Do human leukocyte antigen-typed cellular therapeutics based on induced pluripotent stem cells make commercial sense?

The promise of off-the-shelf cellular therapeutics (CTPs) based on allogeneic induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) may be hindered by alloimmunity, leading many to suggest that such products could be based on a series of human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-typed iPSC lines allowing at least some degree of tissue matching. While based on sound scientific principles, this suggestion presupposes that other immune responses will not be limiting. Technically this approach would present a number of major challenges, the first being the development of a suitably reliable reprogramming method amenable to validation that results in highly consistent iPSC lines. Further, the resulting array of HLA-typed iPSCs would need to be shown to be capable of being manufactured into the same CTP and exhibit comparable quality, safety, and efficacy. When the enormities of these challenges are laid out, it becomes apparent that the manufacturing and product development challenges would be unprecedented. Given the uncertainties and lack of clinical experience with iPSC-based CTPs at this time, the financial costs and commercial risks do not appear to be acceptable.