| Literature DB >> 26060411 |
Deborah L Couldwell1, David A Lewis1.
Abstract
Mycoplasma genitalium is an important cause of non-gonococcal urethritis, cervicitis, and related upper genital tract infections. The efficacy of doxycycline, used extensively to treat non-gonococcal urethritis in the past, is relatively poor for M. genitalium infection; azithromycin has been the preferred treatment for several years. Research on the efficacy of azithromycin has primarily focused on the 1 g single-dose regimen, but some studies have also evaluated higher doses and longer courses, particularly the extended 1.5 g regimen. This extended regimen is thought to be more efficacious than the 1 g single-dose regimen, although the regimens have not been directly compared in clinical trials. Azithromycin treatment failure was first reported in Australia and has subsequently been documented in several continents. Recent reports indicate an upward trend in the prevalence of macrolide-resistant M. genitalium infections (transmitted resistance), and cases of induced resistance following azithromycin therapy have also been documented. Emergence of antimicrobial-resistant M. genitalium, driven by suboptimal macrolide dosage, now threatens the continued provision of effective and convenient treatments. Advances in techniques to detect resistance mutations in DNA extracts have facilitated correlation of clinical outcomes with genotypic resistance. A strong and consistent association exists between presence of 23S rRNA gene mutations and azithromycin treatment failure. Fluoroquinolones such as moxifloxacin, gatifloxacin, and sitafloxacin remain highly active against most macrolide-resistant M. genitalium. However, the first clinical cases of moxifloxacin treatment failure, due to bacteria with coexistent macrolide-associated and fluoroquinolone-associated resistance mutations, were recently published by Australian investigators. Pristinamycin and solithromycin may be of clinical benefit for such multidrug-resistant infections. Further clinical studies are required to determine the optimal therapeutic dosing schedules for both agents to effect clinical cure and minimize the risk of emergent antimicrobial resistance. Continual inappropriate M. genitalium treatments will likely lead to untreatable infections in the future.Entities:
Keywords: Mycoplasma genitalium; fluoroquinolone; macrolide; non-gonococcal urethritis; resistance; treatment failure
Year: 2015 PMID: 26060411 PMCID: PMC4454211 DOI: 10.2147/IDR.S48813
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Infect Drug Resist ISSN: 1178-6973 Impact factor: 4.003
Clinical efficacy studies of tetracycline/doxycycline, alone or versus macrolides, for treatment of Mycoplasma genitalium infection
| Reference | Year | Study type | Population | Tetracycline regimen(s) and | Macrolide regimen and | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Horner et al | 1993 | Prospective case–control study | 164 men with/without NGU attending an STI clinic, UK | 27 men | DOXY 200 mg d 1, 100 mg d 2–d 9 | Not applicable |
| Johannisson et al | 2000 | Uncontrolled observational study | 233 men and 85 women attending STI clinics, Sweden | 18 men | TET 500 mg 12 hourly ×10 d | Not applicable |
| Gambini et al | 2000 | Prospective study with treatment varying by room | 201 men with/without NGU attending an STI clinic, Italy | 53 men | DOXY 200 mg/day ×7 d | AZM 1 g stat |
| Falk et al | 2003 | Uncontrolled observational study | 519 men and 464 women attending an STI clinic, Sweden | 34 men | DOXY 200 mg d 1, 100 mg d 2–d 9 or LYME 300 mg 12 hourly ×10 d | AZM 500 mg d 1, 250 mg d 2–d 5 |
| Björnelius et al | 2008 | Uncontrolled observational study | 152 men with NGU and 60 women with cervicitis attending 6 STI clinics, Norway and Sweden | 152 men | DOXY 200 mg (d 1), 100 mg (d 2–d 9) | AZM 1 g stat |
| Mena et al | 2009 | Randomized controlled trial | 398 men with NGU attending an STI clinic, USA | 78 men | DOXY 100 mg 12 hourly ×7 d | AZM 1 g stat |
| Schwebke et al | 2011 | Randomized controlled trial | 305 men with NGU attending 4 STI clinics, USA | 94 men | DOXY 100 mg 12 hourly ×7 d (± tinidazole 2 g stat) | AZM 1 g stat (± tinidazole 2 g stat) |
| Manhart et al | 2013 | Randomized controlled trial | 606 men with NGU attending an STI clinic, USA | 80 men | DOXY 100 mg 12 hourly ×7 d (+ AZM placebo) | AZM 1 g stat (+ DOXY placebo) |
Abbreviations: M. genitalium, Mycoplasma genitalium; NGU, non-gonococcal urethritis; STI, sexually transmitted infection; DOXY, doxycycline; TET, tetracycline; LYME, lymecycline; AZM, azithromycin; d, day/days; mITT, modified intention to treat population.
