Literature DB >> 24688904

Approaches to Recruiting 'Hard-To-Reach' Populations into Re-search: A Review of the Literature.

Abdolreza Shaghaghi1, Raj S Bhopal2, Aziz Sheikh3.   

Abstract

BACKGROUND: 'Hard-to-reach' is a term used to describe those sub-groups of the population that may be difficult to reach or involve in research or public health programmes. Application of a single term to call these sub-sections of populations implies a homogeneity within distinct groups, which does not necessarily exist. Different sampling techniques were introduced so far to recruit hard-to-reach populations. In this article, we have reviewed a range of ap-proaches that have been used to widen participation in studies.
METHODS: We performed a Pubmed and Google search for relevant English language articles using the keywords and phrases: (hard-to-reach AND population* OR sampl*), (hidden AND population* OR sample*) and ("hard to reach" AND population* OR sample*) and a consul-tation of the retrieved articles' bibliographies to extract empirical evidence from publications that discussed or examined the use of sampling techniques to recruit hidden or hard-to-reach populations in health studies.
RESULTS: Reviewing the literature has identified a range of techniques to recruit hard-to-reach populations, including snowball sampling, respondent-driven sampling (RDS), indigenous field worker sampling (IFWS), facility-based sampling (FBS), targeted sampling (TS), time-location (space) sampling (TLS), conventional cluster sampling (CCS) and capture re-capture sampling (CR).
CONCLUSION: The degree of compliance with a study by a certain 'hard-to-reach' group de-pends on the characteristics of that group, recruitment technique used and the subject of inter-est. Irrespective of potential advantages or limitations of the recruitment techniques reviewed, their successful use depends mainly upon our knowledge about specific characteristics of the target populations. Thus in line with attempts to expand the current boundaries of our know-ledge about recruitment techniques in health studies and their applications in varying situa-tions, we should also focus on possibly all contributing factors which may have an impact on participation rate within a defined population group.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Hard-to-reach populations; capture-recapture; hidden populations; respondent driven sampling; time-location sampling; time-space sampling

Year:  2011        PMID: 24688904      PMCID: PMC3963617          DOI: 10.5681/hpp.2011.009

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Health Promot Perspect        ISSN: 2228-6497


  13 in total

Review 1.  The use of capture-recapture techniques in determining the prevalence of type 2 diabetes.

Authors:  G V Gill; A A Ismail; N J Beeching
Journal:  QJM       Date:  2001-07

2.  Using Internet-based surveys to reach hidden populations: case of nonabusive illicit drug users.

Authors:  David F Duncan; John B White; Thomas Nicholson
Journal:  Am J Health Behav       Date:  2003 May-Jun

Review 3.  Review of sampling hard-to-reach and hidden populations for HIV surveillance.

Authors:  Robert Magnani; Keith Sabin; Tobi Saidel; Douglas Heckathorn
Journal:  AIDS       Date:  2005-05       Impact factor: 4.177

4.  Use of time-location sampling for systematic behavioral surveillance of truck drivers in Brazil.

Authors:  Luiz Oscar Cardoso Ferreira; Eniel Sabino de Oliveira; H Fisher Raymond; Sanny Y Chen; Willi McFarland
Journal:  AIDS Behav       Date:  2008-04-05

5.  An empirical comparison of respondent-driven sampling, time location sampling, and snowball sampling for behavioral surveillance in men who have sex with men, Fortaleza, Brazil.

Authors:  Carl Kendall; Ligia R F S Kerr; Rogerio C Gondim; Guilherme L Werneck; Raimunda Hermelinda Maia Macena; Marta Kerr Pontes; Lisa G Johnston; Keith Sabin; Willi McFarland
Journal:  AIDS Behav       Date:  2008-04-04

Review 6.  Sampling hard to reach populations.

Authors:  J Faugier; M Sargeant
Journal:  J Adv Nurs       Date:  1997-10       Impact factor: 3.187

7.  Sampling designs for HIV molecular epidemiology with application to Honduras.

Authors:  Bryan E Shepherd; Anthony J Rossini; Ramon Jeremias Soto; Ivette Lorenzana De Rivera; James I Mullins
Journal:  AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses       Date:  2005-11       Impact factor: 2.205

8.  'Are you on the market?': a capture-recapture enumeration of men who sell sex to men in and around Mombasa, Kenya.

