Literature DB >> 24932076

Improving the reliability of clinical practice guideline appraisals: effects of the Korean AGREE II scoring guide.

Moo-Kyung Oh1, Heuisug Jo2, You Kyoung Lee3.   

Abstract

The Korean translated Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (Korean AGREE II) instrument was distributed into Korean medical societies in 2011. However, inter-rater disagreement issues still exist. The Korean AGREE II scoring guide was therefore developed to reduce inter-rater differences. This study examines the effects of the Korean AGREE II scoring guide to reduce inter-rater differences. Appraisers were randomly assigned to two groups (Scoring Guide group and Non-Scoring Guide group). The Korean AGREE II instrument was provided to both groups. However, the scoring guide was offered to Scoring Guide group only. Total 14 appraisers were participated and each guideline was assessed by 8 appraisers. To evaluate the reliability of the Korean AGREE II scoring guide, correlation of scores among appraisers and domain-specific intra-class correlation (ICC) were compared. Most scores of two groups were comparable. Scoring Guide group showed higher reliability at all guidelines. They showed higher correlation among appraisers and higher ICC values at almost all domains. The scoring guide reduces the inter-rater disagreement and improves the overall reliability of the Korean-AGREE II instrument.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Clinical Practice Guideline; Observer Variation; Reproducibility of Results

Mesh：

Year:  2014        PMID： 24932076      PMCID： PMC4055808          DOI： 10.3346/jkms.2014.29.6.771

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Korean Med Sci        ISSN： 1011-8934            Impact factor:   2.153


  21 in total

1.  Development and validation of an international appraisal instrument for assessing the quality of clinical practice guidelines: the AGREE project.

Authors: 
Journal:  Qual Saf Health Care       Date:  2003-02

Review 2.  Effectiveness and efficiency of guideline dissemination and implementation strategies.

Authors:  J M Grimshaw; R E Thomas; G MacLennan; C Fraser; C R Ramsay; L Vale; P Whitty; M P Eccles; L Matowe; L Shirran; M Wensing; R Dijkstra; C Donaldson
Journal:  Health Technol Assess       Date:  2004-02       Impact factor: 4.014

3.  Do guidelines for the diagnosis and monitoring of diabetes mellitus fulfill the criteria of evidence-based guideline development?

Authors:  Eva Nagy; Joseph Watine; Peter S Bunting; Rita Onody; Wytze P Oosterhuis; Dunja Rogic; Sverre Sandberg; Krisztina Boda; Andrea R Horvath
Journal:  Clin Chem       Date:  2008-09-04       Impact factor: 8.327

4.  Diagnosis of pheochromocytoma: a clinical practice guideline appraisal using AGREE II instrument.

Authors:  Juping Yan; Jie Min; Bo Zhou
Journal:  J Eval Clin Pract       Date:  2012-07-18       Impact factor: 2.431

Review 5.  New Canadian physical activity guidelines.

Authors:  Mark S Tremblay; Darren E R Warburton; Ian Janssen; Donald H Paterson; Amy E Latimer; Ryan E Rhodes; Michelle E Kho; Audrey Hicks; Allana G Leblanc; Lori Zehr; Kelly Murumets; Mary Duggan
Journal:  Appl Physiol Nutr Metab       Date:  2011-02       Impact factor: 2.665

Review 6.  Guidelines in cardiac clinical practice: evaluation of their methodological quality using the AGREE II instrument.

Authors:  Sanjeeve Sabharwal; Vanash Patel; Sukhjinder S Nijjer; Ali Kirresh; Ara Darzi; John C Chambers; Iqbal Malik; Jaspal S Kooner; Thanos Athanasiou
Journal:  J R Soc Med       Date:  2013-05-28       Impact factor: 5.344

7.  Development and implementation of clinical practice guidelines: current status in Korea.

Authors:  Hyeong Sik Ahn; Hyun Jung Kim
Journal:  J Korean Med Sci       Date:  2012-05-18       Impact factor: 2.153

8.  Guidelines for guidelines: are they up to the task? A comparative assessment of clinical practice guideline development handbooks.

Authors:  Shabnam Ansari; Arash Rashidian
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2012-11-26       Impact factor: 3.240

9.  An interdisciplinary guideline development process: the Clinic on Low-back pain in Interdisciplinary Practice (CLIP) low-back pain guidelines.

Authors:  Michel Rossignol; Stéphane Poitras; Clermont Dionne; Michel Tousignant; Manon Truchon; Bertrand Arsenault; Pierre Allard; Manon Coté; Alain Neveu
Journal:  Implement Sci       Date:  2007-11-24       Impact factor: 7.327

10.  Reliability and validity of the AGREE instrument used by physical therapists in assessment of clinical practice guidelines.

