| Literature DB >> 24800947 |
C Porta1, C Paglino1, V Grünwald2.
Abstract
Despite offering significant clinical benefits in advanced renal-cell carcinoma (RCC), the effectiveness of targeted therapies eventually declines with the development of resistance. Defining optimal sequences of therapy is therefore the focus of much current research. There is also evidence that treatment 're-challenge' may be an effective strategy in some patients. We review evidence to evaluate whether sunitinib may have value as re-challenge therapy in patients who have progressed on prior targeted therapy with sunitinib and/or an alternative tyrosine kinase inhibitor or mammalian target of rapamycin inhibitor. Re-challenge with sunitinib appears to be of clinical benefit, thus representing a feasible therapeutic option for patients with advanced RCC who are refractory to other treatments and are able to receive further therapy. These observations support hypotheses that resistance to targeted agents is transient and can be at least partially reversed by re-introduction of the same agent after a treatment break. Median progression-free survival durations appear to be shorter and response rates lower on re-challenge than following initial treatment, although a wider interval between treatments appears to increase response to sunitinib re-challenge.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2014 PMID: 24800947 PMCID: PMC4453836 DOI: 10.1038/bjc.2014.214
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Br J Cancer ISSN: 0007-0920 Impact factor: 7.640
Sunitinib re-challenge in a/mRCC: summary of data from retrospective trials and patient case reports
| 23 | Male: 78% Median age: 59 years Clear-cell histology: 100% KPS: 90–100% MSKCC risk group: intermediate=74% | PR rate: 65% Median PFS: 13.7 months | ORR: 22% Median PFS: 7.2 months Median interval before re-challenge: 6.7 months | |
| 13 | Male: 62% Median age: 58 years Clear-cell histology: 92% Papillary histology: 8% ECOG PS: 0 (69%), 1 (31%) MSKCC risk group: intermediate=62% Patients failed sunitinib and mTOR inhibitor | ORR: 69% (CR: 15% PR: 54%) Clinical benefit (CR/PR or SD) rate: 92% Median PFS: 21.0 months | ORR: 15% (PR) Clinical benefit (PR or SD) rate: 92% Median PFS: 6.9 months Median interval before re-challenge: 13 months | |
| 9 | Male: 89% Median age: 59 years Clear-cell histology: 100% | Median PFS: 13.7 months | Clinical benefit (PR or SD) rate: 67% Median PFS: 6.8 months | |
| 2 | Male: 100% 61 years and 69 years Sunitinib discontinued during radiotherapy for new metastases | SD after 6 and 13 months of sunitinib treatment | Ongoing survival after a further 18 and 13 months of treatment | |
| 1 | Female 54 years Clear-cell histology Lung and bone metastases Sequential treatment with suntinib, sorafenib and everolimus | PD after 13 months of treatment | Mixed response: reduction in bone metastases; progression of lung metastases PFS: 4 months |
Abbreviations: CR=complete remission; ECOG PS=Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status; KPS=Karnofsky Performance Scale; MSKCC=Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center; ORR=objective response rate; PD=progressive disease; PFS=progression-free survival; PR=partial response; SD=stable disease.
Figure 1Progression-free survival with sunitinib: initial treatment and re-challenge (from
Single-centre experience with sunitinib re-challenge in 5 patients with a/mRCC
| 1 | M | 63 | Good | Good | Sunitinib | 9.5 | PR | Sorafenib | 7 | SD | Everolimus | 5.5 | SD | Int | Int | Sunitinib | 6 | SD | ||
| 2 | M | 57 | Good | Int | Sunitinib | 11.5 | PR | Everolimus | 4.5 | SD | Int | Int | Sunitinib | 6 | SD | |||||
| 3 | F | 72 | Int | Int | Sunitinib | 8.5 | PR | Sorafenib | 5.5 | SD | Everolimus | 4 | SD | Poor | Poor | Sunitinib | 5 | SD | ||
| 4 | M | 60 | Good | Good | Sunitinib | 18 | PR | Everolimus | 10 | PR | Int | Int | Sunitinib | 8 | SD | |||||
| 5 | M | 59 | Good | Good | Sunitinib | 10 | PR | Everolimus | 7.5 | SD | Good | Int | Sunitinib | 7 | SD |
Abbreviations: a/mRCC=advanced/metastatic renal-cell carcinoma; F=female; Int=intermediate; M=male; MSKCC=Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center; PR=partial response; SD=stable disease.
Shaded cells show sunitinib re-challenge (third- and fourth-line therapy).