Natalie Justicz1, Edie R Hapner2, Joshua S Josephs1, Benjamin C Boone1, Hyder A Jinnah3, Michael M Johns2. 1. Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. 2. Department of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia. 3. Departments of Neurology, Human Genetics & Pediatrics, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.A.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: To assess the comparative effectiveness of botulinum toxin and propranolol in patients with essential vocal tremor (EVT). STUDY DESIGN: Individual prospective cohort study. METHODS: Study patients were recruited at the Emory Voice Center from patients seeking treatment for EVT. Exclusion criteria included current β-blocker treatment, spasmodic dysphonia, or other disease that prevented the use of propranolol therapy. A 10-week washout period from prior botulinum toxin treatment occurred before enrollment. Patients were assessed via the Voice-Related Quality-Of-Life (VRQOL) questionnaire, Quality of life in Essential Tremor questionnaire, and blinded perceptual voice assessment. These assessments were made at baseline voice 2 weeks after propranolol therapy and 4 weeks after botulinum toxin injection. RESULTS: Eighteen patients were enrolled. After 2 to 4 weeks of propranolol therapy (with a maximum dosage of 60 mg to 90 mg per day), patients report an average ΔVRQOL of 9.31. Six patients report significant VRQOL improvement >10, with the rest reporting changes between -7.5 and 7.5. Fifteen patients were followed for at least 4 weeks after botulinum toxin injection, reporting an average improvement in scaled VRQOL of 22.00. Blinded perceptual voice assessment demonstrates an improvement in overall severity of tremor with botulinum toxin. CONCLUSIONS: In some patients with EVT, propranolol led to significant vocal improvement with no major side effects. Although botulinum toxin remains the gold-standard therapy for patients with EVT, propranolol represents a possible alternative or adjuvant therapy for certain patients.
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: To assess the comparative effectiveness of botulinum toxin and propranolol in patients with essential vocal tremor (EVT). STUDY DESIGN: Individual prospective cohort study. METHODS: Study patients were recruited at the Emory Voice Center from patients seeking treatment for EVT. Exclusion criteria included current β-blocker treatment, spasmodic dysphonia, or other disease that prevented the use of propranolol therapy. A 10-week washout period from prior botulinum toxin treatment occurred before enrollment. Patients were assessed via the Voice-Related Quality-Of-Life (VRQOL) questionnaire, Quality of life in Essential Tremor questionnaire, and blinded perceptual voice assessment. These assessments were made at baseline voice 2 weeks after propranolol therapy and 4 weeks after botulinum toxin injection. RESULTS: Eighteen patients were enrolled. After 2 to 4 weeks of propranolol therapy (with a maximum dosage of 60 mg to 90 mg per day), patients report an average ΔVRQOL of 9.31. Six patients report significant VRQOL improvement >10, with the rest reporting changes between -7.5 and 7.5. Fifteen patients were followed for at least 4 weeks after botulinum toxin injection, reporting an average improvement in scaled VRQOL of 22.00. Blinded perceptual voice assessment demonstrates an improvement in overall severity of tremor with botulinum toxin. CONCLUSIONS: In some patients with EVT, propranolol led to significant vocal improvement with no major side effects. Although botulinum toxin remains the gold-standard therapy for patients with EVT, propranolol represents a possible alternative or adjuvant therapy for certain patients.
Authors: Gail B Kempster; Bruce R Gerratt; Katherine Verdolini Abbott; Julie Barkmeier-Kraemer; Robert E Hillman Journal: Am J Speech Lang Pathol Date: 2008-10-16 Impact factor: 2.408
Authors: Theresa A Zesiewicz; Jessica D Shaw; Kevin G Allison; Joseph S Staffetti; Michael S Okun; Kelly L Sullivan Journal: Curr Treat Options Neurol Date: 2013-08 Impact factor: 3.598
Authors: Charles H Adler; Stephen F Bansberg; Joseph G Hentz; Lorraine O Ramig; Eugene H Buder; Kristi Witt; Brian W Edwards; Kari Krein-Jones; John N Caviness Journal: Arch Neurol Date: 2004-09
Authors: Priyesh N Patel; Edmond K Kabagambe; Jennifer C Starkweather; Matthew Keller; Vahram Gamsarian; Jane Lee; Vishnutheert Kulkarni; C Gaelyn Garrett; David O Francis Journal: JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 2018-04-01 Impact factor: 6.223
Authors: Soren Y Lowell; Richard T Kelley; Marika Monahan; Carly Jo Hosbach-Cannon; Raymond H Colton; Dragos Mihaila Journal: Laryngoscope Date: 2018-12-25 Impact factor: 3.325
Authors: Hortensia Alonso-Navarro; Elena García-Martín; José A G Agúndez; Félix J Jiménez-Jiménez Journal: Curr Neuropharmacol Date: 2020 Impact factor: 7.363