Experimental visualization of the diffusion pathway of sodium ions in the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] anode for sodium-ion battery.

Sodium-ion batteries have attracted considerable interest as an alternative to lithium-ion batteries for electric storage applications because of the low cost and natural abundance of sodium resources. The materials with an open framework are highly desired for Na-ion insertion/extraction. Here we report on the first visualization of the sodium-ion diffusion path in Na3[Ti2P2O10F] through high-temperature neutron powder diffraction experiments. The evolution of the Na-ion displacements of Na3[Ti2P2O10F] was investigated with high-temperature neutron diffraction (HTND) from room temperature to 600°C; difference Fourier maps were utilized to estimate the Na nuclear-density distribution. Temperature-driven Na displacements indicates that sodium-ion diffusion paths are established within the ab plane. As an anode for sodium-ion batteries, Na3[Ti2P2O10F] exhibits a reversible capacity of ~100 mAh g(-1) with lower intercalation voltage. It also shows good cycling stability and rate capability, making it promising applications in sodium-ion batteries.

Large-scale electric energy storage (EES) requires battery systems not only to have sufficient storage capacity but also to be cost-effective and environmentally friendly123. In recent yen class="Chemical">ars, sodium-ion (Na+) batteries have attracted considerable interest as an alternative to lithium-ion (Li+) batteries for electric storage applications because of the low cost and natural abundance of sodium resources45. In this context, new advanced energy materials are required to enable the technology. Although a lot of transition metal oxides67891011, phosphate12131415, fluorophosphates1617, hexacynides51819, polymers20, alloys2122232425, sulfid26, red and black phosphorus27, organic compounds28 and carbon-based materials29303132 have demonstrated considerable capacity and cycling ability for Na+ insertion-extraction reaction, their energy densities and rate capabilities are far from the requirement of battery applications, because Na-ion has a much larger radius (1.02 Å) than Li-ion (0.76 Å), which leads to a sluggish kinetics of the Na-ion transport. Therefore, the materials with an open framework are highly desired for designing high-performance sodium-ion batteries. Li et al.33 reported a new oxyfluorinated titanium phosphate, Na3[Ti2P2O10F] with a higher ionic conductivity of 1.0 × 10−4 S cm−1 at 200°C, comparable to that of the NASICON type titanium phosphate34. In addition, the framework structure in Na3[Ti2P2O10F] is quite open due to the long Ti–F–Ti distance (~4.3 Å), which may be suitable for Na+ insertion-extraction reaction. To our knowledge, the study of the Na-ion pathways and the evolution with temperature of Na-ion motions in Na3[Ti2P2O10F] has not yet been addressed by neutron powder diffraction (NPD). There are no reports on Na3[Ti2P2O10F] as an electrode for Na-ion batteries.

Herein, we report on the first visualization of the sodium-ion diffusion path in Na3[Ti2P2O10F] through high-temperature neutron powder diffraction experiments. Temperature-driven Na displacements indicate that sodium ion follow well-established diffusion paths within the ab plane. Furthermore, the feasibility of Na3[Ti2P2O10F] as an anode for sodium-ion battery was examined as well. The preliminary results demonstrate Na3[Ti2P2O10F] is a promising anode material for Na-ion batteries with a high capacity, good cycling stability and rate capability.

Results

Structures of the as-prepared Na3[Ti2P2O10F]

The structural refinement was performed from room-temperature (RT) neutron powder diffraction (NPD) data. As reported in the Ref. 33, Na3[Ti2P2O10F] with a tetragonal I4/mmm space group was considered as a stn class="Chemical">arting structural model. The unit-cell parameters at RT are a = 6.41763(8) Å and c = 10.6636(2) Å, in good agreement with the literature33. In this model Ti atoms are placed at 4e (0, 0, z) positions, P at 4d (0, ½, 3/4), F at 2a (0, 0, 0), O1 at 4e, O2 at 16n (0, y, z) and Na at 8h (0, y, y) positions. Isotropic displacement factors were refined for all the atoms, excepting Na for which an anisotropic refinement was considered. Also the Na occupancy was refined; there is a slight deficiency (2.84(3) Na atoms per formula unit) with respect to the nominal value of 3. Figure 1a shows a good agreement between the observed and calculated NPD patterns. The refined structural parameters at RT are summarized in Table 1, while the main bond distances and bond valences are gathered in Table S1 in Supporting Information.

