C Capron1, K Jondeau2, L Casetti3, V Jalbert4, C Costa5, E Verhoeyen, E Verhoyen6, J M Massé3, P Coppo7, M C Béné8, P Bourdoncle3, E Cramer-Bordé1, I Dusanter-Fourt3. 1. 1] Institut Cochin, Inserm U1016, Paris, France [2] Service d'Hématologie-Immunologie, Hôpital Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France [3] Université Paris Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France [4] CNRS UMR8104, Paris, France [5] Université de Versailles St Quentin en Yvelines, Guyancourt, France. 2. 1] Service d'Hématologie-Immunologie, Hôpital Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France [2] Université de Versailles St Quentin en Yvelines, Guyancourt, France. 3. 1] Institut Cochin, Inserm U1016, Paris, France [2] Université Paris Descartes, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France [3] CNRS UMR8104, Paris, France. 4. Service d'Hématologie-Immunologie, Hôpital Ambroise Paré, Boulogne-Billancourt, France. 5. Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon, Université de Lyon, UCB-Lyon1, Lyon, France. 6. 1] Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon, Université de Lyon, UCB-Lyon1, Lyon, France [2] INSERM U1065, Lyon, France. 7. Service d'Hématologie Clinique, Hôpital Saint Antoine and Université UPMC, Paris, France. 8. Service d'Hématologie Biologique, Hôtel-Dieu-CHU, Nantes, France.
Abstract
Chronic lymphoid leukemia (CLL) is characterized by the accumulation of functionally defective CD5-positive B lymphocytes. The clinical course of CLL is highly variable, ranging from a long-lasting indolent disease to an unpredictable and rapidly progressing leukemia requiring treatment. It is thus important to identify novel factors that reflect disease progression or contribute to its assessment. Here, we report on a novel STAT3-mediated pathway that characterizes CLL B cells-extended viability and oxidative stress control. We observed that leukemic but not normal B cells from CLL patients exhibit constitutive activation of an atypical form of the STAT3 signaling factor, phosphorylated on serine 727 (Ser(727)) in the absence of detectable canonical tyrosine 705 (Tyr705)-dependent activation in vivo. The Ser(727)-phosphorylated STAT3 molecule (pSTAT3Ser(727)) is localized to the mitochondria and associates with complex I of the respiratory chain. This pSer(727) modification is further controlled by glutathione-dependent antioxidant pathway(s) that mediate stromal protection of the leukemic B cells and regulate their viability. Importantly, pSTAT3Ser(727), but neither Tyr705-phosphorylated STAT3 nor total STAT3, levels correlate with prolonged in vivo CLL B cells survival. Furthermore, STAT3 activity contributes to the resistance to apoptosis of CLL, but not normal B cells, in vitro. These data reveal that mitochondrial (Mt) pSTAT3Ser(727) overactivity is part of the antioxidant defense pathway of CLL B cells that regulates their viability. Mt pSTAT3Ser(727) appears to be a newly identified cell-protective signal involved in CLL cells survival. Targeting pSTAT3Ser(727) could be a promising new therapeutic approach.
Chronic lymphoid leukemia (CLL) is characterized by the accumulation of functionally defective CD5-positive B lymphocytes. The clinical course of CLL is highly variable, ranging from a long-lasting indolent disease to an unpredictable and rapidly progressing leukemia requiring treatment. It is thus important to identify novel factors that reflect disease progression or contribute to its assessment. Here, we report on a novel STAT3-mediated pathway that characterizes CLL B cells-extended viability and oxidative stress control. We observed that leukemic but not normal B cells from CLL patients exhibit constitutive activation of an atypical form of the STAT3 signaling factor, phosphorylated on serine 727 (Ser(727)) in the absence of detectable canonical tyrosine 705 (Tyr705)-dependent activation in vivo. The Ser(727)-phosphorylated STAT3 molecule (pSTAT3Ser(727)) is localized to the mitochondria and associates with complex I of the respiratory chain. This pSer(727) modification is further controlled by glutathione-dependent antioxidant pathway(s) that mediate stromal protection of the leukemic B cells and regulate their viability. Importantly, pSTAT3Ser(727), but neither Tyr705-phosphorylated STAT3 nor total STAT3, levels correlate with prolonged in vivo CLL B cells survival. Furthermore, STAT3 activity contributes to the resistance to apoptosis of CLL, but not normal B cells, in vitro. These data reveal that mitochondrial (Mt) pSTAT3Ser(727) overactivity is part of the antioxidant defense pathway of CLL B cells that regulates their viability. Mt pSTAT3Ser(727) appears to be a newly identified cell-protective signal involved in CLL cells survival. Targeting pSTAT3Ser(727) could be a promising new therapeutic approach.
Chronic lymphoid leukemia (CLL) is characterized by the accumulation of proliferating
CD5+ B lymphocytes.[1] The clinical course of
CLL is highly variable, ranging from a long-lasting to a rapidly progressing leukemia requiring
treatment. Although the understanding of CLL pathophysiology has improved markedly in the past few
years, therapeutic approaches are still not curative. It is thus important to further identify the
factors that selectively sustain CLL cells survival.CLL B lymphoid cells (CLL-BCs) have a prolonged survival time in vivo but exhibit a high
level of spontaneous apoptosis in vitro, highlighting the critical role of CLL-BC
microenvironment in this pathology.[1-3] Several stromal factors have been shown to
be implicated in promoting CLL-BC viability in vitro,[4,
5, 6] yet the exact mechanisms by
which the microenvironment protects CLL cells from apoptosis in vivo remain unclear.The STAT3 signaling factor mediates numerous extracellular survival/growth messages. It is
activated by phosphorylation of tyrosine 705 (Tyr705), allowing STAT3 to bind to DNA and
activate the transcription of target genes.[7] Abnormal
constitutive activation of Tyr705-phosphorylated STAT3 (pSTAT3Tyr705) is observed in
multiple tumor cells and contributes to oncogenic processes.[8,9] In addition, STAT3 can be phosphorylated at
serine 727 (Ser727) by growth factor-activated serine kinases, thereby modulating STAT3
transcriptional activity and regulating the activity of associated transcriptional factors such as
NFκB.[10] Remarkably, STAT3 was recently reported to
exhibit extranuclear pro-oncogenic activities in murine cells, linked to its mono-phosphorylation on
Ser727 but not Tyr705, subsequent association with mitochondrial (Mt)
components and regulation of the respiratory chain.[11,12] In 1997, Frank and Mahajan[13] showed by western blotting a remarkable constitutive phosphorylation of
STAT3Ser727 in the absence of canonical pSTAT3Tyr705 in 100% of 32
primary CLL-BC samples. Hazan-Halevy et al.[14]
later showed that STAT3 limited the spontaneous apoptosis of CLL-BC in vitro.In the present study, we addressed the role of Ser727-phosphorylated STAT3
(pSTAT3Ser727) in CLL pathophysiology. We demonstrate that circulating CLL-BCs but not
normal B lymphoid cells (N-BCs) overexpress an atypical mitochondria-associated
pSTAT3Ser727 moiety, the level of which correlates with prolonged CLL-BC survival in
vivo. We further identified glutathione (GSH), an antioxidant mediating stromal protection of
the leukemic cells, to be a critical regulator of Ser727 phosphorylation, and provide
evidence that STAT3 is responsible for the extended survival of CLL-BC as compared with N-BC.
