Strain-specific bioaccumulation and intracellular distribution of Cd²⁺ in bacteria isolated from the rhizosphere, ectomycorrhizae, and fruitbodies of ectomycorrhizal fungi.

Bioaccumulation of Cd(2+) in soil bacteria might represent an important route of metal transfer to associated mycorrhizal fungi and plants and may have potential as a tool to accelerate Cd(2+) extraction in the bioremediation of contaminated soils. The present study examined the bioaccumulation of Cd(2+) in 15 bacterial strains representing three phyla (Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, and Bacteroidetes) that were isolated from the rhizosphere, ectomycorrhizae, and fruitbody of ectomycorrhizal fungi. The strains Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, Variovorax sp. ML3-12, and Luteibacter sp. II-116-7 displayed the highest biomass productivity at the highest tested Cd(2+) concentration (2 mM). Microscopic analysis of the cellular Cd distribution revealed intracellular accumulation by strains Massilia sp. III-116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, and Bacillus sp. ML1-2. The quantities of Cd measured in the interior of the cells ranged from 0.87 to 1.31 weight % Cd. Strains originating from the rhizosphere exhibited higher Cd(2+) accumulation efficiencies than strains from ectomycorrhizal roots or fruitbodies. The high Cd tolerances of Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-16 and Bacillus sp. ML1-2 were attributed to the binding of Cd(2+) as cadmium phosphate. Furthermore, silicate binding of Cd(2+) by Bacillus sp. ML1-2 was observed. The tolerance of Massilia sp. III-116-18 to Cd stress was attributed to a simultaneous increase in K(+) uptake in the presence of Cd(2+) ions. We conclude that highly Cd-tolerant and Cd-accumulating bacterial strains from the genera Massilia sp., Pseudomonas sp., and Bacillus sp. might offer a suitable tool to improve the bioremediation efficiency of contaminated soils.

Introduction

Cadmium (pan class="Gene">Cd2+) is not involved in any known biological processes and is one of the most critical heavy metal pollutants due to its high solubility in water (Pinto et al. 2003), rapid accumulation in the food chain, severe toxic effects on living organisms, and mutagenic nature (Rani and Goel 2009; Farooq et al. 2010). Cd2+ exposure has numerous effects in humans, including kidney damage, high blood pressure, and bone fractures (Drasch 1983), and is acknowledged as a priority pollutant by the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) (Krishnan and Anirudhan 2003). The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) has placed Cd2+ on the Candidate List of Substances of Very High Concern for Authorisation (SVHC), and its content in products is subjected to rigorous restrictions [Regulation (EC) No. 1907/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council, 2006]. Cd is commonly present in wastes from technological processes such as plastic manufacturing, galvanizing plating or pigments, and Cd/Ni battery production. Cd2+ is highly toxic in even relatively low concentrations; the World Health Organization (WHO) describes the highest permissible level of this element as 0.003 mg L−1 (Cadmium in drinking water 2011). Cd2+ soil contamination can decrease crop yields by inhibiting photosynthesis, respiration, and nitrogen metabolism and by reducing water and mineral uptake (Tynecka et al. 1981). Microorganisms associated with plant roots can increase biomass production at sites polluted with heavy metals, affect metal mobilization in the soil, and protect the host plant from heavy metal toxicity (Hrynkiewicz and Baum 2012; 2013).

Many bacteria are tolerant to high concentrations of Cd2+; however, this element generally causes reduced growth, long log phases, lower cell denpan class="Chemical">sities, and even bacterial death (Les and Walker 1984; Sinha and Mukherjee 2009). The presence of Cd2+ in the environment can affect the survival and composition of bacterial populations, thereby negatively affecting plant growth (Siripornadulsil and Siripornadulsil 2013) and impacting the entire ecosystem. Bacteria have developed several mechanisms for the detoxification of Cd2+, e.g., extracellular and intracellular sequestration (Hetzer et al. 2006), active efflux out of the cell (Teitzel and Parsek 2003), and biotransformation into less toxic forms (Khan et al. 2010), which allow these bacteria to tolerate increased concentrations of Cd2+ ions in the environment (Nies 1999).

A fundamental strategy to avoid the toxic effects of Cd2+ ions that is widespread among bacterial species is to prevent the ions from entering the cell and to keep them away from the target pan class="Chemical">sites (exclusion). This process may involve three different mechanisms: adsorption on the cell surface, secretion of high amounts of viscous slime outside the cells, and/or precipitation (Bruins et al. 2000; Zamil et al. 2008; Deb et al. 2013). The bacterial cell wall is the first component that interacts with heavy metal ions (Yun et al. 2011). Mechanisms of cell surface sorption are passive and based upon physicochemical interactions between the metal and the functional groups of the cell wall; this process occurs independently of cell metabolism (Oh et al. 2009). The negatively charged bacterial cell wall can bind high quantities of positively charged Cd2+ ions, thereby immobilizing the metal and inhibiting its intracellular toxic effects (Goulhen et al. 2006; Parungao et al. 2007). The carboxyl groups responsible for forming Cd-carboxyl complexes on the bacterial surface may be involved in this process (Yee and Fein 2001). Moreover, some bacteria secrete exopolysaccharides or capsular materials that bind high amounts of Cd2+ (Ron et al. 1992). Exopolysaccharides synthesized by Arthrobacter viscosus accumulate 2.3 times more Cd2+ than an equivalent weight of intact cells and have 13.7 times the sorptive capacity of Arthrobacter globiformis cells, which do not produce exopolysaccharides (Scott and Palmer 1988). This phenomenon of Cd2+ ion accumulation in capsular material has been observed in A. viscosus and Klebsiella aerogenes (Scott and Palmer 1988, Scott and Palmer 1990). Cd2+ influx into bacterial cells can also be limited by external precipitation (Bruins et al. 2000). Citrobacter sp. can resist Cd2+ toxicity by forming insoluble complexes of Cd-phosphate (McEntee et al. 1986), while K. aerogenes excretes sulfur into the surrounding environment to immobilize Cd2+ ions as insoluble Cd-sulfide (Aiking et al. 1982; Scott and Palmer 1990).

