Daily oscillations of pulmonary function depend on the rhythmic activity of the circadian timing system. Environmental tobacco/cigarette smoke (CS) disrupts circadian clock leading to enhanced inflammatory responses. Infection with influenza A virus (IAV) increases hospitalization rates and death in susceptible individuals, including patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). We hypothesized that molecular clock disruption is enhanced by IAV infection, altering cellular and lung function, leading to severity in airway disease phenotypes. C57BL/6J mice exposed to chronic CS, BMAL1 knockout (KO) mice and wild-type littermates were infected with IAV. Following infection, we measured diurnal rhythms of clock gene expression in the lung, locomotor activity, pulmonary function, inflammatory, pro-fibrotic and emphysematous responses. Chronic CS exposure combined with IAV infection altered the timing of clock gene expression and reduced locomotor activity in parallel with increased lung inflammation, disrupted rhythms of pulmonary function, and emphysema. BMAL1 KO mice infected with IAV showed pronounced detriments in behavior and survival, and increased lung inflammatory and pro-fibrotic responses. This suggests that remodeling of lung clock function following IAV infection alters clock-dependent gene expression and normal rhythms of lung function, enhanced emphysematous and injurious responses. This may have implications for the pathobiology of respiratory virus-induced airway disease severity and exacerbations.
Daily oscillations of pulmonary function depend on the rhythmic activity of the circadian timing system. Environmental tobacco/cigarette smoke (CS) disrupts circadian clock leading to enhanced inflammatory responses. Infection with influenza A virus (IAV) increases hospitalization rates and death in susceptible individuals, including patients with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). We hypothesized that molecular clock disruption is enhanced by IAV infection, altering cellular and lung function, leading to severity in airway disease phenotypes. C57BL/6J mice exposed to chronic CS, BMAL1 knockout (KO) mice and wild-type littermates were infected with IAV. Following infection, we measured diurnal rhythms of clock gene expression in the lung, locomotor activity, pulmonary function, inflammatory, pro-fibrotic and emphysematous responses. Chronic CS exposure combined with IAV infection altered the timing of clock gene expression and reduced locomotor activity in parallel with increased lung inflammation, disrupted rhythms of pulmonary function, and emphysema. BMAL1 KO mice infected with IAV showed pronounced detriments in behavior and survival, and increased lung inflammatory and pro-fibrotic responses. This suggests that remodeling of lung clock function following IAV infection alters clock-dependent gene expression and normal rhythms of lung function, enhanced emphysematous and injurious responses. This may have implications for the pathobiology of respiratory virus-induced airway disease severity and exacerbations.
Influenza virus, rhinovirus, coronavirus, respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza,
adenovirus and metapeumovirus are among the respiratory viruses known to cause
exacerbations in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) and asthma1234. In fact, respiratory viral infections account for about
50–70% of acute exacerbations in patients with COPD5. COPD
exacerbations are often followed by subsequent clinical pulmonary deterioration,
including significant declines in forced expiratory volume at 1 second (FEV1)
and increased hospitalization or mortality6. This is associated with
worsening of COPD phenotypes, such as cough, fever and mucus production; the timing of
which depends on the activity of the biological clock.Circadian rhythms are biological oscillations that occur with a near-24-h period and are
synchronized or entrained to environmental cues, such as the day-night cycle7. These rhythms are the manifestation of an autoregulatory molecular
oscillator of interlocked positive and negative transcription factors collectively
referred to as clock genes8. In mammals, the central pacemaker, localized
to the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) of the anterior hypothalamus, drives rhythms of
physiology and behavior, and synchronizes internal timing with the external
environment7. Apart from the central clock, peripheral tissues such
as the liver, heart and the lung also contain autonomous circadian oscillators that
coordinate tissue specific cellular functions and responses to environmental
stimuli789101112. As an example, circadian rhythms in
pulmonary function have been demonstrated in animal models and healthy individuals
(highest at noon time and low during the early morning hours)131415.
The coordinated and synchronized activity of central and peripheral oscillators is
referred to as the circadian timing system912. It has been shown that
recruitment of leukocytes to tissues following infection is also regulated by the
circadian timing system1617. For example, macrophages and mast cells
exhibit robust rhythms of circadian clock and proinflammatory cytokine gene
expression1819. The magnitude of immune and inflammatory parameters
varies with time of day, and disruption of circadian rhythms (chronodisruption) has been
implicated in cellular dysfunction, and in the pathogenesis of chronic metabolic
disease, infection, and inflammatory diseases202122.An early morning surge in lung function and pronounced troughs in forced vital capacity
(FVC), FEV1 and peak expiratory flow (PEF) during the night are common in
patients with COPD exacerbations, including chronic smokers2324. This
could be due to cigarette smoke (CS)-mediated alterations in circadian clock proteins,
levels of steroid hormones, surfactants in the lungs, mucus retention/secretion
accompanied by increased inflammatory responses and a decline in normal rhythms of lung
function15252627. Disruption of pulmonary function rhythms
during COPD exacerbations commonly results in emergency room visits at night or in early
morning hours when lung function is low152526. In addition to a
decline in lung function, patients with COPD have other sleep-related abnormalities,
such as insomnia, excessive daytime sleepiness and altered rhythms of airway caliber and
resistance28. Lung function is also altered following viral
infections, including influenza A virus (IAV29), and IAV is known to
increase the intensity and duration of exacerbations in those patients with COPD.
However, the effect of virus-induced COPD exacerbations on clock function in the lung
and the role of the lung clock in the pathogenesis of COPD and associated exacerbations
are unknown.We hypothesize that IAV infection exacerbates the effects of chronic CS-induced
COPD/emphysema. Moreover, we hypothesize the negative consequences of IAV infection in
chronic smokers and patients with COPD may be due to the combined influence of CS and
influenza infection on circadian clock function in the lungs. To address these
hypotheses, we measured body weight, mortality, locomotor activity, rhythms of clock and
clock-controlled gene (CCG) expression in the lungs, lung function rhythms, inflammation
and emphysematous responses of mice exposed to chronic CS with or without subsequent IAV
infection. Further, to more directly assess the role of the timing system in response to
infection, we measured activity, body weight, mortality, inflammation and emphysematous
responses in the lungs of BMAL1 knockout mice and WT littermates following IAV
infection.
Results
The negative effects of Influenza A virus infection on body weight,
mortality and locomotor activity are exacerbated following chronic CS
exposure
Chronic (6 months) air- and CS-exposed mice were infected intranasally with 120
HAU IAV (H3N2). Before infection (Day 0), we did not observe a significant
difference in body weight among the experimental groups. The body weight of mice
in both IAV-infected groups dropped significantly on days 1–3
post-infection, with a slightly more dramatic decline in the CS+Virus group
(Fig. 1a). This suggests that chronic CS-exposed mice
exhibited greater mortality following IAV infection. Indeed, IAV infection in
chronic CS-exposed mice produced a 14.1% reduction in survival within 9 days of
infection (Fig. 1b). As reported, there was no significant
difference in the body weight and mortality between the chronic air- and
CS-exposed mice30. We found that chronic air and CS-exposed mice
infected with IAV showed significant reduction in body weight compared to
corresponding controls at the end of chronic exposure or day 9 post-infection
(Supplementary Fig. 2b). Thus, while IAV infection alone
(Air+Virus) has modest effects, infection of mice following chronic CS exposure
(COPD/emphysema model) significantly increases mortality.
Figure 1
Influenza A virus infection differentially affects body weight, mortality and
behavior in chronic air or CS-exposed mice.
Data from uninfected air- and CS-exposed mice from a previous experiment were
included for comparison [panels c–e;30]. (a) Chronic CS-exposed mice infected
with IAV showed a modest reduction in weight, marked by a decline on days
1–3 post-infection relative to air-exposed mice infected with
IAV. (b) Mortality was monitored for 9 days post IAV infection. Data
are representative of mean ± SEM (n = 30–40
mice/group). ** P < 0.01 significant compared to Air+Virus
group. Analysis of differences in survival over time was determined by a
Mantel-Cox test (P < 0.68). (c) Nocturnal activity
for 9 days post-infection was plotted as ambulatory counts. IAV infection
reduced locomotor activity in CS-exposed mice by 70–80% during
days 1–7 post-infection when compared to CS-exposed mice treated
with saline. Similarly, IAV infection reduced locomotor activity in
CS-exposed mice by 70–80% on days 1–2 and day 4
post-infection but only 30–45% during days 5–9
post-infection when compared to Air+Virus treated mice. Data are mean
± SEM (n = 6 mice/group) for each time point. ** P
< 0.01; *** P < 0.001 significant compared to
control groups (air or Air+Virus); $$ P <
0.01 significant compared to air-exposed mice; #
P < 0.05; # #
P < 0.01; # # # P < 0.001
significant compared to CS-exposed mice. (d) Representative double
plotted actograms of total cage activity from chronic air, chronic CS,
Air+Virus and CS+Virus treated mice. In panel d, gray shading
indicates the dark phase (ZT12-24) and activity was not recorded during body
weight measurements (ZT5-6). Red arrow head indicates day 0 IAV infection
and asterisks denotes the time during which the mice were infected with IAV
(ZT4-6). (e) Periodogram analysis of activity in L:D during days
1–8 post IAV infection. Period was very similar between air and
CS groups, whereas the Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups showed increased
variation in period though the mean was not significantly different from
controls. Data are mean ± SEM (n = 6 mice/group).