Overall, our data suggest that Mt pSTAT3Ser727 contributes to the protection of CLL-BC.
As such, it may represent a new biochemical pathway for effectively targeting leukemia cells,
especially those that exhibit drug resistance.
Results
Overactivation of pSTAT3Ser727 correlates with CLL-BC resistance to
apoptosis
Circulating B cells were purified from healthy donors (n=8) and CLL patients
(Supplementary Table 1). Samples were studied immediately upon
collection to avoid any culture artifacts owing to the spontaneous apoptosis of these cells in
vitro. Apoptosis was measured by combining Annexin V/7-AAD (7-aminoactinomycin D) staining
of phosphatidyl serine externalization and dead cell DNA labeling. Apoptosis was also assessed by
monitoring the Mt transmembrane potential (MTP) that characterizes mitochondria in viable cells.
CLL-BC showed significantly lower apoptosis than N-BC using both assays, consistent with the
extended survival of CLL-BC in vivo (Figure 1a and data not
shown). The intensity of this labeling was variable from patient to patient, which is in agreement
with the heterogeneity of CLL disease. STAT3 phosphorylation was investigated by flow cytometry
measurements (FCMs). As shown in Figure 1b, CLL-BC showed strong
immunolabeling using an anti-pSTAT3Ser727 antibody. This labeling was abolished by the
pSTAT3Ser727 immunogen peptide (ipep) as well as by an 11 amino-acid-long
STAT3Ser727 phosphopeptide but not by the unphosphorylated peptide, thus confirming
labeling specificity. Conversely, quite low pSTAT3Ser727 immunolabeling was detected in
N-BC under similar conditions, although pSTAT3 Ser727 was normally induced by phorbol
esters in these cells (Figure 1b, left panel). Statistical analyses
confirmed that circulating CLL-BC expressed higher levels of pSTAT3Ser727 as compared
with N-BC (Figure 1c).
Figure 1
Activation of pSTAT3Ser727 correlates with CLL-BC resistance to apoptosis. (a) Flow
cytometry measurement (FCM) of B-cell apoptosis by Annexin V staining of
CD45+CD19+ normal (N-BC) and CLL (CLL-BC) B cells.
(b–e) FCM of pSTAT3Ser727 (b and c),
STAT3Tyr705 (d) and total STAT3 (e) of N-BC and CLL-BC. (b) One
representative experiment is shown. B cells were labeled with rabbit control (dashed black line),
total STAT3 or pSTAT3Ser727 antibodies, as indicated, in the absence (blue line) or
presence of pSTAT3Ser72 immunogen peptide (ipep; green line), phosphorylated
S3Ser727 11-peptide (red line) or unphosphorylated S3Ser727 11-peptide (purple
line). The black line indicates pSTAT3Ser727 labeling following a 15-min treatment of
N-BC with phorbol myristyl acetate. Results are expressed as mean fluorescence intensity (arbitrary
unit, a.u.). (c–e). Statistical analyses of the indicated immunolabeling mean
fluorescence intensities are shown (N-BC, n=8; CLL-BC, n=29;
**P<0.01). (f and g) Correlation between pSTAT3Ser727
or total STAT3 levels (mean fluorescence intensity) and the percentage of apoptotic Annexin
V-positive cells (f) or DiOC6-probed mitochondrial transmembrane potential (G), evaluated in
CLL-BC samples (r, Pearson's coefficient; n=29)
Regarding pSTAT3Tyr705, CLL-BC and N-BC showed a similar weak-to-undetectable
immunolabeling (Figure 1d). In addition, CLL-BC and N-BC expressed the
same total STAT3 levels (Figure 1e). Western blot analysis of the same
cells confirmed that CLL-BC overexpressed pSTAT3Ser727 as compared with N-BC in the
absence of detectable pSTAT3Tyr705. Also, no activation of the related STAT5 factor was
observed (Supplementary Figure 1).The highly variable course of CLL led us to compare pSTAT3Ser727 levels with the
apoptosis indexes of CLL-BC. A significant negative correlation was observed between
pSTAT3Ser727 level and the percentage of apoptotic Annexin V-positive CLL-BC (Figure 1f, right, n=29). Conversely, pSTAT3Ser727
levels showed a positive correlation with the mitochondria transmembrane potential (MTP) that
labeled viable cells (Figure 1g, right, n=29). Notably,
no correlation was observed between total STAT3 levels and CLL-BC basal apoptosis using both
criteria. These data indicate that CLL-BC-extended survival correlates with pSTAT3Ser727
activation in the absence of pSTAT3Tyr705 activation and total STAT3 amplification. This
suggests that pSTAT3Ser727 contributes to CLL-BC leukemic properties in
vivo.
pSTAT3Ser727 localizes to CLL-BC mitochondria
A single serine phosphorylation was shown to mediate STAT transcription activation.[15] We determined whether CLL-BC pSTAT3Ser727 binds DNA.
CLL-BC nuclear extracts were prepared and pull-down experiments using biotin-labeled STAT3-DNA
probes were performed. pSTAT3Ser727 was mostly undetectable in the nuclear fraction.
