| Literature DB >> 26379053 |
Michael P Thomas1, Craig S Parzynski2, Jeptha P Curtis2, Milan Seth3, Brahmajee K Nallamothu1, Paul S Chan4, John A Spertus4, Manesh R Patel5, Steven M Bradley6, Hitinder S Gurm1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Substantial geographic variation exists in percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) use across the United States. It is unclear the extent to which high PCI utilization can be explained by PCI for inappropriate indications. The objective of this study was to examine the relationship between PCI rates across regional healthcare markets utilizing hospital referral regions (HRRs) and PCI appropriateness.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2015 PMID: 26379053 PMCID: PMC4575022 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138251
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Mean PCI rates within each quintile of utilization (per 1000).
| Quintile | # of HRRs | Mean % Capture | Mean PCI Rate (SD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 37 | 98.6% | 4.6 (.61) |
| 2 | 40 | 96.7% | 6.0 (.31) |
| 3 | 37 | 96.9% | 6.9 (.27) |
| 4 | 30 | 95.1% | 8.0 (.42) |
| 5 | 34 | 97% | 10.8 (2.0) |
Abbreviations: HRR = hospital referral regions; PCI = percutaneous coronary intervention
Baseline demographic characteristics of all patients stratified by quintile of PCI rate.
| Variable | Total #,% | Quintile 1 #,% | Quintile 2 #,% | Quintile 3 #,% | Quintile 4 #,% | Quintile 5 #,% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 380981, 100 | 55727, 100 | 72942, 100 | 88886, 100 | 83416, 100 | 80010, 100 |
| Age Mean (SD) | 64.5, 12.2 | 64.5, 12.1 | 64.4, 12.2 | 64.8, 12.3 | 64.4, 12.2 | 64.5, 12.1 |
| Male | 255693, 67.1 | 39051, 70.1 | 49703, 68.1 | 59823, 67.3 | 55316, 66.3 | 51800, 64.7 |
| White Race | 341206, 89.6 | 49172, 88.2 | 63615, 87.2 | 79543, 89.5 | 76658, 91.9 | 72218, 90.3 |
| Private Insurance | 244820, 64.3 | 36012, 64.6 | 47037, 64.5 | 58442, 65.8 | 52345, 62.8 | 50984, 63.7 |
| Public Insurance | 217889, 57.2 | 30120, 54.1 | 41152, 56.4 | 49675, 55.9 | 47988, 57.5 | 48954, 61.2 |
| Non-US Insurance | 137, 0.04 | 20, 0.04 | 24, 0.03 | 59, 0.07 | 19, 0.02 | 15, 0.02 |
| No Insurance | 23817, 6.3 | 3070, 5.5 | 4934, 6.8 | 5734, 6.5 | 5350, 6.4 | 4729, 5.9 |
Baseline clinical characteristics of all patients stratified by quintile of PCI rate.
| Variable | Total #,% | Quintile 1 #,% | Quintile 2 #,% | Quintile 3 #,% | Quintile 4 #,% | Quintile 5 #,% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 380981, 100 | 55727, 100 | 72942, 100 | 88886, 100 | 83416, 100 | 80010, 100 | |
| Current / Recent Smoker (w/in 1 year) | 108719, 28.6 | 14256, 25.6 | 20816, 28.6 | 24227, 27.3 | 25349, 30.4 | 24071, 30.1 | |
| Hypertension | 311080, 81.7 | 44082, 79.1 | 58911, 80.8 | 72158, 81.2 | 68230, 81.9 | 67699, 84.7 | |
| Dyslipidemia | 307237, 80.7 | 44379, 79.7 | 58068, 79.7 | 72534, 81.7 | 67152, 80.6 | 65104, 81.5 | |
| Family History of Premature CAD | 97210, 25.5 | 12745, 22.9 | 19586, 26.9 | 21481, 24.2 | 24056, 28.9 | 19342, 24.2 | |
| Prior MI | 116895, 30.7 | 15811, 28.4 | 21963, 30.1 | 27247, 30.7 | 25708, 30.8 | 26166, 32.7 | |
| Prior Heart Failure | 44787, 11.8 | 5221, 9.4 | 8337, 11.4 | 10097, 11.4 | 10239, 12.3 | 10893, 13.6 | |
| Prior Valve Surgery / Procedure | 5457, 1.4 | 745, 1.3 | 1057, 1.45 | 1373, 1.6 | 1178, 1.4 | 1104, 1.4 | |
| Prior PCI | 154064, 40.5 | 19835, 35.6 | 28157, 38.6 | 34980, 39.4 | 34911, 41.9 | 36181, 45.2 | |
