Emmanuel Gibon1, Thierry Farman2, Simon Marmor3. 1. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Diaconesses Croix-Saint-Simon Teaching Hospital, 125 rue d'Avron, 75020, Paris, France. emmanuel.gibon@gmail.com. 2. Mutuelle d'assurance du corps de santé français (MACSF), 10 cours du Triangle-de-l'Arche, TSA 40100, 92919, La Défense Cedex, Paris, France. thierry.farman@orange.fr. 3. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Diaconesses Croix-Saint-Simon Teaching Hospital, 125 rue d'Avron, 75020, Paris, France. smarmor@hopital-dcss.org.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Data regarding knee arthroplasty and lawsuit are scarce. With the expected increase in knee arthroplasty over the next 25 years, the number of claims might follow the same trend. Therefore, the most frequent causes of litigation after knee arthroplasty in France, and what is considered as malpractice by the expert, were determined. METHODS: Over 8-year period, data gathered from a French private insurance company specializing in malpractice for private practitioners were analyzed. Demographics, type of knee arthroplasty, reason for claim, details of the legal procedure and the expert's decision were reviewed. RESULTS: One hundred and five claims were processed by four jurisdictions. Most of the cases concerned primary total knee arthroplasty. Surgeons and anesthesiologists were charged in 84 and 16 % of claims, respectively. The most frequent causes of litigation were infection, neurological deficit and unsatisfactory result, whereas the most common reasons for the surgeon's liability, as stated by the expert, were delay in diagnosis or treatment of a complication, infection and technical error. CONCLUSION: Our findings show that frequent complications are not those which raise most of the claims. Patients sue the surgeon when the outcome of the surgery is different from what they were expecting. An unsatisfactory result, according to the patient's point of view, is the second most frequent cause of claim. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV, Economic and Decision Analysis. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
PURPOSE: Data regarding knee arthroplasty and lawsuit are scarce. With the expected increase in knee arthroplasty over the next 25 years, the number of claims might follow the same trend. Therefore, the most frequent causes of litigation after knee arthroplasty in France, and what is considered as malpractice by the expert, were determined. METHODS: Over 8-year period, data gathered from a French private insurance company specializing in malpractice for private practitioners were analyzed. Demographics, type of knee arthroplasty, reason for claim, details of the legal procedure and the expert's decision were reviewed. RESULTS: One hundred and five claims were processed by four jurisdictions. Most of the cases concerned primary total knee arthroplasty. Surgeons and anesthesiologists were charged in 84 and 16 % of claims, respectively. The most frequent causes of litigation were infection, neurological deficit and unsatisfactory result, whereas the most common reasons for the surgeon's liability, as stated by the expert, were delay in diagnosis or treatment of a complication, infection and technical error. CONCLUSION: Our findings show that frequent complications are not those which raise most of the claims. Patients sue the surgeon when the outcome of the surgery is different from what they were expecting. An unsatisfactory result, according to the patient's point of view, is the second most frequent cause of claim. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV, Economic and Decision Analysis. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
Authors: Robin W T M van Kempen; Janneke J P Schimmel; Gijs G van Hellemondt; Hilde Vandenneucker; Ate B Wymenga Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2013-03-30 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Benjamin Zmistowski; Camilo Restrepo; Lauren K Kahl; Javad Parvizi; Peter F Sharkey Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2011-01 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Allen Kachalia; Samuel R Kaufman; Richard Boothman; Susan Anderson; Kathleen Welch; Sanjay Saint; Mary A M Rogers Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2010-08-17 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Kevin J Bozic; Steven M Kurtz; Edmund Lau; Kevin Ong; Vanessa Chiu; Thomas P Vail; Harry E Rubash; Daniel J Berry Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2009-06-25 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Carlo L Romanò; Maria Teresa Trentinaglia; Elena De Vecchi; Nicola Logoluso; David A George; Ilaria Morelli; Lorenzo Drago Journal: BMC Infect Dis Date: 2018-04-02 Impact factor: 3.090