We have previously reported that mice exposed to 10 days of CS (acute exposure
model) during the active phase show reduced locomotor activity associated with
increased inflammation30. Similarly, mice exposed to chronic CS
showed significantly reduced activity beginning 5 days after the first exposure
that persisted for much of the exposure period30. In the present
study, chronic CS-exposed mice infected with IAV (CS+Virus) showed a significant
reduction in locomotor activity after infection that persisted for the duration
of measurement (9 days post-infection; Fig.
1c–d). Chronic air-exposed mice infected with influenza
(Air+Virus) showed an initial reduction in locomotor activity 1–5
days after infection with a trough 5–6 days after infection followed
by a modest recovery by day 9 after infection (Fig.
1c–d). Actograms clearly reveal that the CS+Virus group
showed significantly reduced locomotor activity post-infection (lower right
panel) when compared to Air+Virus, air- and CS-exposed mice (Fig.
1d and Supplementary Fig. 2a). Limiting our
analysis to the dark phase reveals that the primary influence of IAV infection
was a reduction in nighttime activity, which was further suppressed in those
mice previously exposed to chronic CS (Fig. 1c). The
period of locomotor activity in L:D during days 1–8 post IAV
infection was very similar between air and CS groups, whereas the Air+Virus and
CS+Virus groups showed increased variation in period between animals although
the mean was not statistically different from controls (Fig.
1e). Analysis of behavior as a function of daily distribution (day
vs. night) emphasizes the effect of IAV treatment in vivo (Supplementary Fig. 3a-d). Control (air) and Air+Virus infected mice
were primarily active (70–80% activity) during the dark phase and
less active (20–30%) during the light phase from day 2 to day 9
post-saline infusion (Supplementary Fig. 3a and c). In three
of the four groups, we detected a transient change in the distribution of
activity on day 1 post-infusion regardless of treatment, suggesting that the
infusion procedure acutely and temporarily altered activity (Supplementary Fig. 3a–d). In agreement with our previous
report, chronic CS-exposed mice displayed a distribution of locomotor activity
similar to air-exposed mice with the majority (70–80%) of activity
limited to the dark phase (Supplementary Fig. 3b)30. Following IAV infection in chronic CS-exposed mice nighttime
activity declined and daytime activity increased from days 3–7
post-infection such that we detected no difference between day and night
activity levels by day 7 (Supplementary Fig. 3d). By day
8–9 post-infection the CS+Virus mice showed recovery of their normal
nighttime (70–80%) and daytime (20–30%) distribution of
activity (Supplementary Fig. 3d).
The negative effects of Influenza A virus infection are enhanced in BMAL1
knockout mice
To dissect the role of clock regulatory proteins in response to respiratory
infection, we measured the response of BMAL1 KO mice and wild-type littermates
to IAV infection. Similar to mice that had been exposed to CS, BMAL1 KO and WT
littermates were infected intranasally with 120 HAU (H3N2) IAV. Before IAV
infection (Day 0), there was no significant difference in body weight between WT
and BMAL1 KO mice (Fig. 2a). The body weight of WT and
BMAL1KO IAV infectedmice dropped by day 2 post-infection and remained low
until day 8 post-infection when compared to control mice of both strains (Fig. 2a). BMAL1KO-Virus infectedmice showed increased
mortality beginning 5 days post-infection and by day 9 all of the BMAL1 KO mice
infected with IAV was deceased (Fig. 2b). WT-Virus
infected mice showed increased mortality beginning 7 days post-infection and
reached a total of 38.5% mortality by day 9 post-infection (Fig.
2b). There was a significant difference in the body weight and
mortality of WT-Virus compared to BMAL1KO-Virus infectedmice. This suggests
that BMAL1 plays an important role in the host response to IAV infection.
Further, our data suggest that circadian disruption may enhance the severity of
infection, resulting in increased morbidity and mortality.
Figure 2
Influenza A virus infection differentially affects body weight, mortality and
behavior in wild-type (WT) and BMAL1 KO mice.
(a) IAV infection significantly reduced body weight of both WT and
BMAL1 KO mice on day 2–9 post-infection compared to uninfected
controls. * P < 0.05; ** P < 0.01; ***
P < 0.001 significant compared to WT-Saline or BMAL1
KO-Saline; (b) Mortality was increased following IAV infection in
both WT and BMAL1 KO mice, reaching 100% in BMAL1 KO mice within 9 days
post-infection. Data are representative of mean ± SEM (n = 10
WT-Saline; n = 4 BMAL1 KO-Saline; n = 13 WT-Virus; n = 13 BMAL1 KO-Virus).
Survival over time was analyzed with a Mantel-Cox test (P
< 0.001). (c) Nocturnal activity of IAV infected mice
(both WT and BMAL1 KO) was reduced on days 1–8 post-infection
when compared to uninfected controls. ***P < 0.001
significant compared to uninfected controls; $ P
< 0.05; $$ P < 0.01 significant
compared to WT-Saline treated mice; ††
P < 0.01 significant compared to WT-Virus infected mice.
(d) Representative double plotted actograms showing considerable
reduction in total cage activity of IAV infected WT and BMAL1 KO mice
relative to uninfected controls. In panel d, gray shading indicates
the dark phase (ZT12-24) and activity was not recorded during body weight
measurements (ZT5-6). Red arrow head indicates day 0 IAV infection and
asterisks denotes the time during which the mice were infected with IAV
(ZT4-6). (e) Periodogram analysis of activity in L:D was calculated
during days 1–8 post-infection. Though there was no overall
effect of IAV infection on period in either group an increase in variation
was detected following infection in BMAL1 KO mice. Data are mean
± SEM (n = 10 WT-Saline; n = 13WT-Virus; n = 4 BMAL1 KO-Saline; n
= 13 BMAL1 KO-Virus).
Locomotor activity of BMAL1 KO and WT littermates was monitored before (5 days)
and after IAV infection (1–9 days post-infection). Regardless of
genotype, IAV infection significantly reduced activity (Fig.
2c–d and Supplementary Fig. 2b). Both
BMAL1 KO and WT mice showed significant reductions in daily activity on days
1–9 post-infection (Fig. 2c–d and
Supplementary Fig. 2b). The period of locomotor activity
in L:D on days 1–8 post IAV infection was very similar between all
four groups, though IAV infectedBMAL1 KO mice had greater variability in period
relative to the other treatment groups (Fig. 2e). Analysis
of behavior as a function of daily distribution (day vs. night) emphasizes
treatment and genotype specific effects (Supplementary Fig.
4a–d). As expected, WT-saline treated mice were mostly
active during the dark phase (ZT12-24; 70–80% of total activity)
while BMAL1 KO-saline treated mice appeared to be arrhythmic and displayed a
more even distribution of activity, though levels were still slightly higher at
night (Supplementary Fig. 4a–b). IAV infection
altered the normal distribution of daily activity in both WT and BMAL1 KO mice,
though the effects were clearly more dramatic in WT mice (Supplementary Fig. 4c-d). WT mice infected with IAV increased their
daytime activity but reduced their nighttime activity, producing apparent
arrhythmia marked by a near equal distribution of activity across the 24h day
(50% light; 50% dark). This effect of IAV infection on daily activity was less
pronounced in BMAL1 KO mice, due largely to the fact that these mice already
displayed a more equal distribution of daily activity/arrhythmia. That said,
within 2 days of infection mean activity was actually higher in BMAL1 KO mice
during the light phase, suggesting a brief period of diurnal preference
following IAV infection (Supplementary Fig. 4d). This effect
was diminished by day 3–4 post-infection with mice becoming more
active during the night 5–9 days post-infection in parallel with
increased mortality. These data reveal that, though BMAL1 KO mice differ from WT
mice in terms of activity distribution prior to infection (most likely due to
entrainment deficits in KO mice) both strains show reduced nocturnal preference
following IAV infection.
Influenza A virus affects the phase and amplitude of circadian clock gene
expression in the lungs
We have previously reported that core clock genes (bmal1, clock, per1-2,
cry1-2, rev-erbα) were rhythmically expressed in the lung of
air- and CS-exposed mice both during acute and chronic CS exposure30. Of the known core clock genes, only rorα gene
expression was not rhythmic in lungs of chronic air- and CS-exposed mice30. The peaks of gene expression rhythms for most clock genes in
air-exposed controls were similar to those previously reported3031. In both the chronic air- and CS-exposed mice, the
expression of bmal1, clock, and cry1 displayed nocturnal
acrophases, peaking during the mid to late portion of the dark phase (ZT18-24;
ZT0 = lights on: ZT12 = lights off)30. As anticipated, both
chronic air- and CS-exposed mice showed peaks of per1, per2, cry2,
rev-erbα, and rev-erbβ antiphase to
bmal1 (between ZT6-ZT12)30. Chronic CS-exposed mice
showed a modest reduction in the amplitude of bmal1 and
rev-erbα expression and substantially reduced amplitude of
per1 expression30. Analysis of clock gene expression 9
days after IAV infection in air-exposed mice (Air+Virus) revealed significant
rhythms of bmal1 (P < 0.001), per1, per2, cry1
and rev-erbβ (P < 0.05) but not clock,
cry2, rev-erbα and rorα in lung tissue
(Fig. 3a–b, Supplementary
Fig. 5 and Table 1). Mice exposed to chronic CS and IAV infection
(CS+Virus) only displayed rhythms of bmal1 (P < 0.01)
and per1 (P < 0.05) expression in the lungs (Fig. 3a–b, Supplementary Fig. 5 and
Table 1). Previously reported data from air-exposed mice are shown
here for comparison (Fig. 3a–b, Supplementary Fig. 5 and Table 1). In Air+Virus infected mice, the
peak expression of bmal1, per1, per2, cry1, cry2, and
rev-erbβ shifted to the middle of the light phase (ZT6;
ZT0 = lights on; ZT12 = lights off) and the amplitude of gene expression was
altered at ZT6 when compared to air-exposed controls and chronic CS+Virus group
(Fig. 3a–b, Supplementary
Fig. 5a-b). As in Air+Virus treated mice, expression of bmal1,
clock and rev-erbβ was shifted to peak at mid-day
(ZT6) in CS+Virus exposed mice (Fig. 3b and Supplementary Fig. 5b). However, unlike Air+Virus treated mice, the
phase of peak per1 and cry2 expression returned to ZT12 and the
remaining clock genes [per2, cry1, rev-erbα and
rorα] peaked at middle of dark phase (ZT18).