| Prior CABG | 70942, 18.6 | 8540, 15.3 | 13109, 18.0 | 16230, 18.3 | 16855, 20.2 | 16208, 20.3 | |
| Currently on Dialysis | 8298, 2.2 | 1221, 2.2 | 1783, 2.5 | 1816, 2.0 | 1663, 2.0 | 1815, 2.3 | |
| Cerebrovascular Disease | 47072, 12.4 | 5811, 10.4 | 8740, 12.0 | 10920, 12.3 | 10508, 12.6 | 11093, 13.9 | |
| Peripheral Arterial Disease | 48300, 12.7 | 5892, 10.6 | 8827, 12.1 | 11156, 12.6 | 10713, 12.9 | 11712, 14.6 | |
| Chronic Lung Disease | 60486, 15.9 | 7140, 12.8 | 10219, 14.0 | 13067, 14.7 | 14174, 17.0 | 15886, 19.9 | |
| Diabetes Mellitus | 135509, 35.6 | 18218. 32.7 | 25760, 35.3 | 30758, 34.6 | 29993, 36.0 | 30780, 38.5 | |
| PCI Indication | |||||||
| Immediate PCI for STEMI | 53677, 14.1 | 9329, 16.7 | 11110, 15.2 | 13073, 14.7 | 10926, 13.1 | 9239, 11.6 | |
| PCI for STEMI (Unstable, >12 hrs from symptom onset) | 3217, 0.8 | 649, 1.2 | 572, 0.8 | 777, 0.9 | 641, 0.8 | 578, 0.7 | |
| PCI for STEMI (Stable, > 12 hrs from symptom onset) | 2210, 0.6 | 362, 0.7 | 431, 0.6 | 525, 0.6 | 439, 0.5 | 453, 0.6 | |
| PCI for STEMI (Stable after successful full-dose thrombolysis) | 1696, 0.5 | 348, 0.6 | 343, 0.5 | 359, 0.4 | 366, 0.4 | 280, 0.4 | |
| Rescue PCI for STEMI (after failed full-dose lytics) | 2047, 0.5 | 382, 0.7 | 446, 0.6 | 445, 0.5 | 434, 0.5 | 340, 0.4 | |
| PCI for high risk Non-STEMI or unstable angina | 171123, 44.9 | 24442, 43.9 | 32936, 45.2 | 41591, 46.8 | 37576, 45.1 | 34578, 43.2 | |
| Staged PCI | 24509, 6.4 | 2585, 4.6 | 4132, 5.7 | 5094, 5.7 | 6668, 8.0 | 6030, 7.5 | |
| Other | 122358, 32.1 | 17616, 31.6 | 22933, 31.5 | 26988, 30.4 | 26338, 31.6 | 28483, 35.6 | |
| CAD Presentation | |||||||
| No symptom, no angina | 35325, 9.3 | 4642, 8.3 | 6374, 8.7 | 8195, 9.2 | 8536, 10.2 | 7578, 9.5 | |
| Symptom unlikely to be ischemic | 11931, 3.1 | 1489, 2.7 | 2199, 3.0 | 2935, 3.3 | 2750, 3.3 | 2558, 3.2 | |
| Stable angina | 65030, 17.1 | 9297, 16.7 | 12858, 17.6 | 14204, 16.0 | 14302, 17.2 | 14369, 18.0 | |
| Unstable angina | 138774, 36.4 | 17834, 32.0 | 25413, 34.8 | 32028, 36.0 | 31507, 37.8 | 31992, 40.0 | |
| Non-STEMI | 68816, 18.1 | 11681, 21.0 | 13521, 18.5 | 16736, 18.8 | 13877, 16.6 | 13001, 16.3 | |
| ST-Elevation MI (STEMI) or equivalent | 61036, 16 | 10774, 19.3 | 12572, 17.2 | 14776, 16.6 | 12426, 14.9 | 10488, 13.1 | |
| Coronary Artery Stenoses | |||||||
| 0 | 21969, 6.4 | 2610, 5.1 | 3694, 5.6 | 5073, 6.4 | 4633, 6.1 | 5959, 8.4 | |
| 1 | 178870, 51.9 | 28113, 54.4 | 34661, 52.4 | 41736, 52.4 | 39093, 51.6 | 35267, 49.6 | |
| 2 | 90822, 26.4 | 13711, 26.5 | 17617, 26.6 | 20920, 26.3 | 19947, 26.3 | 18627, 26.2 | |
| 3 | 52732, 15.3 | 7293, 14.1 | 10169, 15.4 | 11857, 14.9 | 12135, 16.0 | 11278, 15.9 | |
| Presence of Proximal LAD Stenosis | 97810, 28.2 | 14842, 28.3 | 18955, 28.7 | 22789, 28.3 | 20942, 27.6 | 20282, 28.3 |
Abbreviations: CABG = coronary artery bypass grafting; CAD = coronary artery disease; LAD = left anterior descending; MI = myocardial infarction; PCI = percutaneous coronary intervention; STEMI = ST elevation myocardial infarction
In-hospital mortality rates by quintile of PCI rate.
| Quintile 1 | Quintile 2 | Quintile 3 | Quintile 4 | Quintile 5 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All PCIs | ||||||
| Adjusted mortality rate | 1.35 | 1.34 | 1.28 | 1.32 | 1.38 | |
| Acute PCIs | ||||||
| Adjusted mortality rate | 1.81 | 1.81 | 1.73 | 1.79 | 1.87 | |
| Non-acute PCIs | ||||||
| Adjusted mortality rate | 0.25 | 0.22 | 0.21 | 0.21 | 0.24 |
Abbreviations: PCI = percutaneous coronary intervention