E Jason Abel1, Jennifer E Heckman2, Louis Hinshaw3, Sara Best2, Meghan Lubner3, David F Jarrard2, Tracy M Downs2, Stephen Y Nakada2, Fred T Lee3, Wei Huang4, Timothy Ziemlewicz3. 1. Department of Urology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, Wisconsin. Electronic address: abel@urology.wisc.edu. 2. Department of Urology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, Wisconsin. 3. Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, Wisconsin. 4. Department of Pathology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, Wisconsin.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Percutaneous biopsy obtained from a single location is prone to sampling error in large heterogeneous renal masses, leading to nondiagnostic results or failure to detect poor prognostic features. We evaluated the accuracy of percutaneous biopsy for large renal masses using a modified multi-quadrant technique vs a standard biopsy technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Clinical and pathological data for all patients with cT2 or greater renal masses who underwent percutaneous biopsy from 2009 to 2014 were reviewed. The multi-quadrant technique was defined as multiple core biopsies from at least 4 separate solid enhancing areas in the tumor. The incidence of nondiagnostic findings, sarcomatoid features and procedural complications was recorded, and concordance between biopsy specimens and nephrectomy pathology was compared. RESULTS: A total of 122 biopsies were performed for 117 tumors in 116 patients (46 using the standard biopsy technique and 76 using the multi-quadrant technique). Median tumor size was 10 cm (IQR 8-12). Biopsy was nondiagnostic in 5 of 46 (10.9%) standard and 0 of 76 (0%) multi-quadrant biopsies (p=0.007). Renal cell carcinoma was identified in 96 of 115 (82.0%) tumors and nonrenal cell carcinoma tumors were identified in 21 (18.0%). One complication occurred using the standard biopsy technique and no complications were reported using the multi-quadrant technique. Sarcomatoid features were present in 23 of 96 (23.9%) large renal cell carcinomas studied. Sensitivity for identifying sarcomatoid features was higher using the multi-quadrant technique compared to the standard biopsy technique at 13 of 15 (86.7%) vs 2 of 8 (25.0%) (p=0.0062). CONCLUSIONS: The multi-quadrant percutaneous biopsy technique increases the ability to identify aggressive pathological features in large renal tumors and decreases nondiagnostic biopsy rates.
PURPOSE: Percutaneous biopsy obtained from a single location is prone to sampling error in large heterogeneous renal masses, leading to nondiagnostic results or failure to detect poor prognostic features. We evaluated the accuracy of percutaneous biopsy for large renal masses using a modified multi-quadrant technique vs a standard biopsy technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Clinical and pathological data for all patients with cT2 or greater renal masses who underwent percutaneous biopsy from 2009 to 2014 were reviewed. The multi-quadrant technique was defined as multiple core biopsies from at least 4 separate solid enhancing areas in the tumor. The incidence of nondiagnostic findings, sarcomatoid features and procedural complications was recorded, and concordance between biopsy specimens and nephrectomy pathology was compared. RESULTS: A total of 122 biopsies were performed for 117 tumors in 116 patients (46 using the standard biopsy technique and 76 using the multi-quadrant technique). Median tumor size was 10 cm (IQR 8-12). Biopsy was nondiagnostic in 5 of 46 (10.9%) standard and 0 of 76 (0%) multi-quadrant biopsies (p=0.007). Renal cell carcinoma was identified in 96 of 115 (82.0%) tumors and nonrenal cell carcinoma tumors were identified in 21 (18.0%). One complication occurred using the standard biopsy technique and no complications were reported using the multi-quadrant technique. Sarcomatoid features were present in 23 of 96 (23.9%) large renal cell carcinomas studied. Sensitivity for identifying sarcomatoid features was higher using the multi-quadrant technique compared to the standard biopsy technique at 13 of 15 (86.7%) vs 2 of 8 (25.0%) (p=0.0062). CONCLUSIONS: The multi-quadrant percutaneous biopsy technique increases the ability to identify aggressive pathological features in large renal tumors and decreases nondiagnostic biopsy rates.
Authors: Sarp K Keskin; Pavlos Msaouel; Kenneth R Hess; Kai-Jie Yu; Surena F Matin; Kanishka Sircar; Pheroze Tamboli; Eric Jonasch; Christopher G Wood; Jose A Karam; Nizar M Tannir Journal: J Urol Date: 2017-04-11 Impact factor: 7.450
Authors: Jose A Karam; A Ari Hakimi; Kyle A Blum; Sounak Gupta; Satish K Tickoo; Timothy A Chan; Paul Russo; Robert J Motzer Journal: Nat Rev Urol Date: 2020-10-13 Impact factor: 14.432