Peter J Dodd1, Elizabeth Gardiner2, Renia Coghlan3, James A Seddon4. 1. Health Economics and Decision Science, School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK. Electronic address: p.j.dodd@shef.ac.uk. 2. Global Alliance for TB Drug Development, New York, NY, USA. 3. TESS Development Advisors, Geneva, Switzerland. 4. Department of Paediatric Infectious Diseases, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Confirmation of a diagnosis of tuberculosis in children (aged <15 years) is challenging; under-reporting can result even when children do present to health services. Direct incidence estimates are unavailable, and WHO estimates build on paediatric notifications, with adjustment for incomplete surveillance by the same factor as adult notifications. We aimed to estimate the incidence of infection and disease in children, the prevalence of infection, and household exposure in the 22 countries with a high burden of the disease. METHODS: Within a mechanistic mathematical model, we combined estimates of adult tuberculosis prevalence in 2010, with aspects of the natural history of paediatric tuberculosis. In a household model, we estimated household exposure and infection. We accounted for the effects of age, BCG vaccination, and HIV infection. Additionally, we tested sensitivity to key structural assumptions by repeating all analyses without variation in BCG efficacy by latitude. FINDINGS: The median number of children estimated to be sharing a household with an individual with infectious tuberculosis in 2010 was 15,319,701 (IQR 13,766,297-17,061,821). In 2010, the median number of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections in children was 7,591,759 (5,800,053-9,969,780), and 650,977 children (424,871-983,118) developed disease. Cumulative exposure meant that the median number of children with latent infection in 2010 was 53,234,854 (41,111,669-68,959,804). The model suggests that 35% (23-54) of paediatric cases of tuberculosis in the 15 countries reporting notifications by age in 2010 were detected. India is predicted to account for 27% (22-33) of the total burden of paediatric tuberculosis in the 22 countries. The predicted proportion of tuberculosis burden in children for each country correlated with incidence, varying between 4% and 21%. INTERPRETATION: Our model has shown that the incidence of paediatric tuberculosis is higher than the number of notifications, particularly in young children. Estimates of current household exposure and cumulative infection suggest an enormous opportunity for preventive treatment. FUNDING: UNITAID and the US Agency for International Development.
BACKGROUND: Confirmation of a diagnosis of tuberculosis in children (aged <15 years) is challenging; under-reporting can result even when children do present to health services. Direct incidence estimates are unavailable, and WHO estimates build on paediatric notifications, with adjustment for incomplete surveillance by the same factor as adult notifications. We aimed to estimate the incidence of infection and disease in children, the prevalence of infection, and household exposure in the 22 countries with a high burden of the disease. METHODS: Within a mechanistic mathematical model, we combined estimates of adult tuberculosis prevalence in 2010, with aspects of the natural history of paediatric tuberculosis. In a household model, we estimated household exposure and infection. We accounted for the effects of age, BCG vaccination, and HIV infection. Additionally, we tested sensitivity to key structural assumptions by repeating all analyses without variation in BCG efficacy by latitude. FINDINGS: The median number of children estimated to be sharing a household with an individual with infectious tuberculosis in 2010 was 15,319,701 (IQR 13,766,297-17,061,821). In 2010, the median number of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infections in children was 7,591,759 (5,800,053-9,969,780), and 650,977 children (424,871-983,118) developed disease. Cumulative exposure meant that the median number of children with latent infection in 2010 was 53,234,854 (41,111,669-68,959,804). The model suggests that 35% (23-54) of paediatric cases of tuberculosis in the 15 countries reporting notifications by age in 2010 were detected. India is predicted to account for 27% (22-33) of the total burden of paediatric tuberculosis in the 22 countries. The predicted proportion of tuberculosis burden in children for each country correlated with incidence, varying between 4% and 21%. INTERPRETATION: Our model has shown that the incidence of paediatric tuberculosis is higher than the number of notifications, particularly in young children. Estimates of current household exposure and cumulative infection suggest an enormous opportunity for preventive treatment. FUNDING: UNITAID and the US Agency for International Development.
Authors: R J Flick; M H Kim; K Simon; A Munthali; M C Hosseinipour; N E Rosenberg; P N Kazembe; J Mpunga; S Ahmed Journal: Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Date: 2016-08 Impact factor: 2.373
Authors: E R Maritz; G Montepiedra; L Liu; C D Mitchell; S A Madhi; R Bobat; A Violari; A Ogwu; A C Hesseling; M F Cotton Journal: Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Date: 2016-08 Impact factor: 2.373
Authors: Shaun K Morris; Anne-Marie Demers; Ray Lam; Lisa G Pell; Ryan Jp Giroux; Ian Kitai Journal: Paediatr Child Health Date: 2015-03 Impact factor: 2.253
Authors: Bareng A S Nonyane; Mark P Nicol; Nicholas J Andreas; Stefanie Rimmele; Nicole Schneiderhan-Marra; Lesley J Workman; Mark D Perkins; Thomas Joos; Tobias Broger; Jerrold J Ellner; David Alland; Beate Kampmann; Susan E Dorman; Heather J Zar Journal: Pediatr Infect Dis J Date: 2018-01 Impact factor: 2.129
Authors: Courtney M Yuen; Helen E Jenkins; Carly A Rodriguez; Salmaan Keshavjee; Mercedes C Becerra Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2015-06-01 Impact factor: 7.124