Neither STAT3 nor pSTATSer7227 did bind STAT3-DNA elements (Figure 2a
and data not shown). pSTAT3Ser727 localization was next examined using immunolabeling
coupled to confocal microscopy. In CLL-BC, pSTAT3Ser727 distributed to the cytoplasm with
a clear granular pattern but no significant nuclear labeling (Figure 2b,
top). All fluorescence was suppressed when the rabbit anti-pSTAT3Ser727 antibody was
pre-mixed with an excess amount of ipep (Figure 2b) or with pS3-11pep
but not with the unphosphorylated STAT3 (S3)-11pep (Supplementary Figure
2). Compared with CLL-BC, N-BC showed weak-to-undetectable pSTAT3Ser727
labeling (Figure 2b). Immunolabeling of total STAT3 showed a rather
uniform cellular distribution in CLL-BC and N-BC (Figure 2b). The
peculiar intracellular distribution of pSTAT3-Ser727 suggests an association with
cytoplasmic organelles. Because of the reported Mt activities of STAT3,[12] the important involvement of mitochondria in cell survival and the increased MTP
of CLL-BC (Figure 1), we focused on these organelles. Mitotracker, a
selective dye that concentrates into mitochondria along MTP, was first used to visualize these
organelles. pSTAT3-Ser727 was observed within Mitotracker-positive subcellular areas in
co-labeling assays (Figure 2b). An additional experiment was performed
using a murine monoclonal anti-pSTAT3Ser727 antibody that confirmed the predominant
granular cytoplasmic localization of pSTAT3Ser727 in CLL-BC (Figure
2c). Mitochondria were co-labeled by antibodies directed to the Mt electron transfer chain
(ETC) complex I NADH-ubiquinone reductase subunit (mtND1).[16] pSTAT3-Ser727 immunolabeling again co-localized with this second Mt
marker, as assessed by line-scan fluorescence quantification (Figure
2c). Co-labeling was further ascertained at the pixel level using Pearson's
correlation coefficient measurement that validated pSTAT3Ser727/mitochondria
co-localization statistically in patient samples (Figure 2d).
Figure 2
pSTAT3Ser727 subcellular localization characterizes human primary CLL B cells.
(a) Nuclear extracts from CLL-BC (#n upper panel, lower panel) or UT7
hematopoietic cell line were prepared and incubated with biotin-labeled STAT3-binding site DNA
probes and streptavidin magnetic beads for pull-down assays. Attached proteins were separated by
SDS-PAGE and STAT3 was detected by immunoblotting. NE and OP indicate nuclear extracts and
oligo-pull-down extracts, respectively; 1:100 of total NE were loaded on each gel. NE were incubated
with biotin-labeled SIEm67- (upper panel) or with SIEm67 (S), IRF (I)- or Oct (O)-DNA (lower panel)
probes; lo and hi indicate low and high exposure of the immunoblot. UT7 hematopoietic cells were
pre-incubated for 15 min in the absence or presence of phorbol myristyl acetate (P) as
positive controls. α and β indicate STAT3α and
STAT3β isoforms. (b–d) CLL-BC and N-BC were isolated, fixed,
permeabilized and processed for fluorescence confocal microscopy as indicated. (b) Rabbit
(rb) anti-pSTAT3Ser727 (pS3Ser727) antibody in the absence or presence of
immunogen peptide (ipep), rabbit anti-total STAT3 (total S3) and isotype control rabbit
immunoglobulins (rb Ig) were used in co-labelings with mitotracker, as indicated. DIC indicates
differential interference contrast. (c) Mouse anti-pSTAT3Ser727
(pS3Ser727 mAb) and rabbit anti-mtND1 antibodies were used in co-labeling assays.
Fluorescent probes were FITC-coupled anti-rabbit Ig (rb Ig-FITC, green), red-mitotracker or
PE-coupled anti-mouse Ig (red), DAPI (blue). Line scan intensity profiles (bottom) of pS3Ser (red),
mtND1 (green) and DAPI (blue) labeling along indicated axes
(x1–y1;
x2–y2) from gated areas. DAPI-positive nuclear (N) and
DAPI-negative cytoplasmic (C) areas are schematized. Representative images from five patients
(#n relates to Table I patient's number) and five healthy donor samples are
shown. Magnification, × 100. (d) Pearson'correlation coefficients were measured
for the indicated fluorescent signals (rabbit anti-pSTAT3Ser727
versus mitotracker; mouse anti-pSTAT3Ser727
versus rabbit anti-mtND1; mouse anti-pSTAT3Ser727
versus DAPI). Twenty-five cells were randomly examined in confocal microscopy for each
patient, and data from five and three patients were pooled, which corresponds to over 100 cells
observed; **P<0.01)
B lymphocytes are small cells with a very limited cytoplasmic area. pSTAT3Ser727
intracellular distribution was further analyzed using transmission electron microscopy. As shown in
Figure 3a, CLL-BC contained significantly more mitochondria as compared
with N-BC (10.6±0.45 versus 7.5±0.17, P<0.01), which filled most
of the cytoplasmic area. Immunogold labeling, performed on ultrathin sections, revealed the presence
of immunoreactive pSTAT3Ser727, predominantly localized in CLL-BC mitochondria (Figure 3b). No signal was detected in N-BC nor in CLL-BC stained in the presence
of the ipep (data not shown). By contrast, immunolabeling of total STAT3 revealed the presence of
STAT3 moieties in all cell compartments, including mitochondria, in both CLL-BC and N-BC (Figure 3c).
Figure 3
pSTATSer727 associates with mitochondria of CLL-BC but not N-BC. (a) CLL-BC
(n=10) and N-BC (n=2) were processed for transmission electron
microscopy (TEM) as described. Left panel: representative images of B-cell ultrastructures. Right
panel: quantification of mitochondria numbers per TEM cell section. Data are presented as
mean±S.E.M., (**P<0.01). (b and c) CLL-BC
(n=3) and N-BC (C, n=2) were fixed, permeabilized and processed for
immunogold labeling and TEM using rabbit pSTAT3Ser727 (b) or total STAT3
(c) antibody, as indicated. White and black arrow heads, respectively, indicate cytosol and
plasma membrane (PM)- localized signals; dashed black arrows indicate nuclear (N) signals; white
arrows indicate signals associated to mitochondria
pSTAT3Ser727 intracellular localization was also assessed by subcellular
fractionation. Mitochondria were isolated from cell lysates by magnetic labeling with antibodies
directed to the translocase of the outer Mt membrane 22 (TOM22). Mitochondria enrichment was
evaluated by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) coupled to immunoblotting using the
Mt heat-shock protein 60 (hsp60) and NADH dehydrogenase 1 alpha subunit 9 (NDUFA9), a component of
complex I of the ETC, cytoplasmic β-actin and nuclear lysine demethylase 1a (KDM1a;
Figure 4a). STAT3 and pSTAT3Ser727 associate with
β-actin- and KDM1a-negative mitochondria-enriched fraction. Comparison of the amounts
of STAT3 and hsp60 in TOM22-positive and -negative fractions indicated that levels of Mt STAT3 were
~1–5% that of total STAT3. First, evidence for the Mt localization of STAT3 has come
from observations that GRIM-19, a component of the ETC complex I, directly binds to
STAT3.[12] Using an antibody that captures all components of
complex I and immunoprecipation assays, we co-precipitated serine phosphorylated STAT3 in CLL-BC,
but not in N-BC extracts (Figure 4b).
