported data.
PURPOSE: The health consequences of obesity are often assessed using categorical, self-reported data on body mass index (BMI). This article investigates the combined effects of categorization and self-report bias on the estimated association between obesity and mortality. METHODS: We used the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (1988-2008) linked to death records through 2011. Cox models and age-standardized death rates were used to evaluate the effects of categorization and self-report bias on the mortality risks and percent of deaths attributable to obesity. RESULTS: Despite a correlation between measured and self-reported BMI of 0.96, self-reports miscategorized 20% of adults. Hazard ratios using self-reports were overstated for the obese 1 (BMI, 30-35 kg/m(2)) and obese 2 (BMI ≥ 35 kg/m(2)) categories. The bias was much smaller using a continuous measure of BMI. In contrast, the percent of deaths attributable to excess weight was lower using self-reported versus measured data because self-reports led to systematic downward bias in the BMI distribution. CONCLUSIONS: Categorization of BMI and self-report bias combine to produce substantial error in the estimated hazard ratios and percent of deaths attributable to obesity. Future studies should use caution when estimating the association between obesity and mortality using categorical self-reported data.
Authors: Amy Berrington de Gonzalez; Patricia Hartge; James R Cerhan; Alan J Flint; Lindsay Hannan; Robert J MacInnis; Steven C Moore; Geoffrey S Tobias; Hoda Anton-Culver; Laura Beane Freeman; W Lawrence Beeson; Sandra L Clipp; Dallas R English; Aaron R Folsom; D Michal Freedman; Graham Giles; Niclas Hakansson; Katherine D Henderson; Judith Hoffman-Bolton; Jane A Hoppin; Karen L Koenig; I-Min Lee; Martha S Linet; Yikyung Park; Gaia Pocobelli; Arthur Schatzkin; Howard D Sesso; Elisabete Weiderpass; Bradley J Willcox; Alicja Wolk; Anne Zeleniuch-Jacquotte; Walter C Willett; Michael J Thun Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2010-12-02 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Majid Ezzati; Hilarie Martin; Suzanne Skjold; Stephen Vander Hoorn; Christopher J L Murray Journal: J R Soc Med Date: 2006-05 Impact factor: 5.344
Authors: Bo Qin; Adana A M Llanos; Yong Lin; Elizabeth A Szamreta; Jesse J Plascak; Hannah Oh; Karen Pawlish; Christine B Ambrosone; Kitaw Demissie; Chi-Chen Hong; Elisa V Bandera Journal: J Cancer Surviv Date: 2018-03-13 Impact factor: 4.442
Authors: G A Handrigan; N Maltais; M Gagné; P Lamontagne; D Hamel; N Teasdale; O Hue; P Corbeil; J P Brown; S Jean Journal: Osteoporos Int Date: 2016-08-25 Impact factor: 4.507
Authors: Caroline S Kampshoff; Fiona Stacey; Camille E Short; Willem van Mechelen; Mai Jm Chinapaw; Johannes Brug; Ronald Plotnikoff; Erica L James; Laurien M Buffart Journal: Support Care Cancer Date: 2016-03-12 Impact factor: 3.603