Pue Farooque1, Robert Duckrow2. 1. Yale University Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Department of Neurology, New Haven, CT, United States. Electronic address: pue.farooque@yale.edu. 2. Yale University Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Department of Neurology, New Haven, CT, United States.
Abstract
PURPOSE: To evaluate the clinical significance, characteristics and prognostic value of subclinical seizures of temporal and extra-temporal origin. METHODS: Our epilepsy database from 2003 to 2011 was reviewed to identify patients with subclinical seizures during intracranial EEG recording who underwent surgical resection. Two groups were formed: Group 1 where both the clinical and subclinical seizures had the same seizure onset region, and Group 2 where some or all of the clinical and subclinical seizures originated from different regions. RESULTS: A total of 27 patients were identified with 791 seizures, of which 310 were subclinical. In Group 1 (n=14), 64% had good surgical outcome, and 36% had poor surgical outcome. In Group 2 (n=12), 83% had poor outcome while 17% had good outcome. One patient had only subclinical seizures. Eleven patients had subclinical seizures that propagated to a region beyond their onset zone. Of those 11 patients, 6 patients had subclinical seizures propagate to a different anatomical region than their clinical seizures. These six patients had poor surgical outcome. DISCUSSION: Our study, like others, found that subclinical seizures are clinically significant and including their onset region in the volume of surgical resection correlates with good surgical outcome for both temporal and extra-temporal lobe epilepsy (Fisher's exact test p=0.017). Propagation of subclinical seizures to a different region than clinical seizures can affect surgical outcome (Fisher's exact test p=0.06). Subclinical seizures may represent a distinct epileptic network.
PURPOSE: To evaluate the clinical significance, characteristics and prognostic value of subclinical seizures of temporal and extra-temporal origin. METHODS: Our epilepsy database from 2003 to 2011 was reviewed to identify patients with subclinical seizures during intracranial EEG recording who underwent surgical resection. Two groups were formed: Group 1 where both the clinical and subclinical seizures had the same seizure onset region, and Group 2 where some or all of the clinical and subclinical seizures originated from different regions. RESULTS: A total of 27 patients were identified with 791 seizures, of which 310 were subclinical. In Group 1 (n=14), 64% had good surgical outcome, and 36% had poor surgical outcome. In Group 2 (n=12), 83% had poor outcome while 17% had good outcome. One patient had only subclinical seizures. Eleven patients had subclinical seizures that propagated to a region beyond their onset zone. Of those 11 patients, 6 patients had subclinical seizures propagate to a different anatomical region than their clinical seizures. These six patients had poor surgical outcome. DISCUSSION: Our study, like others, found that subclinical seizures are clinically significant and including their onset region in the volume of surgical resection correlates with good surgical outcome for both temporal and extra-temporal lobe epilepsy (Fisher's exact test p=0.017). Propagation of subclinical seizures to a different region than clinical seizures can affect surgical outcome (Fisher's exact test p=0.06). Subclinical seizures may represent a distinct epileptic network.
Authors: Philippa J Karoly; Ewan S Nurse; Dean R Freestone; Hoameng Ung; Mark J Cook; Ray Boston Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2017-01-13 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Gabrielle M Schroeder; Fahmida A Chowdhury; Mark J Cook; Beate Diehl; John S Duncan; Philippa J Karoly; Peter N Taylor; Yujiang Wang Journal: Brain Commun Date: 2022-07-06
Authors: Daniel M Goldenholz; Joseph J Tharayil; Rubin Kuzniecky; Philippa Karoly; William H Theodore; Mark J Cook Journal: Epilepsia Open Date: 2017-01-18
Authors: Gabrielle M Schroeder; Beate Diehl; Fahmida A Chowdhury; John S Duncan; Jane de Tisi; Andrew J Trevelyan; Rob Forsyth; Andrew Jackson; Peter N Taylor; Yujiang Wang Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2020-05-04 Impact factor: 11.205