Figure 4
pSTATSer727 associates with complex I of the mitochondria respiratory chain.
(a) Mitochondria (Mt) were isolated from CLL-BC (whole cells, WC) by magnetic immunolabeling.
Extracts were separated by SDS-PAGE and blots were probed with the indicated antibodies. (b)
Antibody to complex I (CI) of the ETC or a nonspecific isotype-matched IgG (ctl) were
incubated with CLL-BC or N-BC total cell extracts (TEs), as indicated. Immunoprecipitates (IPs) were
resolved on SDS-PAGE and probed for the indicated proteins. 1 : 50 of TE was loaded on
the gel. α and β indicate STAT3α and STATβ
isoforms, respectively
Collectively, these data concur in indicating that CLL-BC display overactivation of an atypical
Mt pSTAT3Ser727 moiety.
In vivo, their microenvironment has a profound effect on CLL-BC survival. Stromal
support of CLL-BC can be reproduced when they are co-cultured with bone marrow stromal cell
lines.[6,17] Indeed, murineMS5 and human HS5 cells significantly reduce the level of CLL-BC spontaneous apoptosis, as assessed
by Annexin V labeling and MTP probing (Figures 5a and b and Supplementary Figure 3). It similarly maintains a strong level of
pSTAT3Ser727 immunolabeling in absence of any immunoreactive pSTAT3Tyr705 in
CLL-BC even after prolonged periods (Figures 5c and d, right panels, and
Supplementary Figure 3), while the expression of total STAT3 remains
unchanged (data not shown). Under similar conditions, stromal cells enhance not only
pSTAT3Ser727 but also pSTAT3Tyr705 activation of N-BC in a time-dependent
manner.
Figure 5
Stromal protection of CLL-BC sustains Mt pSTAT3Ser727 overactivation. (a and
b) FCM of apoptosis (a) and mitochondrial transmembrane potential (MTP; b) of
N-BC and CLL-BC at day 8 of MS5 co-culture. Results are expressed as percentage of AnnexinV-positive
(a) and TMRM-positive (MTP+; b) cells. The mean +/−
S.E.M. of 3 independent experiments is shown, *P<0.05; **P<0.01.
(c and d) FCM analysis of pSTAT3Ser727 (c) or
pSTAT3Tyr705 (d) expression in N-BC and CLL-BC upon MS5 co-culture.
CD45+CD19+ CD5+ B cells were analyzed at day 0
(blue), day 3 (purple) or day 8 (red) of MS5 co-culture. Standard rabbit immunoglobulins were used
as control at day 8 (dashed black line). One representative experiment is shown (samples from three
healthy donors and three individual patients were analyzed). Results are expressed as mean
fluorescence intensity (arbitrary unit, a.u.). (e) N-BC and CLL-BC were collected at day 8 of
MS5 co-culture. Immunofluorescence analyses were performed with the indicated primary antibodies
using fluorescence microscopy (magnification × 100). Fluorescent probes were FITC-coupled
anti-rabbit Ig (green), PE-coupled anti-mouse Ig (red) and DAPI (blue). DIC indicates differential
interference contrast. Representative images from three CLL patients and five healthy donors are
shown
pSTAT3Ser727 localization was assessed in this model. Using again two different
pSTAT3Ser727 antibodies and mitochondria markers, CLL-BC were shown to display the same
predominant Mt localization of pSTAT3Ser727 upon MS5 co-culture, as compared with freshly
isolated CLL-BC (Figure 5e and data not shown). Conversely, a pronounced
difference was observed in stroma co-cultured N-BC in which pSTAT3Ser727 was distributed
to the cytoplasmic and nuclear compartments, and thus not predominantly associated to
mitochondria.Collectively, these observations indicate that stromal cells mimic in vitro the
interactions between CLL-BC and their microenvironment that occur in vivo, in terms of
CLL-BC protection from apoptosis, STAT3 phosphorylation status and intracellular localization. They
further reveal that the same stromal messages are differentially received and translated by N-BC and
CLL-BC, thereby leading to mitochondria-restricted pSTAT3Ser727 overexpression in
leukemic cells only.The accumulation of Mt pSTAT3Ser727 in stroma-supported CLL-BC led us to search for
stromal signals that would regulate pSTAT3Ser727 activation in these cells. CLL-BC
intrinsically have high levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) when compared with normal
lymphocytes.[1,18] This makes
CLL-BC more dependent on such cellular antioxidants as GSH. A critical metabolic interaction between
CLL-BC and bone marrow stromal cells was recently reported to enhance GSH synthesis, and thus
increase the ability of CLL-BC to maintain the redox balance and promote cell survival.[6] We tested the relationship between GSH, oxidative stress and
pSTAT3Ser727 expression of CLL-BC. Dihydroethidium (DHE) provides a clear indication of
primary ROS levels[19] by binding to superoxide anions that
are produced predominantly by the respiratory chain of mitochondria in most cells except phagocytes.
As shown in Figure 6a, the addition of GSH to CLL-BC culture medium, in
absence of stromal cells, indeed enhanced ROS detoxification, thereby lowering superoxide anions
levels and promoting cell survival. It further enhanced pSTAT3Ser727 expression of CLL-BC
without changing pSTAT3Tyr705 activation (data not shown) and total STAT3 levels. Similar
data were obtained upon addition of N-acetylcysteine (NAC), another antioxidant. This increased
activation of pSTAT3Ser727 by antioxidants targeted Mt STAT3, as assessed by
immunolabeling coupled to confocal microscopy (data not shown).
Figure 6
GSH metabolism regulates the phosphorylation of STAT-Ser727 of CLL-BC. (a and
b) Comparison of apoptosis, ROS, pSTAT3Ser727 and total STAT3 expression of CLL-BC
cultured alone for 4 days in the presence or absence of NAC (1 mM) or GSH (2 mM).
