Ali Mirzazadeh1, Mohsen Malekinejad2, James G Kahn2. 1. Philip R. Lee Institute for Health Policy Studies, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA. Electronic address: ali.mirzazadeh@ucsf.edu. 2. Philip R. Lee Institute for Health Policy Studies, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Heterogeneity of effect measures in intervention studies undermines the use of evidence to inform policy. Our objective was to develop a comprehensive algorithm to convert all types of effect measures to one standard metric, relative risk reduction (RRR). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This work was conducted to facilitate synthesis of published intervention effects for our epidemic modeling of the health impact of human immunodeficiency virus [HIV testing and counseling (HTC)]. We designed and implemented an algorithm to transform varied effect measures to RRR, representing the proportionate reduction in undesirable outcomes. RESULTS: Our extraction of 55 HTC studies identified 473 effect measures representing unique combinations of intervention-outcome-population characteristics, using five outcome metrics: pre-post proportion (70.6%), odds ratio (14.0%), mean difference (10.2%), risk ratio (4.4%), and RRR (0.9%). Outcomes were expressed as both desirable (29.5%, eg, consistent condom use) and undesirable (70.5%, eg, inconsistent condom use). Using four examples, we demonstrate our algorithm for converting varied effect measures to RRR and provide the conceptual basis for advantages of RRR over other metrics. CONCLUSION: Our review of the literature suggests that RRR, an easily understood and useful metric to convey risk reduction associated with an intervention, is underused by original and review studies.
OBJECTIVES: Heterogeneity of effect measures in intervention studies undermines the use of evidence to inform policy. Our objective was to develop a comprehensive algorithm to convert all types of effect measures to one standard metric, relative risk reduction (RRR). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: This work was conducted to facilitate synthesis of published intervention effects for our epidemic modeling of the health impact of human immunodeficiency virus [HIV testing and counseling (HTC)]. We designed and implemented an algorithm to transform varied effect measures to RRR, representing the proportionate reduction in undesirable outcomes. RESULTS: Our extraction of 55 HTC studies identified 473 effect measures representing unique combinations of intervention-outcome-population characteristics, using five outcome metrics: pre-post proportion (70.6%), odds ratio (14.0%), mean difference (10.2%), risk ratio (4.4%), and RRR (0.9%). Outcomes were expressed as both desirable (29.5%, eg, consistent condom use) and undesirable (70.5%, eg, inconsistent condom use). Using four examples, we demonstrate our algorithm for converting varied effect measures to RRR and provide the conceptual basis for advantages of RRR over other metrics. CONCLUSION: Our review of the literature suggests that RRR, an easily understood and useful metric to convey risk reduction associated with an intervention, is underused by original and review studies.
Authors: G J van Griensven; E M de Vroome; R A Tielman; J Goudsmit; F de Wolf; J van der Noordaa; R A Coutinho Journal: Am J Epidemiol Date: 1989-03 Impact factor: 4.897
Authors: Joseph G L Lee; Amanda Y Kong; Kerry B Sewell; Shelley D Golden; Todd B Combs; Kurt M Ribisl; Lisa Henriksen Journal: Tob Control Date: 2021-09-03 Impact factor: 6.953
Authors: Agnes Sebastian; June C Carroll; Leslie E Oldfield; Chloe Mighton; Salma Shickh; Elizabeth Uleryk; Yvonne Bombard Journal: Genet Med Date: 2021-01-08 Impact factor: 8.822