OBJECTIVES: To compare between accelerometry (MVPA-A) and self-reported activity (MVPA-SR) in activity-maintenance (Keep Active Minnesota; KAM) and weight loss-maintenance (Keep It Off; KIO) trials. METHODS: Linear regression estimated moderation of study, treatment, or time on MVPA-A and MVPA-SR associations. RESULTS: MVPA-A was similar between studies (KAM 119 minutes, KIO 112 minutes, p = .555), whereas MVPA-SR differed significantly (KAM 350 minutes, KIO 87 minutes, p < .0001). Only study moderated correlation between MVPA-A and MVPA-SR. MVPA-SR better predicted MVPA-A in KIO relative to KAM (p = .023). CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that self-presentation bias may influence validity of self-report in intervention studies with activity as a primary outcome. Researchers should select self-report to assess activity dimensions that objective measures capture poorly.
OBJECTIVES: To compare between accelerometry (MVPA-A) and self-reported activity (MVPA-SR) in activity-maintenance (Keep Active Minnesota; KAM) and weight loss-maintenance (Keep It Off; KIO) trials. METHODS: Linear regression estimated moderation of study, treatment, or time on MVPA-A and MVPA-SR associations. RESULTS: MVPA-A was similar between studies (KAM 119 minutes, KIO 112 minutes, p = .555), whereas MVPA-SR differed significantly (KAM 350 minutes, KIO 87 minutes, p < .0001). Only study moderated correlation between MVPA-A and MVPA-SR. MVPA-SR better predicted MVPA-A in KIO relative to KAM (p = .023). CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest that self-presentation bias may influence validity of self-report in intervention studies with activity as a primary outcome. Researchers should select self-report to assess activity dimensions that objective measures capture poorly.
Authors: Tess J Harris; Christopher G Owen; Christina R Victor; Rika Adams; Ulf Ekelund; Derek G Cook Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2009-07 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Nancy E Sherwood; A Lauren Crain; Brian C Martinson; Marcia G Hayes; Julie D Anderson; Jessica M Clausen; Patrick J O'Connor; Robert W Jeffery Journal: Contemp Clin Trials Date: 2011-03-29 Impact factor: 2.226
Authors: Lisa H Colbert; Charles E Matthews; Thomas C Havighurst; Kyungmann Kim; Dale A Schoeller Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2011-05 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Richard P Troiano; David Berrigan; Kevin W Dodd; Louise C Mâsse; Timothy Tilert; Margaret McDowell Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2008-01 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Meghan M JaKa; Simone A French; Julian Wolfson; Robert W Jeffery; Fabianna Lorencatto; Susan Michie; Rona L Levy; Shelby L Langer; Nancy E Sherwood Journal: Health Educ Behav Date: 2018-09-14
Authors: Catherine A Dufour; María J Marquine; Pariya L Fazeli; Anya Umlauf; Brook L Henry; Zvinka Zlatar; Jessica L Montoya; Ronald J Ellis; Igor Grant; David J Moore Journal: AIDS Behav Date: 2018-05