Where indicated, PEITC (1–5 μM, 5 h) was added at the end of the
culture. (c) Time course of ROS, pSTAT3Ser727 and total STAT3 expression of CLL-BC
cultured alone in the presence of PEITC (5 μM) for the indicated time. ROS were
measured by DHE staining of CD45/CD19+/CD5+ cells;
pSTAT3Ser727 and total STAT3 levels were evaluated upon immunolabeling/FCM. Data are
expressed as relative to untreated cells. The mean±S.E.M. of four separate experiments with
four different CLL patient samples are shown (*P<0.05; **P<0.01;
***P<0.001; ****P<0.0001). (d) FCM of
pMEK (right) and pSTAT3Ser727 (left) of CLL-BC upon a two-day culture in the absence
(black) or presence of 10 nM (dark grey) or 100 nM (medium grey) of MEK inhibitor
PD0325901. B cells were labeled with rabbit control (light grey), pMEK or pSTAT3Ser727 antibodies,
as indicated. Results are expressed as mean fluorescence intensity (arbitrary unit, a.u.)
Conversely, the viability of CLL cells can be decreased by depletion of GSH using
β-phenylethyl isothiocyanate (PEITC), a natural compound capable of inactivating
cellular GSH and modulating ETC activity. PEITC indeed significantly enhanced intracellular ROS
levels of CLL-BC (Figure 6b). It also decreased CLL-BC levels of
pSTAT3Ser727 in a concentration-dependent manner while it had no impact on total STAT3
expression. It further suppressed GSH- and NAC-dependent regulation of ROS and pSTAT3Ser—but
again not total STAT3–expression. Notably, the inhibitory activity of PEITC was time
dependent, with a significant pSTAT3Ser727 loss being detectable at 1 h of
treatment. This effect was observed when CLL-BCs were cultured alone (Figure
6c) or with stromal cells (data not shown), and were detectable before substantial ROS
increase. These data suggest that the oxidative stress status of CLL-BC regulates
pSTAT3Ser727. ROS directly affects the activity of a large number of cellular proteins.
It also regulates the amounts of reduced GSH, which in turn positively or negatively modulate
protein activity through direct conjugation, that is, glutathionylation, as observed for such
Ser/Thr kinases as MEK and JNK, which may mediate GSH-dependent Mt STAT3Ser727
phosphorylation.[20] The MEK–ERK pathway is required
for Ras-induced phosphorylation of Mt STAT3 on Ser727, which is one of the critical steps
of the Ras-MEK–ERK axis during transformation.[21]
Pharmacological inhibition of MEK, however, did not affect serine phosphorylation of STAT3 in CLL-BC
(Figure 6d).Altogether, these data suggest that the oxidative stress status of CLL-BC regulates
pSTAT3Ser727 activation through a MEK–ERK independent pathway.
STAT3 sustains CLL-BC survival
The role of STAT3 in mediating the protection of CLL-BC was next investigated by an RNA
interference-based strategy. Small hairpin RNA (shRNA) that knocks down humanSTAT3 (shS3) was
stably introduced in N-BC and CLL-BC, using a lentiviral vector that co-encodes the green
fluorescent protein (GFP) dye. Lentiviral particles that expressed measles virus glycoprotein
envelope instead of canonical vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein were used to allow efficient
transduction of human B cells, as we reported previously.[22] shRNA targeting luciferase (shL) or STAT5 (shS5) were used as controls. As shown
in Figures 7a and b, shS3 decreased STAT3 gene expression, with
no impact on STAT5 levels as compared with control shRNA (shL)-expressing human RAJI B cells, which
validated the shS3 specificity. This was confirmed on CLL-BC by FCM. Transduced CLL-BC were
maintained on MS5 stromal cells and the level of apoptosis of GFP+ and
GFP− subsets were analyzed along the period of culture, using AnnexinV labeling and
tetramethylrhodamine-methyl-ester (TMRM) MTP probing, together with dead cell DNA staining by 7AAD
or TOPRO-3 dyes. By all criteria, shS3+/GFP+ CLL-BC exhibited
enhanced apoptosis as compared with shS3-/GFP- and
shL+/GFP+ control cells, whereas the viability of
shS5+/GFP+ CLL-BC was unchanged (Figures
7c–e). Notably, shS3 suppressed the enhanced viability of CLL-BC, whereas it had no
consequences on N-BC under similar conditions (Figures 7d and e). These
data indicate that STAT3, but not STAT5, selectively supports CLL-BC survival in the absence of
canonical pSTAT3Tyr705 activation.
Figure 7
CLL-BC depends on STAT3 activity for their growth. (a) Immunoblot analysis of the
indicated proteins in shRNA/GFP+ Raji B cells at day 8 post transduction. shL,
shS3 and shS5 refer to control luciferase, STAT3 and STAT5 shRNA, respectively. Numbers at the
bottom of each panel indicate STAT3/ β-actin and STAT5/β-actin
ratio relative to shL cells, respectively. (b) FCM of pSTAT3Ser727 expression in CLL-BC at
day 8 post transduction with the indicated shRNA/GFP encoding lentiviral vectors. B cells were
co-cultured with MS5 stromal cells since day 1 post transduction. Vertical bars delineate specific
fluorescent signals compared with control isotype immunoglobulins (ctl Ig, left panel). Results are
expressed as mean fluorescence intensity (arbitrary unit, a.u.). Percentages of
pSTAT3Ser727/GFP+ cells are indicated inside each graph.