Together, these data support the notion that IAV induces circadian disruption in
the lungs, though the effects appear to be somewhat attenuated in mice exposed
to chronic CS (Fig. 3a–b and Supplementary Fig. 5a–b).
Figure 3
Diurnal rhythms of clock gene expression in the lungs are differentially
affected by chronic CS and IAV infection.
Data from uninfected air-exposed mice from a previous experiment were
included for comparison [panels a-b;30]. Lung tissues were harvested every 6 h for 24 h beginning at
ZT0 day 9 post-infection. (a) Expression of core clock genes
(bmal1, clock, per1, cry1, and rev-erbα) in
mouse lung tissue. CircWave analysis confirmed statistically significant
rhythms of clock gene expression in Air+Virus (P < 0.05
for per1 and cry1; P < 0.001 for
bmal1) and CS+Virus (P < 0.05 for per1;
P < 0.01 for bmal1) treated mice. (b)
IAV infection adjusted the phase of clock gene expression in a gene- and
treatment- (Air vs. CS) dependent manner. Center of gravity (COG) or
peak phase for each clock gene was plotted on a horizontal phase map. In
panels a and b, gray shading indicates the relative dark phase (ZT12-24).
Data from air-exposed (open circle), Air+Virus (gray square) and CS+Virus
(solid diamond) mice are representative of mean ± SEM (n = 3-4
mice/group) for each time point. * P < 0.05; ** P
< 0.01; *** P < 0.001 significant compared to
Air group. # #
P < 0.01; significant compared to Air+Virus group.
(c) Effect of CSE and IAV infection on the amplitude and period
of PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue explants. PER2::LUC expression in
representative lung tissue explants treated with medium alone (control),
0.1% CSE, virus alone (IAV, 300 HAU/ml), and 0.1% CSE+Virus. Treatment at
the time of culture with 0.1% CSE and 0.1% CSE+Virus dampened the rhythm of
PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue. Treatment with 0.1% CSE had a small
effect whereas IAV infection significantly increased the period of PER2::LUC
expression in lung explants. This effect was attenuated in explants treated
with 0.1% CSE and IAV. Different colored traces represent tissue explants
from different animals. Data are representative of mean ± SEM (n
= 12-15/group). * P < 0.05 significant compared to control
group; #
P < 0.05 significant compared to Virus group.
Table 1
Center of gravity (COG) values and significance for each clock gene and other
gene expression rhythm as determined by CircWave analysis in chronic air- and
CS-exposed mice infected with influenza A virus
Clock gene
COG of Air+Virus ± SD
P- value for Air+Virus
COG of CS+Virus ± SD
P- value for CS+Virus
Bmal1
6.809 ± 2.219
0.0002***
6.803 ± 1.763
0.013**
Clock
0.807 ± 2.617
NS
5.569 ± 2.829
NS
Per1
2.582 ± 2.368
0.024*
13.792 ± 3.503
NS
Per2
3.577 ± 1.967
0.034*
20.847 ±2.698
NS
Cry1
3.841 ± 2.201
0.038*
21.688 ± 2.682
NS
Cry2
1.057 ± 2.500
NS
10.463 ± 3.315
NS
Rev-erbα
21.883 ± 2.4961
NS
16.362 ± 2.973
NS
Rev-erbβ
4.507 ± 1.907
0.037*
2.296 ± 2.686
NS
Rorα
2.130 ± 2.666
NS
21.104 ± 3.095
NS
Other genes
Sirt1
3.599 ± 2.383
0.041*
2.054 ± 3.118
NS
Ahr
0.919 ± 2.014
NS
0.908 ± 3.115
NS
Muc5 ac
13.563 ± 3.089
NS
13.190 ± 3.671
NS
Data are shown as mean ± SEM (n = 3-4 per group).
*P < 0.05, **P <
0.01, ***P < 0.001, significance of
rhythmicity as determined by CircWave analysis in Air+Virus
or CS+Virus exposed mice. NS, Not significant
We also determined the effects of CS with or without IAV infection on the
expression of CCGs including sirt1, ahr and muc5ac in the lungs (Supplementary Fig. 5c–d). We have previously
detected a circadian rhythm of sirt1 expression that was altered by acute
exposure to CS30. Herein we observed daily fluctuation of all
three CCGs but only ahr rhythmicity was confirmed by CircWave analysis
(P < 0.05). Though not statistically rhythmic in the
air-exposed lungs, CircWave analysis did confirm significant rhythms of
sirt1 (P < 0.05) in the Air+Virus group that was
attenuated by previous exposure to CS (Supplementary Fig. 5c-d and
Table 1). Further, we detected a shift in peak sirt1 and
ahr expression from the latter portion of the dark phase (ZT18) in
the air-exposed group to mid-day (ZT6) in both the Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups
(Supplementary Fig. 5d). In addition to these phase
shifts, there was an apparent increase in the amplitude of sirt1
expression following IAV infection (Supplementary Fig. 5c).
According to CircWave analyses muc5ac was not rhythmically expressed in
lung tissue regardless of treatment (Supplementary Fig.
5c).The effect of acute CS exposure combined with or without IAV infection on clock
gene expression in the lung was confirmed by real-time monitoring of PER2::LUC
expression in lung tissue explant cultures. Exposure to 0.1% cigarette smoke
extract (CSE) in vitro produced a modest reduction in the amplitude and
slight increase in the period of PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue explants in
agreement with our previous report30. Viral infection (300
HAU/ml) also significantly reduced the amplitude and increased the period of
PER2::LUC expression in lung explants (Fig. 3c). We
observed comparable effects of 0.1% CSE+Virus similar to 0.1% CSE treatment
alone in the amplitude and period of PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue
explants (Fig. 3c). There was a significant reduction in
the period of PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue explants treated with 0.1%
CSE+Virus compared to IAV infection alone (Fig. 3c).
Overall, CSE+Virus and IAV infection alone both reduced the amplitude and
differentially affected the period of PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue
explants.
Infection with IAV increases macrophages, lymphocytes and CS-mediated
inflammatory responses in the lungs
As previously reported, similar levels of virus-specific antibodies were present
in the blood of both Air+Virus and CS+Virus infected mice32. To
investigate whether IAV infection after chronic CS exposure alters the
inflammatory status in mouse lung, we measured the number of leukocytes in lung
bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid 9 days post-infection. We observed more total
cells, macrophages and lymphocytes near the end of the dark phase (ZT24) in the
CS+Virus group when compared to Air+Virus, air- and CS-exposed mice (Fig. 4a–c). There was also a significant increase
in neutrophils at ZT24 in chronic CS-exposed mice compared to air-exposed
control. That is, in the absence of infection, there was an increase in
neutrophils; however, this was not observed on day 9 of infection (Fig. 4d).
Figure 4
Chronic CS-exposed mice infected with influenza A virus show increased
inflammatory cell influx and proinflammatory cytokine release in BAL
fluid.
Data from chronic (6 months) air- or CS-exposed mice given intranasal
inoculation of either saline (control group) or influenza A virus (IAV;
treatment group) at ZT4-6 are shown. Data from uninfected air- and
CS-exposed mice from a previous experiment were included for comparison
[panels a–d;30]. The
total number of inflammatory cells was determined in BAL fluid from air, CS,
Air+Virus and CS+Virus infected mice on day 9 post-infection. At least 500
cells in the BAL fluid were counted to determine (a) total cells,
(b) total macrophages, (c) total lymphocytes and
(d) total neutrophils. Data are representative of mean
± SEM (n = 3-4 mice/group) for each time point. * P
< 0.05, *** P < 0.001 significant compared to
air-exposed mice; $
P < 0.05 significant compared to air-exposed mice;
# # #
P < 0.001 significant compared to CS-exposed mice. Levels
of proinflammatory mediators (e) MCP-1, (f) MIP-2 and
(g) IL-6 levels were measured in BAL fluid obtained from air, CS,
Air+Virus and CS+Virus infected mice. IAV infection of chronic CS-exposed
mice alters diurnal rhythms of proinflammatory cytokine release in mouse
lungs. Data are representative of mean ± SEM (n = 3-4 mice/group)
for each time point. * P < 0.05; ** P <
0.01; *** P < 0.001 significant compared to air or
Air+Virus groups; #
P < 0.05; # #
P < 0.01; # # #
P < 0.001 significant compared to CS-exposed mice.
We next determined the impact of chronic CS exposure followed by IAV infection on
rhythms of proinflammatory cytokine release in BAL fluid. MCP-1, IL-6 and MIP-2
levels were measured in BAL fluid at day 9 post-infection across the 24h day.
