Anthony Richards1, Chris Dalrymple. 1. Sydney Gynaecology Oncology Group, Sydney Cancer Centre, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Camperdown, New South Wales, Australia.
Abstract
AIM: To determine the effectiveness of vaginal estrogen cream to improve the rate of satisfactory colposcopy and subsequent smear result in patients in a hypoestrogenic state and an abnormal Papanicolaou smear. To delineate between abnormal smears secondary to atrophy and inflammation from preneoplastic change and suggest an effective treatment strategy to deal with this challenging situation. METHODS: Patients with abnormal cervicovaginal smears who were in a low estrogen state (postmenopausal or amenorrheic postnatal) undergoing colposcopy were identified. All patients had an unsatisfactory colposcopy and were treated with vaginal estrogen cream twice per week for 6 weeks and underwent repeat colposcopy, smear and targeted biopsy where required. RESULTS: Fifty-four patients had an abnormal smear and were clinically in a low estrogen state, with four having previously had a hysterectomy. After 6 weeks of vaginal estrogen therapy, 32 out of 50 patients' colposcopic examinations were satisfactory. Also, 40 out of 54 patients' smears returned to normal after treatment. Of the 14 patients with persistent smear abnormalities, only three were diagnosed with true high-grade pre-invasive disease. CONCLUSION: The use of vaginal estrogen cream for patients with smear abnormalities and a low estrogen status improves the satisfactory colposcopy rate and improves the accuracy of the prediction of true high-grade pre-invasive disease. This treatment may then reduce the number of patients that require definitive treatment for their screen-detected abnormalities in this patient population.
AIM: To determine the effectiveness of vaginal estrogen cream to improve the rate of satisfactory colposcopy and subsequent smear result in patients in a hypoestrogenic state and an abnormal Papanicolaou smear. To delineate between abnormal smears secondary to atrophy and inflammation from preneoplastic change and suggest an effective treatment strategy to deal with this challenging situation. METHODS:Patients with abnormal cervicovaginal smears who were in a low estrogen state (postmenopausal or amenorrheic postnatal) undergoing colposcopy were identified. All patients had an unsatisfactory colposcopy and were treated with vaginal estrogen cream twice per week for 6 weeks and underwent repeat colposcopy, smear and targeted biopsy where required. RESULTS: Fifty-four patients had an abnormal smear and were clinically in a low estrogen state, with four having previously had a hysterectomy. After 6 weeks of vaginal estrogen therapy, 32 out of 50 patients' colposcopic examinations were satisfactory. Also, 40 out of 54 patients' smears returned to normal after treatment. Of the 14 patients with persistent smear abnormalities, only three were diagnosed with true high-grade pre-invasive disease. CONCLUSION: The use of vaginal estrogen cream for patients with smear abnormalities and a low estrogen status improves the satisfactory colposcopy rate and improves the accuracy of the prediction of true high-grade pre-invasive disease. This treatment may then reduce the number of patients that require definitive treatment for their screen-detected abnormalities in this patient population.