Figure 1

Observed (crosses), calculated (line), and difference (bottom) neutron-diffraction patterns of the tetragonal Na3[Ti2P2O10F] at room temperature (a) and 600°C (b).

Table 1

Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2) for Na3[Ti2P2O10F] from NPD data at RT. Space group I4/mmm, unit cell parameters a = 6.41763 (8) Å, c = 10.66360 (16) Å, V = 439.19 (1) Å3, Z = 4. Discrepancy factors: Rp = 3.49%; Rwp = 4.50%, Rexp = 1.67%, χ2 = 7.26, RB = 4.34%

	site	x	y	z	Uiso*/Ueq	Occ. (<1)
Na1	8h	0.2760 (5)	0.2760 (5)	0.00000	0.048 (3)	0.714 (11)
Ti	4e	0.00000	0.00000	0.1980 (3)	0.0068 (8)*
O1	16n	0.00000	0.30816 (14)	0.16445 (9)	0.0058 (4)*
O2	4e	0.00000	0.00000	0.35731 (19)	0.0117 (5)*
P	4d	0.00000	0.50000	0.25000	0.0004 (5)*
F	2a	0.00000	0.00000	0.00000	0.0079 (7)*
Atomic displacement parameters (Å2)

Figure 2 shows a schematic view of the crystal structure of Na3[Ti2P2O10F]. The structure consists of layers of n class="Chemical">TiO5F octahedra and PO4 tetrahedra sharing corners; Na atoms are interleaved between the layers. TiO5F octahedra contain four Ti–O1 equatorial distances of 2.0108(1) Å, a very short Ti–O2 axial bond length of 1.699(4) Å which can be considered as a titanyl Ti–O terminal double bond in the framework33 and an opposite Ti–F bond of 2.111(3) Å. Within the tetrahedron P–O1 distances take values of 1.5323(9) Å, adopting an ideal tetrahedral geometry. Na atoms present a sevenfold coordination environment with four Na–O1 bond-lengths (2.501(2) Å), two Na–O2 bonds (2.539(3) Å) and a weak bond to F (2.505(3) Å); as a reference in NaF, the Na–F distance is 2.316 Å. Figure 2b shows a projection of the structure along the c axis, which can be described as a repeat stacking of a buckled square-net sheet. As mentioned above, the Ti–O2 double bond contains a terminal oxygen that does not contribute to the connection between the sheets. The square-net sheets are interconnected thereby only through sharing F atoms on TiFO5 octahedra. Because of the long Ti–F–Ti distance (~4.3 Å), the framework structure is quite open, containing two-dimensional (2D) channels where Na atoms are located.

Figure 2

Crystal structure of tetragonal Na3[Ti2P2O10F] observed (a) approximately along the a axis and (b) along the c axis.

It is interesting to evaluate the actual oxidation states of the different cations present in the solid by means of the Brown's bond valence theory3335, from the observed n class="Chemical">metal-oxygen or metal-fluorine distances listed in Table S1. The valence is the sum of the individual bond valences (si); bond valences are calculated as si = exp[(r0 − ri)/0.37]. Starting from r0 values indicated in Table S1, we obtain valences at RT of 0.986(13), 4.119(15) and 5.029(5) for Na, Ti and P, respectively, which are in excellent agreement with those expected for those cations.