(c–e) N-BC and CLL B cells were transduced with the indicated shRNA/GFP
encoding lentiviral vectors. Apoptosis was analyzed at day 8 post transduction, on
GFP+ and GFP- B cells by FCM using Annexin V/7-AAD and
TMRM/TOPRO3 labeling, as indicated. (c) Representative experiment (n=10),
numbers indicate the percentages of cells in relevant quadrants. (d and e) Statistical
analyses expressed as percentages of AnnexinV positive (d) and TMRM-probed MTP positive
(MTP+) (e) cells. UT indicates untransduced cells (mean±S.E.M.,
CLL-BC, n=10, N-BC, n=5; **P<0.01;
*P<0.05)
Discussion
In the present study, we investigated the physiopathological role of STAT3 phosphorylation in the
natural history of CLL disease. Using human primary B cells from healthy donors and CLL-BCs from
patients, this study shows that CLL-BC but not N-BC exhibit an over-activation of an atypical
mitochondria-associated pSTAT3Ser727 moiety that characterizes leukemic cells survival
and oxidative stress control. Four key results support these conclusions. First, circulating CLL-BC
spontaneously express an abnormally high level of the mitochondria-restricted
pSTAT3Ser727 moiety in the absence of canonical pSTAT3Tyr705 activation, at
variance with what is observed in N-BC in vivo. Second, stroma-supported CLL-BCs, but not
N-BCs, exhibit overactivation of the Mt pSTAT3Ser727 moiety in vitro. Third,
both inhibitors and activators of the antioxidant GSH pathway, which regulates the redox balance and
survival of CLL-BC, similarly regulate CLL-BC Mt pSTAT3Ser727. Fourth, the extended
survival of CLL-BC correlates with their pSTAT3Ser727 status but not overall STAT3
expression level in vivo and rely on STAT3 activity, as opposed to what was observed in
N-BC.Several reports have shown that pSTAT3Ser727 activation in the absence of canonical
pSTAT3Tyr705 mediates cell survival messages, as illustrated by the action of
neutrotrophins on both neuronal stem/progenitor and mature cells, or VEGF activity on CLL-BC
cultured alone.[23, 24, 25, 26] DNA damage inducers similarly
activate pSTAT3Ser727 but not pSTAT3Tyr705 expression in cancer cell models,
thereby enhancing DNA repair.[27] In these analyses,
pSTAT3Ser727 activity involved nuclear transcriptional regulation of cell
survival/DNA repair genes. Our study reveals that CLL-BC exhibit a unique Mt
pSTAT3Ser727 overactivation not observed in N-BC. Wegrzyn et al.[12] have indicated that Mt pSTAT3Ser727 enhanced mitochondria
respiration of murine normal primary B cells, yet without impacting their survival. It however
protected murine cardiomyocytes from ischemia and decreased the production of ROS and
cytochrome-c release.[28] Also, Mt
pSTAT3Ser727 is involved in nerve growth factor-induced neurite outgrowth and the
production of ROS.[29] Remarkably, Mt
pSTAT3Ser727 is overexpressed by Ras-transformed mouse embryo fibroblasts and supports
Ras-dependent malignant transformation.[11] It further
influences the tumorigenic potential of murine4T1breast cancer cells that correlates with the
regulation of ROS concentrations.[30]Here our observations consistently disclosed that human primary CLL-BC spontaneously exhibit
overactivation of Mt pSTAT3Ser727 as compared with their normal counterparts, a feature
that is linked to their extended survival and oxidative stress control. To our knowledge CLL is the
first humanmalignancy linked to a non-canonical mitochondria-restricted pSTAT3Ser727
overactivity in vivo. One prominent biochemical feature of CLL-BC is their high level of
ROS and oxidative stress, when compared with normal lymphocytes. This ROS stress renders them
dependent on proper redox balance and makes them oversensitive to agents that induce further ROS
stress.[31,32] Interestingly,
we observed that CLL-BC exhibit an abnormal accumulation of Mt mass, which is in agreement with the
data reported by Carew et al.[18] The deregulated
mitochondria biogenesis in CLL-BC is significantly related to endogenous ROS levels and further
correlates with enhanced drug resistance.[18] GSH is the
most abundant antioxidant in cells and significantly affect cell survival.[33] Indeed, CLL-BC from patients exhibit deficient GSH synthesis and rely on stromal
cells to provide cysteine for GSH production.[6] Our study
reveals that the oxidative stress status of CLL-BC, which is controlled by cell microenvironment and
dictates leukemic cell apoptosis resistance, also regulates the activation of Mt
pSTAT3Ser727 in CLL-BC in a dose-dependent and rapid manner (<1 h), and also in
absence of the active MEK–ERK pathway. It indicates that various signaling pathways can
modulate serine phosphorylation of Mt STAT3 in tumor cells.We have tested a number of inhibitory agents to decipher which kinase(s) might phosphorylate
STAT3Ser727 of CLL-BC. They included PI3k inhibitors (Ly294002, Wortmanin), mTOR
inhibitors (rapamycin and AZD8055) and many others (data not shown). GSH activators and inhibitors
were the very first ones to affect pSTAT3Ser727 of CLL-BC. Clearly, more work needs to be
done for pSTAT3Ser727 mode of activation in CLL-BC. Our observation that the GSH
antioxidant pathway regulates pSTAT3Ser727 expression questions whether
pSTAT3Ser727 effectors may influence ROS production. pSTAT3Ser727 associates
with complex I of CLL cells. In the presence of increased ROS, STAT3 can be oxidized to form
multimers.[34] An alternative oxidative modification of
STAT3 by S-glutathionylation has also been observed.[35]
Complex I-associated STAT3 of CLL-BC may thus limit ROS production by decreasing electron leak of
complex I and/or by serving as a critical electron scavenger, as previously
suggested.[28, 29, 30]In vivo, the microenvironment has a profound effect on CLL-BC survival. Besides BCR
signaling, several stromal factors have been implicated in sustaining CLL-BC survival. A number of
these factors activate not only pSTAT3Tyr705 but also pSTAT3Ser727 in N-BC and
CLL-BC when added to culture medium separately in the absence of stromal cells.[4,5,23] Our
study now reveals that the mixed protective signals provided by stromal microenvironments in
vivo and ex vivo (i.e., MS5/HS5) are all combined to a unique
mitochondria-associated overactivation of pSTAT3Ser727 in the absence of canonical
activation of pSTAT3Tyr705 in CLL-BC but not N-BC. It provides substantial evidence that
the same stromal signals are differentially translated by CLL-BC and N-BC. Thus, stromal support of
leukemia cells correlates with major intrinsic qualitative changes in CLL-BC signaling pathways
leading to pSTAT3Ser727 overactivation, as compared with N-BC. Our data show that this
pSTAT3Ser727 overactivation is not associated with massive STAT3 delocalization. Indeed,
immunolabelings of human normal and leukemic B cells detected the presence of reasonable levels of
Mt STAT3, which is confirmed by subcellular fractionation. This suggests that constitutive
phosphorylation of STAT3Ser727 occurs within the mitochondria of CLL-BC. As opposed to
our data, previous reports showed that a minor proportion of total STAT3 localizes to mitochondria
upon fractionation of normal cells.[11,12,36] One interpretation of this discrepancy is that
part of Mt STAT3 is lost upon mitochondria isolation based on different subcellular fractionation
protocols. Also, CLL-BC contain significantly more mitochondria as compared with N-BC. Mt STAT3 of
CLL-BC might therefore be more abundant and/or less labile as compared with other cells. Also,
our data indicate that nuclear pSTAT3Ser is undetectable and unable to bind STAT3-DNA-specific
probes in CLL-BC. This is in contradiction with the previously reported nucleocytoplasmic
trafficking of pSTAT3Ser727 in CLL-BC, despite the use of an identical STAT3-DNA
probe.[14] Again, different subcellular fractionation
and/or pull-down protocols may explain such a discrepancy.Overall, our findings indicate that Mt pSTAT3Ser727 overactivation is linked to
leukemic B cell-extended survival and antioxidant defense. It suggests that pSTAT3Ser727
contributes to the antioxidant defense and protection of the leukemic cells. This activity may
similarly reduce that of ROS-generating anticancer agents and favor drug resistance. These results
suggest that pSTAT3Ser727 detection could be used as a new tool to characterize
patients' leukemic cells from blood samples, which, together with current disease criteria,
could help define new patient subgroups and help predict disease outcome and/or drug resistance.
