Fluorescence of 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene dyes Badan and Prodan is quenched by tryptophan in Brij 58 micelles as well as in two cytochrome P450 proteins (CYP102, CYP119) with Badan covalently attached to a cysteine residue. Formation of nonemissive complexes between a dye molecule and tryptophan accounts for about 76% of the fluorescence intensity quenching in micelles, the rest is due to diffusive encounters. In the absence of tryptophan, fluorescence of Badan-labeled cytochromes decays with triexponential kinetics characterized by lifetimes of about 100 ps, 700-800 ps, and 3 ns. Site mutation of a histidine residue in the vicinity of the Badan label by tryptophan results in shortening of all three decay lifetimes. The relative amplitude of the fastest component increases at the expense of the two slower ones. The average quenching rate constants are 4.5 × 10(8) s(-1) (CYP102) and 3.7 × 10(8) s(-1) (CYP119), at 288 K. Cyclic voltammetry of Prodan in MeCN shows a reversible reduction peak at -1.85 V vs NHE that becomes chemically irreversible and shifts positively upon addition of water. A quasireversible reduction at -0.88 V was observed in an aqueous buffer (pH 7.3). The excited-state reduction potential of Prodan (and Badan) is estimated to vary from about +0.6 V (vs NHE) in polar aprotic media (MeCN) to approximately +1.6 V in water. Tryptophan quenching of Badan/Prodan fluorescence in CYPs and Brij 58 micelles is exergonic by ≤0.5 V and involves tryptophan oxidation by excited Badan/Prodan, coupled with a fast reaction between the reduced dye and water. Photoreduction is a new quenching mechanism for 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene dyes that are often used as solvatochromic polarity probes, FRET donors and acceptors, as well as reporters of solvation dynamics.
Fluorescence of 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene dyes Badan and Prodan is quenched by tryptophan in Brij 58 micelles as well as in two cytochrome P450 proteins (CYP102, CYP119) with Badan covalently attached to a cysteine residue. Formation of nonemissive complexes between a dye molecule and tryptophan accounts for about 76% of the fluorescence intensity quenching in micelles, the rest is due to diffusive encounters. In the absence of tryptophan, fluorescence of Badan-labeled cytochromes decays with triexponential kinetics characterized by lifetimes of about 100 ps, 700-800 ps, and 3 ns. Site mutation of a histidine residue in the vicinity of the Badan label by tryptophan results in shortening of all three decay lifetimes. The relative amplitude of the fastest component increases at the expense of the two slower ones. The average quenching rate constants are 4.5 × 10(8) s(-1) (CYP102) and 3.7 × 10(8) s(-1) (CYP119), at 288 K. Cyclic voltammetry of Prodan in MeCN shows a reversible reduction peak at -1.85 V vs NHE that becomes chemically irreversible and shifts positively upon addition of water. A quasireversible reduction at -0.88 V was observed in an aqueous buffer (pH 7.3). The excited-state reduction potential of Prodan (and Badan) is estimated to vary from about +0.6 V (vs NHE) in polar aprotic media (MeCN) to approximately +1.6 V in water. Tryptophan quenching of Badan/Prodan fluorescence in CYPs and Brij 58 micelles is exergonic by ≤0.5 V and involves tryptophan oxidation by excited Badan/Prodan, coupled with a fast reaction between the reduced dye and water. Photoreduction is a new quenching mechanism for 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene dyes that are often used as solvatochromic polarity probes, FRET donors and acceptors, as well as reporters of solvation dynamics.
