| Literature DB >> 26323522 |
Chidubem B Ogwulu1, Louise J Jackson2, Alexander E P Heazell3, Tracy E Roberts4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Compared to other pregnancy-related events, the full cost of stillbirth remains poorly described. In the UK one in every 200 births ends in stillbirth. As a follow-up to a recent study which explored the direct costs of stillbirth, this study aimed to explore the intangible costs of stillbirth in terms of their duration and economic implication.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2015 PMID: 26323522 PMCID: PMC4556317 DOI: 10.1186/s12884-015-0617-x
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Pregnancy Childbirth ISSN: 1471-2393 Impact factor: 3.007
MEDLINE search terms and results: using the Boolean logic terms “OR” and “AND”, these search term sets were used in strategy
| # | Search terms | Results |
|---|---|---|
|
| Stillbirth$.mp. or Stillbirth/ | 8151 |
|
| Fetal death$.mp. or Fetal Death/ | 25,887 |
|
| Perinatal death$.mp. | 3280 |
|
| Perinatal loss$.mp. | 486 |
|
| Pregnancy loss$.mp. | 4033 |
|
| 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 | 36,916 |
|
| Psycho* effects.mp. | 5108 |
|
| Grief.mp. or exp Grief/ | 8957 |
|
| Pain/px [Psychology] | 12,474 |
|
| Stress, Psychological/ | 88,636 |
|
| Suffering.mp. or Stress, Psychological/ | 180,766 |
|
| “Costs and Cost Analysis”/ or “Cost of Illness”/ or intangible costs.mp. | 59,734 |
|
| 7 or 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 or 12 | 262,049 |
|
| 6 and 13 | 924 |
|
| Cost$.mp. or “Costs and Cost Analysis”/ | 414,970 |
|
| Economic$.mp. | 203,888 |
|
| 15 or 16 | 563,572 |
|
| 6 and 17 | 1027 |
|
| 6 and 13 and 17 | 79 |
|
| Limit 19 to (english language and humans) |
|
|
| Limit 18 to (english language and humans) |
|
|
| Limit 14 to (english language and humans) |
|
Highlighted figures indicate final search terms results
Fig. 1Flow diagram of papers through the studies
Results of quantitative studies
| Lead author (year) | Selected results | Author’s conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Radestad (2001) [ | Mean anxiety score: cases; 36.4, controls; 34.8 | Slightly higher anxiety level in women with stillbirth compared to those without stillbirth |
| Turton (2006) [ | Within-couple analysis (negative scores indicate higher levels in mothers), PTSD(−6.63), State anxiety (−4.42), Trait anxiety (−1.41) | Among couples with stillbirth, mothers had higher level of PTSD and anxiety than fathers |
| Compared to parents without stillbirth, parents with stillbirth had significant levels of depression, anxiety and PTSD | ||
| Saflund (2006) [ | WB: Women/ Men, Higher NWB ( | At 3 months post stillbirth; mothers scored significantly higher on NWB and lower on PWB and GWB than fathers |
| None of the fathers was on sick leave whereas all mothers were on full or part-time leave | ||
| Surkan (2008) [ | Relative risk of depressive symptoms, Not held baby long enough (RR 6.9, 95 % CI 2.4–19.8), Not pregnant within 6 months (RR 2.8. 95 % CI 0.9–8.4) | Depression in mothers post stillbirth is influenced by the length of time they spent with their stillborn and if pregnant again within 6 months |
| Turton (2009) [ | No significant association | No evidence to suggest that siblings born after a stillbirth are clinically at risk for psychological problems |
| Cacciatore (2013) [ | Anxiety, 41.3 %, mental distress, 42.3 %, depressive symptoms, 61.7 % | Scores elevated among mothers that blamed themselves for a stillbirth |
Fig. 2Themes and sub-themes identified in qualitative studies
Fig. 3Top 10 questions and represented sections