Akina Hino1, Teruhisa Tanaka2, Maho Takaishi1, Yumiko Fujii1, Juan E Palomares-Rius1, Koichi Hasegawa3, Haruhiko Maruyama1, Taisei Kikuchi1. 1. Division of Parasitology, Faculty of Medicine,University of Miyazaki,Miyazaki, 889-1692Japan. 2. Department of Infections, Respiratory and Digestive Medicine, Faculty of Medicine,University of the Ryukyus,Okinawa, 903-0213Japan. 3. Department of Environmental Biology,College of Bioscience and Biotechnology, Chubu University,Kasugai, Aichi, 487-8501Japan.
Abstract
SUMMARY Strongyloides venezuelensis is a parasitic nematode that infects rodents. Although Strongyloides species described to date are known to exhibit parthenogenetic reproduction in the parasitic stage of their life cycle and sexual reproduction in the free-living stage, we did not observe any free-living males in S. venezuelensis in our strain, suggesting that the nematode is likely to depend on parthenogenetic reproduction. We confirmed by cytological analysis that S. venezuelensis produces eggs by parthenogenesis during the parasitic stage of its life cycle. Phylogenetic analysis using nearly the full length of 18S and D3 region of 28S ribosomal RNA gene suggested that S. venezuelensis is distantly related to another rodent parasite, namely Strongyloides ratti, but more closely related to a ruminant parasite, Strongyloides papillosus. Karyotype analysis revealed S. venezuelensis reproduces with mitotic parthenogenesis, and has the same number of chromosomes as S. papillosus (2n = 4), but differs from S. ratti (2n = 6) in this regard. These results, taken together, suggest that S. venezuelensis evolved its parasitism for rodents independently from S. ratti and, therefore, is likely to have a different reproductive strategy.
SUMMARY Strongyloides venezuelensis is a parasitic nematode that infects rodents. Although Strongyloides species described to date are known to exhibit parthenogenetic reproduction in the parasitic stage of their life cycle and sexual reproduction in the free-living stage, we did not observe any free-living males in S. venezuelensis in our strain, suggesting that the nematode is likely to depend on parthenogenetic reproduction. We confirmed by cytological analysis that S. venezuelensis produces eggs by parthenogenesis during the parasitic stage of its life cycle. Phylogenetic analysis using nearly the full length of 18S and D3 region of 28S ribosomal RNA gene suggested that S. venezuelensis is distantly related to another rodent parasite, namely Strongyloides ratti, but more closely related to a ruminant parasite, Strongyloides papillosus. Karyotype analysis revealed S. venezuelensis reproduces with mitotic parthenogenesis, and has the same number of chromosomes as S. papillosus (2n = 4), but differs from S. ratti (2n = 6) in this regard. These results, taken together, suggest that S. venezuelensis evolved its parasitism for rodents independently from S. ratti and, therefore, is likely to have a different reproductive strategy.
The genus Strongyloides comprises over 50 species of nematodes that
parasitize mammals, amphibians, reptiles and birds (Viney and Lok, 2007). Strongyloides nematodes have complex but
interesting life cycles. Infection by Strongyloides begins when the
infective third stage larvae (iL3) attach to and penetrate the host skin. Once inside the
host, they moult twice into parasitic adults and settle in the small intestine of the host.
Then, the parasitic adults, all female, produce eggs by parthenogenesis (Fig. 1A). Once the eggs or hatched larvae are excreted
from the host, they develop via the homogonic route into iL3 forms or the heterogonic route
into free-living stages that reproduce sexually outside the host (Fig. 1A); sexual reproduction in the free-living generation was shown
for two species, Strongyloides ratti (Viney, 1996) and Strongyloides papillosus (Eberhardt
et al.
2007). The progeny of free-living adults are
entirely female and develop into iL3 forms in most Strongyloides species,
including S. ratti and Strongyloides stercoralis, with a
few exceptions (Yamada et al.
1991; Streit, 2008).
Fig. 1.
(A) Life cycle of Strongyloides ratti. Parasitic females produce
eggs by parthenogenesis in the host's small intestine and the eggs are excreted into
the environment in the faeces. Eggs develop into infective larvae by two alternative
routes. In the homogonic route, eggs develop directly into infective larva. In the
heterogonic route, eggs develop into free-living forms, reproducing sexually, after
which the resultant eggs develop into infective larva. (B) Life cycle of
Strongyloides venezuelensis. S. venezuelensis may lack the
heterogonic developmental route in its life cycle.