Fluorescence quenching
of organic dyes appended to proteins occurs
either by energy transfer (FRET) or, less often, by electron transfer
(ET).[1,2] Quenching kinetics provide important information
on substrate binding, conformational changes, intraprotein interactions,
and protein folding, among others.[1−7] FRET rates fall with the sixth power of the donor–acceptor
distance and can be used to map relatively long-range interactions,
from about 1 to 10 nm. On the other hand, the exponential decay of
ET rates with distance[8] allows investigating
shorter-range interactions around 1 nm and below. Given the short
inherent excited-state lifetimes of organic chromophores (typically
2–8 ns), only very fast ET leads to efficient fluorescence
quenching. This usually happens only when the electron donor and acceptor
come into a close contact, for example, by ππ stacking
and/or hydrophobic forces.[3,4,9] Such interactions are then manifested by static fluorescence intensity
quenching whereas fluorescence decay becomes multiexponential, showing
very fast (usually tens of picosecond or less) kinetics component(s)
due to emission from donor–acceptor contact complexes, and
an unquenched decay due to residual free fluorophore.[1,2] The on–off ET fluorescence switching upon emergence of a
close donor–acceptor contact also can be detected by single-molecule
techniques, such as fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, showing
intensity fluctuations that report on protein conformational changes,
folding, or on interaction dynamics, with applications in biomolecular
recognition and molecular diagnostics.[3,4,10,11] Fluorescence ET quenching
in proteins has been studied mainly using oxazine, rhodamine, or Bodipy
dye labels as excited-state electron acceptors (oxidants) and tryptophan
(Trp) indole side chains as electron donors.[3,4,10,11] Fluorescence
of a variety of dyes also can be quenched by ET from a thioamide group
incorporated into the peptide backbone, as has been employed to investigate
protease activity and protein folding.[12] Notably, electronically excited flavodoxine cofactors are quenched
by ET from Trp in photolyases and cryptochromes, which are involved
in DNA photorepair and blue-light sensing by living organisms, respectively.[13−16]We have investigated fluorescence quenching of two 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene
dyes Badan
and Prodan to Trp in two cytochrome P450 mutants and in Brij 58 micelles
(Figures 1 and 2). Fluorescence
of dimethylnaphthalene-based dyes originates from an intramolecular
charge-transfer excited state in which electron density is transferred
from the NMe2 group to the electron-accepting carbonyl
substituent at the naphthalene 6-position.[1,2,17−19] These photophysics are
strongly medium-dependent, presumably due to the molecular dipole
moment increasing upon excitation and specific solvation, including
hydrogen bonding.[2,19] The dyes are frequently used
as probes of polarity and dynamics of the local environment in proteins[1,20,21] as well as micelles and membranes,[1,2,17,18] by measuring stationary and time-resolved fluorescence spectra.[1] The environmental dependence of Badan fluorescence
lifetimes was employed, for example, in a glucose sensor.[22] These utilities prompted the development of
dimethylnaphthalene-based dyes with a broad range of protein labeling
groups, including Badan (thiol-reactive bromine, Figure 1), Acrylodan (cysteine-reactive ethylene), the unnatural amino
acid Aladan for incorporation into peptide chains, Danca, which binds
apomyoglobin in a single orientation through a carbonycyclohexyl group,
and Dansyl, where the 6-propionyl is replaced by a sulfonamide. Prodan
(and its derivatives with long aliphatic chains) are typically used
as noncovalent membrane probes.[1,17]
Figure 1
Prodan and Badan dye
molecules (top) and the Brij 58 detergent
molecule.
Figure 2
Schematic structures and abbreviations
of the investigated Badan-labeled
cytochrome P450 mutants Bacillus megaterium CYP102 (top, also known as P450 BM3 or CYP102(A1)) and Sulfolobus acidocaldarius CYP119 (bottom). Badan
(yellow) is attached to Cys97 and Cys81, respectively. Native residues
Trp96 of CYP102 and His76 of CYP119 (middle panels) are replaced by
His96 and Trp76, respectively, in the swap mutants (right panels).
The heme is shown in red, His in orange, Trp in blue, and Cys and
Badan in yellow. Based on unlabeled protein structures: pdb 2IJ2(27) (CYP102-Trp), pdb 1IO7(28) (CYP119-His), and yet
unpublished structure of CYP102-His. The Badan orientation was chosen
arbitrarily for illustrative purposes.
