| Literature DB >> 26270185 |
Gillian S Tomlinson1, Niclas Thomas2, Benjamin M Chain2, Katharine Best2, Nandi Simpson2, Georgia Hardavella3, James Brown3, Angshu Bhowmik4, Neal Navani5, Samuel M Janes3, Robert F Miller6, Mahdad Noursadeghi2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Endobronchial ultrasound (EBUS)-guided biopsy is the mainstay for investigation of mediastinal lymphadenopathy for laboratory diagnosis of malignancy, sarcoidosis, or TB. However, improved methods for discriminating between TB and sarcoidosis and excluding malignancy are still needed. We sought to evaluate the role of genomewide transcriptional profiling to aid diagnostic processes in this setting.Entities:
Keywords: cancer; machine learning; sarcoidosis; transcriptome; tuberculosis
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 26270185 PMCID: PMC4740456 DOI: 10.1378/chest.15-0647
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Chest ISSN: 0012-3692 Impact factor: 9.410
Summary of Study Subjects’ Demographic Data
| Diagnosis | No. | Age Range, y | Sex M (F) | Ethnicity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Definite sarcoidosis | 19 | 24-80 | 12 (7) | 16 Eurasian, 3 African |
| Definite TB | 9 | 21-71 | 8 (1) | 7 Eurasian, 2 African |
| Reactive | 10 | 33-78 | 9 (1) | 10 Eurasian |
| Definite cancer | 27 | 49-86 | 16 (11) | 25 Eurasian, 1 East Asian, 1 African |
| Possible sarcoidosis | 3 | 38-50 | 3 (0) | 2 Eurasian, 1 Latin American |
| Probable TB | 2 | 30-35 | 0 (2) | 2 Eurasian |
| Possible cancer | 12 | 56-82 | 5 (7) | 12 Eurasian |
| Undetermined | 6 | 44-58 | 2 (4) | 5 Eurasian, 1 African |
Figure 1Clustering analysis of genomewide lymph node profiles does not distinguish disease groups. Comparison of genomewide transcriptional profiles of lymph node samples by principal component analysis (PCA) shows that the majority of cancer samples cluster away from all other disease groups in PC1, responsible for the greatest differences within the data. However, sarcoidosis, TB, and reactive lymph nodes as well as some cancer samples clustered together in both PC1 and PC2 in this analysis, which was unable to segregate individual disease groups. Each symbol represents a sample.
Figure 2Support vector machines (SVMs) classification performance improves as cohort sample size increases. The performance of SVM to classify cases by training on signatures comprising differentially expressed genes (greater than twofold difference and P < .05, t test) between comparator groups using bootstrap sampling of five, 15, or 25 cases with replacement (100 iterations), is represented by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. Increasing the training dataset sample size progressively improves the ability of SVMs to correctly distinguish granulomatous (n = 28) from nongranulomatous (n = 37) disease (A), sarcoidosis (n = 19) from TB (n = 9) (B), and malignant (n = 27) from reactive (n = 10) lymph nodes (C), with AUC values of > 0.9 once the cohort comprises 25 samples. AUC = area under the curve.
Figure 3Support vector machines classification sequence. In this analysis, SVMs are trained using leave-one-out cross-validation. Step 1: Cases are subjected to initial SVM analysis using the 488-gene signature, which distinguishes granulomatous from nongranulomatous disease. Step 2: Samples classified as granulomatous disease subsequently undergo SVM testing using the 58-gene signature, which discriminates sarcoidosis from TB, and those classified as nongranulomatous disease undergo further SVM evaluation using the 1,223-gene signature, which distinguishes cancer from reactive lymph node. See Figure 2 legend for expansion of abbreviation.
Sensitivity and Specificity of SVM Classification
| Diagnosis | No. | Sensitivity, % | Specificity, % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sarcoidosis | 19 | 85 | 96 |
| TB | 9 | 67 | 98 |
| Reactive | 10 | 80 | 93 |
| Cancer | 27 | 93 | 92 |
SVM = support vector machine.
Figure 4Lymph node transcriptional signatures show greater power to discriminate TB from sarcoidosis than peripheral blood signatures. A, Performance of cumulative genes in rank order of their weighting in each SVM is represented by the mean (± 95% CI) of ROC curve AUCs in 100 bootstrap subsampling cross-validation iterations. B, The published peripheral blood signatures (Maertzdorf, Bloom, Koth) and the LN signature identified in this study that differentiate TB from sarcoidosis exhibit minimal overlap. C, ROC curves represent the ability of SVM algorithms to classify sarcoidosis and TB lymph node samples when trained by bootstrap sampling with replacement on transcriptional signatures that distinguish sarcoidosis from TB lymph nodes (Tomlinson) or peripheral blood profiles (Bloom, Maertzdorf, Koth). D, The LN-derived gene signature performs significantly better (AUC = 0.92) than peripheral blood-derived signatures (AUC all < 0.7) in classifying TB and sarcoidosis samples. LN = lymph node. See Figure 2 legend for expansion of other abbreviations.
