The role of tryptase and anti-type II collagen antibodies in the pathogenesis of idiopathic epiretinal membranes.

PURPOSE: To investigate the pathogenesis of idiopathic epiretinal membrane (ERM) from a biochemical perspective, the relationships between ERM and tryptase activity, a serine protease, and the levels of anti-type II collagen (anti-IIC) antibodies in the serum. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Vitreous samples for measurement of tryptase activity were obtained from 54 eyes of 54 patients who underwent a vitrectomy for vitreoretinal disease, ie, 14 eyes of 14 patients with idiopathic macular hole, 14 eyes of 14 patients with proliferative diabetic retinopathy (PDR), 13 eyes of 13 patients with ERM, and 13 eyes of 13 patients with rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD). Tryptase activity was measured by spectrophotometry. Anti-IIC antibodies were measured in the serum obtained from 17 patients with ERM, eight patients who underwent cataract surgery, 12 patients with PDR, and nine patients with RRD. In these 46 patients, the anti-IIC antibodies were measured using a Human/Monkey Anti-Type I and Type II Collagen IgG Assay Kit.
RESULTS: Vitreal tryptase activity (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) in macular hole, PDR, ERM, and RRD was 0.0146±0.0053, 0.0018±0.0018, 0.0166±0.0046, and 0.0117±0.0029 mU/mg protein, respectively. Vitreal tryptase activity was significantly higher in macular hole and ERM than in PDR and RRD (P<0.05, Fisher's protected least significant difference). The serum levels of anti-IIC immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody (mean ± SD) in ERM, cataract surgery, PDR, and RRD were 58.222±30.986, 34.890±18.165, 55.760±26.008, and 35.453±12.769 units/mL, respectively. The serum levels of anti-IIC IgG antibody were significantly higher in ERM and PDR than in cataract surgery and RRD (P<0.05, Fisher's protected least significant difference, two-sided).
CONCLUSION: In the pathogenesis of ERM, increased vitreal tryptase activity may be involved in tissue fibrosis, and elevated serum anti-IIC antibodies may lead to an immune response at the vitreoretinal interface, thus resulting in membrane formation.

Introduction

Idiopathic epiretinal membrane (ERM) most often occurs in middle-aged and older adults, and ERM causes metamorphopsia and decreased visual acuity. There is currently no effective pharmacotherapy for ERM, the only treatment option being vitrectomy. The pathogenesis of ERM has been postulated to involve cell proliferation and extracellular matrix accumulation on vitreous gel that forms the posterior wall of a posterior precortical vitreous pocket,1 and/or a break in the inner limiting membrane due to posterior vitreous detachment, which then leads to migration and proliferation of glial cells in the sensory retina.2–4 However, almost no other research, other than from a morphological perspective, has been performed in regard to ERM.

Our group previously reported that in cases of idiopathic macular hole (MH), which, like ERM, also occurs specifically at the macular region, the activity of chymase, a serine protease, is increased in the vitreous.5 In addition, we proposed a hypothesis that undifferentiated stem cell-like cells exist in the fovea, and that by chymase-induced apoptosis, there is dysfunction of these undifferentiated cells, which can lead to MH.6

Meanwhile, in patients with diabetic retinopathy (DR), serum anti-type II collagen (anti-IIC) antibody levels are increased, and with the progression of DR, blood–retinal barrier disruption occurs, leading to contact between serum anti-IIC antibodies and type II collagen in the vitreous. This causes an immune response, which may also be involved in the pathogenesis of DR.7

As an extension of this previous research,5–7 the relationships between ERM and the activity of tryptase, a serine protease, and the levels of anti-IIC antibodies were investigated.

Patients and methods

Measurement of vitreal tryptase activity

For the measurement of tryptase activity, vitreous samples were obtained from 54 eyes of 54 patients who underwent vitrectomy for vitreoretinal disease, ie, 14 eyes of 14 patients with MH, 14 eyes of 14 patients with proliferative DR (PDR), 13 eyes of 13 patients with ERM, and 13 eyes of 13 patients with rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD).

For sample collection, an irrigation port was placed, and before starting irrigation, 0.5–1.0 mL of an undiluted vitreous gel sample was obtained using a vitreous cutter. The vitreous samples were frozen immediately and stored. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients prior to their involvement in the study, and this study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Osaka Medical College, Takatsuki City, Osaka, Japan.