It further supports the idea of therapeutically targeting pSTAT3Ser727 activity to
deregulate leukemic cell antioxidant defense and eliminate the CLL-BC protected by their
microenvironment, which could be resistant to immune chemotherapy. To our knowledge, CLL is the
first humanmalignancy linked to a non-canonical mitochondria-restricted pSTAT3Ser727
overactivity in vivo, thereby offering a new potential therapeutic target that spares
healthy B cells.
Materials and Methods
Primary cells and cell lines
After obtaining the approved informed consent of Institutional Review Board, peripheral blood
mononuclear cells were collected from healthy donors and CLL patients, and were isolated by
density-gradient centrifugation on Ficoll Hypaque. B cells were further purified using CD3/CD14
immunomagnetic-bead-negative selection (Miltenyi Biotec, Cologne, Germany) to avoid B-cell
activation. CD5/CD19 double-positive cells were selected by FACS. All patients had
immunophenotypically defined CLL as outlined by the modified 1996 National Cancer Institute Criteria
(Supplementary Table 1). The RAJI human B-cell line, the MS5murine
and HS5 human bone marrow stromal cell lines were purchased from DSMZ cell depository bank. They
were cultured in RPMI (RAJI) and MEM alpha (MS5, HS5) medium supplemented with 10% fetal calf
serum (FCS). B cells were cultured in vitro alone or with a layer of HS5 or MS5 cells under
normoxia in RPMI medium supplemented with 5–10% FCS. The cells were incubated with GSH
(2 mM) or NAC (1 mM) for 4 days and exposed to PEITC (0–5 μM) during
the last 5 h of incubation. Alternatively, B cells were exposed to PEITC
(0–5 μM) alone for 0–5 h. Where indicated, CLL-BC were cultured alone
for 2 days in the absence or presence of the MEK inhibitor PD0325901 (0–100 nM).
Lentiviral constructs and transduction
Oligonucleotides targeting firefly luciferase (shL,
5′-CGTACGCGGAATACTTCGA-3′), STAT3 (shS3,
5′-AAGAAACTGGAGGAGTTGCAG-3′) and STAT5A/B (shS5,
5′-GGAGAACCTCGTGTTCCTG-3′) were inserted downstream of the H1
promoter into an HIV-SIN-SFFVGFP vector that encodes GFP as reporter. Lentiviral particles
displaying measles virus glycoproteins were produced and titrated on 293T cells using GFP FCM as
described. B cells were incubated with lentiviral particles at a multiplicity of infection of 3 in
RPMI1640 supplemented with 10% FCS for 18–24 h and then transferred on MS5
stromal cells for at least 8 days. Transduction efficiencies ranged between 10 and 30%.
Flow cytometry measurements
CLL-BC were identified by anti-CD5-APC-Cy7 and anti-CD19-PC7 antibodies. Apoptosis was assessed
by Annexin V labeling. MTP measurements were achieved using 3.3′dihexyloxacarbocyanine iodide
(Di0C6(3)) or TMRM fluorescent probes, sequestered by active mitochondria.[37] Dead cells were stained by 7-AAD or TO-PRO-3 iodide (Life Technologies,
Carlsbad, CA, USA). ROS were evaluated using the DHE fluorescent probe that binds to superoxide
anions. For STAT3 and pMEK labeling, CD5+CD19+ pre-labeled B cells
were fixed, permeabilized and incubated with relevant antibodies, according to Irish et
al.[38] The antibodies were total STAT3,
pSTAT3Tyr705, pSTAT3Ser727 and pMEK (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA, USA).
pSTAT3-Ser727 antibodies were pre-mixed or not with pSTAT3-Ser727ipep (Santa
Cruz, Dallas, TX, USA) or a chemically synthesized STAT3 peptide (IDLPMS727PRTLD) that
was phosphorylated (pS3-11pep) or not (S3-11pep) on Ser727 (Thermo Fisher Scientific,
Waltham, MA, USA) at a 1 : 100 molar ratio. FCM analyses were performed using Diva and
Cellquest on a FACS-Canto II (BD Biosciences). Data are expressed as the percentage of labeled cells
among total or as the mean fluorescence intensity.
Immunofluorescence microscopy
B cells, pre-incubated or not for 15 min at 37 °C with red Mitotracker
(500 nM, Life Technologies) were loaded on poly-L-lysine-coated slides, fixed in
3.7% paraformaldehyde, permeabilized with phosphate-buffered saline (PBS)/0.1%
Triton X-100 for 5 min at room temperature and incubated in 1 × PBS/5%
bovineserum albumin (BSA) for 1 h at 37 °C in the presence of primary antibodies.
The latter were murine anti-pSTAT3Ser727 antibodies (BD Biosciences), rabbit
anti-pSTAT3Ser727 and anti-total STAT3 antibodies (Cell Signaling Technology, Danvers,
MA, USA), and antibodies directed to the Mt DNA-encoded complex I (NADH-ubiquinone reductase)
subunit (mtND1, gift of Dr. Lombes).[16] Rabbit
pSTAT3-Ser727 antibodies were pre-mixed or not with the indicated
pSTAT3-Ser727 peptide (Santa Cruz) at a 1 : 1 concentration ratio. Then,
FITC-conjugated anti rabbit immunoglobulin G antibody (BD Biosciences) or PE-conjugated anti-murine
immunoglobulin G (Life Technologies) secondary antibodies were used for 1 h incubation at
room temperature. Slides were DAPI-stained and viewed using a Leica confocal microscope
(LEICA,Wetzlar, Germany), with a digital AxioCamERc camera and analyzed with AxioVisio software
(Carl Zeiss, Jena, Germany). At least 25 cells/patient sample were observed at × 63 and
× 100 magnifications. Co-localization analyses used a cooled Coolsnap camera (Roper
Scientific, Trenton, NJ, USA) with optical z-sections collected at
0.63 μm steps. Image analyses were performed with the software ImageJ associated
with the JACoP plugin tool to integrate statistics to spatial exploration of correlated pixel
signals (expressed as Pearson's correlation coefficient). Coefficients >0.5 indicated
significant colocalization.[39]
Transmission electron microscopy
B cells were fixed in 3% glutaraldehyde and postfixed in 1 × PBS/1%
osmium tetroxide, dehydrated in ethanol followed by propylene oxide (VWR, Radnor, PA, USA), embedded
in Epon and polymerized overnight at 60 °C. Ultrathin sections were cut with a
LEICA/Reichert Ultracut S ultramicrotome, stained with uranyl acetate and lead citrate.