Prodan and Badan dye
molecules (top) and the Brij 58 detergent
molecule.(Dimethylamino)naphthalene-type
dyes also serve as energy acceptors
from electronically excited tryptophan, *Trp,[1,23] or
as energy donors toward hemes in cytochromes,[24,25] as utilized in FRET experiments. Photoinduced electron transfer,
in contrast, is not a common quenching mechanism of these dyes, although
Badan photoreduction by Trp was proposed to occur in one of the CYP3A4
conformers.[5] An opposite process, photooxidation
of a (dimethylamino)naphthalene by a guanine cation, has been observed
in a protein–DNA complex.[26]Herein, we present compelling evidence for ET quenching of Badan
fluorescence by comparing the behaviors of Badan-labeled cytochrome
P450 mutants (CYP, Figure 2) with and without a Trp residue in the dye vicinity. The
occurrence of photoinduced ET from Trp to electronically excited 2-(dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene
dyes is further supported by electrochemistry and by fluorescence
quenching of Badan and Prodan in Trp-containing micelles. Observation
of an ET quenching mechanism for these dyes highlights an important
constraint for their use as microenvironmental probes, while opening
new avenues for study of ultrafast dynamics associated with short-range
interactions in biological systems.Schematic structures and abbreviations
of the investigated Badan-labeled
cytochrome P450 mutants Bacillus megaterium CYP102 (top, also known as P450 BM3 or CYP102(A1)) and Sulfolobus acidocaldarius CYP119 (bottom). Badan
(yellow) is attached to Cys97 and Cys81, respectively. Native residues
Trp96 of CYP102 and His76 of CYP119 (middle panels) are replaced by
His96 and Trp76, respectively, in the swap mutants (right panels).
The heme is shown in red, His in orange, Trp in blue, and Cys and
Badan in yellow. Based on unlabeled protein structures: pdb 2IJ2(27) (CYP102-Trp), pdb 1IO7(28) (CYP119-His), and yet
unpublished structure of CYP102-His. The Badan orientation was chosen
arbitrarily for illustrative purposes.
Experimental Section
Materials
Badan and Prodan were
obtained from Anaspec
and Invitrogen, respectively, and used without further purification.
Brij 58 and tryptophan were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich.
Protein Expression
The CYP102 (also called P450 BM3
or CYP102(A1)) C62A/C156S/K97C triple mutant has been reported.[29] The His-containing mutant C62A/C156S/K97C/W96H
and CYP119 mutants S81C/H86 and S81C/H76W were prepared by the same
procedure. The plasmid for CYP119 was obtained from Prof. Paul Ortiz
de Montellano (UCSF). All mutations were made using a QuickChange
Site-Directed Mutagenesis kit (Qiagen). All primers were obtained
from Operon. The proteins were expressed with an N-terminal His6 tag in Escherichia coli BL21(DE3)
cells as described previously.[29] All proteins
were purified according to a literature procedure[29] and characterized by ESI mass spectrometry.
Protein Labeling
Approximately a 5-fold molar excess
of Badan was added to a 10 μM solution of protein in 20 mM Tris
buffer (pH 8), and the mixture was shaken in the dark at 4 °C
for 4 h. Excess Badan was removed during concentration in 30 kDa filters,
and the protein was purified on a PD-10 desalting column (GE Healthcare
and Life Sciences). Mass spectrometry indicated that the samples were
labeled to 75–100%. Concentrated protein samples were stored
with dithiothreitol (DTT, to prevent disulfide bond formation) in
25% glycerol solutions at −80 °C. Prior to use, they were
thawed on ice and DTT was removed using a HiTrap desalting column
(GE Healthcare Bio-Science AB, Uppsala) in a 20 mM Tris (pH 8) buffer.
Samples were stored in the dark at 4 °C.
Preparation
of Badan/Tryptophan-Containing Micelle Solutions
Badan (or
Prodan) was added in a 1:2000 ratio to a ∼8 mM
solution of the detergent Brij 58 in 20 mM Tris buffer (pH 8). The
Brij 58 concentration was kept 2 orders of magnitude above the critical
micelle concentration (CMC ∼ 0.08 mM).[30] Trp was dissolved separately in a basic aqueous solution (NaOH,
pH ∼ 12). Aliquots of the Trp solution were added stepwise
to the solution of Badan-containing micelles to achieve desired Trp
concentrations. Samples were mixed by manually shaking directly in
the cuvette, followed by measuring stationary fluorescence spectra
and decay traces. To measure corresponding I0 and τ0 values, the same aliquots of aqueous
NaOH solution not containing Trp were added to the same micelle/dye
stock solution, eliminating thus possible pH and concentration effects
on the quenching measurements. The Trp concentration range examined
in Badan quenching experiments was limited to about 20 mM because
Badan aggregation occurred at higher Trp concentrations due to increased
pH. Aggregation onset was indicated by a fluorescence red shift and
lifetime shortening.