In order to clarify the Na distribution and how Na ion is transported in the framework, we have undertaken a high-temperature neutron diffraction (HTND) of n class="Chemical">Na3[Ti2P2O10F] from RT to 600°C. No structural transition was observed in the temperature range studied; the crystal structures can be refined within the same tetragonal structural model. Figure 1b illustrates the goodness of the fit at 600°C; the atomic parameters for the refinements and the Rietveld plots at 200 and 400°C are shown in Table S2 and Figure S1 in the Supporting Information. An interesting insight into the Na ion motion was achieved by removing Na atoms from the structural model at 600°C and performing a difference Fourier synthesis from the observed and calculated NPD data. The difference contains information of the missing scattering density (in this case nuclear density). Figure 3 shows a difference Fourier map corresponding to the z = 0 section where strong positive peaks corresponding to the 8h sites for Na1 are observed, and some intermediate nuclear density is observed between both peaks, indicating that Na is partially delocalized at intermediate positions. It can be visualized clearly in Figure 4, where Na atoms are delocalized in octagonal rings within the interlayer space, suggesting that the diffusion is two dimensional (2D), since there is no residual Na scattering through the layers even at an elevated temperature of 600°C.

Figure 3

(a) Difference Fourier maps in a model where Na has been removed. Na1 peaks are clearly located at 8 h sites, but there is intermediate nuclear density between the peaks, indicating Na is delocalized on the ac plane.

Figure 4

Unit cell of Na3[Ti2P2O10F] including the Na delocalization observed by Fourier Synthesis; Na are delocalized in octagonal rings places in the interlayer space between PO4-TiO5F sheets.

Furthermore, at higher temperatures the Na displacement factors become very anisotropic, as shown in Figure 5. Looking at one ab layer, we see that the Na ellipsoids are elongated along the unit-cell diagonals, suggesting that a jump from Na sites at adjacent unit cells is possible, thus allowing the 2D motion. They jump though a wide window formed by two F− ions very far apart (≈6.4 Å), so the potential barrier to prevent this jump is very low. Based on the NPD results, we propose that the sodium ion diffusion paths may follow a trajectory through the ab plane, as shown in Figure 5b.

Figure 5

(a) Enhanced anisotropic motion of Na atoms at 600°C, with the major axis of the ellipsoids (90% probability) along the diagonals of the unit cell. (b) ab projection suggesting the jumping path of Na+ ions to neighboring unit cells from partially occupied 8h sites.

Electrochemical properties of Na3[Ti2P2O10F]

The sodium-ion insertion/extraction properties of the n class="Chemical">Na3[Ti2P2O10F] as an anode material were investigated by galvanostatic charge-discharge measurements over a voltage range of 0 to 2.5 V versus Na+/Na. Figure 6a shows the charge (Na+ extraction)/discharge (Na+ insertion) profiles at various current rates. It shows a discharge capacity of about 100 mAh g−1 at 10 mA g−1 charge/discharge rate, which is acceptable for Na-ion batteries.

Figure 6

Sodium storage performance of Na3[Ti2P2O10F] electrodes.

(a) The charge/discharge profiles at various current rates in the voltage range of 0 to 2.5 V versus Na+/Na; (b) Rate capability: the capacity versus cycle number at various current rates; (c) Long-term cycling performance: the capacity and Coulombic efficiency versus cycle number at a current rate of 100 mA g−1.

The rate capability of the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] electrode is evaluated by charging/discharging at various current densities from 10 mA g−1 to 200 mA g−1 (Figure 6b). The reversible specific capacity remains approximately 41 mAh g−1 at a charge/discharge rate of 100 mA g−1 and 26 mAh g−1 at a charge/discharge rate of 200 mA g−1. Importantly, after the high current density testing, the capacity of the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] electrode can recover to the initial value, indicating its high reversibility. Figure 6c shows the cycling performance of the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] electrode at a current density of 100 mA g−1. The reversible specific capacity of the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] electrode keeps almost stable. Simultaneously, the Coulombic efficiency keeps above 98% after 20 cycles. These results clearly demonstrate that the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] is a promising candidate for practical applications in sodium ion batteries.