For the measurement of tryptase activity, N-p-Tosyl-Gly-Pro-Arg-p-nitroanilide was dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide and diluted with reaction buffer (0.06 M Tris) for use as the substrate solution. The enzyme solution (vitreous sample) was added to the reaction buffer, allowed to react with the substrate solution for 1 hour at 37°C, and the absorbance was then measured at 420 nm.

Fisher’s protected least significant difference (PLSD) was used for statistical analysis, and a P-value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Anti-IIC IgG antibody measurement in the serum

Anti-IIC antibodies were measured in serum obtained from 17 patients with ERM, eight patients who underwent cataract surgery (CAT), 12 patients with PDR, and nine patients with RRD. In these 46 patients, the anti-IIC antibodies were measured using a Human/Monkey Anti-Type I and Type II Collagen IgG Assay Kit (Chondrex Inc., Redmond, WA, USA). Patients were excluded from the study if their blood samples were positive for rheumatoid factor, if they had symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis, or if they had inflammatory eye diseases. Patients who had previously undergone any other eye surgeries were also excluded.

The obtained blood samples were centrifuged, with the blood serum diluted 20-fold using sample/standard dilution buffer. The samples were then diluted 20-fold by adding 125 μL of 10 mM ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid/0.02% sodium azide/phosphate buffered saline and 250 μL of sample/standard dilution buffer. The samples were then stored at −20°C until the experiment was performed. The levels of anti-IIC immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibody in the serum were measured using a Human/Monkey Anti-Type I and Type II Collagen IgG Assay Kit (Chondrex Inc.) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. To correct for any false-positive reactions caused by the adhesive immunoglobulin contained in the samples, a unique nonspecific background value was first determined for each of the individual samples by using antigen non-coated wells. This was then subtracted from the value determined in antigen-coated wells in order to obtain the correct result for the antigen–antibody reaction.

Fisher’s PLSD was used for statistical analysis, and a P-value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

Vitreal tryptase activity in vitreoretinal diseases

The 54 eyes of the 54 patients who underwent vitrectomy included 14 eyes of 14 MH patients (six males and eight females; mean age: 66.1±5.3 years), 14 eyes of 14 PDR patients (nine males and five females; mean age: 59.0±13.7 years), 13 eyes of 13 ERM patients (four males and nine females; mean age: 63.8±8.9 years), and 13 eyes of 13 RRD patients (ten males and three females; mean age: 53.8±7.5 years). All patient ages are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD).

Vitreal tryptase activity (mean ± SD) in MH, PDR, ERM, and RRD was 0.0146±0.0053, 0.0018±0.0018, 0.0166±0.0046, and 0.0117±0.0029 mU/mg protein, respectively. Vitreal tryptase activity was significantly higher in MH and ERM than in PDR and RRD (P<0.05, Fisher’s PLSD, two-sided) (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Tryptase activity in vitreoretinal diseases.

Note: Tryptase activity was found to be significantly higher in MH and ERM than in PDR and RRD (*P<0.05, Fisher’s PLSD test, two-sided).

Abbreviations: MH, macular hole; ERM, epiretinal membrane; PDR, proliferative diabetic retinopathy; RRD, rhegmatogenous retinal detachment; PLSD, protected least significant difference.

Optical coherence tomography (OCT) showed that the foveal thickness increased in all ERM patients; however, we did not confirm by use of fluorescein fundus angiography in all cases. Judging by use of OCT alone, obvious macular edema was revealed in only two cases. Moreover, no relationships were found between the presence of macular edema and the intravitreal tryptase levels.

We also investigated the presence of posterior vitreous detachment (PVD) via the patients’ medical records. The results revealed PVD in five cases and no PVD in eight cases. Moreover, no relationships were found between the presence of PVD and the intravitreal tryptase levels.

In addition, we carefully evaluated the severity of ERM by fundus photograph and OCT imaging. The results showed no relationships between the severity of ERM and the intra-vitreal tryptase levels.