Instrumentation
Fluorescence
Stationary
emission spectra were obtained
on a Fluorolog-3 spectrofluorometer (model FL3-11; HORIBA Jobin Yvon)
equipped with a Xenon-arc lamp. All spectra were collected in 1 nm
steps (2 nm bandwidths were chosen for both the excitation and emission
monochromators). Time-resolved fluorescence decays were measured using
the time-correlated single photon counting technique on an IBH 5000
U SPC instrument equipped with a cooled Hamamatsu R3809U-50 microchannel
plate photomultiplier with 40 ps time resolution and time setting
of 7 or 14 ps per channel. Bandwidths for both the excitation and
emission monochromators were set to 16 nm. To eliminate scattered
light, a 399 nm cutoff filter was used. Samples were excited at 373
nm with an IBH NanoLED-11 diode laser (80 ps fwhm) with a repetition
frequency of 1 MHz. The detected signal was kept below 20 000
counts per second to avoid shortening of the recorded lifetime due
to the pile-up effect. Fluorescence decays were fitted (using the
iterative reconvolution procedure with IBH DAS6 software) to a multiexponential
function (eq 1) convoluted with the experimental
response function IRF (“prompt”), yielding sets of lifetimes
τ and corresponding amplitudes A. The average lifetimes ⟨τ⟩
were calculated according to eq 2.We also report relative lifetime-weighted
amplitudes B that are
proportional to the relative number of photons emitted in a kinetics
component i (eq 3).
Electrochemistry
Cyclic voltammograms were obtained
in MeCN containing 0.1 M Bu4NPF6 as an electrolyte
and in aqueous Britton-Robinson buffer (pH = 7.3, I = 90 mM), using a home-built system for cyclic voltammetry consisting
of a fast rise-time potentiostat, interfaced to a personal computer
via an IEEE-interface card (AdvanTech, model PCL-848) and a data acquisition
card (PCL-818) using 12-bit precision for A/D and D/A conversions.
Electrochemical measurements were performed in a three-electrode electrochemical
cell with a hanging Hg drop working electrode, a platinum mesh auxiliary
electrode and Ag/AgCl/1 M LiCl reference electrode, which was separated
from the test solution by a salt bridge with two frit junctions and
whose potential (−90 mV vs NHE) was calibrated using the Fc+/Fc couple as an internal standard (+0.54 V at a Pt working
electrode vs Ag/AgCl/1 M LiCl; +0.630 V vs NHE[31]). All potentials are reported vs NHE.
Results
Fluorescence
Quenching in Badan-Labeled CYP Mutants
All four investigated
CYPs show a typical Badan fluorescence band
at about 485 nm using excitation at 373 nm (Figure S1, Supporting Information). Fluorescence decay was
investigated at 550 nm, within the red side of the emission band.
(The emission wavelength of 550 nm was chosen to avoid interference
from fast decay components due to medium relaxation instead of population
decay. These relaxation dynamics are currently under investigation
in our laboratories.) Figure 3 shows that fluorescence
decays of CYP102-Trp and CYP119-Trp were faster than in the case of
their His counterparts.
Figure 3
Fluorescence decay of Badan-labeled CYPs. Data
for His and Trp
mutants are shown in red and blue, respectively.
Fluorescence decay of Badan-labeled CYPs. Data
for His and Trp
mutants are shown in red and blue, respectively.Emission decay kinetics were multiexponential for all mutants,
regardless whether Trp or His was present. Fitting to a triple exponential
function yielded kinetics components occurring in the tens-of-picosecond
(τ1), hundreds-of-picosecond (τ2), and nanosecond (τ3) ranges (Table 1). Substituting His by Trp shortened all three lifetimes and
strongly increased the relative amplitude of the fastest process, A1 and B1 indicating
that the excited-state quenching reactions occur in several parallel
pathways with lifetimes ranging from tens of picoseconds to tens of
nanoseconds. The average quenching rate constants ⟨kq⟩ (eq 4) are comparable
for CYP119-Trp and CYP102-Trp (4 × 108 s–1 at 288 K), whereas the quenching rate constant kq,3 (based on the slow kinetics component τ3) is 1.4–1.6 times higher for CYP102-Trp, in accordance
with a shorter Trp–Badan distance (Figure 2). As expected, both quenching rate constants slightly decreased
on decreasing the temperature from 296 to 288 K.