Increased bacterial tolerance to Cd stress is accomplished through the intracellular immobilization of ions accumulated in bacterial cells. pan class="Chemical">Magnesium (Gram-negative) or manganese (Gram-positive) uptake systems sequester Cd2+ by internal precipitation or by binding Cd2+ to thiol-rich peptides (Ron et al. 1992; Nies 1995). One Citrobacter mutant isolated from metal-polluted soil accumulates Cd2+ as insoluble cell-bound CdHPO4; this transformation is mediated by a cell-bound phosphatase that precipitates inorganic phosphate with heavy metals (Macaskie et al. 1987). A strain of Pseudomonas putida isolated from sewage can sequester intracellular Cd2+ by producing three low-molecular-weight cysteine-rich proteins related to eukaryotic metallothioneins (Trevors et al. 1986). Moreover, some bacterial antioxidant defense enzymes, e.g., catalase, peroxidase, and superoxide dismutase (SOD), can participate in monitoring metal ion levels and respond accordingly by regulating gene expression (Horsburgh et al. 2001).

Bacterial detoxification of Cd2+ can also be accomplished by active efflux of the ions (Tynecka et al. 1981). In Gram-negative bacteria, pan class="Gene">Cd2+ appears to be detoxified by RND-driven systems such as Czc, which is mainly a zinc exporter (Nies 1995; Nies and Silver 1989), and Ncc, which is mainly a nickel exporter (Nies 1995; Schmidt and Schlegel 1994). The Czc system is driven by a H+ ion gradient that allows CzcA (located in the inner membrane) to pump Cd2+ out of the cytoplasm (Diels et al. 1995). The presence of this system has been confirmed, inter alia, for Ralstonia metallidurans and Ralstonia eutropha (Nies 1995; Rani and Goel 2009). In Gram-positive species, the removal of Cd2+ from the interior of the cell is mediated by the CadA pump, which acts as a Cd-exporting P-type ATPase; this mechanism has also been described for Staphylococcus aureus (Nucifora et al. 1989; Silver et al. 1989). The presence of CadA-like proteins has also been confirmed in other Gram-positive bacteria, such as Bacillus sp. and Listeria sp. (Bruins et al. 2000). Although detoxification of Cd2+ by biological methylation has been proposed, there is no conclusive evidence for microbial transformation of Cd2+ (Ron et al. 1992).

Several studies have confirmed the ability of heavy-metal-repan class="Chemical">sistant bacteria to accumulate Cd2+ in their living cells (Malik 2004). Roane and Pepper (2000) observed that bacterial strains originating from metal-contaminated soils had different capacities to remove Cd2+ from growth media; these varying capacities were most likely due to differing Cd2+ resistance mechanisms. Surprisingly, the most efficient strains in this investigation comprised both Gram-negative (Pseudomonas strain H1) and Gram-positive (Bacillus strain H9) bacteria. Similarly, Haq et al. (1999) observed a significant reduction in the Cd2+ content in the medium during the growth of bacteria derived from industrial effluents but did not observe strain-specific differences in the mechanism of resistance. These data suggest that the use of growing microbial cells could be a very promising method of Cd2+ removal that, unlike conventional biosorption techniques, exhibits a constant capacity. However, a more accurate overview of the mechanisms of Cd2+ accumulation at the cellular level is needed (Roane and Pepper 2000).

The main objectives of this study were (i) to select the most effective Cd-accumulating bacterial strains from 15 bacterial strains isolated from the rhizosphere, ectomycorrhizae, and fruitbody of ectomycorrhizal fungi; (ii) to determine the strain-specific distribution of absorbed pan class="Gene">Cd2+ within single cells; and (iii) to assess atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS) as a suitable tool to indicate the Cd2+ uptake capacity of bacteria for future bioremediation application.