The CS+Virus group showed significant increases in the expression of MCP-1 at
ZT6 and ZT24 when compared to Air+Virus and air-exposed controls (Fig. 4e). We observed a significant decline in the levels of
proinflammatory cytokines MIP-2 at ZT0 and ZT12 and IL-6 at ZT12 in the
Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups 9 days post-infection compared to uninfected
CS-exposed mice (Fig. 4f–g). Chronic CS-exposed
mice showed significant increases in the levels of IL-6 and MIP-2 that peaked at
ZT12 compared to air-exposed controls (Fig.
4f–g). Overall, IAV infection dampened the total number of
neutrophils, MIP-2 and IL-6 levels, while it increased the total number of
macrophages, lymphocytes and MCP-1 levels by day 9 post-infection. CircWave
analysis confirmed significant diurnal rhythms of both IL-6 and MIP-2 levels in
BAL fluid from chronic CS-exposed mice (P < 0.01). In
contrast, chronic air-exposed, Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups did not show
rhythmic expression of MCP-1, IL-6 and MIP-2 in BAL fluid as confirmed by
CircWave analysis. The increase in levels of cytokines that we observed on day 9
post-infection was associated with influx of inflammatory cells in the lung in
CS+Virus and chronic CS-exposed mice (Fig. 4a–g
and Supplementary Fig. 6a-d).We have also analyzed proinflammatory cytokine release in BAL fluid by pooling
time points according to photoperiod (ZT6+ZT12 = daytime and ZT18+24 =
nighttime) for MCP-1, MIP-2, IL-6 and TGF-β1. Chronic CS-exposed mice
showed a significant increase in the levels of MIP-2, IL-6 at ZT6+ZT12 (daytime)
and TGF-β1 at ZT18+ZT24 (nighttime) compared to controls (Supplementary Fig. 6a–d). Chronic CS-exposed mice
infected with IAV showed a significant increase in the level of MCP-1 both at
ZT6+ZT12 (daytime) and ZT18+ZT24 (nighttime). The levels of other cytokines
including MIP-2, IL-6 and TGF-β1 were significantly reduced in
CS+Virus group compared to CS-exposed mice at ZT6+ZT12 (Supplementary Fig. 6a-d). Thus, our data show that disruption of
circadian clock function in the lung was associated with augmented MCP-1 levels
during IAV-induced exacerbation in chronic CS-exposed mice.To further examine the role of circadian regulatory factors on host responses to
infection, we determined the total number of leukocytes in the airways.
Consistent with prior reports, there was a significant increase in total cells,
macrophages, lymphocytes and neutrophils in BAL fluid from WT-Virus infectedmice compared to WT-Saline treated mice (Supplementary Fig.
7a–d). However, we were unable to evaluate immune cells in
lungs of infected BMAL1 KO mice due to 100% mortality in this group by day-9
post-infection (see Fig. 2b). Because we observed a
significant increase in inflammatory cellular influx into the lung of IAV
infected WT mice, we next determined the level of proinflammatory
cytokines/chemokines in BAL fluid. WT-Virus infectedmice showed a significant
increase in release of proinflammatory mediators such as IL-6, MCP-1, IP-10, KC,
IL-10, and TNFα when compared to WT-Saline treated mice (Supplementary Fig. 8). The change in the lung proinflammatory
mediators in BAL fluid observed at day 9 post-infection was correlated with
influx of inflammatory cells in the lung (Supplementary Fig. 7a-d
and Supplementary Fig. 8). Thus, our data show correlation of
alteration in inflammatory cells in the lung with augmented pro-inflammatory
cytokine responses during IAV infection in vivo.
Influenza A virus augments chronic cigarette smoke-mediated inflammation
and fibrosis
Chronic CS exposure enhanced IAV induced inflammatory responses, as observed by
increases in peribronchial and perivascular inflammatory cell infiltration in
the airways (Fig. 5a). Mucus hypersecretion in the airways
is an important characteristic pathological feature during acute exacerbation of
COPD and is a key facet of inflammation-induced airway obstruction33. We determined the degree of mucus production in the airways of
Air+Virus and CS+Virus infected mice at day 9 post-infection. Mucus-producing
PAS positive cells were significantly increased in airway epithelium of chronic
CS+Virus infected mice compared to Air+Virus infected mice that displayed a
paucity of mucus producing cells in the airway epithelium (Fig.
5b). Trichrome staining demonstrated significant increases in airway
fibrosis in mice exposed to CS+Virus with increase in collagen deposition
observed around the airways (Fig. 5c). Further, we
detected a significant increase in α-SMA levels, a marker for
activated myofibroblasts observed in fibrotic lung disease, in the fibrotic
regions of the lung from both air and CS-exposed mice infected with IAV (Supplementary Fig. 9a). These characteristic features suggest
that IAV infection of mice previously exposed to chronic CS results in
exaggerated lung inflammation and fibrotic airway remodeling in vivo. It
has been documented that after IAV infection, epithelial damage induced by the
virus could be repaired in order to completely restore lung structure and
function in vivo. Clara cell specific marker, CCSP was used to identify
changes that occur during virus infection in the airway bronchial epithelial
cell population. At day 9 post-infection, we observed a significant decrease in
the expression of CCSP positive cells in the airway bronchial epithelium of
chronic CS+Virus infected mice compared to Air+Virus, air- and CS-exposed mice
(Supplementary Fig. 9a).
Figure 5
Chronic CS-exposed mice infected with IAV show persistent inflammation, mucus
hypersecretion, and pulmonary fibrosis.
Data from chronic (6 months) air- or CS-exposed mice given intranasal
inoculation of either saline (control group) or influenza A virus (IAV;
treatment group) at ZT4-6 are shown. Lungs were harvested on day 9
post-infection. (a) Representative images of lung tissues stained
with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) to demonstrate parenchymal and
bronchial airway inflammation. Bronchial inflammation scores were calculated
for each treatment group. (b) Representative images of lung tissues
stained with Periodic-acid Schiff (PAS) to visualize mucus overproduction
induced by IAV in the bronchial epithelium of chronic air- and CS-exposed
mice. Average mucus scores from 3–4 different areas per
slide/treatment group (n = 4-5mice/group) was used to calculate the
percentage of PAS positive cells. (c) Representative images of lung
tissues stained with Gomori’s Trichrome to visualize matrix
accumulation/collagen deposition and quantified by Ashcroft fibrosis score.
Original magnification x200. Data are representative of mean ±
SEM (n = 4-5 mice/group). * P < 0.05; ** P
< 0.01; significant compared to air- or CS-exposed mice. #
#
P < 0.01; # # #
P < 0.001; significant compared to air-exposed mice.
Influenza A virus exaggerates chronic cigarette smoke-mediated airspace
enlargement/emphysema and altered rhythms of lung function
To investigate the role of IAV-induced circadian clock disruption of the lungs
and the possible impact on lung airway remodeling and pulmonary function, we
examined airspace enlargement/emphysema by lung histopathologic and functional
measurements in chronic CS+Virus infected mice. There was a significant
difference in lung histopathological changes between chronic CS+Virus infected
mice and Air+Virus infected mice 9 days post-infection, which was confirmed with
measurements of the mean linear intercept (MLI; Air+Virus 43.27 ±
3.31 vs. CS+Virus 62.27 ± 3.20; P < 0.001; Supplementary Fig. 9b). These data suggest that IAV infection
and chronic CS exposure can synergistically enhance airway remodeling in
mice.We then determined the impact of IAV infection on diurnal rhythms of lung
function, including lung compliance, resistance and tissue elastance. We have
previously reported that when examined as a function of time of day (day vs.
night) chronic CS-exposed mice show significantly increased lung compliance and
reduced elastance, but resistance is not significantly reduced30.
When analyzed at specific time points across the day, elastance and resistance
were only significantly reduced at ZT18 in chronic CS-exposed mice30. Lung compliance was significantly decreased at ZT12 and ZT24 in
the CS+Virus group when compared to the Air+Virus group (Fig.
6a–b; Tables 2–3 and Supplementary Tables
1–3). There was a change in the phase and rhythms of lung
compliance in Air+Virus group when compared to air-exposed and chronic CS+Virus
infected mice (Fig. 6a–b; Tables 2–3 and Supplementary Tables 1–3). However, lung resistance
decreased significantly only at ZT6 in CS+Virus group as compared to Air+Virus
group (Fig. 6a–b; Tables
2–3 and Supplementary Tables 1–3). Tissue elastance was
significantly decreased at ZT6 and significantly increased at ZT24 in the
CS+Virus group when compared to the Air+Virus group (Fig.
6a–b; Tables 2–3 and Supplementary Tables
1–3). Similarly, there were significant alterations in the
phase and amplitude of lung resistance and tissue elastance rhythms in CS+Virus
group and Air+Virus group when compared to air-exposed controls (Fig. 6a–b; Table
2–3 and Supplementary Tables 1–3). Overall, when we combined the
data from day (ZT6 and ZT24) and night (ZT12 and ZT18), lung compliance was
significantly reduced whereas lung resistance and tissue elastance significantly
increased during the dark phase (ZT12-18) in CS+Virus group compared to
Air+Virus group (Fig. 6a–b; Tables 2–3 and Supplementary Tables 1–3). Thus, IAV infection appeared to
invert the phase of peak tissue elastance and resistance but not lung compliance
such that each marker of pulmonary function peaked during the light phase (when
the animal is generally sleeping; Fig. 6b). Exposure to CS
prior to IAV appeared to oppose this response, preventing the dramatic shifts
produced by IAV infection.
