Ira J Chasnoff1, Anne M Wells2, Lauren King2. 1. Children's Research Triangle, Chicago, Illinois ichasnoff@cr-triangle.org. 2. Children's Research Triangle, Chicago, Illinois.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this article is to assess the rate of misdiagnosis and missed diagnoses of fetal alcohol spectrum disorders (FASD) among a population of foster and adopted youth referred to a children's mental health center. METHODS: Data were collected from a sample of 547 children who underwent a comprehensive multidisciplinary diagnostic evaluation. Utilizing current diagnostic criteria, children were diagnosed, as appropriate, with fetal alcohol syndrome, partial fetal alcohol syndrome, alcohol-related neurodevelopmental disorder, or alcohol-related birth defects. Changes in rates of alcohol exposure-related diagnoses and cooccurring mental health disorders pre- and postassessment were analyzed by using McNemar's test for dependent proportions. RESULTS: Among 156 children and adolescents who met criteria for a diagnosis within the fetal alcohol spectrum, 125 had never been diagnosed as affected by prenatal alcohol exposure, a missed diagnosis rate of 80.1%. Of the 31 who had been recognized before referral as affected by prenatal alcohol exposure, 10 children's FASD diagnoses were changed within the spectrum, representing a misdiagnosis rate of 6.4%. The remaining 21 (13.5%) children's diagnoses stayed the same. There also were significant changes in the rate of mental health diagnosis, and learning disorders, communication disorders, and intellectual disability, objective signs of neurocognitive damage, were not recognized in a significant number of children with FASD. CONCLUSIONS: Within this clinical sample, 86.5% of youth with FASD had never been previously diagnosed or had been misdiagnosed. These high rates of missed diagnoses and misdiagnosis have significant implications for intervention and therapeutic services.
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this article is to assess the rate of misdiagnosis and missed diagnoses of fetal alcohol spectrum disorders (FASD) among a population of foster and adopted youth referred to a children's mental health center. METHODS: Data were collected from a sample of 547 children who underwent a comprehensive multidisciplinary diagnostic evaluation. Utilizing current diagnostic criteria, children were diagnosed, as appropriate, with fetal alcohol syndrome, partial fetal alcohol syndrome, alcohol-related neurodevelopmental disorder, or alcohol-related birth defects. Changes in rates of alcohol exposure-related diagnoses and cooccurring mental health disorders pre- and postassessment were analyzed by using McNemar's test for dependent proportions. RESULTS: Among 156 children and adolescents who met criteria for a diagnosis within the fetal alcohol spectrum, 125 had never been diagnosed as affected by prenatal alcohol exposure, a missed diagnosis rate of 80.1%. Of the 31 who had been recognized before referral as affected by prenatal alcohol exposure, 10 children's FASD diagnoses were changed within the spectrum, representing a misdiagnosis rate of 6.4%. The remaining 21 (13.5%) children's diagnoses stayed the same. There also were significant changes in the rate of mental health diagnosis, and learning disorders, communication disorders, and intellectual disability, objective signs of neurocognitive damage, were not recognized in a significant number of children with FASD. CONCLUSIONS: Within this clinical sample, 86.5% of youth with FASD had never been previously diagnosed or had been misdiagnosed. These high rates of missed diagnoses and misdiagnosis have significant implications for intervention and therapeutic services.
Authors: Matthew Valentine; Dustin C J Bihm; Lior Wolf; H Eugene Hoyme; Philip A May; David Buckley; Wendy Kalberg; Omar A Abdul-Rahman Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2017-12 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Philip A May; Anna-Susan Marais; Marlene M de Vries; Wendy O Kalberg; David Buckley; Julie M Hasken; Colleen M Adnams; Ronel Barnard; Belinda Joubert; Marise Cloete; Barbara Tabachnick; Luther K Robinson; Melanie A Manning; Kenneth Lyons Jones; Heidre Bezuidenhout; Soraya Seedat; Charles D H Parry; H Eugene Hoyme Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2016-10-06 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: Leila Glass; Eileen M Moore; Natacha Akshoomoff; Kenneth Lyons Jones; Edward P Riley; Sarah N Mattson Journal: Alcohol Clin Exp Res Date: 2017-03-24 Impact factor: 3.455
Authors: Patrick K Goh; Lauren R Doyle; Leila Glass; Kenneth L Jones; Edward P Riley; Claire D Coles; H Eugene Hoyme; Julie A Kable; Philip A May; Wendy O Kalberg; Elizabeth R Sowell; Jeffrey R Wozniak; Sarah N Mattson Journal: J Pediatr Date: 2016-07-29 Impact factor: 4.406
Authors: Philip A May; Carol Keaster; Rosemary Bozeman; Joelene Goodover; Jason Blankenship; Wendy O Kalberg; David Buckley; Marita Brooks; Julie Hasken; J Phillip Gossage; Luther K Robinson; Melanie Manning; H Eugene Hoyme Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2015-08-14 Impact factor: 4.492