Immunolabeling was performed on B cells fixed in 0.2% glutaraldehyde/4%
paraformaldehyde for 1 h at room temperature as described,[40] using rabbit total STAT3 or pSTAT3Ser727 antibodies (Cell Signaling
Technology). Ultrathin (Peabody, MA, USA) sections were examined with a JEOL1011 transmission
electron microscope. Digital images of ≥10 cells/sample were obtained using a GATAN-CCD
camera and Digital Micrograph software (Warrendale, MA, USA).
Preparation of mitochondria extracts
Mitochondria were isolated from B cells using Mitochondria isolation kit (Miltenyi Biotec)
following manufacturer's instructions with some modifications. Briefly, frozen B cells
(2–10 × 107 cells) were directly resuspended in pre-cooled phosphate-buffered
saline (1 ml per 108 total cells) supplemented with ethylenediamine tetraacetatic
acid (EDTA; 2 mM), anti-protease and –phosphatase inhibitors and benzonase
(50 U), and incubated for 20 min at 4 °C. Cell homogenization was performed
with a 26-G needle stepwise using 5–10 stokes. Lysates were diluted to 1 × separation
buffer (Miltenyi Biotec) and proceeded to magnetic labeling by incubation with anti-Tom22 magnetic
beads for 1 h at 4 °C on a wheel. The labeled cell lysate was loaded on a MACS
column placed in a magnetic field and let run through. Lysates were re-loaded three times. Column
was then intensively washed out and the magnetically labeled mitochondria were then flushed out.
Pre- and post-mitochondria-purified fractions were separated by SDS-PAGE and the presence of
cytoplasmic β-actin protein, Mt hsp60 or NDUFA9 proteins, and nuclear KDM1a were
evaluated by western blot analysis using monoclonal anti-β-actin (AC-15,
Sigma-Aldrich), -hsp60 (Biosciences Inc., Allentown, PA, USA), -NDUFA9 (Abcam, Cambridge, UK) and
KDM1a (Cell Signaling Technology).
Immunoprecipitation
Total cell extracts from B cells (5 107) were obtained by a 30-min incubation at
4 °C in lysis buffer (20 mM Tris, pH 8, 137 mM NaCl, 1% NP40,
10% glycerol and 2 mM EDTA) supplemented with cocktails of proteinase (Roche) and
phosphatase inhibitors. Lysates were immunoprecipitated for 4 h at 4 °C with
4 μg of complex I immunocapture monoclonal antibody (MitoSciences, Eurogen, OR,
USA) or isotype-matched control (ctl). Immunoprecipitates were separated by SDS-PAGE and
immunoblotted with the indicated antibodies.
Oligo pull-down assays
Cytoplasmic and nuclear extracts were obtained from B cells, as previously
described.[41] To confirm proper subcellular fractionation,
extracts were separated by SDS-PAGE and the presence of the nuclear lamin B and A/C, or the
cytoplasmic β-actin was assessed by western blot analysis using monoclonal mouse
anti-β-actin (Sigma-Aldrich), polyclonal rabbit anti-lamin B, -lamin A/C (Cell
Signaling Technology) antibodies. Nuclear extracts (2–5 × 107) were incubated
with 1 μg of the indicated biotin-labeled STAT3-DNA probe SIE367
(5′-TTCCCGTAA-3′) or IRF1
(5′-GATCCATTTCCCCGAAATGA-3′) or control Oct-DNA probe
(5′-CGGGTATAATTTCTGC-3′) in binding buffer (10 mM HEPES,
100 μM EDTA, 50 mM NaCl, 50 mM KCl, 5 mM MgCl2,
4 mM spermidine, 2 mM dithiothreitol, 0.1 mg of BSA/ml, 2.5%
glycerol and 4% Ficoll) for 2 h at 4 °C, as described.[41] Streptavidin magnetic beads (Pierce, Thermo Fisher Scientific) were
added for 30 min at 4 °C, extensively washed, resuspended in SDS-PAGE loading
buffer and analyzed by SDS-PAGE and immunoblotting.
Statistics
Data were expressed as means or medians depending on the normality of the distribution.
Statistical significance was determined by Student's t-test or
Mann–Whitney/Wilcoxon test. P-values≤0.05 were considered as significant
(*) and P-values ≤0.01 as highly significant (**). Statistical analyses were
performed with the Medcalc (Ostende, Belgium) and GraphPad Prism softwares (San Diego, CA, USA).
Authors: J S Carew; S T Nawrocki; R H Xu; K Dunner; D J McConkey; W G Wierda; M J Keating; P Huang Journal: Leukemia Date: 2004-12 Impact factor: 11.528
Authors: Mustafa Benekli; Zheng Xia; Kathleen A Donohue; Laurie A Ford; Lynda A Pixley; Maria R Baer; Heinz Baumann; Meir Wetzler Journal: Blood Date: 2002-01-01 Impact factor: 22.113
Authors: Jinbo Yang; Xudong Liao; Mukesh K Agarwal; Laura Barnes; Philip E Auron; George R Stark Journal: Genes Dev Date: 2007-05-17 Impact factor: 11.361
Authors: Jeremy A Meier; Moonjung Hyun; Marc Cantwell; Ali Raza; Claudia Mertens; Vidisha Raje; Jennifer Sisler; Erin Tracy; Sylvia Torres-Odio; Suzana Gispert; Peter E Shaw; Heinz Baumann; Dipankar Bandyopadhyay; Kazuaki Takabe; Andrew C Larner Journal: Sci Signal Date: 2017-03-28 Impact factor: 8.192
Authors: Ushma A Doshi; Jeremy Shaw; Todd E Fox; David F Claxton; Thomas P Loughran; Mark Kester Journal: Signal Transduct Target Ther Date: 2017-10-27
Authors: Jing Pan; Yongik Lee; Gang Cheng; Jacek Zielonka; Qi Zhang; Martina Bajzikova; Donghai Xiong; Shirng-Wern Tsaih; Micael Hardy; Michael Flister; Christopher M Olsen; Yian Wang; Ole Vang; Jiri Neuzil; Charles R Myers; Balaraman Kalyanaraman; Ming You Journal: iScience Date: 2018-04-22