Literature DB >> 24664239

The harm argument against surrogacy revisited: two versions not to forget.

Marcus Agnafors1.   

Abstract

It has been a common claim that surrogacy is morally problematic since it involves harm to the child or the surrogate-the harm argument. Due to a growing body of empirical research, the harm argument has seen a decrease in popularity, as there seems to be little evidence of harmful consequences of surrogacy. In this article, two revised versions of the harm argument are developed. It is argued that the two suggested versions of the harm argument survive the current criticism against the standard harm argument. The first version argues that the child is harmed by being separated from the gestational mother. The second version directs attention to the fact that surrogacy involves great incentives to keep the gestational mother's level of maternal-fetal attachment low, which tend to increase the risk of harm to the child. While neither of the two arguments is conclusive regarding the moral status of surrogacy, both constitute important considerations that are often ignored.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2014        PMID: 24664239     DOI: 10.1007/s11019-014-9557-x

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Med Health Care Philos        ISSN: 1386-7423


  31 in total

1.  The exploitation argument against commercial surrogacy.

Authors:  Stephen Wilkinson
Journal:  Bioethics       Date:  2003-04       Impact factor: 1.898

2.  Care ethics and the global practice of commercial surrogacy.

Authors:  Jennifer A Parks
Journal:  Bioethics       Date:  2010-09       Impact factor: 1.898

3.  Fair trade international surrogacy.

Authors:  Casey Humbyrd
Journal:  Dev World Bioeth       Date:  2009-06-08       Impact factor: 2.294

4.  Surrogacy: review for the UK Health Ministers of current arrangements for payments and regulation.

Authors:  M Brazier; S Golombok; A Campbell
Journal:  Hum Reprod Update       Date:  1997 Nov-Dec       Impact factor: 15.610

5.  India's unregulated surrogacy industry.

Authors:  Priya Shetty
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  2012-11-10       Impact factor: 79.321

6.  The association of prenatal attachment and perinatal factors with pre- and postpartum depression in first-time mothers.

Authors:  T W Goecke; F Voigt; F Faschingbauer; G Spangler; M W Beckmann; A Beetz
Journal:  Arch Gynecol Obstet       Date:  2012-03-22       Impact factor: 2.344

7.  Surrogate motherhood: attachment, attitudes and social support.

Authors:  S Fischer; I Gillman
Journal:  Psychiatry       Date:  1991-02       Impact factor: 2.458

8.  Families created through surrogacy: mother-child relationships and children's psychological adjustment at age 7.

Authors:  Susan Golombok; Jennifer Readings; Lucy Blake; Polly Casey; Alex Marks; Vasanti Jadva
Journal:  Dev Psychol       Date:  2011-09-05

9.  Attitudes toward surrogate motherhood in Canada.

Authors:  V Krishnan
Journal:  Health Care Women Int       Date:  1994 Jul-Aug

10.  Opinions of infertile Turkish women on gamete donation and gestational surrogacy.

Authors:  Baris Baykal; Cem Korkmaz; Seyit Temel Ceyhan; Umit Goktolga; Iskender Baser
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  2008-04       Impact factor: 7.329

View more
  1 in total

1.  Narratives of neoliberalism: 'clinical labour' in context.

Authors:  Bronwyn Parry
Journal:  Med Humanit       Date:  2015-06
  1 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.