For the measurement of anti-IIC IgG antibody in the serum, blood samples were obtained from 46 patients, ie, 17 patients with ERM, eight patients with CAT, 12 patients with PDR, and nine patients with RRD. The serum levels of anti-IIC IgG antibody (mean ± SD) in ERM, CAT, PDR, and RRD were 58.222±30.986, 34.890±18.165, 55.760±26.008, and 35.453±12.769 units/mL, respectively. The serum levels of anti-IIC IgG antibody were significantly higher in ERM and PDR than in CAT and RRD (P<0.05, Fisher’s PLSD, two-sided) (Figure 2).

Figure 2

Serum anti-IIC antibody levels in the patients with ERM, PDR, CAT, and RRD.

Note: Serum anti-IIC antibody levels were found to be significantly higher in ERM and PDR than in CAT and RRD (*P<0.05, Fisher’s PLSD test, two-sided).

Abbreviations: anti-IIC, anti-type II collagen; ERM, epiretinal membrane; PDR, proliferative diabetic retinopathy; CAT, cataract surgery; RRD, rhegmatogenous retinal detachment; PLSD, protected least significant difference.

We also evaluated the levels of anti-IIC antibodies according to the presence/absence of PVD, and no relationships were found between the presence of PVD and the levels of anti-IIC antibodies.

Discussion

Kishi and Shimizu proposed that the pathogenesis of ERM involved cell proliferation and extracellular matrix accumulation on vitreous gel that forms the posterior wall of the posterior precortical vitreous pocket.1 ERM is a disease usually seen in older adults. The progression of PVD that occurs with aging can cause rupture of the inner limiting membrane (the basement membrane of Muller cells), and the migration and proliferation of retinal glial cells from this site may lead to ERM.2 In fact, histological examination of ERM in samples obtained at vitrectomy reportedly showed numerous glial cells.3 Yamashita et al reported that ERMs are the result of anomalous PVD with vitreoschisis, leaving the outermost layer of posterior vitreous cortex attached to the macula.4 However, much remains unclear in regard to the pathogenesis of ERM. For example, the reason why these types of proliferative changes specifically occur at the macular region or why ERM of the macular region may recur even after removal of membranes at vitrectomy, remains unknown.

Our group previously reported that chymase, which is a serine protease produced by mast cells, is possibly involved in the pathogenesis of MH, which is also a macular disease.5 Chymase has a variety of effects, including 1) the conversion of angiotensin I to angiotensin II; 2) the conversion of bound transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-β1) to free TGF-β1, which leads to cleavage of procollagen and the formation of collagen; 3) the activation of matrix metalloproteinases, which degrade the extracellular matrix; and 4) the inactivation of tissue inhibitors of metalloproteinases, which promotes collagen degradation.8–10 Thus, chymase is probably involved in tissue remodeling by virtue of a combination of two actions, namely, collagen production and degradation. In addition, chymase promotes fibroblast proliferation, and chymase induces apoptosis of cells with relatively low differentiation, which have the ability to dedifferentiate into other cells such as vascular smooth muscle cells, bronchial smooth muscle cells, and cardiomyocytes.11–13

In a study using monkey eyes, we also previously reported a higher number of nestin-positive cells in the fovea compared to other retinal areas, and that with intravitreal injection of chymase into monkey eyes, there were TdT-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL)-positive cells in the fovea.6 In other words, in the pathogenesis of MH, increased vitreal chymase activity may be involved in the apoptosis of undifferentiated cells in the fovea.

The present study involving the measurement of tryptase activity is an extension of our previous research.5–7 Our findings showed that tryptase activity was significantly higher in ERM and MH than in the other two vitreoretinal diseases. Some patients with MH also have ERM, thus suggesting the possibility of a common pathogenic mechanism in both of these vitreomacular interface diseases.

Serine proteases such as chymase and tryptase are produced in mast cells, and the roles of mast cells in tissue fibrosis, tissue remodeling, and angiogenesis have recently attracted attention.14,15 The existence of mast cells in the eye, including the choroid, ciliary body, conjunctiva, and sclera, has also been reported.16 At present, it is unknown which tissues in the eye produce chymase and tryptase in the vitreous, however, uveal tissues such as the choroid and ciliary body are likely candidates. There are two types of mast cells: tryptase-positive cells and tryptase/chymase-positive cells. In regard to the localization of mast cells in the choroid, many tryptase/chymase-positive mast cells are reportedly found in the posterior portion of the ocular fundus.16

Both chymase and tryptase are serine proteases, and both probably have actions that influence tissue fibrosis and angiogenesis.17–20 However, chymase is predominantly involved in apoptosis and tryptase is predominantly involved in tissue fibrosis. The degree of activity of both chymase and tryptase may influence the development of MH or ERM. Based on our findings, chymase activity was high in MH, while tryptase activity was not that high in MH; however, the activities of both the enzymes were high in ERM.

