Sofiya Alhassan1, Melicia C Whitt-Glover2. 1. Department of Kinesiology, University of Massachusetts Amherst, 110 Totman Building, 30 Eastman Lane, Amherst, MA 01003, USA. Electronic address: alhassan@kin.umass.edu. 2. Gramercy Research Group, 500 West 4th Street, Suite 203, Winston-Salem, NC 27101, USA. Electronic address: mwhittglover@gramercyresearch.com.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To examine protocol fidelity among teachers involved in a six-month cluster-randomized physical activity (PA) intervention. METHODS:In 2011, preschools in Springfield, MA were randomized to short bouts of structured PA (SBS-PA, n=5) or unstructured playtime (UPA, n=5). SBS-PA provided structured PA in the classroom during the first 10 min of gross-motor playtime followed by 20 min of unstructured playtime. UPA consisted of 30 min of unstructured playtime. All teachers (SBS-PA and UPA) received a written study protocol and 1.5h of training. SBS-PA also received videos to use to lead structured PA and 1.5 additional hours of training. Study fidelity and process evaluation were assessed twice weekly via semi-structured questionnaire. RESULTS: Only 56.6% of SBS-PA and 75.2% of UPA free playtimes lasted for 30 min; 86.3% of SBS-PA teachers implemented structured PA during the first 10 min of gross-motor playtime but only 67.2% delivered the intervention as instructed. Only 68.5% of SBS-PA teachers implemented the 20-minute unstructured playtime. SBS-PA teachers reported that time limitations was a major barrier in implementing the designed intervention. Pre-post changes in PA did not differ between groups. CONCLUSION: Limited fidelity to intervention protocol likely impacted study findings. Future studies should focus on strategies to improve adherence among intervention leaders.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To examine protocol fidelity among teachers involved in a six-month cluster-randomized physical activity (PA) intervention. METHODS: In 2011, preschools in Springfield, MA were randomized to short bouts of structured PA (SBS-PA, n=5) or unstructured playtime (UPA, n=5). SBS-PA provided structured PA in the classroom during the first 10 min of gross-motor playtime followed by 20 min of unstructured playtime. UPA consisted of 30 min of unstructured playtime. All teachers (SBS-PA and UPA) received a written study protocol and 1.5h of training. SBS-PA also received videos to use to lead structured PA and 1.5 additional hours of training. Study fidelity and process evaluation were assessed twice weekly via semi-structured questionnaire. RESULTS: Only 56.6% of SBS-PA and 75.2% of UPA free playtimes lasted for 30 min; 86.3% of SBS-PA teachers implemented structured PA during the first 10 min of gross-motor playtime but only 67.2% delivered the intervention as instructed. Only 68.5% of SBS-PA teachers implemented the 20-minute unstructured playtime. SBS-PA teachers reported that time limitations was a major barrier in implementing the designed intervention. Pre-post changes in PA did not differ between groups. CONCLUSION: Limited fidelity to intervention protocol likely impacted study findings. Future studies should focus on strategies to improve adherence among intervention leaders.
Authors: Ruth P Saunders; Karin Pfeiffer; William H Brown; Erin K Howie; Marsha Dowda; Jennifer R O'Neill; Kerry McIver; Russell R Pate Journal: Health Educ Behav Date: 2017-01-04
Authors: Joanne Trigwell; Ciara E McGee; Rebecca C Murphy; Lorna A Porcellato; Michael Ussher; Katy Garnham-Lee; Zoe R Knowles; Lawrence Foweather Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2015-04-10 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Sally E Barber; Cath Jackson; Catherine Hewitt; Hannah R Ainsworth; Hannah Buckley; Shaheen Akhtar; Daniel D Bingham; Ash C Routen; Carolyn Summerbell; Gerry Richardson; Helen J Moore; Kate E Pickett; Claire O'Malley; Shirley Brierley; John Wright Journal: Pilot Feasibility Stud Date: 2016-02-18