SVM Classification of Cases Without a Definite Clinical Diagnosis
| Diagnosis | Clinical Question | Histology | SVM 1 | SVM 2 | SVM 3 | Clinical Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Possible S1 | Sarcoidosis? | G | NG | … | R | Clinical diagnosis of sarcoidosis. Spontaneous resolution of symptoms, under observation only. |
| Possible S2 | Sarcoidosis? | NG | G | S | … | Definite sarcoidosis confirmed by noncaseating granulomas on lymph node sample from mediastinoscopy. Clinical improvement with steroid treatment. |
| Possible S3 | Sarcoidosis? | NG | G | S | … | Spontaneous improvement in clinical symptoms and chest radiograph lymphadenopathy. |
| Probable TB1 | TB? | G | G | TB | … | Good clinical and radiologic response to empirical TB treatment. |
| Probable TB2 | TB? | G | G | S | … | Pleural fluid acid- alcohol-fast bacilli positive, |
| Possible C1 | Metastatic endometrial cancer? | G | G | … | R | Palliative chemotherapy for presumed lung metastases. |
| Possible C2 | Sarcoidosis/lymphoma? | G | G | … | R | Died of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma diagnosed on bone marrow biopsy. |
| Possible C3 | Metastatic bowel cancer? | G | G | … | R | Patient declined empirical TB treatment and did not attend further respiratory follow-up appointment. |
| Possible C4 | Metastatic bowel cancer? | G | G | … | R | Died. |
| Possible C5 | Metastatic lung cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Developed further lung lesion and fluorodeoxyglucose-avid lymph node following wedge resection of right lower lobe tumor. |
| Possible C6 | Cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Remains in remission from lung cancer—no further treatment. |
| Possible C7 | Metastatic lung cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Died. |
| Possible C8 | Metastatic bladder/renal cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Clinically well after neoadjuvant chemotherapy, right nephroureterectomy, cystoprostatectomy, and ileal conduit formation. |
| Possible C9 | Metastatic lung cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Neoadjuvant chemotherapy, left upper lobe resection, consolidation chemotherapy. Clinically stable but mediastinal lymphadenopathy still evident on CT scan. |
| Possible C10 | Metastatic lung cancer? | NG | NG | … | C | Left upper lobe resection specimen showed metastatic carcinoma in the lymph node, which had shown no histologic evidence of malignancy on samples obtained via EBUS. |
| Possible C11 | Metastatic lung cancer? | NG | NG | … | C | Previous right middle lobe resection for lung adenocarcinoma and had confirmed metastatic adenocarcinoma on a second EBUS procedure performed 4 mo later due to progressive lymph node enlargement. |
| Possible C12 | Metastatic bladder cancer? | NG | NG | … | R | Clinically stable, static appearance of lymphadenopathy on interval CT scan; discharged from respiratory follow-up. |
| U1 | Sarcoidosis/TB? | G | G | S | … | Empirical TB treatment stopped after 2 mo as no response. Now under observation—remains clinically stable. |
| U2 | Sarcoidosis? | NG | NG | … | C | Presumptive diagnosis of sarcoidosis-induced peripheral neuropathy. Minor clinical improvement with steroid and cyclophosphamide treatment. |
| U3 | Sarcoidosis/lymphoma? | NG | G | S | … | Unknown—patient did not attend follow-up clinical appointments. |
| U4 | Sarcoidosis? | G | G | S | … | Remains clinically stable—under observation only. |
| U5 | Sarcoidosis/TB? | G | G | S | … | Spontaneous improvement in clinical symptoms and chest radiograph lymphadenopathy. Subsequently completed 6 mo empirical TB treatment (Mantoux 45 mm, interferon-γ release assay negative). Now well—discharged. |
| U6 | Sarcoidosis/TB/lymphoma? | NG | NG | … | R | Clinically well after 6 mo empirical TB treatment—discharged. |
C = cancer; EBUS = endobronchial ultrasound; G = granulomatous; NG = nongranulomatous; R = reactive; S = sarcoidosis; U = undetermined, See Table 2 legend for expansion of other abbreviation.