Clinical efficacy studies of fluoroquinolones, alone or versus macrolides, for treatment of Mycoplasma genitalium infection
| Reference | Year | Study type | Population | Fluoroquinolone regimen(s) and | Macrolide regimen(s) and | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yasuda et al | 2005 | Uncontrolled observational study | 97 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 97 men | LVFX 100 mg 8 hourly ×7 d or 14 d | Not applicable |
| Jernberg et al | 2005 | Uncontrolled observational study | 5,423 men and 4,683 women attending an STI clinic, Norway | 234 men | OFX 200 mg 12 hourly ×10 d | AZM 1 g stat |
| Bradshaw et al | 2006 | Prospective case–control study | 636 men with/without NGU attending an STI clinic, Australia | 34 men | MXF 400 mg daily ×10 d (following AZM 1 g stat on basis of persistent urethral symptoms) | AZM 1 g stat |
| Bradshaw et al | 2008 | Uncontrolled observational study | 1,538 men and 313 women attending an STI clinic, Australia | 161 men | MXF 400 mg daily ×10 d (following AZM 1 g stat on basis of persistent urethral symptoms) | AZM 1 g stat |
| Takahashi et al | 2011 | Uncontrolled observational study | 87 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 5 men | LVFX 500 mg daily ×7 d | Not applicable |
| Hamasuna et al | 2011 | Uncontrolled clinical trial | 169 men with NGU attending urology clinics, Japan | 18 men | GFLX 200 mg 12 hourly ×7 d | Not applicable |
| Ito et al | 2012 | Uncontrolled clinical trial | 89 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 14 men | STFX 100 mg 12 hourly ×7 d | Not applicable |
| Terada et al | 2012 | Uncontrolled retrospective study | 257 women with | 257 women | MXF 400 mg daily ×7 d | AZM 1 g stat |
| Takahashi et al | 2013 | Uncontrolled clinical trial | 208 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 16 men | STFX 100 mg 12 hourly ×7 d | Not applicable |
| Bissessor et al | 2015 | Prospective cohort study | 160 patients with | 112 men | MXF 400 mg daily ×10 d | AZM 1 g stat |
Notes:
Six of the seven patients who failed MXF therapy were treated with pristinamycin at a dose of 1 g 6 hourly ×10 d; these six patients were M. genitalium polymerase chain reaction-negative at 28 d post-pristinamycin therapy.
Abbreviations: NGU, non-gonococcal urethritis; STI, sexually transmitted infection; PID, pelvic inflammatory disease; LVFX, levofloxacin; TFLX, tosufloxacin; GFLX, gatifloxacin; STFX, sitafloxacin; OFX, ofloxacin; MXF, moxifloxacin; AZM, azithromycin; CAM, clarithromycin; M. genitalium, Mycoplasma genitalium; SR, slow release; d, day/days.
Laboratory studies of Mycoplasma genitalium antimicrobial susceptibility and genotypic resistance testing
| Reference | Year | Study type | Population | Macrolide resistance (MIC data/resistance mutations | Fluoroquinolone resistance (MIC data/resistance mutations | Comments | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bradshaw et al | 2006 | Prospective case–control study | 9 men with NGU attending an STI clinic, Australia | 4 isolates | All 4 isolates had raised MICs to macrolides (AZM >8 mg/L, ERY >32 mg/L, CAM >32 mg/L) | Not applicable | 8/9 men experienced improvement/resolution of symptoms before NGU recurrence; one was persistently asymptomatic |
| Jensen et al | 2008 | Laboratory analysis | 12 AZMR DNA extracts | 7/7 isolates persisting after azithromycin therapy had raised MICs to macrolides (AZM ≥8 mg/L, ERY ≥16 mg/L, CAM ≥16 mg/L) | Not applicable | None | |
| Chrisment et al | 2012 | Uncontrolled retrospective study | 136 patients with | 115 DNA extracts | 13 23S rRNA gene mutations reported: 9 at position 2059 (6 A2059G, 2 A2059T, 1 A2059C); | Not applicable | None |
| Shimada et al | 2010 | Uncontrolled retrospective study | 308 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 28 DNA extracts | Not applicable | Single substitutions reported in the | None |
| Shimada et al | 2011 | Uncontrolled retrospective study | 308 men with NGU attending a urology clinic, Japan | 25 DNA extracts | 4 23S rRNA gene mutations reported: 1 at position 2059 (A2059G); 3 at position 2185 (T2185G) | Not applicable | The A2158G mutation is not associated with macrolide resistance in other bacteria. Amino acid substitutions reported in the L4 and L22 ribosomal proteins of unknown significance. The strain with the A2059G mutation was cured with AZM 1 g |
