Mohamed S Nassar1, Srinivas A Narayan2, Andrew Nyman2, Caner Salih2, Conal B Austin2, David Anderson3, Tarique Hussain3. 1. Department of Cardiovascular Imaging, Division of Imaging Sciences and Biomedical Engineering, King's College, London, United Kingdom; Evelina London Children Hospital, Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom; Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt. Electronic address: dinassar@yahoo.com. 2. Evelina London Children Hospital, Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom. 3. Department of Cardiovascular Imaging, Division of Imaging Sciences and Biomedical Engineering, King's College, London, United Kingdom; Evelina London Children Hospital, Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Hybrid palliation for hypoplastic left heart syndrome has been developed as an alternative to neonatal Norwood surgery. At the second stage, a source of pulmonary blood flow has to be established. Options include an arterial modified Blalock-Taussig or a venous superior cavopulmonary shunt. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed patients who received second-stage palliation after the initial hybrid. Patients were stratified according to the source of pulmonary blood supply into the arterial shunt (n = 17 patients) or venous shunt (n = 26 patients). RESULTS: Age and weight at second stage were lower in the arterial group (85 [45-268] days vs 152.5 [61-496] days, P = .001 and 3.6 [2.7-9.4] kg vs 5.1 [2.97-9.4] kg, P = .001, respectively). All recorded surgical times were shorter in the arterial group. Mechanical ventilation and intensive care stay were shorter in the venous group (5.82 [2.01-14.9] days vs 2.42 [0.56-13.67] days, P = .005 and 8.5 [3.6-23.7] vs 5.75 [0.8-17.6] days, P = .036, respectively) There was no difference in mortality (2/17 vs 5/26; P = .685) or incidence of complications between the 2 groups. There was a tendency toward a higher need for intervention in the immediate postoperative period in the venous group, but this did not reach significance (6/17 vs 13/26, P = .342). The arterial group has shown better development of the branch pulmonary arteries with a higher lower lobe index (158.38 ± 39.43 mm(2)/m(2) vs 113.33 ± 43.96 mm(2)/m(2), respectively, P = .037). CONCLUSIONS: Both arterial and venous shunts are viable options with mortality and morbidity results comparable to those in the literature. The arterial shunt pathway (2-stage Norwood I) may offer better pulmonary arterial growth than the venous shunt (comprehensive/combined Norwood I and II).
OBJECTIVE: Hybrid palliation for hypoplastic left heart syndrome has been developed as an alternative to neonatal Norwood surgery. At the second stage, a source of pulmonary blood flow has to be established. Options include an arterial modified Blalock-Taussig or a venous superior cavopulmonary shunt. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed patients who received second-stage palliation after the initial hybrid. Patients were stratified according to the source of pulmonary blood supply into the arterial shunt (n = 17 patients) or venous shunt (n = 26 patients). RESULTS: Age and weight at second stage were lower in the arterial group (85 [45-268] days vs 152.5 [61-496] days, P = .001 and 3.6 [2.7-9.4] kg vs 5.1 [2.97-9.4] kg, P = .001, respectively). All recorded surgical times were shorter in the arterial group. Mechanical ventilation and intensive care stay were shorter in the venous group (5.82 [2.01-14.9] days vs 2.42 [0.56-13.67] days, P = .005 and 8.5 [3.6-23.7] vs 5.75 [0.8-17.6] days, P = .036, respectively) There was no difference in mortality (2/17 vs 5/26; P = .685) or incidence of complications between the 2 groups. There was a tendency toward a higher need for intervention in the immediate postoperative period in the venous group, but this did not reach significance (6/17 vs 13/26, P = .342). The arterial group has shown better development of the branch pulmonary arteries with a higher lower lobe index (158.38 ± 39.43 mm(2)/m(2) vs 113.33 ± 43.96 mm(2)/m(2), respectively, P = .037). CONCLUSIONS: Both arterial and venous shunts are viable options with mortality and morbidity results comparable to those in the literature. The arterial shunt pathway (2-stage Norwood I) may offer better pulmonary arterial growth than the venous shunt (comprehensive/combined Norwood I and II).