Materials and methods

Bacterial strains

A total of 15 bacterial strains were isolated from the rhizosphere, ectomycorrhizae, and fruitbodies of ectomycorrhizal fungi associated with willows (Salix viminalis L.) growing at anthropogenic degraded pan class="Chemical">sites. The examined strains represented three phyla (Firmicutes, Proteobacteria, and Bacteroidetes) and were characterized by different cell wall compositions, both Gram-negative and Gram-positive. Four strains from the class Bacilli (Bacillus cereus B1, B2, B3, B4) had been previously identified and described by Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012). Six strains from the class Gammaproteobacteria (Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, Luteibacter sp. II-116-7, Serratia entomophila I-111-21), Betaproteobacteria (Massilia sp. III-116-18), Bacteroidetes sp. I-116-1 and Flavobacterium sp. I-111-11 were selected from a group of 50 investigated bacterial strains on the basis of physiological properties by Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010). The strain Pseudomonas fulva was isolated from the interior tissues of the roots of Scots pine trees growing in sand dunes at the Baltic Sea of Poland (Strzelczyk and Li 2000), a noncontaminated site. The remaining four strains, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, Luteibacter rhizovicinus ML3-1, Variovorax sp. ML3-12, and Pseudomonas fluorescens LIC 1, were isolated from ectomycorrhizae or fruitbodies collected at heav- metal-contaminated test sites (Hrynkiewicz et al. 2008) and identified and described for the first time (based on 16S rDNA) in this work. The identification procedure was performed according to Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010, 2012) with small modifications. The DNA of bacterial strains was isolated using Dneasy® Blood & Tissue Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). The amplification of the 16S ribosomal RNA (16S rRNA) gene was performed using Taq PCR Master Mix (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) and primers F1 (5′-GAG TTT GAT CCT GGC TCA G-3′) and R12 (5′-ACG GCT ACC TTG TTA CGA CTT–3′) (Dorsch and Stackebrandt 1992). The thermal program comprised an initial denaturation step of 2 min at 95 °C, followed by 30 cycles of 1-min denaturation at 94 °C, 1-min annealing at 55 °C, and 2-min extension at 72 °C, and a final elongation step of 5 min at 72 °C. The PCR products were purified using the QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). Direct sequencing of PCR products was performed using the PCR primers as sequencing primers. Sequences were aligned manually aided by the Sequencher system (TW Version 5.1, Gene Codes, Ann Arbor, MI, USA). The BLAST database (Altschul et al. 1997) of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) was used to compare obtained sequences of all isolates with known 16S rRNA gene sequences of bacterial strains. The DNA sequences determined in this study were deposited in GenBank under accession numbers [KM411501], [KM411502], [KM411503], [KM411504] (Table 1). The results of molecular identification of newly identified bacterial strains were presented in the form of phylogenetic tree and presented in the supplementary data (Fig. 4).

Table 1

Bacterial strains used in the study

Nr	Strain	Accession number	Origina	References
Phylum Firmicutes, class Bacilli
1	Bacillus cereus B1	HM989918	M	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012)
2	Bacillus cereus B2	HM989916	M	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012)
3	Bacillus cereus B3	HM989917	M	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012)
4	Bacillus cereus B4	HM989919	F	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012)
5	Bacillus sp. ML1-2	[KM41111502]a	M	This work
Phylum Proteobacteria, class Gammaproteobacteria
6	Pseudomonas fluorescens LIC 1	[KM411503]a	F	This work
7	Pseudomonas fulva	[KM411501]a	R	This work
8	Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14	FJ786066	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)
9	Luteibacter rhizovicinus ML3-1		M	This work
10	Luteibacter sp. II-116-7	FJ786052	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)
11	Serratia entomophila I-111-21	FJ786072	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)
Phylum Proteobacteria, class Betaproteobacteria
12	Massilia sp. III-116-18	FJ786054	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)
13	Variovorax sp. ML3-12	[KM411504]a	M	This work
Phylum: Bacteroidetes
14	Bacteroidetes sp. I-116-1	FJ786045	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)
15	Flavobacterium sp. I-111-11	FJ786048	R	Hrynkiewicz et al. (2010)

M mycorhizosphere, F fruitbody, R rhizosphere

aAccession numbers will be given

Concentration of Cd in bacterial biomass—AAS analysis

Analyses of Cd2+ accumulation were performed upan class="Chemical">sing the biomass of 3-day bacterial cultures (liquid medium R2A, Difco, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) supplemented with CdSO4 × 7H2O to final Cd concentrations of 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, and 3.0 mM. The chemicals present in the medium can induce Cd2+ ion precipitation. To evaluate the real availability of soluble Cd2+ to the cultivated bacterial strains in the medium, the concentration of available Cd2+ ions was measured by AAS. The control samples were cultured in liquid medium without added heavy metal. The bacterial inoculum was grown on solid R2A medium at 26 °C for 3 days and suspended in distilled water to obtain a cell density of approximately OD600 0.02. After incubation with Cd2+ for 24 h, the bacterial cells were centrifuged and rinsed three times in buffer (0.1 M Tris–HCl, 10 mM EDTA, and deionized water) to remove residual broth. The biomass of the bacterial cells was then dried and weighed. The dried bacterial pellets were digested in concentrated nitric and hydrochloric acids (1:3 v/v). The Cd2+ contents of the digests were analyzed using a Perkin Elmer 4100 apparatus for AAS. The influence of the Cd2+ concentration in the growth medium on the cell biomass and metal uptake efficiency was analyzed according to the following formula:

Amount of Cd2+ accumulated in the dried biomass (μg)

Amount of Cd2+ in the medium (mg)

