Marc Riquet1, Caroline Rivera2, Ciprian Pricopi2, Alex Arame2, Pierre Mordant2, Christophe Foucault2, Antoine Dujon3, Françoise Le Pimpec-Barthes2. 1. Department of General Thoracic Surgery, Georges Pompidou European Hospital, Paris Descartes University, Paris, France marc.riquet@egp.aphp.fr. 2. Department of General Thoracic Surgery, Georges Pompidou European Hospital, Paris Descartes University, Paris, France. 3. Department of General Thoracic Surgery, Cedar Surgical Centre, Bois-Guillaume, France.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Nowadays, early-stage lung cancers are more frequently encountered. Selective lymph node (LN) dissection based on lobe-specific lymphatic pathway has been proposed. Our aim was to study nodal involvement according to tumour location. METHODS: We reviewed 1779 lobectomized patients and analysed their pathological characteristics according to tumour location: Group 1 (G1), right upper lobe; Group 2 (G2), right middle lobe; Group 3 (G3), right lower lobe; Group 4 (G4), left upper division; Group 5 (G5), lingula; Group 6 (G6), left lower lobe. The pN status was recorded for each group to analyse the lymphatic spread of non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) according to tumour location. RESULTS: The numbers and proportions of lobectomies in each group were 613 patients in G1 (59.2%), 64 in G2 (6.4%), 359 in G3 (34.6%), 404 in G4 (54.3%), 54 in G5 (7.3%) and 286 in G6 (38.4%). The rates of pN2 involvement were similar, whatever the group was, even when deciphering single- and multistation diseases. on the right side, single-station N2 disease was mainly found in the superior mediastinum (SM) for G1 (95%), and in the inferior for G3 (90%). On the left side, single-station N2 was mainly found in the SM in G4 (94%), and the inferior in G6 (48%). Whatever the side, in case of two-station involvement, both mediastina were concerned in 40% (in G4) to 81% of the case (in G3). Long-term survival rates were different in skip metastasis, single- and multistation involvement, but not between lobes. CONCLUSIONS: Tumour location is not a predictor of nodal metastasis pattern. In surgical treatment of NSCLC, complete systematic mediastinal LN dissection remains the only acceptable procedure from an oncological point of view.
OBJECTIVES: Nowadays, early-stage lung cancers are more frequently encountered. Selective lymph node (LN) dissection based on lobe-specific lymphatic pathway has been proposed. Our aim was to study nodal involvement according to tumour location. METHODS: We reviewed 1779 lobectomized patients and analysed their pathological characteristics according to tumour location: Group 1 (G1), right upper lobe; Group 2 (G2), right middle lobe; Group 3 (G3), right lower lobe; Group 4 (G4), left upper division; Group 5 (G5), lingula; Group 6 (G6), left lower lobe. The pN status was recorded for each group to analyse the lymphatic spread of non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) according to tumour location. RESULTS: The numbers and proportions of lobectomies in each group were 613 patients in G1 (59.2%), 64 in G2 (6.4%), 359 in G3 (34.6%), 404 in G4 (54.3%), 54 in G5 (7.3%) and 286 in G6 (38.4%). The rates of pN2 involvement were similar, whatever the group was, even when deciphering single- and multistation diseases. on the right side, single-station N2 disease was mainly found in the superior mediastinum (SM) for G1 (95%), and in the inferior for G3 (90%). On the left side, single-station N2 was mainly found in the SM in G4 (94%), and the inferior in G6 (48%). Whatever the side, in case of two-station involvement, both mediastina were concerned in 40% (in G4) to 81% of the case (in G3). Long-term survival rates were different in skip metastasis, single- and multistation involvement, but not between lobes. CONCLUSIONS:Tumour location is not a predictor of nodal metastasis pattern. In surgical treatment of NSCLC, complete systematic mediastinal LN dissection remains the only acceptable procedure from an oncological point of view.
Authors: Stylianos Korasidis; Cecilia Menna; Claudio Andreetti; Giulio Maurizi; Antonio D'Andrilli; Anna Maria Ciccone; Francesco Cassiano; Erino Angelo Rendina; Mohsen Ibrahim Journal: Ann Transl Med Date: 2016-10