Table 1
Fluorescence
Decay Kinetics of Badan-Labeled
CYP Mutants
lifetimes
(ns)
τ-weighted
amplitudes (%)
amplitudes
(%)
sample
T (K)
τ1a
τ2
τ3
B1
B2
B3
A1
A2
A3
average lifetime (ns)b
⟨kq⟩ (s–1)
kq,3 (s–1)
CYP102-Trp
288
0.02c
0.48
2.24
33
37
30
96
3
1
0.86
4.5 × 108
1.0 × 108
CYP102-His
288
0.13
0.74
2.92
19
46
35
66
28
6
1.40
CYP102-Trp
296
0.02c
0.40
2.13
32
29
39
96
3
1
0.95
5.1 × 108
1.4 × 108
CYP102-His
296
0.09
0.70
3.03
12
36
52
65
26
9
1.85
CYP119-Trp
288
0.05
0.50
2.24
30
40
30
87
11
2
0.90
3.7 × 108
7.3 × 107
CYP119-His
288
0.10
0.69
2.68
17
45
38
68
26
6
1.35
CYP119-Trp
296
0.05
0.53
2.42
31
40
29
88
10
2
0.94
3.8 × 108
8.8 × 107
CYP119-His
296
0.10
0.80
3.07
19
45
35
72
23
5
1.47
The τ1 kinetics
occur at the limit of the experimental time resolution, and the corresponding
lifetime and amplitude values were obtained by IRF deconvolution.
Although this might introduce some absolute error, it did not affect
significantly the relative change between His- and Trp-containing
mutants.
Virtually identical
average lifetime
values were obtained from 4-exponential fits. Accuracy ±50 ps.
Estimated, at the limit of
IRF deconvolution.
The τ1 kinetics
occur at the limit of the experimental time resolution, and the corresponding
lifetime and amplitude values were obtained by IRF deconvolution.
Although this might introduce some absolute error, it did not affect
significantly the relative change between His- and Trp-containing
mutants.Virtually identical
average lifetime
values were obtained from 4-exponential fits. Accuracy ±50 ps.Estimated, at the limit of
IRF deconvolution.
Badan Fluorescence
Quenching in Micelles
Addition of
a large excess of the surfactant Brij 58 to an aqueous Badan solution
(Tris, pH 8) strongly increased Badan solubility and shifted the fluorescence
maximum from 550 to 500 nm (Figure S2, Supporting
Information), indicating that the micellar environment is a
good model for the protein (λem = 485 nm). Prodan
showed very similar behavior. Badan fluorescence decayed single-exponentially,
τ0 = 2.64 ns, whereas Prodan showed a small initial
0.55 ns rise followed by a 3.87 ns decay (all measurements at 550
nm). The lifetime-weighted rise amplitude was less than 10% of the
decay amplitude. The rise component is tentatively attributed to a
dynamic Stokes shift, whereby the fluorescence intensity initially
increases in the red part of the band.[1,2,17,32]Addition of Trp
quenched fluorescence intensity more strongly than the lifetime (Figures 4 and S2, Tables S1 and S2, Supporting
Information). This behavior is characteristic of combined dynamic
and static quenching,[1,2] which is described by Stern–Volmer
(SV) equations (eq 5 and 6).Here, k2 is the
bimolecular rate constant corresponding to dynamic (collisional) quenching
and Ks is the stability constant of a
supposedly nonemissive Trp–Badan (or Trp–Prodan) complex.
