Ying Chen1, Shouyao Liu2, Peng Lin1, Yunting Wang3, Jinhui Wang4, Jianfeng Tao4, Rongrong Cai2. 1. Department of Orthopedics, China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing 100029, China. 2. Department of Graduate School, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing 100029, China. 3. Department of Orthopedics, China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing 100029, China. Email: yunting1118@sina.com. 4. Department of Orthopedics, Ji Shui Tan Hospital, Beijing 100035, China.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Unstable intertrochanteric fractures (ITFs) are mostly treated by proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA), Inter-Tan, Asian Hip, and other new internal fixation devices. But for complex unstable fractures, such as crushed lateral wall of the greater trochanter, the loss of fixation point on lateral wall slightly reduces the fixing effect. This study aimed to compare the biomechanical strengths between reversed less invasive stabilization system (LISS) and PFNA for treatment of unstable ITFs. METHODS: Forty synthetic femurs were used to simulate unstable ITFs in vitro and were fixed using the reversed LISS or PFNA. These fractures were divided into two groups depending on whether the lateral wall of the greater trochanter is intact or not (AO classification: 31-A2.3 and 31-A3.3, respectively). The load-displacement of femur, stiffness, ultimate load, and cyclic fatigue resistance were detected using an incremental load test and a dynamic fatigue test through an MTS 858 test system. RESULTS: For both 31-A2.3 and 31-A3.3, the vertical sinking displacement (VSD) of the femoral head under 500 N load was insignificantly smaller after treatment with reversed LISS than with PFNA, and when the displacement was 5 mm, the femoral head bore insignificantly greater load. The fixation with reversed LISS resulted in greater axial stiffness of the femur but smaller ultimate load. During the same cycle in the dynamic fatigue test, the VSD was insignificantly smaller with the fixation of reversed LISS. CONCLUSION: Reversed LISS and PFNA have similar biomechanical strength for unstable ITFs. This conclusion should be supported by additional large-size research on basic biomechanics and clinical application. This is the first comparative biomechanical study comparing reversed LISS and PFNA for unstable ITFs.
OBJECTIVE: Unstable intertrochanteric fractures (ITFs) are mostly treated by proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA), Inter-Tan, Asian Hip, and other new internal fixation devices. But for complex unstable fractures, such as crushed lateral wall of the greater trochanter, the loss of fixation point on lateral wall slightly reduces the fixing effect. This study aimed to compare the biomechanical strengths between reversed less invasive stabilization system (LISS) and PFNA for treatment of unstable ITFs. METHODS: Forty synthetic femurs were used to simulate unstable ITFs in vitro and were fixed using the reversed LISS or PFNA. These fractures were divided into two groups depending on whether the lateral wall of the greater trochanter is intact or not (AO classification: 31-A2.3 and 31-A3.3, respectively). The load-displacement of femur, stiffness, ultimate load, and cyclic fatigue resistance were detected using an incremental load test and a dynamic fatigue test through an MTS 858 test system. RESULTS: For both 31-A2.3 and 31-A3.3, the vertical sinking displacement (VSD) of the femoral head under 500 N load was insignificantly smaller after treatment with reversed LISS than with PFNA, and when the displacement was 5 mm, the femoral head bore insignificantly greater load. The fixation with reversed LISS resulted in greater axial stiffness of the femur but smaller ultimate load. During the same cycle in the dynamic fatigue test, the VSD was insignificantly smaller with the fixation of reversed LISS. CONCLUSION: Reversed LISS and PFNA have similar biomechanical strength for unstable ITFs. This conclusion should be supported by additional large-size research on basic biomechanics and clinical application. This is the first comparative biomechanical study comparing reversed LISS and PFNA for unstable ITFs.
Authors: Hui Zhang; Xianshang Zeng; Nan Zhang; Dan Zeng; Ping Xu; Lili Zhang; Deng Chen; Weiguang Yu; Xinchao Zhang Journal: J Int Med Res Date: 2017-06-06 Impact factor: 1.671
Authors: Markus Simon Hanke; Nicholas Andreas Beckmann; Marius Johann Baptist Keel; Klaus Arno Siebenrock; Johannes Dominik Bastian Journal: Trauma Case Rep Date: 2021-02-11