Figure 6
Daily rhythms of lung function are differentially affected by chronic
CS-exposure and influenza A virus infection.
Data from chronic (6 months) air- or CS-exposed WT mice given intranasal
inoculation of either saline (control group) or influenza A virus (IAV;
treatment group) at ZT4-6 are shown. Data from uninfected air-exposed mice
from a previous experiment were included for comparison [panels
a–b;30]. (a) Daily
rhythms of compliance, resistance and elastance were measured in air,
Air+Virus and CS+Virus mice. As in previous experiments, measurements were
taken on day 9 post-infection. (b) COG or peak phase values for each
measure of lung function were plotted on a horizontal phase map. Gray
shading in panels a and b indicates the relative dark phase (ZT12-24). Data
from air-exposed (open circle), Air+Virus (gray square) and CS+Virus (solid
diamond) are representative of mean ± SEM (n = 3-4 mice/group)
for each time point. ** P < 0.01; *** P
< 0.001, significant compared to Air+Virus; $
P < 0.05; $$$
P < 0.001 significant compared to air-exposed mice.
(c) Influenza A virus infection altered lung function in WT mice.
After day 9 post-infection, lung compliance, resistance and tissue elastance
were determined in WT-Saline, WT-Virus, BMAL1 KO-Saline and BMAL1 Het-Saline
(heterozygous) treated mice. Data are representative of mean ±
SEM (n = 10 WT-Saline; n = 8 WT-Virus, n = 4 BMAL1 KO-Saline and n = 6 BMAL1
Het-Saline) for each time point. *** P < 0.001,
significant compared to WT-Saline; #
P < 0.05; # #
P < 0.01 significant compared to WT-Virus.
Table 2
Center of gravity (COG) values and significance for rhythm of lung mechanical
properties as determined by CircWave analysis in chronic air alone, air- and
CS-exposed mice infected with influenza A virus
Mechanical Properties
Air‡
Air+Virus
CS+Virus
COG ± SD
P- value
COG ± SD
P- value
COG± SD
P-
value</emph>
Compliance
0.64 ± 3.01
0.001***
15.08 ± 3.61
0.005**
3.00
± 3.11
0.014**
Resistance
23.35 ± 3.04
NS
1.76
± 3.59
0.0001***
15.45 ± 3.70
0.005**
Elastance
23.35 ± 3.08
0.001***
3.84
± 3.59
0.004**
23.51 ± 3.39
0.023*
Data are shown as mean ± SEM (n = 3-4 per group).
*P < 0.05, **P <
0.01, ***P < 0.001, significance of
rhythmicity as determined by CircWave analysis in air or
Air+Virus or CS+Virus exposed mice. NS, Not significant
‡Data from animals exposed to air for 6 months
from a previous study were included here for comparison30.
Table 3
Lung mechanical properties measured during different ZTs in WT mice exposed
to chronic air and CS infected with influenza A virus
Sl. No.
ZT time (Hrs)
Lung Compliance
(mL/cmH2O)
Lung Resistance
(cmH2O.s/mL)
Tissue Elastance
(cmH2O/mL)
Air+Virus
CS+Virus
Air+Virus
CS+Virus
Air+Virus
CS+Virus
1.
ZT6
0.038 ± 0.003
0.052 ± 0.003 $
0.849 ± 0.018
0.683 ± 0.042
26.943 ± 1.775
19.587 ± 1.390
2.
ZT12
0.054 ± 0.002
0.041 ± 0.007 **,
†
0.673 ± 0.032
0.972 ± 0.181*,†
18.704 ± 0.643
27.801 ± 6.493*
3.
ZT18
0.047 ± 0.003
0.036 ± 0.012**,
††
0.748 ± 0.016
1.171 ± 0.365*, §,
††
21.464 ± 1.259
32.189 ± 11.074 §, †
4.
ZT24
0.048 ± 0.001
0.035 ± 0.004 **,
††
0.809 ± 0.016
0.783 ± 0.078 #
21.022 ± 0.337
28.697 ± 3.123
Data are shown as mean ± SEM (n = 2–4
per group). **P < 0.01, significant
compared to Air+Virus (ZT12); $
P < 0.05, significant compared to
Air+Virus (ZT6); *P < 0.05, significant
compared to Air+Virus (ZT12, and ZT18);
§
P < 0.05, significant compared to
Air+Virus (ZT12 and ZT24); †
P < 0.05, and
†† P
< 0.01, significant compared to CS+Virus
(ZT6); # P < 0.05,
significant compared to CS+Virus (ZT18).
BMAL1 KO mice show altered lung function and pro-fibrotic
responses
To investigate the role of the molecular clock in the response to IAV infection,
we measured lung compliance, resistance and tissue elastance in WT mice infected
with IAV on day 9 post-infection, uninfected BMAL1 heterozygous KO mice and
uninfected homozygous BMAL1 KO mice. Lung compliance was significantly decreased
in both WT-Virus and BMAL1 KO-Saline treated mice compared to WT-Saline and
BMAL1 Het-Saline treated mice (Fig. 6c). However, lung
resistance and tissue elastance were significantly increased in both WT-Virus
and BMAL1 KO-Saline treated mice (Fig. 6c). BMAL1
KO-Saline treated mice displayed a significant increase in lung compliance and
decrease in resistance and elastance when compared to WT-Virus infectedmice
suggesting an inherent defect in the lung mechanical properties of BMAL1 KO mice
in the absence of infection (Fig. 6c). In a separate
experiment, we determined lung function at different ZT (ZT0-ZT18; n = 1 mice/
ZT time point) in 2–3 months old BMAL1 KO mice and WT littermates. We
also performed differential cell counts in BAL fluid collected from WT and BMAL1
KO mice at all the four ZT time points. We averaged the cell counts data from
different time points and found that Bmal1 KO mice had a significant increase in
neutrophil counts compared to WT littermates (Supplementary Fig.
10a). Total cell counts and macrophage counts were not significantly
different between BMAL1 KO and WT littermates (Supplementary Fig.
10a).We measured the rhythms of lung mechanical properties in BMAL1 KO and WT
littermates at different ZT time points. BMAL1 KO mice showed similar peaks of
lung function measurements as air-exposed controls but each was significantly
altered (reduced compliance, increased resistance and elastance) compared to WT
littermates (Supplementary Fig. 10b). We found that BMAL1 KO
mice develop spontaneous pro-fibrotic lung phenotype as they age when compared
to WT littermates (Supplementary Fig. 10c). The development
of a fibrotic-like phenotype in BMAL1 KO mice could contribute to the altered
lung function we observed in these mice (Fig. 6c). Thus,
our data suggest that the clock gene activator BMAL1 may play an essential role
in maintaining normal pulmonary function. Influenza A virus infection in BMAL1
KO mice further enhance the severity of virus infection resulting in increased
morbidity and mortality.
Discussion
Patients with COPD display daily rhythms of symptom exacerbation affiliated with
sleep disruption343536. Given the daily nature of these
exacerbations and their impact on sleep quality, we hypothesized that disruption of
the biological timing system occurs during the etiology of COPD. We have previously
reported that rhythms of behavior (locomotor activity), hormone secretion (serotonin
and corticosterone) and clock gene expression in the lungs and brain are altered in
a mouse model of COPD due to environmental tobacco/cigarette smoke exposure3037. Influenza infection is also known to alter behavior3839 and has a negative influence on lung function29.
The immune-inflammatory system is regulated by the circadian clock at multiple
levels with immune and inflammatory responses showing robust daily oscillations2021. Though limited evidence suggests that IAV infection alters
sleep patterns via targeted effects on gene expression in particular hypothalamic
sleep centers40, it has yet to be determined if IAV infection alters
circadian clock function directly in the lungs or affects daily rhythms of lung
function. Further, the potential for exacerbation of COPD impacts on clock function
due to IAV infection has not been determined. Using a mouse model of COPD, we have
determined the impact of IAV infection alone or IAV infection comorbid with COPD on
clock function in the lungs, activity levels, inflammatory/injurious lung responses
and daily rhythms of lung function. To address the role of the clock during COPD
and/or infection, we carried out these experiments in bmal1 knockout mice
that lack a functioning oscillator. We demonstrate that IAV infection further
exacerbates the effects of COPD on clock function in the lungs and daily rhythms of
behavior. Further, our data reveal a potentially critical role for the circadian
clock in mitigating a normal immune response to IAV infection.Patients with COPD have poor sleep quality, increased sleep latency, decreased total
sleep time, increased waking after sleep onset and decreased non-REM and REM sleep
episodes36. These individuals are also commonly diagnosed with
sleep disorders including obstructive sleep apnea41. Psychological
distress in those with COPD is associated with a decline in lung function, increased
exacerbation frequency and worsening of cardiovascular disease, further disrupting
sleep in these patients34. Though our experiments did not directly
measure sleep per se (e.g. using polysomnographic recording), the
considerable reduction in activity during the day and night in both WT and BMAL1 KO
mice following IAV infection implies adaptive changes in the homeostatic or
circadian sleep drive that lead to increased inactivity during IAV infection. This
increase in sleep/reduced activity level could be as a result of immune/inflammatory
cell infiltration (e.g. macrophages) that can generate influenza-induced sleep
enhancement38. Alternative compensatory immune mechanisms that
generate an effective host defense response may also contribute to sleep propensity
during viral infection38. It has been suggested that altered
expression of Temt (thioether-S-methyltransferase) in the hypothalamus and
basal forebrain during IAV infection may influence sleep patterns through its
effects on prostaglandin metabolism42.We show for the first time that IAV infection alters circadian clock gene expression
in the lungs and reduces the amplitude of locomotor activity in a COPD/emphysemamouse model. The effect of IAV infection persisted longer (post-infection day
7–9) in chronic CS-exposed mice, coincident with a decrease in body
weight and increased mortality. BMAL1 KO mice infected with IAV also displayed a
significant decline in body weight and survival (100% mortality), suggesting that
proper function of the timing system is necessary for maintaining the innate immune
response to infection. Chronic air- and CS-exposed mice infected with IAV after 6
months of exposure and WT and BMAL1 KO mice infected with IAV show widely varying
changes in morbidity (weight) and mortality. This could be due to strain background-
and age-dependent effects of IAV infection. The mice were 2–3 months old
when we started the chronic air and CS exposure. At the end of chronic air and CS
exposure (6 months) and before IAV infection chronic air- and CS-exposed mice were
about 9–10 months old. Similarly, WT littermates and BMAL1 KO mice were
2–4 months old when they were infected with IAV. Hence, we speculate the
two confounding factors such as strain background and age of these mice when they
were infected with IAV play an essential role on the severity of IAV on the loss of
body weight and mortality in vivo. This notion is supported by studies
wherein circadian desynchronization due to experimental jet-lag increased
inflammatory responses and mortality following LPS challenge43. It is
evident that changes in the phase and amplitude of clock gene expression in the
lungs are affiliated with impaired lung function (compliance, resistance and tissue
elastance). Analysis of lung function rhythms clearly revealed a near inversion of
peak phase rhythms of lung function in Air+Virus group compared to air-exposed mice.