It is unclear if ERM exhibits only fibrotic changes, and not endothelial cell proliferation or neovessel formation. The macular region is an avascular area, and this specific environment might prevent endothelial cell proliferation in the ERM.

The findings of the present study also showed elevated serum anti-IIC antibody levels in patients with ERM. We previously reported elevated anti-IIC antibody levels in patients with DR, and that the blood–retinal barrier disruption leads to contact between serum anti-IIC antibodies and type II collagen in the vitreous, thus causing an immune response which may be involved in the pathogenesis of DR.6 In ERM as well, an immune response primarily in the macular region, which involves a similar mechanism, may lead to the formation of membrane-like tissue. In fact, histological examination in ERM has shown the existence of immune cells such as lymphocytes and macrophages.21

As described in previous reports, because cartilage and the vitreous, where type II collagen is present, are both avascular tissues, type II collagen has the property of being a sequestered antigen that can escape surveillance by immune cells circulating in blood throughout the body, thus leading to immunological tolerance.22–24 In chronic rheumatoid arthritis (RA), this immunological tolerance is lost for some reason, and various autoantibodies (including anti-IIC antibodies) form and joint tissue is destroyed by an autoimmune response.25–27 Moreover, serum anti-IIC antibody levels, besides those in chronic RA, are reportedly also elevated in osteoarthritis, relapsing polychondritis, and Meniere’s disease.28,29 For this reason, the patients who had symptoms of RA were excluded in the present study if their blood samples were positive for rheumatoid factor.

The three tissues where type II collagen is present, namely, joints, the inner ear, and vitreous, contain synovial fluid, lymph, and vitreous fluid, respectively. These body fluids are sequestered from immune cells in the blood by the blood–joint barrier, blood–labyrinth barrier, and blood–retinal (ocular) barrier, respectively. With chronic hyperglycemia in patients with DR, it is known that the blood–retinal barrier is disrupted, vascular permeability is increased, and macular edema can occur. With progression of chronic RA and Meniere’s disease, hydrarthrosis and endolymphatic hydrops are known to occur, and in these diseases as well, there is a possibility of barrier function disruption, increased vascular permeability, and a loss of immunological tolerance.

Tryptase is not only involved in tissue fibrosis,30–31 but it is also involved, via matrix metalloproteinases-2, in the degradation of type IV collagen, the chief component of basement membranes.32 Tryptase is also reported to damage vascular endothelial cells.33 In patients with ERM, mast cells are activated by some mechanism, and tryptase, which is produced by these mast cells, can disrupt the inner limiting membrane (basement membrane of Muller cells), which then promotes the migration of glial cells in the sensory retina. In addition, vascular endothelial cells in the blood–retinal barrier are damaged, anti-IIC antibodies can diffuse into the vitreous cavity, and an immune response is elicited at the vitreoretinal interface, thus leading to membrane formation. In fact, fluorescein fundus angiography in ERM is reported to show leakage of fluorescein and macular edema in areas of membrane formation.34,35 This finding suggests damage of vascular endothelial cells in the blood–retinal barrier. In this study, no relationships were found between the presence of PVD, the severity of the ERM and the intravitreal tryptase levels, and the levels of anti-IIC antibodies. Due to the small number of patients involved in this clinical study, further investigations are needed to evaluate the relevant questions.

Although further studies are necessary to elucidate why mast cell production of tryptase is increased, as well as why serum anti-IIC antibodies are increased, in patients with ERM, the present findings suggest that at least these two biologically active substances may be involved in the pathogenesis of ERM. In ERM, a disease for which there is very little prior biochemical research data, the results of this present study may serve as a clue to further clarify the pathogenesis of the disease. Of note, previous studies have shown that toll-like receptors, which play an important role in natural immunity, are also expressed in mast cells.36–39 Thus, further investigation of the association between ERM and natural immunity is needed.