Authors:  Joy C MacDermid; Dina Brooks; Sherra Solway; Sharon Switzer-McIntyre; Lucie Brosseau; Ian D Graham
Journal:  BMC Health Serv Res       Date:  2005-03-02       Impact factor: 2.655
View more
  11 in total

Review 1.  Development of Quality Management Systems for Clinical Practice Guidelines in Korea.

Authors:  Heui-Sug Jo; Dong Ik Kim; Sung-Goo Chang; Ein-Soon Shin; Moo-Kyung Oh
Journal:  J Korean Med Sci       Date:  2015-10-16       Impact factor: 2.153

2.  Applying the RE-AIM Framework to Evaluate the Dissemination and Implementation of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Sexually Transmitted Infections.

Authors:  Heon-Jae Jeong; Heui-Sug Jo; Moo-Kyung Oh; Hyung-Won Oh
Journal:  J Korean Med Sci       Date:  2015-06-10       Impact factor: 2.153

3.  National Priority Setting of Clinical Practice Guidelines Development for Chronic Disease Management.

Authors:  Heui-Sug Jo; Dong Ik Kim; Moo-Kyung Oh
Journal:  J Korean Med Sci       Date:  2015-11-30       Impact factor: 2.153

4.  Appraising the methodological quality of the clinical practice guideline for diabetes mellitus using the AGREE II instrument: a methodological evaluation.

Authors:  Mahmoud Radwan; Ali Akbari Sari; Arash Rashidian; Amirhossein Takian; Sanaa Abou-Dagga; Aymen Elsous
Journal:  JRSM Open       Date:  2017-01-01

Review 5.  Korean clinical practice guideline for perioperative red blood cell transfusion from Korean Society of Anesthesiologists.

Authors:  Bon-Nyeo Koo; Min A Kwon; Sang-Hyun Kim; Jong Yeop Kim; Young-Jin Moon; Sun Young Park; Eun-Ho Lee; Min Suk Chae; Sung Uk Choi; Jeong-Hyun Choi; Jin-Young Hwang
Journal:  Korean J Anesthesiol       Date:  2018-12-05

6.  Quality and utilization of the Finnish clinical practice guideline in schizophrenia: evaluation using AGREE II and the vignette approach.

Authors:  Anu Vähäniemi; Maritta Välimäki; Virve Pekurinen; Minna Anttila; Tella Lantta
Journal:  Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat       Date:  2019-05-09       Impact factor: 2.570

7.  Clinical Practice Guideline for Postoperative Rehabilitation in Older Patients With Hip Fractures.

Authors:  Kyunghoon Min; Jaewon Beom; Bo Ryun Kim; Sang Yoon Lee; Goo Joo Lee; Jung Hwan Lee; Seung Yeol Lee; Sun Jae Won; Sangwoo Ahn; Heui Je Bang; Yonghan Cha; Min Cheol Chang; Jung-Yeon Choi; Jong Geol Do; Kyung Hee Do; Jae-Young Han; Il-Young Jang; Youri Jin; Dong Hwan Kim; Du Hwan Kim; In Jong Kim; Myung Chul Kim; Won Kim; Yun Jung Lee; In Seok Lee; In-Sik Lee; JungSoo Lee; Chang-Hyung Lee; Seong Hoon Lim; Donghwi Park; Jung Hyun Park; Myungsook Park; Yongsoon Park; Ju Seok Ryu; Young Jin Song; Seoyon Yang; Hee Seung Yang; Ji Sung Yoo; Jun-Il Yoo; Seung Don Yoo; Kyoung Hyo Choi; Jae-Young Lim
Journal:  Ann Rehabil Med       Date:  2021-06-30

8.  The quality of clinical practice guidelines in traditional medicine in Korea: appraisal using the AGREE II instrument.

Authors:  Tae-Young Choi; Jiae Choi; Ju Ah Lee; Ji Hee Jun; Bongki Park; Myeong Soo Lee
Journal:  Implement Sci       Date:  2015-07-28       Impact factor: 7.327

9.  Methodological Quality Appraisal of 27 Korean Guidelines Using a Scoring Guide Based on the AGREE II Instrument and a Web-based Evaluation.

Authors:  Sung-Goo Chang; Dong-Ik Kim; Ein-Soon Shin; Ji-Eun Jang; Ji-Yun Yeon; Yoon-Seong Lee
Journal:  J Korean Med Sci       Date:  2016-03-24       Impact factor: 2.153

10.  Quality and reporting of clinical guidelines for breast cancer treatment: A systematic review.

Authors:  Marta Maes-Carballo; Luciano Mignini; Manuel Martín-Díaz; Aurora Bueno-Cavanillas; Khalid Saeed Khan
Journal:  Breast       Date:  2020-08-10       Impact factor: 4.380
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.