Though generally similar, prior exposure to CS (COPD) did not fully attenuate the
effects of IAV infection, as there were still slight differences in peak lung
functions in these mice. These changes in lung function rhythms may underlie the
reduced activity and increased mortality observed among IAV infectedmice.To assess the impact of IAV with or without CS exposure more directly, we examined
the influence of cigarette smoke extract (CSE) and influenza A virus
(300 HAU/ml) on PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue explants. As reported
earlier, CSE treatment at a very low dose (0.1%) tended to lengthen the period of
PER2::LUC expression in lung tissue explants, though the effect was modest.
Infection with IAV resulted in a significant increase in period when compared to
uninfected controls. Surprisingly, CSE treatment combined with IAV infection
attenuated the effect of IAV infection alone on the period but not the amplitude of
PER2::LUC expression in lung explants. Circadian disruption due to chronic jet lag
has been shown to alter lung mechanics and clock gene expression in the lungs in a
sexually dimorphic manner44. As a whole these data strongly suggest
that CS exposure and virus infection either alone or in combination can affect clock
function in the lungs. CS combined with IAV infection affects both lung CCGs and
pulmonary function akin to other models of circadian disruption, suggesting that
even a subtle change in clock function may have significant impact on
clock-dependent physiological processes in both the lungs and immune system1620214546. Though implied, direct support for a functional
link between rhythms of lung function and circadian clock gene expression in the
lungs remains elusive. While not conclusive evidence for such a link, the combined
and somewhat parallel impacts of IAV infection on pulmonary function and clock gene
expression in the lungs support the notion that the lung clock contributes in a
meaningful way to the timing of pulmonary physiology.It is well known that immune-inflammatory parameters change with time of day and
disruption of circadian rhythms has been associated with infectious and inflammatory
diseases202145. Studies from animal models highlight the
extent to which the core clock proteins (BMAL1, CLOCK and REV-ERBα)
regulate fundamental aspects of the immune-inflammatory response21,
such as toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9)46 and repressing chemokine (C-C
motif) ligand 2 (CCL2) expression47. Further, REV-ERBα has
been shown to attenuate the activation of IL-6 expression1947. It
has been shown that the core circadian clock protein was bound to nuclear factor
kappa B (NF-κB) RelA/p65 activating NF-κB-dependent
transcription48. Both transcription factors activator protein 1
(AP-1) and NF-κB share unique sequences that overlaps consensus sequence
from rev-erbα promoters demonstrating role of REV-ERBα
in regulating oxidative stress and/or inflammation49. These reports
suggest involvement of these proinflammatory gene regulatory transcription factors
and role of molecular clock on exaggerated inflammatory responses observed in our
mouse model of COPD.BMAL1 KO mice are behaviorally arrhythmic50 and show signs of advanced
aging and underlying pathologies, correlated with increased levels of ROS and
cellular senescence5152. We have recently shown that CS exposure
reduced mRNA and protein levels of BMAL1 and BMAL1-CC10 cre (epithelium specific
Bmal1 KO) with augmented inflammatory responses and dysregulation of CS-induced
oxidative stress. These data suggest the involvement of the molecular clock in
regulation of CS-induced lung inflammation30, which supports previous
work indicating that BMAL1 has an anti-inflammatory function1953.
Recently, ClockΔ19 circadian mutant mouse lung showed
altered temporal Nrf2 activity complemented with reduced GSH levels, increased
protein oxidation and a spontaneous fibrotic-like phenotype54. We
found that BMAL1 KO mice also develop a pro-fibrotic phenotype in the lung which
could be due to increased ROS levels and altered oxidative stress-mediated cellular
senescence5152. BMAL1 deletion in myeloid cells demonstrated
diurnal variation in the absolute number of specific monocytes
(Ly6Chi) in blood and in the spleen under normal conditions which
was enhanced during inflamed peritoneum at ZT8 versus ZT053. This
study also revealed that BMAL1 binds to E-boxes in the promoters of Ccl2,
Ccl8 and S100a8 (encoding S100 calcium binding protein A8) and
recruits with it members of the polycomb repressor complex (PRC2) thereby allowing
repressive histone marks to block transcription and attenuate Ly6Chi
monocyte numbers and inflammation at the site of damage53. It has
been shown that the number of leukocytes in the mouse circulation strongly
correlates with circadian variability, such that leukocyte numbers peak at ZT5 and
recruitment into the tissues peaks at ZT1317. Keller et al.
demonstrated that the role of entire toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) pathway in
peritoneal macrophages is tightly regulated under the control of circadian clock and
thus equip the immune cell to face exaggerated response at times18.
In the present study, analysis of clock gene expression revealed a significant
impact of IAV infection on the expression of core clock genes. There was also a time
of day-dependent increase in the number of total cells, macrophage counts and
lymphocyte counts following IAV infection of CS-exposed mice. In the present study,
the total numbers of inflammatory cells were significantly increased at ZT24 when
compared to ZT0 though they represent the same circadian phase. Previous reports
suggest that inflammatory cells in the lungs were significantly increased in BAL
fluid of mice euthanized 24 h after the last exposure compared to 2 h post-last CS
exposure5556. These findings suggests that CS exposure has a
suppressive effect on the number of inflammatory cells recovered in the lavage,
possibly due to capillary trapping or increased adhesion, which causes reduction in
the numbers recovered from the air spaces at ZT0 compared to ZT24. This finding is
supported by increased proinflammatory mediators released into the lung at 24 h
compared to 2 h after the last CS exposure, which would attract more inflammatory
cells into the lung interstitium during CS exposure.The proinflammatory cytokine MCP-1 response was also greater in the IAV infectedmice
exposed to CS. Similarly, chronic CS exposure also increased MIP-2 and IL-6 at
ZT6/12 when compared to controls. However, IL-6 and MIP-2 levels were dampened in CS
plus Virus group which could be due to immunosuppressive effects of CS which is in
line with recent report in which CS exposure suppressed the production of cytokines
and chemokines after pandemic H1N1 or avian H9N2virus infection in mice57. It has been shown that the IAV-mediated inflammatory response
begins early on day 3 and remains high until day 5–7 post-infection58. Subsequently, viral clearance occurs by day 10 in the lungs,
thereby resolving the inflammatory phenotype, such as inflammatory cellular influx
and proinflammatory mediators release observed during IAV infection in
vivo58. Hence, we did not observe significant increases in
pro-inflammatory mediators at day 9 post IAV infection in chronic air- and
CS-exposed mice. CS-exposed mice infected with IAV showed sign of severe pulmonary
inflammation, lung permeability damage and mucus hypersecretion which are
characteristic features of acute exacerbation of COPD5960. We have
previously reported that mainstream CS exposure at a concentration of
300 mg/m3 (TPM) for 8 weeks causes significant
increase in PAS positive cells in mouse lungs61. In this study, we
used a low dose side-stream smoke exposure
(~90–100 mg/m3) for 6 months, that unlike
mainstream smoke, does not cause mucus production in the chronic CS-exposed mouse
lungs when compared to Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups. A recent study identified a
regulatory mechanism, whereby the lung epithelial clock and glucocorticoid hormones
control both time-of-day variation and magnitude of pulmonary inflammatory responses
to bacterial infection62. Similarly, rhythms of pulmonary function
define time-of-day dependent sensitivity to steroids and β2-agonists in
patients with nocturnal asthma and asthmatics who smoke636465.