(A) Life cycle of Strongyloides ratti. Parasitic females produce
eggs by parthenogenesis in the host's small intestine and the eggs are excreted into
the environment in the faeces. Eggs develop into infective larvae by two alternative
routes. In the homogonic route, eggs develop directly into infective larva. In the
heterogonic route, eggs develop into free-living forms, reproducing sexually, after
which the resultant eggs develop into infective larva. (B) Life cycle of
Strongyloides venezuelensis. S. venezuelensis may lack the
heterogonic developmental route in its life cycle.Parthenogenetic reproduction by parasitic females was found to be mitotic in cytological
studies for S. papillosus, Stronglyoides ransomi (Triantaphyllou and
Moncol, 1977) and for S. ratti
(Chitwood and Graham, 1940), and using molecular
markers for S. ratti (Viney, 1994)
and S. papillosus (Nemetschke et al.
2010). In these species, the progeny from parasitic
females can develop into one of three distinct morphologies: free-living females,
free-living males (both via the heterogonic route) or iL3s (homogonic route). Although the
ratio of these morphologies is influenced by environmental factors such as host immune
response, temperature and pH (Arizono, 1976; Moncol
and Triantaphyllou, 1978; Nwaorgu, 1983; Viney, 1996; Harvey et al.
2000; Minato et al.
2008; Sakamoto and Uga, 2013), the detailed mechanisms which determine their route of
development remain unclear. Moreover, S. stercoralis and S.
ratti harbour three pairs of chromosomes, and one of them is a sex (X) chromosome.
Females of these species have an XX and free-living males have an XO karyotype (Streit,
2008). Genetic material homologous to two
chromosomes in S. ratti, namely I and X, appears combined into one
chromosome in S. papillosus. Additionally, an XX/XO karyotype appears to be
functionally restored in males by a chromatin diminution event (Nemetschke et al.
2010).Strongyloides venezuelensis parasitizes rodent species including rats,
mice and Mongolian gerbilMeriones unguiculatus and is distributed
worldwide (Brumpt, 1934; Wertheim and Lengy, 1964; Little, 1966; Hasegawa et al.
1988). Strongyloides
venezuelensis, alongside S. ratti, is one of the most widely used
laboratory models to study Strongyloides infection and mucosal immunity
(Sato and Toma, 1990; El-Malky et al.
2013). Although both S. ratti and
S. venezuelensis have rodents as hosts, the individual mechanisms by
which they establish parasitism are thought to differ from each other. Phylogenetic analysis
with ribosomal RNA gene suggested that S. venezuelensis is not as closely
related to S. ratti as to S. papillosus and the primate
parasite Strongyloides fuelleborni (Dorris et al.
2002). The migration patterns of the two rodent
parasites in the host (Takamure, 1995), as well as
mechanisms of host immunomodulation for successful parasitism, differ from each other as
well (Wilkes et al.
2007; Matsumoto et al.
2013). More interestingly, observation of
free-living adults is less common in S. venezuelensis as compared with
S. ratti (Hasegawa et al.
1988; Harvey et al.
2000), suggesting that reproduction strategies used
by the two species may also be different. Thus, the parasitic abilities of the two species
may have evolved independently from each other, and a comparison between the two may provide
invaluable insights into understanding the parasitic mechanism and its evolution in
Strongyloides nematodes.Though S. venezuelensis is a widely used laboratory model, some aspects of
its basic biology remain unclear. In this report, we re-examined the phylogenetic position
of S. venezuelensis within the genus Strongyloides, using
18S rRNA and the D3 expansion segment of 28S rRNA genes. We also examined the developmental
routes of progeny from the parasitic females, chromosome behaviour in the germ cells and
early embryos in S. venezuelensis. Our analyses suggest that acquisition of
rodent parasitism occurred independently in S. venezuelensis and S.
ratti.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Culturing and handling nematodes
Strongyloides venezuelensis HH1 and S. ratti TDI
isolates were used in this study. They were isolated from Okinawa, Japan (Hasegawa
et al.