Transmission electron microscopy/X-ray microanalysis

Elemental analysis was conducted by high-angle annular dark field scanning transmispan class="Chemical">sion electron microscopy (STEM-HAADF) with energy-dispersive X-ray microanalysis (EDS) for the five selected bacterial strains: Massilia sp. III-116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, P. fulva, and S. entomophila I-111-21. These strains exhibited the highest Cd2+ accumulation efficiency in the biomass (based on the results presented in Table 2). Bacterial cells were fixed and embedded in LRGold resin using a standard procedure described in Hrynkiewicz et al. (2012), with one modification: Ultrathin sections were not contrasted with osmium tetroxide (OsO4) to avoid osmium interference. A Tecnai F20 X-Twin electron microscope (FEI Europe), equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectrometer, was used to perform qualitative and quantitative analyses of control cells and cells cultured in 2 mM Cd2+ to characterize the elemental composition (C, O, S, P, Na, K, Ca, Mg, and Si) and location of the Cd within the bacterial cells. The linear profile of changes in the content of Cd and other elements in the cross sections of bacterial cells was determined using the TIA software (TEM Imaging & Analysis Offline ver. 4.2 SP1, FEI Co.) based on point measurements taken every 10 nm along the diameter. These analyses were performed for six Cd-treated and three untreated (control) bacterial cells.

Table 2

Grouping of bacteria according to biomass production in the presence of different concentrations of Cd2+ (0.2, 0.3, 1.0, 2.0 mM) in the medium and efficiency of bioaccumulation of Cd2+ based on AAS analyses

aGrouping of bacteria according to their highest biomass obtained at the highest concentration of Cd2+ (0.2, 0.3, 1.0, 2.0 mM).

bCd concentration at which the highest efficiency of metal uptake by bacterial cells was achieved

cDry weight of bacterial cells obtained with maximum efficiency (mg)

dMaximum amount of Cd accumulated in the biomass of the bacterial cells expressed by the formula E = Cd content (μg)/1,000 / mass Cd in the sample (mg) *100 %

Statistical analyses

The differences in elemental composition between the control cells and the pan class="Chemical">Cd-treated cells were analyzed by Student’s t test using Statistica software (Statistica ver. 7, Statsoft). The linear dependence of the Cd2+ content on the quantities of other elements within the bacterial cells was expressed by Pearson’s correlation coefficient, and the significance of this correlation was verified by Student’s t test.

Results

The analysis of the influence of the Cd2+ concentration in the growth medium on the intracellular metal accumulation in the 15 studied bacterial strains revealed four classes based on biomass and three based on Cd2+ uptake efficiency, with no appreciable effect of bacterial origin or genus (Table 2). Three strains, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, Variovorax sp. ML3-12, and Luteibacter sp. II-116-7, displayed the highest biomass productivity at the highest Cd2+ concentration (2 mM), while most of the strains (particularly P. fulva, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, B. cereus B4, P. fluorescens LIC 1, and Bacteroidetes sp. I-116-1) exhibited highest growth in the medium containing 1 mM Cd2+. In terms of Cd2+ uptake efficiency, three strains of B. cereus (B2, B3, and B4) comprised the class that exhibited the greatest metal accumulation at the highest Cd2+ concentration. The other 12 strains exhibited maximum Cd2+ accumulation capacity at 0.2 mM Cd2+ (S. entomophila I-111-21, Variovorax sp. ML3-12, P. fluorescens LIC 1, Luteibacter sp. II-116-7, and Bacteroidetes sp. I-116-1) or 0.3 mM Cd2+ (Massilia sp. III-116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, L. rhizovicinus ML3-1, P. fulva, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, Flavobacterium sp. I-111-11, and B. cereus B1). In the majority of cases (8 of 15 tested strains), the maximum biomass production occurred when the Cd2+ concentration in the medium was higher than the concentration associated with the maximum Cd2+ accumulation capacity. Only two strains—B. cereus B1 and Flavobacterium sp. I-111-11—exhibited the highest biomass production and Cd uptake capacity at the same Cd2+ concentration (0.3 mM).

Analysis of the biomass yield obtained at maximum Cd2+ accumulation efficiencies revealed three classes of bacterial strains (Table 2, max. efficiency). The class of bacteria characterized by a biomass production exceeding 20 mg of dry weight included six Gram-negative strains belonging to the Gammaproteobacteria and Betaproteobacteria—three Pseudomonas spp., Massilia sp. III-116-18, S. entomophila I-111-21, and Variovorax sp. ML3-12—and were mostly (four of six) isolated from rhizospheres. Fruitbody-derived Variovorax sp. ML3-12 reached the highest biomass growth—30 mg of dry weight (DW). The cellular biomass of seven of the bacterial strains ranged from 10 to 20 mg of DW. Only two strains of B. cereus (B3 and B2), which were isolated from ectomycorrhizal roots of Salix caprea formed by Hebeloma spp., produced less than 10 mg of DW at the maximum Cd2+ uptake capacity.

The AAS analyses revealed four groups of bacteria based on their Cd2+ bioaccumulation efficiency (Table 2, max. efficiency). The class characterized by the highest pan class="Chemical">Cd accumulation in the bacterial cellular biomass—exceeding 50 % of the quantity of Cd2+ added to the medium—comprised three rhizosphere-derived Gram-negative strains (Massilia sp. III–116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, and L. rhizovicinus ML3-1). Massilia sp. III–116-18 exhibited the highest efficiency among these strains, taking up 100 % of the Cd2+ added to the medium. Four strains (P. fulva, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, B. cereus B4, and S. entomophila I-111-21) displayed Cd2+ uptake capacities of 32–44 %. The lowest efficiencies (<10 %) were observed for Variovorax sp. ML3-12, Flavobacterium sp. I-111-11, P. fluorescens LIC 1, Luteibacter sp. II-116-7, B. cereus B1, Bacteroidetes sp. I-116-1, and B. cereus B2; these strains were considered inefficient with respect to Cd2+ accumulation and were omitted from further analyses.