(The assumption of an “instantaneous” quenching upon
a close contact between the dye and Trp is supported by the lack of
any observable ultrafast decay kinetics, indicating that the excited-state
lifetime of any such complex is shorter than 50 ps.) Analysis of the
lifetime quenching yielded a k2 value
of 1.74 × 109 M–1 s–1 for Badan and 5.79 × 108 M–1 s–1 for Prodan (based on τdec values
listed in Table S2, Supporting Information). Lifetime quenching kinetics are virtually independent of the emission
wavelength, as was checked for Badan at 500 nm (k2 = 1.90 × 109 M–1 s–1) and Prodan at 490 nm (5.74 × 108 M–1 s–1). Intensity-based SV
plots (Figure 4) yielded (after correction
for dynamic quenching) the bimolecular static quenching constant Ks values of 14.7 and 3.5 M–1 for Badan and Prodan, respectively. The percentage of the total
intensity quenching due to static quenching was estimated as 100Ks/(Ks + k2τ0) ∼76% for Badan
and ∼61% for Prodan. Stationary fluorescence spectra also showed
a very small blue shift upon Trp addition, from 509 to 504 nm, with
an isoemissive point at 484 nm (Figure S3, Supporting
Information). This effect indicates the presence of at least
two slightly different Badan populations in the micelles, the red-absorbing
one being preferentially quenched by Trp.
Figure 4
Fluorescence intensity
(red) and lifetime (blue) Stern–Volmer
plots of Prodan (left) and Badan (right) quenching by tryptophan in
Brij 58 micelles. All lifetime values were measured at 550 nm.
Fluorescence intensity
(red) and lifetime (blue) Stern–Volmer
plots of Prodan (left) and Badan (right) quenching by tryptophan in
Brij 58 micelles. All lifetime values were measured at 550 nm.
Electrochemistry
2-(N,N-Dimethylamino)naphthalene
dyes are known to undergo irreversible
electrochemical oxidation that was studied in detail for Prodan.[33] Herein, we report on its reductive electrochemistry
that is relevant to the fluorescence quenching by Trp. A cyclic voltammogram
(CV) of Prodan in MeCN (Figure 5) showed a
nearly reversible reduction at E1/2 =
−1.85 V vs NHE. (The small prewave is due to adsorption of
the reduced form.) Changing the solvent from MeCN (ε = 35.9)
to a more polar DMSO (ε = 46.5) has only a small effect: the
reduction wave stays reversible and shifts to −1.77 V. No reduction
is observed in much less polar 1,2-dichloroethane (ε = 10.4)
up to −2.2 V. On the other hand, water changes the reduction
mechanism and shifts the potential positively: A small addition of
water (1%) to the solution of Prodan in MeCN made the reduction chemically
irreversible and shifted the cathodic peak potential (Epcat) by +70
mV while two small anodic peaks appeared at −0.25 and −0.48
V, attributable to reoxidation of the decomposition products of reduced
Prodan. CV in MeCN containing 17% H2O showed a chemically
irreversible reduction peak whose Epcat shifted by +280 mV relative
to neat MeCN. The peak shape is consistent with rapid heterogeneous
electron transfer, followed by a fast reaction with H2O
(presumably protonation). The CV in H2O (Britton–Robinson
buffer, pH 7.3) showed a quasireversible peak at −0.88 V (Epan – Epcat = 0.18 V) followed by two chemically irreversible
reduction peaks at −1.24 and −1.40 V. The signal was
very weak due to low Prodan solubility. (Results obtained for Prodan
should be extendable to Badan because both species contain the same
photo- and electroactive group, i.e., 2-(N,N-dimethylamino)-6-propionylnaphthalene (Figure 1). However, Badan electrochemistry was complicated
by the presence of a reducible C–Br bond.)
Figure 5
Cyclic voltammetry of
Prodan at a Hg electrode (v = 0.5 V/s): red, in acetonitrile
(0.1 M Bu4NPF6, 0.40 mM Prodan); green, addition
of 1% H2O (0.40 mM
Prodan); blue, addition of 17% H2O (0.44 mM Prodan). Inset:
in Britton–Robinson buffer (pH = 7.3).
Cyclic voltammetry of
Prodan at a Hg electrode (v = 0.5 V/s): red, in acetonitrile
(0.1 M Bu4NPF6, 0.40 mM Prodan); green, addition
of 1% H2O (0.40 mM
Prodan); blue, addition of 17% H2O (0.44 mM Prodan). Inset:
in Britton–Robinson buffer (pH = 7.3).The excited-state reduction potential of Prodan and Badan
in MeCN
can be estimated as a sum of the ground-state reduction potential
(−1.85 V) and the excited-state energy of 2.5 eV (Eoo, estimated from fluorescence spectra), giving the value
of +0.6 V vs NHE. Generally, the excited-state redox potential will
depend on medium polarity that affects both the ground-state reduction
potential and the excited-state energy. However, these two effects
could partly compensate each other as decreasing medium polarity increases Eoo while shifting the reduction potential negatively.