1988) and Tokyo, Japan, respectively, and
maintained in the Parasitology laboratory of the University of Miyazaki, using male Wistar
rats. Infectious aliquots were prepared by faecal culture using filter paper at 27 °C for
2 days and 5 days for S. venezuelensis and S. ratti,
respectively (Sato and Toma, 1990). The nematodes
were washed three times in distilled water, and administered by subcutaneous injection.
Strongyloides papillosus iL3 was supplied from Dr Ayako Yoshida of
University of Miyazaki. Parastrongyloides trichosuri DNA (strain KNP from
Warwick Grant's lab) was supplied by Berriman lab from Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute,
UK. Strongyloides stercoralis was collected in Yangon, Myanmar.
PCR conditions and DNA sequencing
Nearly full-length 18S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) was amplified with primers 988F–1912R and
1813F–2646R from a lysate of a single nematode as described previously (Holterman
et al.
2006). These primers amplify 1652 bp out of
1754 bp of full-length 18S rDNA of C. elegans (NR_000053·1). The D3
region of 28S rDNA was amplified using primers D3A-D3B (Nunn et al.
1996). PCR amplifications were carried out in
30 μL reaction mixtures containing 15 μL GoTaq Green
Master Mix (Promega), 0·5 μm of each primer, and
1 μL of appropriately diluted nematode lysate under thermal-cycling
conditions of 94 °C for 1 min, followed by 30 cycles of 94 °C for 30 s, 53 °C for 30 s and
72 °C for 1 min. PCR products were purified before sequencing using a MinElute 96 UF PCR
purification plate (QIAGEN). DNA sequencing was performed using the BigDye Terminator 3.1
kit and ABI PRISM 3700 or 3130 Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems).
Phylogenetic analyses
Nearly full-length 18S rRNA gene and D3 expansion segments of 28S rRNA gene of
Strongyloides species were used for phylogenetic reconstruction.
Parastrongyloides trichosuri was used as an outgroup taxon. The newly
obtained and published sequences for each gene were aligned using MAFFT (Katoh et
al.
2002) with iterative refinement method
(FFT-NS-i). Both datasets were concatenated using Concatenator v.1.1.0. (Pina-Martins and
Paulo, 2008). Phylogenetic analyses of the
sequence dataset were performed with maximum likelihood (ML) using PAUP*4b10 (Wilgenbusch
and Swofford, 2003) and Bayesian inference (BI)
using MrBayes 3.1.2 (Huelsenbeck and Ronquist, 2001). The best-fitted model of DNA evolution was obtained using ModelTest v.2
(Darriba et al.
2012) with the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC).
The Akaike-supported model, base frequency, proportion of invariable sites, gamma
distribution shape parameters and substitution rates in the AIC were then used in
phylogenetic analyses. BI analysis under the TVM+G model for D3 expansion segment of 28S
and the TVM+I+G model for 18S rDNA was initiated with a random starting tree and run with
four Metropolis-coupled Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) for 1×106 generations
in the combined dataset. The MCMC were sampled every 100 generations. Two runs were
performed for each analysis. After discarding burn-in samples and evaluating convergence,
the remaining samples were retained for further analyses. The topologies were used to
generate a 50% majority rule consensus tree. Trees were visualized using TreeView (Page,
1996). In ML analysis the estimation of the
support for each node was obtained by bootstrap analysis with 1000 heuristic search
replicates using the previously obtained models. Posterior probabilities and bootstrap
support are given on respective clades.
Free-living occurrence observation
Three rats were infected with 500 iL3s of S. venezuelensis or S.
ratti. Faeces samples from each rat were collected at 8, 12, 14, 16 and 24 days
post-infection (d.p.i.) for S. venezuelensis and at 8 d.p.i. for
S. ratti. Faeces (approx. 0·5 g) were cultured on a 2% (w/v) agar plate
at various temperatures (19, 25, or 30 °C) for 3 days and free-living male and female
nematodes were counted. Three agar plates for each day and each condition were used. A
portion of the faecal samples (c. 1·5 g) was diluted in distilled water
to determine the eggs/larvae per gram (epg/lpg) of faeces. All statistical analyses were
performed using the software package R version 2.15.2 (http://www.r-project.org).
