Sarah E Gollust1, Hanna A Kite, Sara J Benning, Rachel A Callanan, Susan R Weisman, Marilyn S Nanney. 1. Sarah E. Gollust is with the Division of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota School of Public Health, Minneapolis. At the time of the study, Hanna A. Kite was with the Division of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota School of Public Health, and Sara J. Benning was with the Children, Youth, & Family Consortium, University of Minnesota Extension, Minneapolis. Rachel A. Callanan is with the American Heart Association Midwest Affiliate, Edina, MN. Susan R. Weisman is with the Public Health Law Center, William Mitchell College of Law, St. Paul, MN. Marilyn S. Nanney is with the Department of Family Medicine and Community Health and the Program in Health Disparities Research, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: We describe how scientific evidence about obesity has been used in Minnesota legislative materials to understand how research evidence might more effectively be translated into policymaking. METHODS: We selected 13 obesity-related bills introduced from 2007 to 2011 in Minnesota. Using state archives, we collected all legislative committee meeting materials and floor testimony related to each bill. We used a coding instrument to systematically analyze the content of a sample of 109 materials for their use of research evidence and non-research-based information. RESULTS: Research evidence was mentioned in 41% of all legislative materials. Evidence was often used to describe the prevalence or consequences of obesity or policy impacts but not to describe health disparities. In 45% of materials that cited evidence, no source of evidence was indicated. By contrast, 92% of materials presented non-research-based information, such as expert beliefs, constituent opinion, political principles, and anecdotes. CONCLUSIONS: Despite an abundance of available research evidence on obesity, less than half of legislative materials cited any such evidence in discussions around obesity-related bills under consideration in Minnesota.
OBJECTIVES: We describe how scientific evidence about obesity has been used in Minnesota legislative materials to understand how research evidence might more effectively be translated into policymaking. METHODS: We selected 13 obesity-related bills introduced from 2007 to 2011 in Minnesota. Using state archives, we collected all legislative committee meeting materials and floor testimony related to each bill. We used a coding instrument to systematically analyze the content of a sample of 109 materials for their use of research evidence and non-research-based information. RESULTS: Research evidence was mentioned in 41% of all legislative materials. Evidence was often used to describe the prevalence or consequences of obesity or policy impacts but not to describe health disparities. In 45% of materials that cited evidence, no source of evidence was indicated. By contrast, 92% of materials presented non-research-based information, such as expert beliefs, constituent opinion, political principles, and anecdotes. CONCLUSIONS: Despite an abundance of available research evidence on obesity, less than half of legislative materials cited any such evidence in discussions around obesity-related bills under consideration in Minnesota.
Authors: Ross C Brownson; Elizabeth A Dodson; Katherine A Stamatakis; Christopher M Casey; Michael B Elliott; Douglas A Luke; Christopher G Wintrode; Matthew W Kreuter Journal: J Natl Cancer Inst Date: 2011-01-06 Impact factor: 13.506
Authors: Julie A Jacobs; Elizabeth A Dodson; Elizabeth A Baker; Anjali D Deshpande; Ross C Brownson Journal: Public Health Rep Date: 2010 Sep-Oct Impact factor: 2.792
Authors: Hanna A Kite; Sarah E Gollust; Rachel A Callanan; Susan R Weisman; Sara J Benning; Marilyn S Nanney Journal: Am J Health Promot Date: 2014 Jan-Feb
Authors: Judy Jou; Marilyn S Nanney; Elizabeth Walker; Rachel Callanan; Susan Weisman; Sarah E Gollust Journal: J Public Health Manag Pract Date: 2018 May/Jun
Authors: Jonathan Purtle; Félice Lê-Scherban; Xi Wang; Paul T Shattuck; Enola K Proctor; Ross C Brownson Journal: Implement Sci Date: 2018-09-19 Impact factor: 7.327
Authors: Natalie R Smith; Stephanie Mazzucca; Marissa G Hall; Kristen Hassmiller Lich; Ross C Brownson; Leah Frerichs Journal: Implement Sci Commun Date: 2022-03-04
Authors: Nasreen S Jessani; Sameer M Siddiqi; Carly Babcock; Melissa Davey-Rothwell; Shirley Ho; David R Holtgrave Journal: Health Res Policy Syst Date: 2018-07-25