PURPOSE: The purpose of this paper is to explore the readiness of contracted and non-contracted first-level healthcare facilities in Pakistan to deliver quality maternal and neonatal health (MNH) care. A balanced scorecard (BSC) was used as the assessment framework. DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: Using a cross-sectional study design, two rural health centers (RHCs) contracted out to Aga Khan Health Service, Pakistan were compared with four government managed RHCs. A BSC was designed to assess RHC readiness to deliver good quality MNH care. In total 20 indicators were developed, representing five BSC domains: health facility functionality, service provision, staff capacity, staff and patient satisfaction. Validated data collection tools were used to collect information. Pearson χ2, Fisher's Exact and the Mann-Whitney tests were applied as appropriate to detect significant service quality differences among the two facilities. FINDINGS: Contracted facilities were generally found to be better than non-contracted facilities in all five BSC domains. Patients' inclination for facility-based delivery at contracted facilities was, however, significantly higher than non-contracted facilities (80 percent contracted vs 43 percent non-contracted, p=0.006). PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: The study shows that contracting out initiatives have the potential to improve MNH care. ORIGINALITY/VALUE: This is the first study to compare MNH service delivery quality across contracted and non-contracted facilities using BSC as the assessment framework.
PURPOSE: The purpose of this paper is to explore the readiness of contracted and non-contracted first-level healthcare facilities in Pakistan to deliver quality maternal and neonatal health (MNH) care. A balanced scorecard (BSC) was used as the assessment framework. DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: Using a cross-sectional study design, two rural health centers (RHCs) contracted out to Aga Khan Health Service, Pakistan were compared with four government managed RHCs. A BSC was designed to assess RHC readiness to deliver good quality MNH care. In total 20 indicators were developed, representing five BSC domains: health facility functionality, service provision, staff capacity, staff and patient satisfaction. Validated data collection tools were used to collect information. Pearson χ2, Fisher's Exact and the Mann-Whitney tests were applied as appropriate to detect significant service quality differences among the two facilities. FINDINGS: Contracted facilities were generally found to be better than non-contracted facilities in all five BSC domains. Patients' inclination for facility-based delivery at contracted facilities was, however, significantly higher than non-contracted facilities (80 percent contracted vs 43 percent non-contracted, p=0.006). PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: The study shows that contracting out initiatives have the potential to improve MNH care. ORIGINALITY/VALUE: This is the first study to compare MNH service delivery quality across contracted and non-contracted facilities using BSC as the assessment framework.
Entities:
Keywords:
Balanced scorecard; Contracting; Maternal and neonatal health; Pakistan; Quality care; Rural health centres
Authors: Faten Amer; Sahar Hammoud; David Onchonga; Abdulsalam Alkaiyat; Abdulnaser Nour; Dóra Endrei; Imre Boncz Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-06-10 Impact factor: 4.614
Authors: Sanam Zulfiqar Mcnojia; Sarah Saleem; Anam Feroz; Kausar S Khan; Farnaz Naqvi; Shiyam Sunder Tikmani; Elizabeth M McClure; Sameen Siddiqi; Robert L Goldenberg Journal: Reprod Health Date: 2020-01-13 Impact factor: 3.223
Authors: Faten Amer; Sahar Hammoud; Haitham Khatatbeh; Huda Alfatafta; Abdulsalam Alkaiyat; Abdulnaser Ibrahim Nour; Dóra Endrei; Imre Boncz Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-07-26 Impact factor: 4.614