The strains that most efficiently accumulated Cd2+, Massilia sp. III–116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, L. rhizovicinus ML3-1, P. fulva, S. entomophila I-111-21, and B. cereus B3, exhibited higher growth in the presence of Cd2+ compared to the control, while no significant differences in the growth of Bacillus sp. ML1-2 and B. cereus B4 were observed in the absence and presence of Cd2+ (Fig. 1). The biomasses of the strains Massilia sp. III–116-18 and L. rhizovicinus ML3-1 did not statistically differ with increasing Cd2+ content. However, P. fulva, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, and S. entomophila I-111-21 produced significantly higher biomasses in media with Cd2+ concentrations ranging from 0.3 to 2.0 mM than at 0.2 mM Cd2+, while B. cereus strain B3 exhibited highest growth at the lowest Cd2+ concentration (0.2 mM).

Fig. 1

Cell biomass produced within 3 days by eight soil bacterial strains characterized by high Cd accumulation efficiency in media containing different amounts of Cd

No significant differences in the efficiency of pan class="Gene">Cd2+ uptake with increasing concentrations of Cd2+ were observed for the strain S. entomophila I-111-21 (Fig. 2). B. cereus B3 and B4 increased Cd2+ accumulation with increasing Cd2+ concentrations in the medium, while Massilia sp. III–116-18, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, and L. rhizovicinus ML3-1 significantly increased Cd2+ accumulation in 0.3 mM Cd2+ but gradually decreased it at higher Cd2+ concentrations. Two strains of Pseudomonas species exhibited considerably higher Cd2+ uptake in 0.2–0.3 mM Cd2+ compared to 1 and 2 mM Cd2+. All strains except B. cereus B4 produced higher biomass in the media supplemented with Cd2+ than in the untreated medium.

Fig. 2

Cd accumulation capacity of eight bacterial strains characterized by high Cd uptake efficiency in culture media containing different amounts of Cd

The Cd2+ and elemental nutrient composition of five highly Cd-accumulating strains were investigated in detail: Massilia sp. III–116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, P. fulva, Bacillus sp. ML1-2, and S. entomophila I-111-21. In Massilia sp. III–116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, and Bacillus sp. ML1-2, Cd was present within the cells (Tables 3–5 and Fig. 3). Intracellular Cd levels in Cd-treated P. fulva and S. entomophila I-111-21 were no different from the levels in the untreated control (Tables 6 and 7 and Fig. 3). In the cells of strains that contained substantial amounts of Cd, the metal was present both in the cell wall and the interior of the cells. The quantities of Cd differed significantly between the two investigated cellular compartments (data not shown). The quantities measured in the interior of the cells ranged from 0.87 to 1.31 weight % Cd. Cd2+ content was always lower in the cell wall (0.18–0.60 weight % Cd). In the strain Massilia sp. (which had the highest maximum Cd2+ accumulation efficiency according to the AAS analyses), the proportion of Cd in the cell wall was higher compared to that of the other strains (0.60 ± 0.37 weight % Cd), but the proportion of Cd in the interior of the cells did not differ from that of the other strains. A positive correlation between Cd content and K content (0.95, p = 0.015) inside the cells and in the cell walls of Bacillus sp. ML1-2 was observed. Moreover, the Cd content was correlated with the Ca content (0.94, p = 0.006) inside Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14 cells and with the O content (0.99, p = 0.008) within Massilia sp. III–116-18 cells. In the cell walls of Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, a negative correlation of the Cd content with the K content was observed. Testing of whole cells of Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, Massilia sp. III–116-18, and Bacillus sp. ML1-2 revealed a positive correlation between the P content and Cd content in all three strains (Pearson’s r values: 0.89, p = 0.000; 0.85, p = 0.001; and 0.77, p = 0.006, respectively). Furthermore, in Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14 and Bacillus sp. ML1-2, a significant correlation between the amounts of S and of Cd was observed. In the cells of Massilia sp. III–116-18 and Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, the Ca content was positively correlated with the Cd content (the linear correlation coefficients were 0.70, p = 0.011, and 0.95, p = 0.000, respectively).

Fig. 3

Representative STEM HAADF images indicating a linear profile of Cd content within single cells of a Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, b Massilia sp. III-116-18, and c Bacillus sp. ML

Phylogenetic relationships of newly identified bacterial strains: Bacillus sp. ML1-2, Luteibacter rhizovicinus ML3-1, Variovorax sp. ML3-12, and Pseudomonas fluorescens LIC 1 (Clustal W analysis of 16S rDNA bacterial sequences)

The analyses of the changes in elemental composition between Cd-treated and untreated cells revealed significant differences in all five studied strains. The changes in the elemental composition in response to increased Cd2+ concentrations in the medium were more significant inside the cells than in the cell walls. Only Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14 exhibited similar decreases in P, S, K, and Ca contents in the cell wall and inside cells in response to increased Cd concentrations. The strongest changes in the elemental composition of the interior of the cells were measured in Massilia sp. III–116-18. In response to Cd treatment, the C content increased, and O, Mg, Si, S, P, and Ca levels decreased, while in the cell walls, only the S and Ca contents decreased. In the interior of the cells of Bacillus sp. ML1-2, larger changes in the elemental compositions of C, Si, P, and K were measured, while smaller changes in C and Si contents were observed in the cell walls. In the cellular compartments of P. fulva and S. entomophila I-111-21, which did not accumulate Cd2+ at relevant levels, the changes in elemental composition were less significant than those in the other investigated strains. However, the same number of changes (4) was observed in the interior of the cells of S. entomophila I-111-21 as in Bacillus sp. ML1-2 and Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14. The whole cell analyses revealed no differences in the number of elements that changed quantities (4) between Bacillus sp. ML1-2 and Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14 or between Massilia sp. III–116-18 and P. fulva strains. The fewest changes (2) in elemental composition were observed in S. entomophila I-111-21.