Hence, it is possible that the mechanism that couples the circadian clock and
bronchiolar glucocorticoid receptor to pulmonary innate immunity plays an essential
role during COPD exacerbations by IAV infection. These data suggest that temporal
increases in chemoattractants, leukocyte trafficking, proinflammatory
cytokines/chemokines, and phagocytic ability before the activity phase is indicative
of clock-controlled sensitivity and immunosurveillance. Collectively, these data
suggest that the molecular clock and associated transcription factors, epigenetic
regulators, and key regulatory signaling pathways play an essential role in cytokine
gene expression through temporal gating of immune responses.Several studies have examined the effects of acute CS exposure combined with IAV
infection5866676869. Only two prior reports determined
the effects of IAV infection combined with chronic CS exposure model7071. Robbins et al. were the first to show chronic CS affects
primary antiviral immune-inflammatory responses, yet secondary immune protection
remained intact suggesting exaggerated inflammatory responses during viral infection
might possibly influence decline in clinical status associated with COPD
exacerbations70. Wortham et al. demonstrated NKG2D
stimulation during chronic CS exposure plays an essential role in the development of
NK cell hyper-responsiveness and influenza-mediated exacerbations of COPD71. Based on the published studies, it is evident that both acute and
chronic CS exposure combined with influenza infection causes increased pulmonary and
systemic inflammation in vivo which was accompanied by increased viral
proliferation or reduced clearance5867. In this study, the dynamics
of viral proliferation were not affected; instead we observed an exaggerated
inflammatory response and apparent normalization of lung function rhythms in chronic
CS-exposed mice infected with IAV. The discrepancies observed in previous studies
include CS exposure protocols, dose and duration of CS exposure (acute vs. chronic),
viral dose (low and high) used, time of virus infection (ZT0-24) and duration
post-infection of analyses. Regardless of these discrepancies, these studies support
the fact that CS-induced inflammation plays a defining role in the initial
inflammatory responses to IAV infection in the lungs. It is possible that
IAV-mediated resetting of clock function in the lungs may influence the survival of
mice previously exposed to chronic CS. The re-alignment of many of the clock genes
following IAV infection may represent transient
‘sensitization’ of the timing system to an acute inflammatory
mediator1272. It is worth noting that, outside of
rorα, only those clock genes associated with the repressive function of
the clock (per1,2 and cry1,2) were in effect ‘phase-reset’ by
IAV. This suggests a disparate influence of IAV infection on the oscillator, a
phenomenon reported previously in response to dual entrainment by multiple cues in
the liver73.In conclusion, we show for the first time that IAV infection can cause temporally
gated circadian disruption associated with exaggerated lung inflammation and
injurious response in the lungs, culminating in exacerbations of COPD/emphysema. Our
in vivo model of COPD exacerbation clearly demonstrates how changes in
molecular clock function and immune responses can affect morbidity and mortality,
rhythms of locomotor activity, lung inflammation and small airway remodeling. The
role of the clock gene BMAL1 in COPD exacerbation was tested using the IAV infection
model. Overall, our findings clearly show that the circadian clock plays a crucial
role in modulating immune-inflammatory response during viral respiratory infection
in mice. The COPD exacerbation mouse model develops augmented inflammatory responses
and lung damage due to involvement of clock-dependent mechanisms that in turn affect
immune response and rhythms of lung function. Understanding molecular clock function
and its physiological significance in different animal models of chronic lung
disease, including our COPD exacerbation model, could hasten the development of
novel chronotherapeutic approaches for the treatment and management of COPD and
associated exacerbations.
Methods
All the methods were carried out in accordance with the NIH guidelines for the care
and use of laboratory animals. All of the experimental protocols were approved by
the University of Rochester Committee on Animal Resources (UCAR).
Animals
Male C57BL/6J (C57) and BMAL1 knockout (KO: B6.129-Arntltm1Bra/J)
mice were purchased from the Jackson Laboratory (Bar Harbor, ME). C57BL/6J and
BMAL1 KO mice were housed under a 12:12 light-dark (LD) cycle with lights on at
6 a.m. and fed with a regular diet and water ad libitum unless otherwise
indicated. For chronic (6 months) CS exposure, mice were kept in a standard
12:12 L:D cycle with lights on from 6 am-6 pm throughout the experiment. Data
from animals exposed to air/CS for 6 months from a previous study were included
here for comparison30.
Tobacco/cigarette smoke exposure and influenza A virus
infection
Eight week-old mice were used for tobacco/CS exposure as previously
described307475. We used chronic (6 mo. exposure which
causes pulmonary emphysema) CS exposure mouse models to determine the effect and
mechanism of chronic CS exposure followed by influenza virus infection on
circadian clock function and lung inflammation. Mice were exposed to CS using an
environmental side-stream delivering Teague TE-10 smoking machine (Teague
Enterprises, Davis, CA) for 6 months CS exposure in the Inhalation Facility at
the University of Rochester Medical Center. The smoke was generated from 3R4F
research cigarettes containing 11.0 mg of total particulate matter
(TPM), 9.4 mg of tar and 0.73 mg of nicotine per cigarette
(University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY). The total particulate matter (TPM) in
per cubic meter of air in exposure chamber was monitored in real-time with a
MicroDust Pro-aerosol monitor (Casella CEL, Bedford, UK), and verified daily by
gravimetric sampling307475. Control mice were exposed to
filtered air in an identical chamber according to the same protocol described
for CS exposure. For chronic 6 months CS exposures, 3R4F cigarettes were used to
generate a mixture of sidestream smoke (89%) and mainstream smoke (11%) at a
concentration of ~100 mg/m3 TPM, so as to avoid the
possible toxicity to mice at a high concentration of long-term CS exposure3074 according to the Federal Trade Commission protocol
(1 puff/min of 2 second duration and 35 ml volume). Each
smoldering cigarette was puffed for 2 seconds, once every minute for a total of
5 puffs, at a flow rate of 1.05 L/min, to provide a standard puff of
35 cm3. Mice received 5-hour exposures per day, 5
days/week for the duration of exposure and were sacrificed at 6-hour intervals
24h after the last CS exposure.After 6 months chronic Air/CS exposure, mice were intranasally infected under
anesthesia (Avertin; 2,2,2-tribromoethanol; Sigma-Aldrich) with 120
hemagglutination units (HAU) of influenza A virus (IAV), strain HKx31 (x31;
H3N2) in 25 µl sterile PBS as previously described3276. Mock-infected control group mice received
25 µl of sterile PBS alone. After infection, survival and
body weight of all the experimental groups were monitored and recorded daily
until post-infection day 9. Mice were euthanized post-infection day 9 at 6 hour
intervals for 24 hours (5 time points: ZT0, ZT6, ZT12, ZT18 and ZT24). The 6-hr
sampling interval was based on prior studies on circadian gene expression in
mice3037. Schematic for chronic CS exposure combined with
IAV infection and IAV infection in BMAL1 KO and wild-type littermates including
parameters measured from these experiments are included in the Supporting
information (see Supplementary Fig. 1a-b).
Locomotor activity recording
Mice were individually housed and allowed free access to food and water.
Locomotor activity was measured using the Photobeam Activity System (San Diego
Instruments, San Diego, CA), a computerized system that measures the frequency
of photobeam breaks along the side of the cage. Total cage activity (photobeam
break) activity was recorded in 1-min intervals and analyzed using ClockLab
software (Actimetrics, Evanston IL) as previously described30.
Circadian periodicity of locomotor activity in L:D was calculated during days
1-8 post IAV infection with a χ2 periodogram analysis
(tau range 20–28 h).
Real-Time Luminescence recording
Adult male Period2::luciferase knock-in (PER2::LUC) mice77 were
euthanized three hours before lights-off (Zeitgeber Time 9–12, lights
off = ZT12) by excess CO2 exposure. Portions of the lung were removed
and collected in cold sterile Hanks balanced salt solution (HBSS). Small
5 mm3 fragments of lung tissue were isolated. Lung
tissues were placed in 35mm culture dishes with 1.2 ml of culture
medium [DMEM supplemented with B27 (Gibco), 10 mM HEPES,
352.5 μg/ml NaHCO3, 3.5 mg/ml D- glucose,
25 U/ml penicillin, 25 μg/ml streptomycin and
0.1 mM luciferin (Promega)]. Cultures were prepared with
clean media as described above (control) or the same media containing cigarette
smoke extract (CSE 0.1%), media containing 300 HAU influenza A virus ( and
sealed with sterile vacuum grease and a glass coverslip. Sealed cultures were
maintained at 35 °C in a light-tight incubator and luminescence was
continuously recorded (counts/sec) with an automated luminometer (LumiCycle,
Actimetrics). Raw luminescence data were detrended (24 h moving average) and
smoothed (2 h moving average; Origin Pro 8.5, OriginLabs, Northampton, MA) as
previously described30.
Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL)
Mice were anesthetized at 24 h after the last exposure or on day 9 post-infection
by an intraperitoneal injection with 100 mg/kg (BW) of pentobarbital
sodium (Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, IL) and sacrificed by exsanguination.
The heart and lungs were removed en bloc, and the lungs were lavaged
three times with 0.6 ml of saline (0.9% sodium chloride) via a
cannula inserted into the trachea as described previously7578.
The lavaged fluid was centrifuged, and the cell-free supernatants were frozen at
−80°C for later analysis. The BAL inflammatory cell pellet
was resuspended in 1 ml saline and the total cell number was counted
using a hemocytometer. Cytospin slides (Thermo Shandon, Pittsburgh, PA) were
prepared using 50,000 cells per slide, and differential cell counts (~500
cells/slide) were performed on cytospin-prepared slides stained with Diff-Quik
(Dade Behring, Newark, DE).
