Matthew Witek1, Erik S Blomain2, Michael S Magee2, Bo Xiang2, Scott A Waldman2, Adam E Snook3. 1. Department of Radiation Oncology, Kimmel Cancer Center; Jefferson Medical College, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 2. Department of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 3. Department of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Electronic address: adam.snook@jefferson.edu.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Radiation therapy (RT) is thought to produce clinical responses in cancer patients, not only through direct toxicity to cancer cells and supporting tumor stroma cells, but also through activation of immunologic effectors. More recently, RT has potentiated the local and systemic effects of cancer immunotherapy (IT). However, combination regimens that maximize immunologic and clinical efficacy remain undefined. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We evaluated the impact of local RT on adenoviral-mediated vaccination against the colorectal cancer antigen GUCY2C (Ad5-GUCY2C) in a murine subcutaneous tumor model using mouse CT26 colon cancer cells (CT26-GUCY2C). Immune responses were assessed by ELISpot, and clinical responses were assessed by tumor size and incidence. RESULTS: The specific sequence of tumor-directed RT preceding Ad5-GUCY2C IT transformed inactive therapeutic Ad5-GUCY2C vaccination into a curative vaccine. GUCY2C-specific T cell responses were amplified (P<.05), tumor eradication was maximized (P<.01), and tumor volumes were minimized (P<.001) in mice whose tumors were irradiated before, compared with after, Ad5-GUCY2C vaccination. The immunologic and antitumor efficacy of Ad5-GUCY2C was amplified comparably by unfractionated (8 Gy × 1), or biologically equivalent doses of fractionated (3.5 Gy × 3), RT. The antitumor effects of sequential RT and IT (RT-IT) depended on expression of GUCY2C by tumor cells and the adenoviral vaccine vector, and tumor volumes were inversely related to the magnitude of GUCY2C-specific T cell responses. Moreover, mice cured of CT26-GUCY2C tumors by RT-IT showed long-lasting antigen-dependent protection, resisting tumors formed by GUCY2C-expressing 4T1 breast cancer cells inoculated 50 days after CT26 cells. CONCLUSIONS: Optimal sequencing of RT and IT amplifies antigen-specific local and systemic immune responses, revealing novel acute and long-term therapeutic antitumor protection. These observations underscore the importance of modality sequence optimization before the initiation of clinical trials of RT and IT to maximize immune and antitumor responses.
PURPOSE: Radiation therapy (RT) is thought to produce clinical responses in cancerpatients, not only through direct toxicity to cancer cells and supporting tumor stroma cells, but also through activation of immunologic effectors. More recently, RT has potentiated the local and systemic effects of cancer immunotherapy (IT). However, combination regimens that maximize immunologic and clinical efficacy remain undefined. METHODS AND MATERIALS: We evaluated the impact of local RT on adenoviral-mediated vaccination against the colorectal cancer antigen GUCY2C (Ad5-GUCY2C) in a murine subcutaneous tumor model using mouseCT26colon cancer cells (CT26-GUCY2C). Immune responses were assessed by ELISpot, and clinical responses were assessed by tumor size and incidence. RESULTS: The specific sequence of tumor-directed RT preceding Ad5-GUCY2C IT transformed inactive therapeutic Ad5-GUCY2C vaccination into a curative vaccine. GUCY2C-specific T cell responses were amplified (P<.05), tumor eradication was maximized (P<.01), and tumor volumes were minimized (P<.001) in mice whose tumors were irradiated before, compared with after, Ad5-GUCY2C vaccination. The immunologic and antitumor efficacy of Ad5-GUCY2C was amplified comparably by unfractionated (8 Gy × 1), or biologically equivalent doses of fractionated (3.5 Gy × 3), RT. The antitumor effects of sequential RT and IT (RT-IT) depended on expression of GUCY2C by tumor cells and the adenoviral vaccine vector, and tumor volumes were inversely related to the magnitude of GUCY2C-specific T cell responses. Moreover, mice cured of CT26-GUCY2Ctumors by RT-IT showed long-lasting antigen-dependent protection, resisting tumors formed by GUCY2C-expressing 4T1 breast cancer cells inoculated 50 days after CT26 cells. CONCLUSIONS: Optimal sequencing of RT and IT amplifies antigen-specific local and systemic immune responses, revealing novel acute and long-term therapeutic antitumor protection. These observations underscore the importance of modality sequence optimization before the initiation of clinical trials of RT and IT to maximize immune and antitumor responses.
Authors: S L Carrithers; M T Barber; S Biswas; S J Parkinson; P K Park; S D Goldstein; S A Waldman Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 1996-12-10 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Lisa H Butterfield; A Karolina Palucka; Cedrik M Britten; Madhav V Dhodapkar; Leif Håkansson; Sylvia Janetzki; Yutaka Kawakami; Thomas-Oliver Kleen; Peter P Lee; Cristina Maccalli; Holden T Maecker; Vernon C Maino; Michele Maio; Anatoli Malyguine; Giuseppe Masucci; Graham Pawelec; Douglas M Potter; Licia Rivoltini; Lupe G Salazar; Dolores J Schendel; Craig L Slingluff; Wenru Song; David F Stroncek; Hideaki Tahara; Magdalena Thurin; Giorgio Trinchieri; Sjoerd H van Der Burg; Theresa L Whiteside; Jon M Wigginton; Francesco Marincola; Samir Khleif; Bernard A Fox; Mary L Disis Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2011-05-10 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Ruth Birbe; Juan P Palazzo; Rhonda Walters; David Weinberg; Stephanie Schulz; Scott A Waldman Journal: Hum Pathol Date: 2005-02 Impact factor: 3.466
Authors: Scott A Waldman; Terry Hyslop; Stephanie Schulz; Alan Barkun; Karl Nielsen; Janis Haaf; Christine Bonaccorso; Yanyan Li; David S Weinberg Journal: JAMA Date: 2009-02-18 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Inge Verbrugge; Jim Hagekyriakou; Leslie L Sharp; Mara Galli; Alison West; Nicole M McLaughlin; Hélène Duret; Hideo Yagita; Ricky W Johnstone; Mark J Smyth; Nicole M Haynes Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2012-05-08 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Bo Xiang; Trevor R Baybutt; Lisa Berman-Booty; Michael S Magee; Scott A Waldman; Vitali Y Alexeev; Adam E Snook Journal: J Immunol Date: 2017-03-24 Impact factor: 5.422
Authors: Abraham G Lin; Bo Xiang; Dante J Merlino; Trevor R Baybutt; Joya Sahu; Alexander Fridman; Adam E Snook; Vandana Miller Journal: Oncoimmunology Date: 2018-07-26 Impact factor: 8.110
Authors: Daniel K Ebner; Walter Tinganelli; Alexander Helm; Alessandra Bisio; Shigeru Yamada; Tadashi Kamada; Takashi Shimokawa; Marco Durante Journal: Front Immunol Date: 2017-02-06 Impact factor: 7.561
Authors: Adam E Snook; Trevor R Baybutt; Bo Xiang; Tara S Abraham; John C Flickinger; Terry Hyslop; Tingting Zhan; Walter K Kraft; Takami Sato; Scott A Waldman Journal: J Immunother Cancer Date: 2019-04-23 Impact factor: 13.751