Marguerite Hoyler1, Lars Hagander2, Rowan Gillies3, Robert Riviello4, Kathryn Chu5, Staffan Bergström6, John G Meara3. 1. Department of Surgery, Columbia University/New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York, New York, USA; Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; Center for Surgery and Public Health, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. Electronic address: hoylerm@gmail.com. 2. Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; Department of Clinical Sciences in Lund, International Pediatrics and Pediatric Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Lund University, Lund, Sweden; Center for Surgery and Public Health, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. 3. Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; Department of Plastic and Oral Surgery, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. 4. Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA; Center for Surgery and Public Health, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. 5. Center for Surgery and Public Health, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA. 6. Division of Global Health, Department of Public Health Sciences, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Anecdotal evidence suggests that task-shifting or the redistribution of responsibilities from fully-trained surgeons to clinicians with fewer qualifications could become a major component of surgical care delivery in many low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs). Our goal was to summarise the scope of surgical task-shifting in LMICs through a systematic review of the medical literature. METHODS: We searched PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, LILACS, and African Index Medicus databases for papers and abstracts published between 1975, and November, 2014, that provided original data regarding non-surgeon providers, the type and volume of operations they perform, and the outcomes they achieve. The search was done in English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese, and included terms related to surgery, non-physician providers, and LMIC country names. Outcomes included the number of non-physicians and non-surgeons practicing surgery in LMICs, their qualifications, practice models and locations, and the types and volume of operations performed. FINDINGS: We identified 65 articles and 14 abstracts that described non-surgeon and non-physician providers performing 46 types of surgical procedures, across eight surgical disciplines, in 41 LMICs. These procedures extended beyond those recommended by WHO, such as male circumcision and emergency obstetric surgery. Non-surgeons and non-physicians provided a large amount of surgical care in some locations, including 90% of obstretric surgeries, 38·5% of general surgery procedures, and 43% of non-obstetric laparotomies at three separate hospitals. Of the 38 papers that specified urban or rural locations, 35 described task-shifting in rural areas or district hospitals. A variety of formal training models for surgical task-shifting were noted, including collaborations between national governments, WHO, and private non-governmental organisations. Surgical providers often had no formal surgical training, and did not operate under the supervision of a fully trained provider. INTERPRETATION: Our results suggest that non-surgeon physicians and non-physician clinicians provide surgical care many in low-resource settings. A limitation of our study is that our search was conducted in only four languages. Because many studies described the same country, countries or regions in overlapping time frames, it was not possible to determine the total number of task-shifting providers. In view of the shortage of fully-trained surgeons in many LMICs, it seems likely that task-shifting is far more widespread than is indicated by the medical literature. More research is needed to accurately determine the full extent and implications of surgical task-shifting in LMICs worldwide. FUNDING: None.
BACKGROUND: Anecdotal evidence suggests that task-shifting or the redistribution of responsibilities from fully-trained surgeons to clinicians with fewer qualifications could become a major component of surgical care delivery in many low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs). Our goal was to summarise the scope of surgical task-shifting in LMICs through a systematic review of the medical literature. METHODS: We searched PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, LILACS, and African Index Medicus databases for papers and abstracts published between 1975, and November, 2014, that provided original data regarding non-surgeon providers, the type and volume of operations they perform, and the outcomes they achieve. The search was done in English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese, and included terms related to surgery, non-physician providers, and LMIC country names. Outcomes included the number of non-physicians and non-surgeons practicing surgery in LMICs, their qualifications, practice models and locations, and the types and volume of operations performed. FINDINGS: We identified 65 articles and 14 abstracts that described non-surgeon and non-physician providers performing 46 types of surgical procedures, across eight surgical disciplines, in 41 LMICs. These procedures extended beyond those recommended by WHO, such as male circumcision and emergency obstetric surgery. Non-surgeons and non-physicians provided a large amount of surgical care in some locations, including 90% of obstretric surgeries, 38·5% of general surgery procedures, and 43% of non-obstetric laparotomies at three separate hospitals. Of the 38 papers that specified urban or rural locations, 35 described task-shifting in rural areas or district hospitals. A variety of formal training models for surgical task-shifting were noted, including collaborations between national governments, WHO, and private non-governmental organisations. Surgical providers often had no formal surgical training, and did not operate under the supervision of a fully trained provider. INTERPRETATION: Our results suggest that non-surgeon physicians and non-physician clinicians provide surgical care many in low-resource settings. A limitation of our study is that our search was conducted in only four languages. Because many studies described the same country, countries or regions in overlapping time frames, it was not possible to determine the total number of task-shifting providers. In view of the shortage of fully-trained surgeons in many LMICs, it seems likely that task-shifting is far more widespread than is indicated by the medical literature. More research is needed to accurately determine the full extent and implications of surgical task-shifting in LMICs worldwide. FUNDING: None.
Authors: Elissa K Butler; Adam Gyedu; Barclay T Stewart; Robert Quansah; Peter Donkor; Charles N Mock Journal: Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Date: 2019-11-25 Impact factor: 2.374
Authors: H A Bolkan; A van Duinen; B Waalewijn; M Elhassein; T B Kamara; G F Deen; I Bundu; B Ystgaard; J von Schreeb; A Wibe Journal: Br J Surg Date: 2017-05-18 Impact factor: 6.939
Authors: Elissa K Butler; Tu M Tran; Anthony T Fuller; Christine Muhumuza; Sarah Williams; Joao R N Vissoci; Samuel Luboga; Michael M Haglund; Fredrick Makumbi; Moses Galukande; Jeffrey G Chipman Journal: Ann Glob Health Date: 2019-04-01 Impact factor: 2.462
Authors: Mahmood F Bhutta; Xingkuan Bu; Patricia Castellanos de Muñoz; Suneela Garg; Kelvin Kong Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2019-08-20 Impact factor: 9.408
Authors: Eliana E Kim; David Araujo; Bruce Dahlman; Shivum Agarwal; Pratap Prasad; Walter Johnson; Kee B Park Journal: Bull World Health Organ Date: 2020-08-27 Impact factor: 9.408