CONTEXT: Depression is the leading cause of early death, affecting 15% of Americans older than 65 y and costing $43 billion each year. The current mental health service system for seniors, particularly for the population hospitalized in acute inpatient psychiatric units, is fragmented because of poor funding and a shift to a transitory health care paradigm, leading to inadequate treatment modalities, questionable quality of care, and lack of research demonstrating the superiority of a particular treatment. These issues are likely to lead to a public health crisis in the coming years. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effectiveness of combining exercise and psychotherapy in improving acute depressive symptoms among older adults who were receiving treatment in an inpatient psychiatric unit. DESIGN: Based on rolling admissions, inpatients were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups. The study was blinded and controlled. SETTING: This study took place in inpatient psychiatric units at the Loma Linda University's Behavioral Medicine Center (LLUBMC) in Redlands, California. PARTICIPANTS: Participants were 78 inpatients, aged 50-89 y. INTERVENTION: Participants in the simultaneous exercise and psychotherapy (STEP) group (n = 26) took part in exercise and received psychotherapy for 30 min per session, whereas those in the TALK group (n = 26) received individual psychotherapy for 30 min per session. Participants in the control group (n = 26) served as a comparison group, receiving standard therapy. OUTCOME MEASURES: The effects of the interventions were determined by assessing differences from baseline to postintervention in the symptomatology of all 3 groups. The research team also administered the Behavioral and Symptom Identification Scale (BASIS-32) and the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) pre- and postintervention. RESULTS: At posttest, the STEP group (M = 4.24, SE = 0.62) had a better response than the TALK group (M = 11.34, SE = 0.62, P < .001), which in turn showed greater improvement than the control group (M = 14.84, SE = 0.62, P < .001). Overall, these results indicate that patients' posttreatment depression scores were significantly lower in those receiving the STEP treatment compared with those receiving individual psychotherapy only or standard care. CONCLUSION: A short-term exercise program consisting of 30 min of walking in conjunction with individual psychotherapy was an effective intervention for depression among older adults in inpatient psychiatric units.
RCT Entities:
CONTEXT: Depression is the leading cause of early death, affecting 15% of Americans older than 65 y and costing $43 billion each year. The current mental health service system for seniors, particularly for the population hospitalized in acute inpatient psychiatric units, is fragmented because of poor funding and a shift to a transitory health care paradigm, leading to inadequate treatment modalities, questionable quality of care, and lack of research demonstrating the superiority of a particular treatment. These issues are likely to lead to a public health crisis in the coming years. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effectiveness of combining exercise and psychotherapy in improving acute depressive symptoms among older adults who were receiving treatment in an inpatient psychiatric unit. DESIGN: Based on rolling admissions, inpatients were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups. The study was blinded and controlled. SETTING: This study took place in inpatient psychiatric units at the Loma Linda University's Behavioral Medicine Center (LLUBMC) in Redlands, California. PARTICIPANTS: Participants were 78 inpatients, aged 50-89 y. INTERVENTION: Participants in the simultaneous exercise and psychotherapy (STEP) group (n = 26) took part in exercise and received psychotherapy for 30 min per session, whereas those in the TALK group (n = 26) received individual psychotherapy for 30 min per session. Participants in the control group (n = 26) served as a comparison group, receiving standard therapy. OUTCOME MEASURES: The effects of the interventions were determined by assessing differences from baseline to postintervention in the symptomatology of all 3 groups. The research team also administered the Behavioral and Symptom Identification Scale (BASIS-32) and the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) pre- and postintervention. RESULTS: At posttest, the STEP group (M = 4.24, SE = 0.62) had a better response than the TALK group (M = 11.34, SE = 0.62, P < .001), which in turn showed greater improvement than the control group (M = 14.84, SE = 0.62, P < .001). Overall, these results indicate that patients' posttreatment depression scores were significantly lower in those receiving the STEP treatment compared with those receiving individual psychotherapy only or standard care. CONCLUSION: A short-term exercise program consisting of 30 min of walking in conjunction with individual psychotherapy was an effective intervention for depression among older adults in inpatient psychiatric units.
Authors: Ryan E Ross; Catherine J VanDerwerker; Jennifer H Newton; Mark S George; E Baron Short; Gregory L Sahlem; A J Manett; James B Fox; Chris M Gregory Journal: Brain Stimul Date: 2017-10-31 Impact factor: 8.955