Proinflammatory mediators analysis
The levels of proinflammatory mediators, such as CCL2/monocyte chemotatic protein
1 (MCP-1), CXCL2/macrophage inflammatory protein 2 (MIP-2), interleukin 6 (IL-6)
and TGF-β1 in bronchioalveolar lavage fluid were measured by
enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using respective duo-antibody kits
(R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN) according to the
manufacturer’s instructions. The results were expressed in the
samples as pg/ml.
Histological analysis, Periodic Acid-Schiff (PAS) staining,
immunohistochemistry and trichrome staining
Fixed tissues were H&E stained for inflammation scoring and mean
linear intercept analysis. Histological analysis of H&E stained
slides were used to determine bronchial inflammation using a semi-quantitative
method. Briefly, the intensity of bronchial inflammation was scored on a scale
of 1 to 9. 0, for no inflammation; 1–3 for scant cells but not
forming a defined layer; 4–6, for one to three layers of cells
surrounding the vessels; 7–9, for four or greater layers of cells
surrounding the vessel or bronchial area. For each treatment multiple lung lobes
from n = 4-5 slide/group were scored and average values were presented as
bronchial inflammation scores.Similarly airway mucus was identified by the Periodic Acid-Schiff (PAS) staining
(Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) and PAS positive cells were quantified by a
semi-quantitative method with slight modification as previously described61. In brief, airways were examined under light microscopy and
assigned a score between 0 and 3 based on the following criteria: 0, for no
staining; 1, for PAS staining <25% of airway perimeter; 2, for PAS
staining 25 to <50% of airway perimeter; and 3, for PAS staining
>50% of airway perimeter. Mucus scores were obtained by scoring
3–4 different areas per slide from n = 4-5 slide/group. The average
from all the areas scored per each treatment group was used to calculate the
percentage of PAS positive cells.Immunostaining was performed on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded lung tissue.
Paraffin sections (4 µm thick) were deparaffinized and
then rehydrated through series of xylene and graded ethanol. Antigen retrieval
was performed by heating in citrate buffer (10 mM Citric acid, 0.05%
Tween 20, pH 6.0). Primary antibody was incubated overnight at 4°C
with rabbit anti-CCSP polyclonal antibody (Seven Hills Bioreagents, Cincinnati,
OH) and mouse anti α-smooth muscle actin (Abcam, Cambridge, MA)
antibodies32747679. Appropriate fluorescently labeled
secondary antibodies (FITC- or Texas red-conjugated 2° antibodies)
were used to detect the immune complexes before tissues sections were
counterstained with 4’,d-diamidino-2-phenylindole (dapi).Gomori’s trichrome staining was performed according to the
manufacturer’s instructions (Richard-Allan Scientific, Kalamazoo,
MI). The nuclei stains black, cytoplasm and muscle fibers in red and the
collagen deposition stains blue. Both double immunostaining and trichrome
stained tissue sections were visualized with Nikon Eclipse Ni-U fluorescence
microscope (Nikon, Melville, NY) and images were captured with a SPOT-RT3
digital camera (Diagnostic Instruments, Sterling Heights, MI). Quantification of
fibrosis was done using the Ashcroft scoring system80.
Lung morphometry
Mouse lungs (which had not been lavaged) were inflated by 1% low-melting point
agarose at a pressure of 25 cm H2O, and then fixed with 4%
neutral buffered formalin7475. Fixed lung tissues were
dehydrated, embedded in paraffin and sectioned (4 μm)
using a rotary microtome (MICROM International GmbH). Lung sections were
deparaffinized and rehydrated by passing through a series of xylene and graded
ethanol, then stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E). Alveolar size
was estimated from the mean linear intercept (Lm) of the airspace, which is a
measure of airspace enlargement/emphysema using the MetaMorph software
(Molecular Devices) as previously described307475. Lm was
calculated for each sample based on 10 random fields per slide observed at a
magnification of ×200. The airway and vascular structures were
eliminated from the analysis.
Measurements of lung mechanical properties
Lung mechanical properties in mouse lung were determined using Scireq Flexivent
apparatus (Montreal, Canada) as described previously307475.
Briefly, lung compliance (C), lung resistance (R), and tissue elastance (E) were
measured in mice, anesthetized by sodium pentobarbital (50 mg/kg BW,
intraperitoneally). A tracheotomy was performed, and an 18-gauge cannula was
inserted 3 mm into an anterior nick in the exposed trachea and
connected to a computer controlled rodent ventilator (FlexiVent; SCIREQ).
Initially, the mice were ventilated with room air (150 breaths/min) at a volume
of 10 ml/kg body mass. After 3 min of ventilation, measurement of
lung mechanical properties was initiated by a computer-generated program to
measure quasi-static compliance, lung resistance, and tissue elastance at
3 cm H2O positive end expiratory pressure obtained by
fitting a model to each impedance spectrum. The calibration procedure removed
the impedance of the equipment and tracheal tube within this system81. These measurements were repeated three times for each animal
using Scireq FlexiVent apparatus (Montreal, Canada) as described previously30747579.
RNA isolation and quantitative PCR
Total RNA was isolated from non-lavaged lung tissue specimens (stored in
RNAlater, Ambion, Austin, TX) using RNeasy kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). RNA
yields were determined by UV absorbance using a Nanodrop instrument (ND-1000
Spectrophotometer, NanoDrop Technologies). cDNA was synthesized from
0.5 μg of total RNA using the RT2 First
Strand Kit (SABioscience, Frederick, MD). To validate the expression of diverse
genes in lung tissue by quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) (Bio-Rad CXF-96
real-time system) using the SYBR Green qPCR Master mix from SABioscience. In
chronic Air/CS exposed mice infected with or without influenza A virus, this
includes qPCR data from circadian genes at ZT0-ZT24 time point (n = 3-4
mice/group) in all datasets. All the specific primers were purchased from
SABioscience. Expression of genes was normalized to RPL13 (60S ribosomal protein
L13 gene) levels. The samples from chronic air- and CS-exposed mice represented
in this study were obtained from our previous study that was conducted in
parallel with the chronic air and CS combined with influenza A virus
infection30. In chronic air exposure group, qPCR data
gathered from circadian gene expression at the ZT24 time point (n = 2/air group)
in all qPCR datasets. Relative RNA abundance was quantified by the comparative
2-ΔΔCt methods. Significant rhythms of
gene expression were verified using CircWave software (Version 1.4). In
addition, the center of gravity (COG) or peak phase was determined for each
rhythm using CircWave as previously described3082.
Statistical analysis
The period of PER2::LUC expression in each tissue explant was determined using a
chi-squared periodogram analysis (LumiCycle Analysis Software, Actimetrics). A
minimum of 5 days of data were used to calculate the period of PER2::LUC
expression in each explant of lung tissue. Period data from lung tissue were
analyzed with two-factor ANOVA. Data are representative of mean ±
SEM. For statistical analysis of qPCR data, CircWave software (Version 1.4) was
employed. In addition to multiple non-linear regression analyses to determine if
the data conform to a significant rhythm, CircWave also calculates the peak of
gene expression or Center of Gravity (COG). The software determines a peak of
gene expression even if the qPCR data do not conform to a significant circadian
rhythm (P < 0.05). In addition to CircWave analysis,
statistical significance between air-exposed, Air+Virus and CS+Virus groups was
calculated by Fisher’s multiple comparisons using two-way ANOVA. To
emphasize the waveform of the data, percentage of daily activity (light and dark
phase) was subjected to nonlinear regression analysis with a 6th
order polynomial using GraphPad (Prism 6). Statistical analysis of significance
was calculated using one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) followed by
Tukey’s post-hoc test for multi-group comparisons using
StatView software. Mortality was evaluated by comparison of survival curves and
analyzed for significance by Log-rank (Mantel-Cox) test using GraphPad (Prism
6). P < 0.05 was considered as significant.
Author Contributions
I.K.S., I.R., M.T.S., and B.P.L. conceived and designed the experiments; I.K.S.,
T.A., H.Y., J.H., J.G., and M.T.S. performed the experiments; I.K.S., J.H., M.T.S.
data analysis; I.K.S., T.A., H.Y., J.H., M.T.S., B.P.L., and I.R. interpretation of
results, editing the manuscript; I.K.S. M.T.S., and I.R. PER2::luciferase expression
assays; I.K.S., M.T.S., and I.R. wrote the paper.
Authors: Jose M Marin; Joan B Soriano; Santiago J Carrizo; Ana Boldova; Bartolome R Celli Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2010-04-08 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: Oscar Castanon-Cervantes; Mingwei Wu; J Christopher Ehlen; Ketema Paul; Karen L Gamble; Russell L Johnson; Rachel C Besing; Michael Menaker; Andrew T Gewirtz; Alec J Davidson Journal: J Immunol Date: 2010-10-13 Impact factor: 5.422
Authors: Hongwei Yao; Gnanapragasam Arunachalam; Jae-Woong Hwang; Sangwoon Chung; Isaac K Sundar; Vuokko L Kinnula; James D Crapo; Irfan Rahman Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2010-08-16 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Colleen M Bartman; Aleksey Matveyenko; Christina Pabelick; Y S Prakash Journal: Am J Physiol Lung Cell Mol Physiol Date: 2021-01-06 Impact factor: 5.464
Authors: Rachel S Edgar; Alessandra Stangherlin; Andras D Nagy; Michael P Nicoll; Stacey Efstathiou; John S O'Neill; Akhilesh B Reddy Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2016-08-15 Impact factor: 11.205