Maren Mylius1, Andreas Frewer2. 1. Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nuremberg, Institute for History of Medicine and Medical Ethics maren.mylius@ethik.med.uni-erlangen.de. 2. Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nuremberg, Institute for History of Medicine and Medical Ethics.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Migrants without residence permits are de facto excluded from access to healthcare in Germany. There is one exception in relevant legislation: in the case of sexually transmitted infections and tuberculosis, the legislator has instructed the local Public Health Authorities to offer free and anonymous counseling, testing and, if necessary, treatment in case of apparent need. Furthermore, recommended vaccinations may be carried out free of charge. This study intends to comprehensively capture the services for undocumented migrants at Public Health Authorities in Germany. METHODS: An e-mail survey of all Local Public Health Authorities (n = 384) in Germany was carried out between January and March 2011 using a standardized questionnaire. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-nine of 384 targeted local Health Authorities completed the questionnaire (36.2%), of which approximately a quarter (n = 34) reported interaction with 'illegal' immigrants. Twenty-give authorities (18.4%) gave the indication to carry out treatment. This outpatient treatment option is mostly limited to patients afflicted with sexually transmitted infections with the distinct exception of human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immune deficiency syndrome. CONCLUSIONS: The study highlights the gap between legislation and the reality of restricted access to medical services for undocumented migrants in Germany. It underlines the need of increased financial and human resources in Public Health Authorities and, overall, the simplification of national legislation to assure the right to healthcare.
BACKGROUND: Migrants without residence permits are de facto excluded from access to healthcare in Germany. There is one exception in relevant legislation: in the case of sexually transmitted infections and tuberculosis, the legislator has instructed the local Public Health Authorities to offer free and anonymous counseling, testing and, if necessary, treatment in case of apparent need. Furthermore, recommended vaccinations may be carried out free of charge. This study intends to comprehensively capture the services for undocumented migrants at Public Health Authorities in Germany. METHODS: An e-mail survey of all Local Public Health Authorities (n = 384) in Germany was carried out between January and March 2011 using a standardized questionnaire. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-nine of 384 targeted local Health Authorities completed the questionnaire (36.2%), of which approximately a quarter (n = 34) reported interaction with 'illegal' immigrants. Twenty-give authorities (18.4%) gave the indication to carry out treatment. This outpatient treatment option is mostly limited to patients afflicted with sexually transmitted infections with the distinct exception of humanimmunodeficiency virus/acquired immune deficiency syndrome. CONCLUSIONS: The study highlights the gap between legislation and the reality of restricted access to medical services for undocumented migrants in Germany. It underlines the need of increased financial and human resources in Public Health Authorities and, overall, the simplification of national legislation to assure the right to healthcare.
Authors: Lukas Kratzsch; Kayvan Bozorgmehr; Joachim Szecsenyi; Stefan Nöst Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-05-28 Impact factor: 4.614
Authors: P B Shete; D Boccia; P Dhavan; N Gebreselassie; K Lönnroth; S Marks; A Matteelli; D L Posey; M J van der Werf; C A Winston; C Lienhardt Journal: Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Date: 2018-08-01 Impact factor: 2.373
Authors: Elisabetta De Vito; Chiara de Waure; Maria Lucia Specchia; Paolo Parente; Elena Azzolini; Emanuela Maria Frisicale; Marcella Favale; Adele Anna Teleman; Walter Ricciardi Journal: Public Health Rev Date: 2016-10-03
Authors: Jing Liang; Yujia Shi; Mohammedhamid Osman; Bhawana Shrestha; Peigang Wang Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-09-08 Impact factor: 3.390