A Kishore, R Kathariya1, V Deshmukh, S Vaze, N Khalia, R Dandgaval. 1. Department of Periodontology and Oral Implantology, Dr. D.Y Patil Dental College & Hospital, Dr. D.Y Patil Vidyapeeth (Deemed University), Pune-411018, India; Tel: +918983370741; e-mail: rkathariya@gmail.com.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although clinical melanin pigmentation does not present itself as a medical problem or a disease entity, "black gums" is a major esthetic complaint for many people, who often requests cosmetic corrections. Gingival depigmentation can be carried out using many procedures; lasers of various types being a new addition. This study was undertaken to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of CO2 and Er:YAG lasers for the treatment of gingival melanin hyper pigmentation. MATERIALS & METHODS: Twenty young age and gender matched subjects were selected for a randomized split mouth depigmentation procedure using Er:YAG (Group A) and CO2 laser (Group B). Parameters evaluated were: Dummet index, Hedin melanin Index, Gingival and Plaque Index, time taken for the procedure, bleeding during the procedure, VAS scale for pain perception and wound healing and patient preference for the procedure. Wilcoxon signed rank test, Chi-square test, paired t test were used to analyze statistical significance between different variables. RESULTS: CO2 laser treatment caused increased pain and delayed wound healing when compared to Er:YAG laser treatment. CONCLUSION: Although both treatment modalities are highly effective depigmentation procedures, giving excellent esthetics results; when pain, wound healing and patient preferences were considered Er:YAG outscored CO2 Laser. SUMMARY: The effectiveness of the Er:YAG and CO2 laser for the treatment of gingival melanin depigmentation was evaluated clinically and histologically, although both treatment modalities are highly effective, giving excellent esthetics results, however, when pain and wound healing were considered Er:YAG was better than CO2 laser.
BACKGROUND: Although clinical melanin pigmentation does not present itself as a medical problem or a disease entity, "black gums" is a major esthetic complaint for many people, who often requests cosmetic corrections. Gingival depigmentation can be carried out using many procedures; lasers of various types being a new addition. This study was undertaken to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of CO2 and Er:YAG lasers for the treatment of gingival melanin hyper pigmentation. MATERIALS & METHODS: Twenty young age and gender matched subjects were selected for a randomized split mouth depigmentation procedure using Er:YAG (Group A) and CO2 laser (Group B). Parameters evaluated were: Dummet index, Hedin melanin Index, Gingival and Plaque Index, time taken for the procedure, bleeding during the procedure, VAS scale for pain perception and wound healing and patient preference for the procedure. Wilcoxon signed rank test, Chi-square test, paired t test were used to analyze statistical significance between different variables. RESULTS:CO2 laser treatment caused increased pain and delayed wound healing when compared to Er:YAG laser treatment. CONCLUSION: Although both treatment modalities are highly effective depigmentation procedures, giving excellent esthetics results; when pain, wound healing and patient preferences were considered Er:YAG outscored CO2 Laser. SUMMARY: The effectiveness of the Er:YAG and CO2 laser for the treatment of gingival melanin depigmentation was evaluated clinically and histologically, although both treatment modalities are highly effective, giving excellent esthetics results, however, when pain and wound healing were considered Er:YAG was better than CO2 laser.