Both dyes become much stronger excited-state oxidants (ca. +1.6 V)
in the presence of water, as the reduced form is stabilized by a very
rapid reaction with the solvent. The actual value depends on the water
accessibility of the dye molecules.
Discussion
Fluorescence
lifetimes of the two investigated Badan-labeled CYP-Trp
mutants were significantly shorter than those of their His-containing
counterparts, indicating that the emissive singlet excited state of
Badan is quenched by the proximal Trp residue. To study the Badan–Trp
quenching without any possible interfering effects of the protein
environment or the heme cofactor, we also investigated Badan (and
analogous Prodan) fluorescence quenching by Trp in Brij 58 micelles.
Both species concentrate in the micelles, promoting formation of contact
pairs. Indeed, we observed very efficient static quenching attributable
to the formation of nonemissive ππ complexes between the
aromatic Trp-indole groups and Badan (Prodan) inside micelles. These
complexes are moderately stable, with association constants of 14.7
M–1 (3.5 M–1), and their excited-state
lifetimes are much shorter than the instrument time resolution, much
less than 50 ps. Residual dynamic quenching, which accounts for 25−40%
of the total quenching, is attributable to the highly dynamic nature
of the micelles that still allows for diffusive encounters.Quenching of Badan and Prodan fluorescence can occur by either
an energy- or electron-transfer mechanism. Energy transfer can be
ruled out, because the population of *1Trp is energetically
uphill (and *3Trp is slightly uphill and spin-forbidden).
The feasibility of an electron-transfer mechanism, i.e., Trp oxidation
by excited dyes, can be assessed using electrochemical arguments.
Trp is a redox-active amino acid whose indole side chain is oxidized
to the corresponding radical cation at rather positive potentials,
between +1.02 and +1.21 V vs NHE.[34−37] Above, we have estimated the
excited-state reduction potential of Prodan and Badan as +0.6 V in
aprotic media and +1.6 V in water. It follows that electron-transfer
quenching in aprotic media is endergonic by about 0.5 V (taking E°′(Trp/Trp•+) = +1.1 V[35]). In CYPs, Badan is located at the protein surface,
partly exposed to water (Figure 2). In Brij
58 micelles, the dye and Trp molecules likely occur in the regions
between the polyether head groups that are intermixed with water.[38] It is the aqueous solvation that makes the photoreduction
of (dimethylamino)naphthalene dyes by Trp thermodynamically possible
because water changes the dye reduction mechanism and upshifts the
excited-state reduction potential to roughly +1.6 V (the actual value
likely depends on the dye exposure to water). Trp oxidation by electronically
excited Badan (Prodan) in the present systems is thus thermodynamically
favorable by ≤0.5 V and ET is coupled to a very fast reaction
between the solvating water molecules to the reduced dye (presumably
proton transfer).Having established Badan photoreduction by
Trp as the most likely
quenching mechanism, we turn our attention to the fluorescence decay
kinetics of Badan-labeled CYPs. Both CYP102-His and CYP119-His exhibited
multiexponential behavior that probably reflects conformational heterogeneity,
together with medium relaxation dynamics[39] in the Badan vicinity. The longest lifetime measured for the His-containing
mutants (τ3, ∼3 ns) is longer than that observed
in aqueous solutions (1.3–1.4 ns, Prodan)[40] or in Brij micelles (2.64 ns, Table S1, Supporting Information), indicating that the Badan label is
to some extent shielded from the solvent and oriented to disfavor
energy transfer to the heme. The two faster components likely arise
from conformations where Badan is more exposed and/or quenched by
Förster energy transfer to the heme. (Indeed, heme cofactors
are known to quench fluorescence of (dimethylamino)naphthalene dyes,
such as Dansyl.[6]) Crystal structures of
unlabeled CYP102-Trp (pdb 2IJ2) and CYP102-His (to be published) show that the five-membered
part of the Trp96indole ring of CYP102-Trp overlaps perfectly with
the imidazole ring of the His mutant. The distances and orientations
of the heme also are comparable. In both mutants, the Badan-bearing
Cys97 is, on average, 6 Å away from the aromatic side chain (His96
or Trp96). The structure also reveals the presence of various rotamers
that introduces significant variability in positions and orientations
of the Cys97sulfur atom and, hence, of the attached Badan label.