The Cd2+-mediated changes in the proportions of the individual elements in the cell wall, interior of the cells, and whole bacterial cells were investigated upan class="Chemical">sing a simple comparative analysis of the elemental content in Cd-treated and untreated control cells. The results were expressed as the percentage ratio of the difference between the mean values of the element quantities. The statistical outliers were rejected from the data set (Dixon’s Q test, p = 0.05). In addition to Cd, the analyses included elements indicated as the most abundant (C, O, and Si), light metals (Na, K, Mg, and Ca), P, and S, which may be involved in bacterial Cd2+ uptake. The analysis revealed two types of changes among strains that exhibited a capacity for intracellular Cd2+ accumulation. Increased contents of P and O were observed simultaneously with decreased amounts of C in both the cell walls and cell interior. The amounts of P and O in the interior of the cells of Cd-treated cells exceeded those in the control cells by 87–186 % and 11 %, respectively, while the C content decreased by 2–5 %. The changes in C and O contents were greater in the cell walls than in the interior of the cells and ranged from 6 to 23 % (decrease) and from 55 to 106 % (increase), respectively. Similar changes were observed in Bacillus sp. and Pseudomonas sp. strains. In addition, in Bacillus sp. cells, an apparent increase in Si content in the cell wall (1,298 %) and the interior of the cells (433 %) was observed. In the second type of elemental composition change, Na (30 %), Mg (48 %), and Ca (93 %) declined and K (2,293 %) increased within the interior of the cells; both decreases (Ca 92 %) and increases (Na 10 %, Si 93 %, and K 1,583 %) in the cell wall were also noted. This phenomenon was also observed for a third Cd2+-accumulating strain—Massilia sp. Changes similar to those observed in the cell wall and interior of the cells were observed in whole cells. C decreased (4–14 %) and the O and P contents increased (23–65 % and 101–118 %, respectively) in Bacillus sp. and Pseudomonas sp. in response to Cd2+ treatment. In addition, in whole cells of Massilia sp., lower P (48 %) and Ca (92 %) and higher K (1896 %) and Si (40 %) were measured in response to Cd2+ treatment.

Discussion

This work is the first to analyze the bioaccumulation of Cd2+ ions by soil bacterial species across a broad spectrum of genera, origins, and cell structures. All 15 studied bacterial strains were able to accumulate pan class="Gene">Cd2+ in their cellular biomass; however, the efficiency of Cd2+ bioaccumulation differed significantly among the investigated strains, ranging from 2 to 100 %. These extremely dissimilar Cd2+ bioaccumulation capacities may be due primarily to differences in morphology, e.g., differences in the cell wall structure, which plays an important role in the biosorption of Cd2+ (Gourdon et al. 1990). Cell wall composition is a key factor in differentiating two basic bacterial morphotypes: Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria (Yun et al. 2011). Of the 15 tested strains, 10 were Gram-negative bacteria, and among these, 3 strains exhibited a maximum amount of Cd2+ accumulation in their biomasses (>50 %): Massilia sp., Pseudomonas sp., and L. rhizovicinus. The major Cd2+ binding sites of Gram-negative bacteria have been proposed to be located on the cell surface, which includes many carboxylate groups from the phospholipid and lipopolysaccharide characteristic of the external layer (Gourdon et al. 1990; Leung et al. 2001; Italiano et al. 2009). In the present study, Bacillus sp. ML1-2 and B. cereus B4 and B2 (22–38 %) exhibited the highest Cd2+ bioaccumulation efficiency among the tested Gram-positive bacteria. The lower Cd2+ accumulation efficiency of the Gram-positive bacteria may suggest other bioaccumulation mechanisms that are independent of passive sorption onto the cell surface. For Gram-positive strains, the process of Cd2+ bioadsorption can be achieved by extracellular deposition mediated by functional groups (i.e., −OH, −NH, and −PO4 3−) present in the cell wall components peptidoglycan, glycoprotein, teichoic acid, and teichuronic acid (Gourdon et al. 1990; Liu et al. 2010); the last two compounds are characteristic of Gram-positive bacteria (Yee and Fein 2001). Roane et al. (2001) studied four Cd2+-resistant soil bacteria representing the genera Arthrobacter, Bacillus, and Pseudomonas and identified a plasmid-dependent intracellular mechanism of Cd2+ detoxification for two of these strains (Pseudomonas sp. H1 and Bacillus sp. H9). The capacities of these strains to accumulate Cd2+ were higher than those of strains producing an extracellular polymer layer. Based on the absence of the cad operon in the investigated isolates and the concurrent reduction of soluble Cd2+ concentrations in the medium, an intracellular mechanism of Cd2+ sequestration, such as metallothionein production or polyphosphate precipitation, could be assumed (Malik 2004). Roane et al. (2001) demonstrated that resistant strains belonging to the same bacterial genus may vary in their strategies of resistance to Cd2+, e.g., two Pseudomonas spp. accumulated Cd2+ by extracellular (Pseudomonas sp. 11a) or intracellular (Pseudomonas sp. H1) sequestration, which may indicate a strain-dependent mechanism of Cd2+ accumulation. This explanation was supported by Selenska–Pobell et al. (1999), who revealed that the cellular accumulation of some metal ions, including Cd2+, by three Bacillus strains (B. cereus, Bacillus megaterium, and Bacillus sphaericus) was species specific. Similarly, our study reveals strain-specific differences in Cd2+ accumulation efficiencies within the genera Pseudomonas, Bacillus, and Luteibacter. The differences in the Cd2+ uptake capacities of the strains belonging to the genera Pseudomonas and Bacillus might be due to their different origins. Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14 derived from rhizosphere exhibited considerably higher Cd2+ accumulation efficiencies (61 %) than the P. fluorescens LIC1 isolated from a fruitbody (8 % accumulation of Cd2+). Conversely, the strains of B. cereus isolated from ectomycorrhizae of Tomentella and Hebeloma spp. (B1–B3) were less effective than Bacillus sp. ML1-2 and B4 isolated from the fruitbodies of H. mesophaeum (33 and 38 %, respectively). This phenomenon can be explained by a habitat-specific adaptation to high concentrations of Cd2+ in these strains. Plants can increase the concentration of heavy metals in the soil solution by secreting metal-mobilizing substances called phytosiderophores into the rhizosphere (Lone et al. 2008) or by secreting H+ ions, which can increase metal dissolution by acidification of the soil (Ali et al. 2013). Consequently, bacteria from the rhizosphere exhibited greater capacities to accumulate heavy metals than strains isolated from fruitbodies. Bacteria inhabiting ectomycorrhizal roots may be exposed to lower concentrations of Cd2+ due to the restriction in metal movement to roots caused by the ectomycorrhizal sheath or by binding to the cell wall of the mycelium (Hall 2002).

