Jessica K Holzer1, Lauren Ellis, Maria W Merritt. 1. From the *Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, Yale University, New Haven, CT; and †Department of Health Policy and Management, ‡Berman Institute of Bioethics, and §Department of International Health, Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The medical research enterprise depends on public recognition of its societal value. In light of evidence indicating public mistrust, especially among minorities, inadequate enrollment as well as diversity of research participants, and poor uptake of findings, medical research seems to fall short of sufficient public regard. Community engagement in medical research, with special attention to minority communities, may help to remedy this shortfall by demonstrating respect for the communities in practical ways. APPROACH: We provided 3 case examples that illustrate how specific approaches to community-engaged research can build trust between researchers and communities, encourage participation among underrepresented groups, and enhance the relevance as well as the uptake of research findings. DISCUSSION: A common attribute of the specific approaches discussed here is that they enable the researchers to demonstrate respect by recognizing community values and interests. The demonstration of respect for the communities has intrinsic ethical importance. CONCLUSIONS: The 2 potential outgrowths of demonstrating respect specifically through community engagement are (1) the production of research that is more relevant to the community and (2) the mitigation of asymmetry in the researcher-community relationship. We summarized practical resources available to researchers who seek to incorporate community engagement in their research.
BACKGROUND: The medical research enterprise depends on public recognition of its societal value. In light of evidence indicating public mistrust, especially among minorities, inadequate enrollment as well as diversity of research participants, and poor uptake of findings, medical research seems to fall short of sufficient public regard. Community engagement in medical research, with special attention to minority communities, may help to remedy this shortfall by demonstrating respect for the communities in practical ways. APPROACH: We provided 3 case examples that illustrate how specific approaches to community-engaged research can build trust between researchers and communities, encourage participation among underrepresented groups, and enhance the relevance as well as the uptake of research findings. DISCUSSION: A common attribute of the specific approaches discussed here is that they enable the researchers to demonstrate respect by recognizing community values and interests. The demonstration of respect for the communities has intrinsic ethical importance. CONCLUSIONS: The 2 potential outgrowths of demonstrating respect specifically through community engagement are (1) the production of research that is more relevant to the community and (2) the mitigation of asymmetry in the researcher-community relationship. We summarized practical resources available to researchers who seek to incorporate community engagement in their research.
Authors: Margaret Cargo; Lucie Lévesque; Ann C Macaulay; Alex McComber; Serge Desrosiers; Treena Delormier; Louise Potvin Journal: Health Promot Int Date: 2003-09 Impact factor: 2.483
Authors: Gina Moreno-John; Anthony Gachie; Candace M Fleming; Anna Nápoles-Springer; Elizabeth Mutran; Spero M Manson; Eliseo J Pérez-Stable Journal: J Aging Health Date: 2004-11
Authors: Linda K Larkey; Lisa K Staten; Cheryl Ritenbaugh; Renée A Hall; David B Buller; Tamsen Bassford; Barbara Rempfer Altimari Journal: Control Clin Trials Date: 2002-06
Authors: Nancy S Sung; William F Crowley; Myron Genel; Patricia Salber; Lewis Sandy; Louis M Sherwood; Stephen B Johnson; Veronica Catanese; Hugh Tilson; Kenneth Getz; Elaine L Larson; David Scheinberg; E Albert Reece; Harold Slavkin; Adrian Dobs; Jack Grebb; Rick A Martinez; Allan Korn; David Rimoin Journal: JAMA Date: 2003-03-12 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Jennifer Cunningham-Erves; Jason Deakings; Tilicia Mayo-Gamble; Kendria Kelly-Taylor; Stephania T Miller Journal: Psychol Health Med Date: 2019-01-10 Impact factor: 2.423
Authors: Cynthia D Morrow; Blaine P Reeder; Marcelo Coca Perraillon; Mustafa Ozkaynak; Heidi L Wald; Leslie E Eber; Joanna I Trojanowski; Catherine Battaglia; Rebecca S Boxer Journal: AMIA Annu Symp Proc Date: 2021-01-25
Authors: Lindsay P Zimmerman; Satyender Goel; Shazia Sathar; Charon E Gladfelter; Alejandra Onate; Lindsey L Kane; Shelly Sital; Jasmin Phua; Paris Davis; Helen Margellos-Anast; David O Meltzer; Tamar S Polonsky; Raj C Shah; William E Trick; Faraz S Ahmad; Abel N Kho Journal: Appl Clin Inform Date: 2018-02-14 Impact factor: 2.342
Authors: Jennifer Cunningham-Erves; Yvonne Joosten; Charrise P Hollingsworth; Joshua D Cockroft; Velma M Murry; Lexie Lipham; Patrick Luther; Yolanda Vaughn; Stephania T Miller Journal: Prog Community Health Partnersh Date: 2020
Authors: Nabila El-Bassel; Louisa Gilbert; Tim Hunt; Elwin Wu; Emmanuel A Oga; Trena I Mukherjee; Aimee N C Campbell; Nasim Sabounchi; Damara Gutnick; Robin Kerner; Kamilla L Venner; David Lounsbury; Terry T K Huang; Bruce Rapkin Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2021-03-18 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: Wilberforce Tumwesige; Phionah Namatovu; Ozge Sensoy Bahar; William Byansi; Mary M McKay; Fred M Ssewamala Journal: Pediatr Med Date: 2021-02-28