Early embryogenesis
Parasitic females were obtained from rat intestine at 5–10 d.p.i. Fresh parasites were
transferred to a pre-warmed (37 °C) agarose pad (4% (w/v) agarose) prepared on a
microscope slide (Shaham, 2006) and covered with
a silicon grease-rimmed cover slip and viewed under a Nomarski microscope (IX71, Olympus,
Japan). All procedures involving the microscopic observations were performed at 37 °C.
DAPI staining/microscopy
Parasitic females were fixed with ice-cold methanol and stained with DAPI as previously
described (Nemetschke et al.
2010). To collect the eggs, parasitic females
were allowed to lay eggs in PBS, the eggs were then squashed and stained as previously
described with the exception of using methanol instead of acetic acid for fixation
(Albertson et al.
1979). Microscopic observations were carried out
using a confocal laser scanning microscope (LSM700, Zeiss).
RESULTS
Phylogenetic position of S. venezuelensis
In order to determine the phylogenetic position of S. venezuelensis in
the genus, we used nearly full-length 18S rRNA and D3 expansion segments of 28S rRNA
genes. We sequenced these regions in S. venezuelensis, S. papillosus, S.
stercoralis, S. ratti and P. trichosuri for phylogenetic
analysis. 18S sequences from other Strongyloides species obtained from
the public database were also included in the analysis. Our phylogenetic tree using
P. trichosuri as an outgroup indicated that the
Strongyloides species can be divided into two clades (Fig. 2): one clade comprising of S.
papillosus, S. fuelleborni, S. venezuelensis, Strongyloides callosciureus, Strongyloides
robustus and Strongyloides cebus, and the other including
S. stercoralis, Strongyloides procyonis and S. ratti.
Within the former clade, S. venezuelensis was further clustered into a
subclade with S. papillosus and S. fuelleborni.
Fig. 2.
The molecular phylogenetic relationship between Strongyloides
species inferred from concatenated nearly full-length 18S rRNA gene (1640 positions
from edited alignment) and D3 expansion segments of 28S rRNA gene (289 positions
from edited alignment). TVM+G and TVM+I+G were used for D3 expansion segment of 28S
and 18S, respectively. Posterior probabilities (first number in the node label) more
than 65% are given for appropriate clades; bootstrap values greater than 50% are
given on appropriate clades in ML analysis (second number in the node label).
The molecular phylogenetic relationship between Strongyloides
species inferred from concatenated nearly full-length 18S rRNA gene (1640 positions
from edited alignment) and D3 expansion segments of 28S rRNA gene (289 positions
from edited alignment). TVM+G and TVM+I+G were used for D3 expansion segment of 28S
and 18S, respectively. Posterior probabilities (first number in the node label) more
than 65% are given for appropriate clades; bootstrap values greater than 50% are
given on appropriate clades in ML analysis (second number in the node label).
Occurrences of free-living adults in S. venezuelensis
As the ratio of free-living females/males vs females developing
homogonically into iL3s is influenced by several factors, including host immunity and
other environmental conditions (temperature, pH etc.), in other
Strongyloides species (Arizono, 1976; Moncol and Triantaphyllou, 1978;
Nwaorgu, 1983; Viney, 1996; Harvey et al.
2000; Minato et al.
2008; Sakamoto and Uga, 2013), we used two parameters (days post infection and faeces
incubation temperature) to examine the occurrence of free-living nematodes (FLNs) in
S. venezuelensis.In a total of 162 attempts, comprising of six d.p.i.s (8, 12, 14, 16, 20 and 24) and
three temperature conditions (19, 25 and 30 °C), each with three rats and triplicate, we
observed FLNs of S. venezuelensis in only 19 cases. As this frequency is
much lower than that reported in S. ratti (Harvey et al.
2000; Minato et al.
2008; Sakamoto and Uga, 2013), we validated our method using S. ratti in
place of S. venezuelensis. In the S. ratti experiment we
observed FLNs in all culture plates tested (Table S1) and the numbers of FLNs (8·32 to
17·4 FLNs per 1000 eggs) were similar to those reported previously (Minato et al.
