Beuy Joob1, Viroj Wiwanitkit2. 1. Sanitation Medical Academic Center, Bangkok, Thailand. 2. Hainan Medical University, China ; Faculty of Medicine, University of Nis, Serbia ; Joseph Ayobabalola University, Nigeria.
Sir,The previous report on “2009 pandemic influenza A (H1N1) infection in Saurashtra region, India” by Chudasama et al is very interesting.[1] In that report (n = 274), they concluded that “delayed referral from general practitioner/physician, duration of antiviral treatment, and presence of coexisting condition (especially pregnancy) were responsible for intensive care or mortality in patients of severe influenza A (H1N1) illness.[1]” Of interest, Chudasama et al. have just reported another article in J Family Med Prim Care (n = 511) and came to a similar conclusion.[2] Although, the second study might confirm the finding in the first report, it seems that it might be a kind of self-plagiarism. It should also be noted that Chudasama et al. also studied the same group of subjects (n = 274) and published the report in Lung India, but concluded differently that “pregnancy is found as a significant (P < 0.05) risk factor for severe disease.[3]” It should be questioned on what the exact conclusion should be and whether these publications are salami publications.
Authors: Rajesh K Chudasama; Pramod B Verma; Chikitsa D Amin; Bharat Gohel; Dinkar Savariya; Rakesh Ninama Journal: Indian J Crit Care Med Date: 2010-07
Authors: Rajesh K Chudasama; Umed V Patel; Pramod B Verma; Chikitsa D Amin; Dinkar Savaria; Rakesh Ninama; Nilesh Fichadiya Journal: Lung India Date: 2011-01