| Literature DB >> 24935221 |
Minal R Patel1, Lara J Thomas, Kausar Hafeez, Matthew Shankin, Margaret Wilkin, Randall W Brown.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Massive resources are expended every year on cross-cultural communication training for physicians. Such training is a focus of continuing medical education nationwide and is part of the curriculum of virtually every medical school in America. There is a pressing need for evidence regarding the effects on patients of cross-cultural communication training for physicians. There is a need to understand the added benefit of such training compared to more general communication. We know of no rigorous study that has assessed whether cross-cultural communication training for physicians results in better health outcomes for their patients. The current study aims to answer this question by enhancing the Physician Asthma Care Education (PACE) program to cross cultural communication (PACE Plus), and comparing the effect of the enhanced program to PACE on the health outcomes of African American and Latino/Hispanic children with asthma. METHODS/Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24935221 PMCID: PMC4070340 DOI: 10.1186/1472-6920-14-118
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Med Educ ISSN: 1472-6920 Impact factor: 2.463
Inclusion criteria for participation in current RCT
| 1. Licensed physician in practice - board certified pediatrics/family medicine | 1. Treated by the participating physician during the study intake period | 1. Has primary responsibility for the child’s care |
| 2. Treating children with asthma | 2. Age 1–16 years | 2. Self-identified as African American or Hispanic/Latino |
| 3. Full-time (>25 hrs.) in a practice in GA, MI or NY | 3. Diagnosis of asthma by a physician using NAEPP Guidelines (alternative descriptions such as reactive airway disease, bronchitis, or wheezy bronchitis were not accepted) | 3. Has access to a telephone |
| 4. Not Hispanic/Latino or African American in ethnicity/race (this allowed us to test the PACE Plus components that addressed cross cultural communication) | 4. Has persistent asthma as defined by NAEPP classification for asthma severity | 4. Consents to participate |
| 5. Consented to participate | 5. Does not have other chronic disorders that cause pulmonary complications, e.g. sickle cell disease | |
| 6. Willing to generate a roster of pediatric African American and Hispanic/Latino asthma patients | 6. Self-identify as African American or Hispanic/Latino |
Comparison of physician interventions
| Seminar comprises 2 face-to-face group meetings lasting 2 ½ hrs. each, held over a 2-week period. Format is a combination of mini lecture, video, case studies, & discussion. | Original PACE delivery format with integrated cultural competence skills and components. | |
| Includes an asthma specialist, behavioral science expert, and a primary care physician. | Includes an asthma specialist, behavioral science expert skilled in cross-cultural communication, and a primary care physician. | |
| Trends of asthma in primary care practice | ||
| Components of good asthma control based on NAEPP Guidelines | ||
| Written instructions & asthma action plans | ||
| Review of long-term treatment plan | ||
| Asthma medications | ||
| Cases of asthma diagnosis | ||
| Theoretical background | ||
| Evidence on asthma medication adherence and from efficacy trial of PACE | ||
| Video of communication strategies + discussion | ||
| Introduction of 10 communications strategies | ||
| Use of self-rating scale and communications strategies with patients between intervention sessions + reflection with group | ||
| Video of patient education and presentation of core asthma messages and discussion | Additional discussion questions concerning diverse patient groups specifically African American and Hispanic/Latino pediatric patients and families responding differently to messages | |
| Asthma treatment cases + discussion | Review of case studies highlighting perceptions of treating asthma among patients of African American and Hispanic/Latino race/ethnicity | |
| Billing and coding asthma visits | ||
| -review of billing and coding practices for asthma education and counseling via mini-lecture and video. Segment is especially enhanced when facilitated by a billing and coding expert | Review of concerns of African American and Hispanic/Latino patients | |
| Review of cross cultural communication strategies | ||
| Video highlights cultural issues | ||
| Emphasis on communication barrier being more evident with patients of a different race/ethnicity & means to reduce barriers | ||