2008). Therefore we confirmed that this low
frequency (19 out of 162 cases) was not due to errors in handling of the samples. Of note
is that in some culture plates (52 cases) we did not observe the homogonically developed
nematodes (iL3s) although the faeces contained a sufficient number of eggs, which may
suggest that the development of S. venezuelensis is more sensitive to
environmental conditions than that of S. ratti. Furthermore, free-living
males were never detected in S. venezuelensis (Table 1) while approximately half of FLNs in the S.
ratti experiment were males (Table S1). Consequently, no hatching was observed in
eggs derived from the free-living females (data not shown).
Table 1.
Total number of free living nematodes observed in S. venezuelensis
faeces samples
19 °C
25 °C
30 °C
Free-living female
0 (0/54)
17 (7/54)
46 (12/54)
Free-living male
0 (0/54)
0 (0/54)
0 (0/54)
Fifty-four culture plates were used at each temperature.
Numbers in parentheses represent numbers of incidents of free-living observation
(i.e. 17(7/54) indicates a total number of 17 free-living nematodes found in 7 out
of 54 culture plates).
Total number of free living nematodes observed in S. venezuelensis
faeces samplesFifty-four culture plates were used at each temperature.Numbers in parentheses represent numbers of incidents of free-living observation
(i.e. 17(7/54) indicates a total number of 17 free-living nematodes found in 7 out
of 54 culture plates).In the 19 plates with S. venezuelensisFLNs, 7 plates (17 FLNs in total)
were from 25 °C culture and 12 plates (46 FLNs) were from 30 °C culture (Table 1). We did not observe any FLNs in 19 °C
cultures (Table 1).We observed S. venezuelensisFLNs in 1, 3, 4, 3, 2, and 2 cases at 8,
12, 14, 16, 20 and 24 d.p.i., respectively (Fig.
3) and the number of FLNs on each d.p.i. was 3, 6, 6, 43, 4, and 4, respectively.
Although the number of eggs per gram of faeces (epg) decreased as the d.p.i. increased
(Fig. 3), the number of instances that FLNs were
observed did not change significantly (Generalized Linear Model with binomial error
distribution: df = 52, P>0·9). Then, we sought to
investigate the relationship between epg and occurrence of FLNs. Figure S1 shows a plot of
epg and number of FLNs per gram of faeces. The trend observed was that fewer epg showed
more numbers of FLNs per egg (Fig. S1).
Fig. 3.
(Upper) Free-living occurrences in S. venezuelensis. Nineteen
positive cultures (in which free-living nematodes were found) out of 162 were
plotted by number of free-living nematodes (FLNs) per 1000 eggs and day post
infection (d.p.i.). Faeces were cultured at 19, 25 or 30 °C. No free-living
nematodes were observed in 19 °C cultures. (Bottom) EPG change by d.p.i. The black
dot represents the mean and crosses represent the highest and the lowest in each
d.p.i.: n = 3.
(Upper) Free-living occurrences in S. venezuelensis. Nineteen
positive cultures (in which free-living nematodes were found) out of 162 were
plotted by number of free-living nematodes (FLNs) per 1000 eggs and day post
infection (d.p.i.). Faeces were cultured at 19, 25 or 30 °C. No free-living
nematodes were observed in 19 °C cultures. (Bottom) EPG change by d.p.i. The black
dot represents the mean and crosses represent the highest and the lowest in each
d.p.i.: n = 3.The highest number of FLNs was obtained with faeces collected at 16 d.p.i. and cultured
at 30 °C (34 FLNs, 6·58 per 1000 eggs). However this was an outlier as the other two
plates under the same conditions (same rat, d.p.i. and temperature) showed much lower
numbers of FLNs (0·24 or 0 per 1000 eggs).
Germ cells in the parasitic female
Strongyloides venezuelensis parasitic females have two elongated
(didelphic) gonads extending from the vulva to the head or the tail directions, reflexed
around the beginning of the intestine or anus, continuing around the vulva (Little, 1966) (Fig.