Authors:  Scott Geibel; Elisabeth M van der Elst; Nzioki King'ola; Stanley Luchters; Alun Davies; Esther M Getambu; Norbert Peshu; Susan M Graham; R Scott McClelland; Eduard J Sanders
Journal:  AIDS       Date:  2007-06-19       Impact factor: 4.177

9.  Methods to recruit hard-to-reach groups: comparing two chain referral sampling methods of recruiting injecting drug users across nine studies in Russia and Estonia.

Authors:  Lucy Platt; Martin Wall; Tim Rhodes; Ali Judd; Matthew Hickman; Lisa G Johnston; Adrian Renton; Natalia Bobrova; Anya Sarang
Journal:  J Urban Health       Date:  2006-11       Impact factor: 3.671

10.  Hidden diabetes in the UK: use of capture-recapture methods to estimate total prevalence of diabetes mellitus in an urban population.

Authors:  Geoffrey V Gill; Aziz A Ismail; Nicholas J Beeching; Sarah B J Macfarlane; Mark A Bellis
Journal:  J R Soc Med       Date:  2003-07       Impact factor: 18.000

View more
  80 in total

1.  Remote data collection for public health research in a COVID-19 era: ethical implications, challenges and opportunities.

Authors:  B Hensen; C R S Mackworth-Young; M Simwinga; N Abdelmagid; J Banda; C Mavodza; A M Doyle; C Bonell; H A Weiss
Journal:  Health Policy Plan       Date:  2021-02-07       Impact factor: 3.344

2.  System Failure: Work Organization and Injury Outcomes among Latino Forest Workers.

Authors:  Carl Wilmsen; A Butch de Castro; Diane Bush; Marcy J Harrington
Journal:  J Agromedicine       Date:  2019-02-08       Impact factor: 1.675

3.  Challenges in Recruiting African-Born, US-Based Participants for HIV and Tuberculosis Research.

Authors:  Roxanne Kerani; Masahiro Narita; Lauren Lipira; Meheret Endeshaw; King K Holmes; Matthew R Golden
Journal:  J Immigr Minor Health       Date:  2019-06

4.  Working in the Shadows: Safety and Health in Forestry Services in Southern Oregon.

Authors:  Carl Wilmsen; Diane Bush; Dinorah Barton-Antonio
Journal:  J For       Date:  2015-03-12       Impact factor: 2.047

5.  Preferences of Resettled Refugees on Pictograms Describing Common Symptoms of Illness.

Authors:  Kim Bellamy; Ros Dowse; Remo Ostini; Nataly Martini; Therese Kairuz
Journal:  J Immigr Minor Health       Date:  2020-02

6.  Faith, Family, and Social Networks: Effective Strategies for Recruiting Brazilian Immigrants in Maternal and Child Health Research.

Authors:  Ana Cristina Lindsay; Sherrie F Wallington; Luísa M Rabello; Amanda De Sá Melo Alves; Carlos André Moura Arruda; Thaís C Rocha; Gabriela P De Andrade; Gabriela V B Vianna; Raquel de Souza Mezzavilla; Mariana Gonçalves de Oliveira; Maria Helena Hasselmann; Márcia M T Machado; Mary L Greaney
Journal:  J Racial Ethn Health Disparities       Date:  2020-05-26

7.  Reflections and Challenges of Pregnant and Postpartum Participant Recruitment in the Context of the Opioid Epidemic.

Authors:  Caitlyn D Placek; Jean Marie Place; Jennifer Wies
Journal:  Matern Child Health J       Date:  2021-04-26

Review 8.  Who and what is a "population"? Historical debates, current controversies, and implications for understanding "population health" and rectifying health inequities.

Authors:  Nancy Krieger
Journal:  Milbank Q       Date:  2012-12       Impact factor: 4.911

9.  Reaching "hard to reach" workers: Evaluating approaches to disseminate worker safety information via the Mexican consular network.

Authors:  Michael A Flynn; Donald E Eggerth; Brenna M Keller; Pietra Check
Journal:  J Occup Environ Hyg       Date:  2021-04-21       Impact factor: 2.155

10.  Advancing health equity in cancer care: The lived experiences of poverty and access to lung cancer screening.

Authors:  Ambreen Sayani; Mandana Vahabi; Mary Ann O'Brien; Geoffrey Liu; Stephen Hwang; Peter Selby; Erika Nicholson; Meredith Giuliani; Lawson Eng; Aisha Lofters
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2021-05-06       Impact factor: 3.240

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.