The most effective strains for Cd2+ accumulation belonged to the genera pan class="Species">Pseudomonas (Selenska-Pobell et al. 2001; Pardo et al. 2003; Ziagova et al. 2007; Choudhary and Sar 2009) and Bacillus (Selenska-Pobell et al. 2001; Zouboulis et al. 2004; Yilmaz and Ensari 2005); high Cd2+ accumulation by species of these genera has been previously reported. However, this study is the first to report Cd2+ accumulation in a Massilia sp. strain. Massilia sp. III–116-18 exhibited the highest Cd2+ uptake at Cd2+ concentrations of 0.3–2 mM. The high potential for Cd2+ uptake observed for strains of L. rhizovicinus and S. entomophila in the present study has not been extensively reported. In one of the few papers describing this aspect of Serratia sp., Choudhary et al. (2012) reported high Cd2+ resistance and accumulation capacities of the tested strain. The present results suggest that an extension of the screening of bacterial taxa for Cd2+ bioaccumulation to improve the efficiency of bioremediation of contaminated soils or sludge would be promising because only a few taxa have been evaluated in detail and many highly valuable candidates might still be unknown.

In our work, the majority of the tested bacterial strains (Massilia sp. III–116-18, pan class="Species">Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, L. rhizovicinus ML3-1, P. fulva, S. entomophila I-111-21, B. cereus B3, B. cereus B4, and Bacillus sp. ML1-2) did not exhibit significant changes in biomass or actually increased biomass production when grown in media containing increasing concentrations of Cd2+. This phenomenon was discussed by Roane and Pepper (2000), who observed higher biomass production by Pseudomonas H1 at Cd2+ concentrations of 60, 150, and 300 μg ml−1 compared to lower Cd2+ concentrations (48 μg Cd ml−1). The authors suggested that the increased resistance of bacteria with increasing Cd2+ concentrations might be due to a shift in the mechanism of resistance under more stressful conditions. Naz et al. (2005) did not observed any changes in the growth of five investigated sulfate-reducing bacteria in the presence of subtoxic Cd2+ concentrations compared to the control without toxic ions.

Microscopic analysis of the pan class="Chemical">Cd distribution within the cells of the five most efficient Cd-accumulating bacterial strains revealed intracellular accumulation by Massilia sp. III–116-18, Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-14, and Bacillus sp. ML1-2. Cd2+ was bound in both the cell wall and within the interior of the cells, and the amounts measured in the cytosol were significantly higher compared to those measured in the peripheral parts of the cells. This finding may suggest the presence of Cd-binding and/or efflux mechanisms inside the cells that mediate resistance against Cd2+ toxicity. Similar to our findings, Trevors et al. (1986) demonstrated intracellular Cd2+ sequestration in a cysteine-rich-protein-producing strain of P. putida isolated from sewage. Both periplasmic and cytoplasmic sequestrations of Cd2+ in Escherichia coli due to metallothionein expression were observed by Pazirandeh et al. (1998) and Yoshida et al. (2002). Similarly, the simultaneous accumulation of Cd2+ in the cell envelope and within the cytoplasm was reported by Choudhary and Sar (2009) and Sinha and Mukherjee (2009); however, the investigated Pseudomonas strains preferentially sequestrated Cd2+ in and around the cell periphery compared to the cytoplasm.