4A, B). Egg development and embryogenesis progress as stages move along the tract
from the germinal tissue to the vulva. Both gonads spiral about themselves around the
intestine (Fig. 4A, B, E). As with many nematodes
the distal part of the germ line was a syncytium; nuclei were located at the inner surface
of the germ line (Fig. 4C–E). Chromosomes in all
nuclei in the distal region dispersed peripherally, and nuclei were condensed in the
‘germinal zone’ (Fig. 4F). As nuclei moved away
from the germinal zone they were packed one by one into a cell in the ‘growth zone’ and
became oocytes (Fig. 4G). Germinal vesicles
appeared and chromosomes became condensed during the oocyte movement towards the proximal
region, and they seemed to be arrested at this stage until they passed through the oviduct
(Fig. 4G). We detected four chromosomes and this
state could be prometaphase of the ‘maturation division’ (see below). We did not identify
any sperm or sperm nuclei in the gonad in either bright-field or DAPI-stained
observations. From these results, we conclude that parasitic females of S.
venezuelensis reproduce parthenogenetically.
Fig. 4.
Germ cells in a parasitic female of S. venezuelensis. (A, B) Whole
body of a parasitic female under bright field and DAPI fluorescence microscopy. V,
vulva; SR, spiralled region; (C) Distal side of a gonad. DR: distal region GZ:
germinal zone; (D) Oogonium in distal end of a gonad; (E) Oogonium in spiralled
region of a gonad; (F) Condensed nucleus in the germinal zone; (G) Condensed
chromosomes in the growth zone. (Scale bars: A, B, C = 100 μm; D,
E, F = 10 μm; G = 20 μm; boxes in F,
G = 1 μm).
Germ cells in a parasitic female of S. venezuelensis. (A, B) Whole
body of a parasitic female under bright field and DAPI fluorescence microscopy. V,
vulva; SR, spiralled region; (C) Distal side of a gonad. DR: distal region GZ:
germinal zone; (D) Oogonium in distal end of a gonad; (E) Oogonium in spiralled
region of a gonad; (F) Condensed nucleus in the germinal zone; (G) Condensed
chromosomes in the growth zone. (Scale bars: A, B, C = 100 μm; D,
E, F = 10 μm; G = 20 μm; boxes in F,
G = 1 μm).
Early embryogenesis of eggs from the parasitic female
To see if the embryo starts development without fertilization, we observed oocyte
maturation and early embryogenesis in the parasitic female sequentially with light
microscopy. After the mature oocyte passed through the oviduct into the uterus, the
eggshell was formed (Fig. 5A). The embryo shape
was oval and the long axis of the embryo in the uterus was in parallel to the
anterior-posterior axis of the mother. The germinal vesicle disappeared, and then only one
pronucleus appeared at the lagging side-pole of the embryo (Fig. 5A, B). At this stage a protruded polar body-like structure was
observed adjacent to the pronucleus (Fig. 5B).
Pseudocleavage furrow and cytoplasmic streaming were observed (Fig. 5C), the pronucleus moved towards the middle of the cell (Fig. 5D) and its membrane broke down (Fig. 5E, F). Subsequently the embryo divided to form
the two-cell stage (Fig. 5G, H) and the four-cell
stage (Fig. 5I). All embryos
(n = 7) observed in these experiments developed to first-stage larvae and
hatched successfully (not shown), suggesting that the process observed was normal
development.
Fig. 5.
Early embryogenesis in a live S. venezuelensis parasitic female.
The leading edge of the embryo is arranged to be upper right. (A) An embryo that has
passed through the oviduct; (B) An embryo under maturation division; (C)
Pseudocleavage with one pronucleus; (D) Nucleus moving to the centre of the cell;
(E) Nucleus dispersed at the centre of the cell; (F, G, H) Cell division to form a
two-cell embryo; (I) Four-cell embryo (Arrow head indicates a polar body, Scale
bar = 10 μm). Time frame of the development is shown in Table
S2.
Early embryogenesis in a live S. venezuelensis parasitic female.
The leading edge of the embryo is arranged to be upper right. (A) An embryo that has
passed through the oviduct; (B) An embryo under maturation division; (C)
Pseudocleavage with one pronucleus; (D) Nucleus moving to the centre of the cell;
(E) Nucleus dispersed at the centre of the cell; (F, G, H) Cell division to form a
two-cell embryo; (I) Four-cell embryo (Arrow head indicates a polar body, Scale
bar = 10 μm). Time frame of the development is shown in Table
S2.
Chromosome structure and behaviour during early embryogenesis
To clarify the mechanism by which ploidy is maintained, we observed chromosome structure
and behaviour during early embryogenesis by DAPI staining. Developmental stages of the
fixed and stained embryos were decided by comparison to the living embryos observed above.