Discussion

Na3[Ti2P2O10F] has an interesting framework structure consisting of TiFO5 octahedra and PO4 tetrahedra. The TiFO5 octahedra and PO4 tetrahedra are alternatively linked via sharing four oxygen atoms (in the ac plane)33. The square-net sheets are interconnected thereby only through sharing F atoms on TiFO5 octahedra. The framework structure in Na3[Ti2P2O10F] is quite open due to the long Ti–F–Ti distance (~4.3 Å). The temperature-driven Na displacements indicate that sodium ion diffusion paths follow a trajectory through the ab plane. Moreover, as an anode for sodium-ion batteries, Na3[Ti2P2O10F] exhibits a reversible capacity of ~100 mAh g−1 with lower intercalation voltage. It also shows good cycling stability and rate capability, making it a promising anode for sodium-ion batteries.

Methods

Materials synthesis

Pure phase Na3[Ti2P2O10F]·xH2O were obtained by a modified hydrothermal method as reported by Li et al.33. In a typical synthesis, a mixture of 6.00 g of n class="Chemical">Ti(SO4)2, 36.0 g of NaBO3·4H2O, and 19.0 g of NH4H2PO4, together with 3.0 g of NaBF4 and 20.0 mL distilled water, was put into a 100 mL Teflon-lined stainless steel autoclave. The autoclave was sealed, heated to 200°C under autogenous pressure for 2 days, and then cooled to room temperature naturally. The white precipitate was isolated by washing with hot distilled water and drying it at ambient temperature. The obtained product was calcined at 650°C in Ar atmosphere for 2 hours to get the final product Na3[Ti2P2O10F]. For improving the low electronic conductivity of Na3[Ti2P2O10F], the product obtained by hydrothermal synthesis was mixed with Ketjen black (KB) using ball-milling. After calcination at 500°C for 2 h in Ar, the Na3[Ti2P2O10F] coated with carbon was obtained. The amount of carbon was about 7wt% after ball-milling.

Characterizations

XRD analyses were performed on a D8-Advance diffractometer with Cu Kα radiation (λ = 1.54 Å). The amount of carbon was analyzed by induced coupled plasma- atomic emission spectrometer (ICP-AES, Thermo Electron Corporation). NPD patterns were collected at the D2B diffractometer of the Institut Laue-Langevin, Grenoble, with a wavelength λ = 1.594 Å within the 2θ range from 10 to 153° at 25, 200, 400, and 600°C. About 2 g of the sample were contained in a vanadium cylinder. For the T ≥ 200°C collection, the sample was placed in the isothermal zone of a furnace with a vanadium resistor operating under vacuum (PO2 ≈ 1 × 10−6 Torr). In all cases a time of 3 h was required to collect a full diffraction pattern. The NPD data were analyzed by the Rietveld method with the FULLPROF program36. A pseudo-Voigt function was chosen to generate the line shape of the diffraction peaks. The irregular background coming from the quartz container was extrapolated from points devoid of reflections.

Electrochemical measurements

The working electrode was prepared by spreading the slurry of the active materials (75wt%), n class="Chemical">acetylene black (15wt%) and the polyvinylidene fluoride (10wt%) binder on a Cu foil. Considering the carbon coating in the active material, the actual mass ratio of the Na3[Ti2P2O10F]: carbon: binder is about 7:2:1. The working electrodes were dried at 100°C under vacuum for 10 h. The electrolyte for Na-ion batteries is 1M NaClO4 in EC:DEC (4:6 in volume). The coin-type (CR2032) cells were assembled with pure sodium foil as a counter electrode, and a glass fiber as the separator in an argon-filled glove box. The charge and discharge measurements were carried out on a Land BT2000 battery test system (Wuhan, China) in a voltage range of 0–2.5 V under room temperature. Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was measured using Autolab PGSTA128N at a scan rate of 0.04 mV/s in a voltage range of 0–2.5 V versus Na+/Na.