| Ito et al | 2011 | Laboratory analysis | 7 men with | 7 DNA extracts | 4 23S rRNA gene mutations reported: 2 at position 2059 (A2059G); 2 at position 2058 (A2058G) | Not applicable | All 7 men had no AZMR mutations in pretreatment |
| Walker et al | 2013 | Longitudinal study | 1,100 women attending 29 primary care clinics, Australia | 33 DNA extracts | Unspecified 23S rRNA gene mutations were reported in 2/27 pretreatment samples from patients cured with AZM 1 g stat, and also in the test-of-cure samples of 3/3 patients who failed AZM 1 g stat therapy | Not applicable | Women were recruited in the Chlamydia Incidence and Re-infection Rates Study. |
| Twin et al | 2012 | Laboratory analysis | 82 pretreatment and 20 post-treatment samples from patients with clinical treatment failure attending an STI clinic, Australia | 102 DNA extracts | 16/82 pretreatment samples had 23S rRNA gene mutations (A2058G, A2059G, A2059C) 20/20 post-treatment samples from patients failing AZM therapy had 23S rRNA gene mutations (12 A2059G, 7 A2058G, 1 A2059C) | Not applicable | Mutations detected by high resolution melt analysis that may not have been able to detect the type 4 SNP (A-to-T) at position 2058 |
| Gesink et al | 2012 | Uncontrolled observational study | 314 participants recruited through telephone and community initiatives, Greenland | 26 DNA extracts | Single 23S rRNA gene mutations reported in 26/26 | Not applicable | None |
| Tagg et al | 2013 | Laboratory analysis | 143 initial and 43 follow-up | 186 DNA extracts | 62/143 (43.4%) initial DNA extracts had 23S rRNA gene mutations at either position 2058 (21 A2058G, 2 A2058T, 1 A2058C), or 2059 (38 A2059G) | 1/143 (0.7%) had | The matched initial DNA extract for 8/23 follow-up specimens with 23S rRNA mutations did not have evidence of these same AZMR mutations |
| Couldwell et al | 2013 | Uncontrolled observational study | 33 patients attending a STI clinic with | 32 DNA extracts | 15/32 (46.9%) had 23S rRNA gene mutations at position 2058 (A2058G, A2058T) or position 2059 (A2059G) | 6/32 (18.8%) had | Transmitted macrolide resistance was reported in 4/20 (20.0%) of samples from patients who had not received AZM pretreatment. None of the study group reported prior fluoroquinolone use |
| Yew et al | 2011 | Laboratory analysis | 11 | 9 DNA extracts | 4/9 (44.4%) had A2059G mutations in the 23S rRNA gene | Not applicable | Unable to amplify 23S rRNA genes of 2/11 known |
| Anagrius et al | 2013 | Uncontrolled retrospective study | 11 patients testing positive for | 8 DNA extracts | 1/8 (12.5%) pretreatment and 8/8 (100.0%) post-treatment samples had non-specified macrolide-associated 23S rRNA gene mutations | Not applicable | 2/10 pretreatment samples were missing and 1/10 pretreatment samples had insufficient DNA for amplification. The patient failing the extended azithromycin had macrolide mutations in the pretreatment DNA extract |
| Pond et al | 2014 | Uncontrolled observational study | 217 men with urethritis-related symptoms, UK | 22 DNA extracts | 23S rRNA gene mutations reported in 9/22 (40.9%) samples: 5 at position 2058 (A2058G); 9 at position 2059 (3 A2059G, 1 A2059C) | 1/22 (4.5%) had a | None |
| Kikuchi et al | 2014 | Laboratory analysis | 90 | 68 DNA extracts (macrolide resistance testing) | 23S rRNA gene mutations reported in 5/68 (7.4%) samples: 4 at position 2058 (A2058G); 1 at position 2059 (A2059G) | 5/51 (9.8%) had | The significance of the reported C356A mutation is unclear as it is outside the fluoroquinolone resistance-determining region |
| Salado-Rasmussen and Jensen | 2014 | Uncontrolled retrospective survey | 1,008 patients from general practice, private specialists and hospitals with | 1,085 DNA extracts | 385/1,008 (35.5%) patients had macrolide resistance; A2058G (61%) and A2059G (35%) were the most common mutations | Not applicable | None |
| Hay et al | 2015 | Laboratory analysis | 601 women attending primary health care clinics, South Africa | 41 DNA extracts | A2058G mutations reported in the 23S rRNA gene of 4/41 (9.8%) DNA extracts tested | Not applicable | None |
Notes:
Mutation positions are according to Escherichia coli numbering;
mutation positions are according to M. genitalium G37 genome (GenBank accession number NC000908.2).
Abbreviations: M. genitalium, Mycoplasma genitalium; NGU, non-gonococcal urethritis; STI, sexually transmitted infection; AZM, azithromycin; CAM, clarithromycin; ERY, erythromycin; AZMS, azithromycin-susceptible; AZMR, azithromycin-resistant; SNP, single nucleotide polymorphism; MIC, minimum inhibitory concentration.