After passing through the oviduct into the uterus, the oocyte resumed mitotic cell
division (Fig. 6A). This division always occurred
asymmetrically at the lagging side-pole of the embryo (Fig. 6A) to produce one polar body. Polar bodies stained clearly as blue dots,
but often disappeared as embryogenesis progressed. One pronucleus was reconstructed with
vesicle (Fig. 6B), moved to the centre, and
chromosomes were visible in the prophase stage (Fig.
6C). Chromatids fused and aligned along the metaphase plate (Fig. 6D) and migrated to each pole (Fig. 6E) subsequently forming two-cell stage embryos (Fig. 6F). The cleavage occurred asymmetrically with a bigger
blastomere in the leading pole than the lagging one, which is contrary to the observations
in Caenorhabditis elegans (Wallenfang and Seydoux, 2000) and other Caenorhabditis nematodes (Brauchle
et al.
2009). Most eggs were laid as two-cell stage
embryos. Then, we collected the laid eggs, squashed and stained with DAPI. Four
chromosomes, two longer than the others, were observed in prophase cells in the four-cell
stage embryos (Fig. 6G, H), suggesting that the
karyotype of S. venezuelensis is 2n = 4. We confirmed in
nine eggs, all of which had four chromosomes, and no specimens showed different
compositions of chromosomes.
Fig. 6.
Chromosome behaviour after passing through oviduct into the uterus. The leading
edge of the embryo is arranged to be upper right. (A) Anaphase of maturation
division; (B) A pronucleus reconstructed after maturation division; (C) A pronucleus
moves to the centre and chromosomes are formed; (D) Metaphase of the first embryonic
cell division; (E) Anaphase of the first embryonic cell division; (F) Telophase of
the first embryonic cell division; (G, H) Four cell embryos. Newly laid eggs were
squashed and stained for the observation. (Arrows indicate polar bodies. All scale
bars = 10 μm).
Chromosome behaviour after passing through oviduct into the uterus. The leading
edge of the embryo is arranged to be upper right. (A) Anaphase of maturation
division; (B) A pronucleus reconstructed after maturation division; (C) A pronucleus
moves to the centre and chromosomes are formed; (D) Metaphase of the first embryonic
cell division; (E) Anaphase of the first embryonic cell division; (F) Telophase of
the first embryonic cell division; (G, H) Four cell embryos. Newly laid eggs were
squashed and stained for the observation. (Arrows indicate polar bodies. All scale
bars = 10 μm).
DISCUSSION
Strongyloides spp. are unique among parasitic nematodes in having both
parasitic and free-living stages in their life cycle. Since the parasitic females produce
eggs by parthenogenesis, the free-living stage is the only occasion for them to exchange
genetic materials with other individuals. Eggs that are parthenogenetically produced by the
parasitic females can develop into three morphs: free-living males, free-living females or
iL3. In S. ratti the frequency of free-living development is as high as 60%
(Minato et al.
2008), which suggests frequent exchanges of genetic
materials take place in this species. In this study we observed a much lower frequency of
free-living development in S. venezuelensis than S. ratti.
Furthermore, we did not find any free-living males. This suggests that S.
venezuelensis rarely, or possibly never, exchanges genetic materials with other
individuals in its life cycle. It is still possible, however, that there are unknown
triggers to stimulate the nematode to have more free-living males and enable them to perform
genetic exchanges. This could be an artificial loss of ability due to the stress of
prolonged maintenance in laboratory, though absence of free-living males was reported
previously in a recent field isolate of S. venezuelensis (Hasegawa
et al.
1988). It would be of value to investigate
free-living occurrence rates in other strains or wild isolates to confirm if this is a
general characteristic of the species or the observation in this study is an exceptional
case.We noted that the number of free-living females increased with days after infection,
although it was not clear which parameter was more influential, days post infection (i.e.
ageing of worms and effect of host immunity) or dispersed density of eggs in the faeces. We
also observed a higher number of free-living females in 30 and 25 °C cultures than at 19 °C.
A similar trend for temperature conditions was also observed with other
Strongyloides species (Arizono, 1976; Nwaorgu, 1983; Minato et al.
