BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness of a systemic steroid therapy vs. a thermal therapy based on sulphurous water insufflation. The therapy was performed in Telese Terme Spa based on the Salimbani-Politzer technique on children suffering of otitis media with effusion (OME), using the variations of the tympanogram as objective outcome in a short time follow-up. METHODS:Eighty children suffering of monolateral or bilateral OME (44 male, 36 female, age 4-12 years, average age 7.2±2.83 ys.), enrolled in ENT or paediatrics offices, have been included in the study. Children were included in a randomization list in order to obtain two therapeutic groups, the first one to be treated through a systemic steroid therapy, the second one to be treated through sulphuruos water insufflation in Telese Spa. Children underwent otoscopic/otomicroscopic visit and tympanometry before the beginning of the therapy (T0), 7 days after the beginning of the therapy (T1), 7-10 days after the end of the therapy (T2), 30-35 days after the end of the therapy (T3). The variation of the type of tympanogram was considered the objective outcome. The shift either from a type B to a type C or o type A tympanogram and from a type C to a type A tympanogram was considered a positive outcome; the persistence either of the same type of tympanogram and the shift from a type C to a type B or from a type A to a type C or a type B were considered a negative outcome. RESULTS: Thermal therapy showed better outcomes at each time, with differences in improvement and healing often reaching the statistical significance. The most important prognostic indicator was the presence of an initial type B tympanogram, associated to a worst prognosis in both therapeutic groups and in each subgroup of OME. CONCLUSIONS:Sulphurous water insufflation therapy appeared a good therapeutic choose in the treatment of OME in a pediatric population.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness of a systemic steroid therapy vs. a thermal therapy based on sulphurous water insufflation. The therapy was performed in Telese Terme Spa based on the Salimbani-Politzer technique on children suffering of otitis media with effusion (OME), using the variations of the tympanogram as objective outcome in a short time follow-up. METHODS: Eighty children suffering of monolateral or bilateral OME (44 male, 36 female, age 4-12 years, average age 7.2±2.83 ys.), enrolled in ENT or paediatrics offices, have been included in the study. Children were included in a randomization list in order to obtain two therapeutic groups, the first one to be treated through a systemic steroid therapy, the second one to be treated through sulphuruos water insufflation in Telese Spa. Children underwent otoscopic/otomicroscopic visit and tympanometry before the beginning of the therapy (T0), 7 days after the beginning of the therapy (T1), 7-10 days after the end of the therapy (T2), 30-35 days after the end of the therapy (T3). The variation of the type of tympanogram was considered the objective outcome. The shift either from a type B to a type C or o type A tympanogram and from a type C to a type A tympanogram was considered a positive outcome; the persistence either of the same type of tympanogram and the shift from a type C to a type B or from a type A to a type C or a type B were considered a negative outcome. RESULTS: Thermal therapy showed better outcomes at each time, with differences in improvement and healing often reaching the statistical significance. The most important prognostic indicator was the presence of an initial type B tympanogram, associated to a worst prognosis in both therapeutic groups and in each subgroup of OME. CONCLUSIONS: Sulphurous water insufflation therapy appeared a good therapeutic choose in the treatment of OME in a pediatric population.
Authors: Respati W Ranakusuma; Yupitri Pitoyo; Eka D Safitri; Sarah Thorning; Elaine M Beller; Sudigdo Sastroasmoro; Chris B Del Mar Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2018-03-15