The similarity between the structures of the Trp- and His-containing
mutants supports our conclusion that the fluorescence lifetime decrease
on going from CYP102-His to CYP102-Trp is attributable solely to the
photoinduced ET between excited Badan and Trp. (Presumably, this conclusion
remains valid also for CYP119, where only the structure of the His
mutant is available, pdb 1IO7.) In particular, replacing the His residue proximal
to Badan by Trp caused partial fluorescence quenching, with an average
quenching rate constant of about 4 × 108 M–1 s–1 for both CYP102-Trp and CYP119-Trp (at 288
K). Quenching influences all three fluorescence decay components (Table 1). The most pronounced change was observed for the
shortest, tens-of-picoseconds, component that became much shorter
lived and whose relative amplitude strongly increased. This fastest
quenching process presumably occurs in a protein conformation where
the Trp-indole and Badan make a close contact, resulting in almost
complete quenching. The amplitude increase then reflects a change
in conformational distribution, whereby close Trp–Badan contact
formation is driven by ππ and/or hydrophobic interactions.
Quenching of the longest lifetime τ3 (kq,3 = 1 × 108 and 7 × 107 s–1 for CYP102 and CYP119, respectively) is too
slow for a contact pair. Instead, it probably corresponds to long-range
ET from Trp to the excited Badan label.We conclude that (dimethylamino)naphthalene-based
dyes Badan and
Prodan can behave as photooxidants whose excited-state reduction potentials
vary from about +0.6 V (vs NHE) in polar aprotic media (MeCN) to approximately
+1.6 V in water, where reduction is presumably coupled to proton transfer.
Fluorescence of these (dimethylamino)naphthalene dyes is quenched
by close-lying tryptophan in proteins as well as micelles. Excited-state
ET reactions in Badan-labeled CYPs occur in several kinetics steps
whose lifetimes range from tens of picoseconds to about 10 ns, presumably
depending on protein conformation as well as the relative orientation
of the Badan and indole aromatic groups. The possibility of photoinduced
ET must be considered whenever (dimethylamino)naphthalene dyes are
used as fluorescence protein labels, as this reaction channel can
complicate the interpretation of FRET experiments as well as analyses
of solvation dynamics studied by time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy.
On the other hand, as nanosecond Badan fluorescence quenching kinetics
are expected to be sensitive to structural and conformational factors,
Badan protein labeling could be employed to investigate short-range
(≤10 Å) intraprotein interactions and conformational changes
due to folding or substrate binding.
Authors: Andrea Jesenská; Jan Sýkora; Agnieszka Olzyńska; Jan Brezovský; Zbynek Zdráhal; Jirí Damborský; Martin Hof Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2009-01-21 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Seiji Yamada; Nicole D Bouley Ford; Gretchen E Keller; William C Ford; Harry B Gray; Jay R Winkler Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2013-01-14 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Maraia E Ener; Young-Tae Lee; Jay R Winkler; Harry B Gray; Lionel Cheruzel Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2010-10-14 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Andrea C Vaiana; Hannes Neuweiler; Andreas Schulz; Jürgen Wolfrum; Markus Sauer; Jeremy C Smith Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2003-11-26 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Hazel M Girvan; Harriet E Seward; Helen S Toogood; Myles R Cheesman; David Leys; Andrew W Munro Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2006-10-31 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Katarzyna Rybicka-Jasińska; Eli M Espinoza; John A Clark; James B Derr; Gregory Carlos; Maryann Morales; Mimi Karen Billones; Omar O'Mari; Hans Ågren; Glib V Baryshnikov; Valentine I Vullev Journal: J Phys Chem Lett Date: 2021-10-15 Impact factor: 6.475
Authors: Alexander V Fonin; Sergey A Silonov; Iuliia A Antifeeva; Olga V Stepanenko; Olesya V Stepanenko; Anna S Fefilova; Olga I Povarova; Anastasia A Gavrilova; Irina M Kuznetsova; Konstantin K Turoverov Journal: Int J Mol Sci Date: 2021-10-15 Impact factor: 5.923