2008; Sakamoto and Uga, 2013).We observed four chromosomes in S. venezuelensis somatic cells, suggesting
S. venezuelensis has a karyotype of 2n = 4. It is known
that S. ratti has three pairs of chromosomes (2n = 6) and
one of them is a sex chromosome. On the other hand, S. papillosus females
have two pairs of chromosomes (2n = 4). The lengths of the two are
significantly different and the longer one is suggested to be the result of a fusion of a
sex chromosome with one of the autosomes of 2n = 6 (Triantaphyllou and
Moncol, 1977). The number of chromosomes in
S. venezuelensis could also result from such a fusion. However, the
lengths of the two pairs of the four S. venezuelensis chromosomes did not
differ from each other to the extent seen in S. papillosus (Nemetschke
et al. 2010). It would be very
interesting to correlate the evolutionary history of reproduction in
Strongyloides species with their chromosome structures.Nemetschke et al. showed that S. papillosus employs
chromatin diminution to exclude chromosome regions corresponding to the S.
ratti sex chromosome in males (Albertson et al.
1979; Nemetschke et al.
2010). Although S. venezuelensis
has the same number of chromosomes as S. papillosus and chromosome
diminution could generate males in this species, we did not observe such events or any
different chromosome composition in this study. This correlates with the absence of males in
S. venezuelensis, although the basis for the lack of chromatin diminution
is unclear: it could be that we were unable to generate S. venezuelensis
males via this procedure or that males were not observed because S.
venezuelensis is not capable of chromatin diminution.Because embryogenesis occurred without fertilization and the chromosome number in mature
oocytes, which are located proximal to the oviduct, was the same as that of the somatic
cells it is likely the S. venezuelensis reproduces via mitotic
parthenogenesis. Even without sperm stimulation, an embryo of S.
venezuelensis had a polarity and produced the polar body on the lagging pole of the
embryo. This orientation is opposite from C. elegans (Wallenfang and
Seydoux, 2000). Parasitic stages of
Strongyloides species including S. ratti or S.
papillosus have been reported to have only female sex and reproduce by mitotic
parthenogenesis (Zaffagnini, 1973; Triantaphyllou
and Moncol, 1977; Viney, 1994). Our observation is consistent with these reports. In order to
confirm this, molecular studies would be useful by checking the progenies have the same
genotype (clones) or have genetic variations due to cross-overs of sister chromosomes.Our phylogenetic analysis using genes for 18S and D3 of 28S ribosomal RNA showed two
well-supported clusters in Strongyloides species, namely a group including
S. ratti and S. stercoralis and another including
S. papillosus and S. venezuelensis (Fig. 2). This is consistent with the gonad morphologies of these
species, wherein members of the S. papillosus group have spiral morphology,
while those of the S. ratti group have straight morphology (Bartlett, 1995; Little, 1966; Sato et al.
2007). The number of chromosomes observed for
Strongyloides species was also consistent with the phylogeny; karyotypes
known thus far are 2n = 6 for S. ratti and S. stercoralis
and 2n = 4 for S. papillosus and S. venezuelensis. Strongyloides
ratti and S. venezuelensis are both parasites of rodents.
However they are clearly different in terms of rRNA phylogeny, chromosome number and gonad
morphology. Therefore, it is likely that they acquired their ability to parasitize rodents
independently from each other.
Authors: Vicky L Hunt; Isheng J Tsai; Avril Coghlan; Adam J Reid; Nancy Holroyd; Bernardo J Foth; Alan Tracey; James A Cotton; Eleanor J Stanley; Helen Beasley; Hayley M Bennett; Karen Brooks; Bhavana Harsha; Rei Kajitani; Arpita Kulkarni; Dorothee Harbecke; Eiji Nagayasu; Sarah Nichol; Yoshitoshi Ogura; Michael A Quail; Nadine Randle; Dong Xia; Norbert W Brattig; Hanns Soblik; Diogo M Ribeiro; Alejandro Sanchez-Flores; Tetsuya Hayashi; Takehiko Itoh; Dee R Denver; Warwick Grant; Jonathan D Stoltzfus; James B Lok; Haruhiko Murayama; Jonathan Wastling; Adrian Streit; Taisei Kikuchi; Mark Viney; Matthew Berriman Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2016-02-01 Impact factor: 38.330