Karen Pierce1, Steven Marinero2, Roxana Hazin2, Benjamin McKenna3, Cynthia Carter Barnes2, Ajith Malige2. 1. Department of Neurosciences, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California.. Electronic address: kpierce@ucsd.edu. 2. Department of Neurosciences, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California. 3. Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, California.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Clinically and biologically, autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is heterogeneous. Unusual patterns of visual preference as indexed by eye tracking are hallmarks; however, whether they can be used to define an early biomarker of ASD as a whole or leveraged to define a subtype is unclear. To begin to examine this issue, large cohorts are required. METHODS: A sample of 334 toddlers from six distinct groups (115 toddlers with ASD, 20 toddlers with ASD features, 57 toddlers with developmental delay, 53 toddlers with other conditions [e.g., premature birth, prenatal drug exposure], 64 toddlers with typical development, and 25 unaffected toddlers with siblings with ASD) was studied. Toddlers watched a movie containing geometric and social images. Fixation duration and number of saccades within each area of interest and validation statistics for this independent sample were computed. Next, to maximize power, data from our previous study (n = 110) were added for a total of 444 subjects. A subset of toddlers repeated the eye-tracking procedure. RESULTS: As in the original study, a subset of toddlers with ASD fixated on geometric images >69% of the time. Using this cutoff, sensitivity for ASD was 21%, specificity was 98%, and positive predictive value was 86%. Toddlers with ASD who strongly preferred geometric images had 1) worse cognitive, language, and social skills relative to toddlers with ASD who strongly preferred social images and 2) fewer saccades when viewing geometric images. Unaffected siblings of ASD probands did not show evidence of heightened preference for geometric images. Test-retest reliability was good. Examination of age effects suggested that this test may not be appropriate with children >4 years old. CONCLUSIONS: Enhanced visual preference for geometric repetition may be an early developmental biomarker of an ASD subtype with more severe symptoms.
BACKGROUND: Clinically and biologically, autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is heterogeneous. Unusual patterns of visual preference as indexed by eye tracking are hallmarks; however, whether they can be used to define an early biomarker of ASD as a whole or leveraged to define a subtype is unclear. To begin to examine this issue, large cohorts are required. METHODS: A sample of 334 toddlers from six distinct groups (115 toddlers with ASD, 20 toddlers with ASD features, 57 toddlers with developmental delay, 53 toddlers with other conditions [e.g., premature birth, prenatal drug exposure], 64 toddlers with typical development, and 25 unaffected toddlers with siblings with ASD) was studied. Toddlers watched a movie containing geometric and social images. Fixation duration and number of saccades within each area of interest and validation statistics for this independent sample were computed. Next, to maximize power, data from our previous study (n = 110) were added for a total of 444 subjects. A subset of toddlers repeated the eye-tracking procedure. RESULTS: As in the original study, a subset of toddlers with ASD fixated on geometric images >69% of the time. Using this cutoff, sensitivity for ASD was 21%, specificity was 98%, and positive predictive value was 86%. Toddlers with ASD who strongly preferred geometric images had 1) worse cognitive, language, and social skills relative to toddlers with ASD who strongly preferred social images and 2) fewer saccades when viewing geometric images. Unaffected siblings of ASD probands did not show evidence of heightened preference for geometric images. Test-retest reliability was good. Examination of age effects suggested that this test may not be appropriate with children >4 years old. CONCLUSIONS: Enhanced visual preference for geometric repetition may be an early developmental biomarker of an ASD subtype with more severe symptoms.
Authors: Fabiënne Naber; Marian J Bakermans-Kranenburg; Marinus H van Ijzendoorn; Claudine Dietz; Emma van Daalen; Sophie H N Swinkels; Jan K Buitelaar; Herman van Engeland Journal: Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2008-04 Impact factor: 4.785
Authors: Thomas W Frazier; Eric W Klingemier; Sumit Parikh; Leslie Speer; Mark S Strauss; Charis Eng; Antonio Y Hardan; Eric A Youngstrom Journal: J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2018-09-13 Impact factor: 8.829
Authors: Thomas W Frazier; Eric W Klingemier; Mary Beukemann; Leslie Speer; Leslie Markowitz; Sumit Parikh; Steven Wexberg; Kimberly Giuliano; Elaine Schulte; Carol Delahunty; Veena Ahuja; Charis Eng; Michael J Manos; Antonio Y Hardan; Eric A Youngstrom; Mark S Strauss Journal: J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2016-02-04 Impact factor: 8.829
Authors: Michael V Lombardo; Lisa Eyler; Adrienne Moore; Michael Datko; Cynthia Carter Barnes; Debra Cha; Eric Courchesne; Karen Pierce Journal: Elife Date: 2019-12-17 Impact factor: 8.140