In the present study, the absence of Cd2+ within the cells of pan class="Species">P. fulva and S. entomophila I-111-21 suggests cell surface binding of Cd2+ as a dominant detoxification mechanism. Siripornadulsil and Siripornadulsil (2013) investigated the Cd2+ accumulation ability of 24 Gram-negative bacteria isolated from rice fields and observed cell-surface- or cell-wall-bound Cd2+, which was easily washed out by EDTA. A similar phenomenon was reported for vegetative cells of Bacillus strains isolated from the drain waters of a uranium waste dump, where most of the heavy metals accumulated were easily extracted with EDTA/Tris solution (Selenska-Pobell et al. 1999). Thus, we suggest that the absence of Cd peaks in energy dispersive X-ray spectra for both P. fulva and S. entomophila I-111-21 cells in the present study could be the result of chelation and subsequent rinsing of the surface-bound Cd2+.

Based on the observed differences in elemental composition within the cell walls and interior of the cells between pan class="Gene">Cd2+-treated and control cells of the investigated bacterial strains, we suggest three different mechanisms of intracellular Cd2+-accumulation. The first mechanism is related to the increased accumulation of phosphate detected in Pseudomonas sp. IV-111-16 and Bacillus sp. ML1-2. Because cadmium phosphate is poorly soluble (Aiking et al. 1984) and significantly increased levels of phosphate were observed in the Cd2+-treated bacterial cells (compared to bacterial cells cultivated without Cd2+), this phenomenon might indicate a mechanism of detoxification by intracellular sequestration. This suggestion is supported by previous reports (Aiking et al. 1984; Keasling and Hupf 1996) indicating a clear correlation between increased resistance to Cd2+ and increased phosphate content inside K. aerogenes and E. coli cells. Moreover, some authors suggest that polyphosphate granules present in bacterial cells are responsible for the intracellular binding of metals (Volesky et al. 1992; Volesky and May-Philips 1995). The second mechanism assumes that some Gram-positive bacteria (e.g., Bacillus subtilis) are able to retain several heavy metals as silicate minerals (Mera and Beveridge 1993a). This mechanism could explain the results observed for the Bacillus sp. ML1-2 strain analyzed in our work. The binding of silicate and the formation of metallic salts on the surface of Gram-positive bacteria cells could occur in two different ways: (i) by the binding of SiO3 2− to positively charged groups present in the teichoic acids and in the peptidoglycan or (ii) by binding of SiO3 2− through cationic bridging by wall-bound metallic cations (Mera and Beveridge 1993b). However, the Bacillus sp. ML1-2 strain investigated in this study exhibited an increased content of silicates within the interior of the cells, in contrast to the proposed definition. A third mechanism, ion exchange, has been suggested as a leading process for Cd2+ entry into cells for Massilia sp. III-116-18. For this bacterial strain, significant changes in the amounts of Na, Mg, Ca, and K in the interior of the cells and Na, Ca, and K in the cell wall were observed. The replacement of Ca2+ by Cd2+ in the cell wall could be explained by the ion exchange properties of polysaccharides, in which metallic ions can exchange with the counter ions such as Zn2+, Cu2+, or Cd2+ (based on the hard-and-soft principle proposed by Avery and Tobin (1993)), resulting in their accumulation (Veglio and Beolchini 1997). A simultaneous increase in Na and K content may indicate cation competition between monovalent cations and Cd2+, which has been previously demonstrated for Na+ and Tl+ in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Avery and Tobin 1993), but this phenomenon is not clear. The elemental changes within the interior of Massilia sp. III-116-18 cells indicated a phenomenon of Ca and Mg release from bacteria during metal accumulation (Choudhary and Sar 2009). However, the increased intracellular K content observed in our studies is in contrast to the findings of Choudhary and Sar (2009), who used the same EDX technique and observed a significant loss of cellular K after metal uptake by metal-resistant Pseudomonas sp. isolated from a uranium mine (from 25.7 to 3.5 % and less). However, in a study by Nies (1992) similar to our study, a stimulatory effect of Cd2+ on K+ uptake was observed in R. metallidurans CH34. Thus, referring to the claim of Guffanti et al. (2002), K+ uptake may have a protective function in conjunction with efflux activity.

Conclusions

The ability of soil bacteria to accumulate Cd2+ is strain specific, and the variation within a species can exceed the variations between different species or genera. The rhizosphere appears to be a promipan class="Chemical">sing source of highly Cd-tolerant and Cd-accumulating bacterial strains. The mechanisms of Cd2+ tolerance vary by strain and cause a strain-specific pattern of response to increased Cd2+ concentrations in the medium. Within bacterial cells, Cd2+ is mainly accumulated in the interior of the cells and in smaller quantities in the cell walls. The present results suggest that an extension of the screening of bacterial taxa for Cd2+ bioaccumulation to improve the efficiency of bioremediation of contaminated soils might yield promising results because only a few taxa have been evaluated in detail and many highly valuable candidates might be still unknown. As the most promising, we suggest strains from the genus Massilia sp., Pseudomonas sp., and Bacillus sp.

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

(DOCX 37 kb)