Literature DB >> 24489990

Lost in translation: animal models and clinical trials in cancer treatment.

Isabella Wy Mak1, Nathan Evaniew1, Michelle Ghert1.   

Abstract

Due to practical and ethical concerns associated with human experimentation, animal models have been essential in cancer research. However, the average rate of successful translation from animal models to clinical cancer trials is less than 8%. Animal models are limited in their ability to mimic the extremely complex process of human carcinogenesis, physiology and progression. Therefore the safety and efficacy identified in animal studies is generally not translated to human trials. Animal models can serve as an important source of in vivo information, but alternative translational approaches have emerged that may eventually replace the link between in vitro studies and clinical applications. This review summarizes the current state of animal model translation to clinical practice, and offers some explanations for the general lack of success in this process. In addition, some alternative strategies to the classic in vivo approach are discussed.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Animal models; cancer; clinical trials; review; translational studies

Year:  2014        PMID: 24489990      PMCID: PMC3902221     

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Am J Transl Res            Impact factor:   4.060


  23 in total

1.  Cytokine storm in a phase 1 trial of the anti-CD28 monoclonal antibody TGN1412.

Authors:  Ganesh Suntharalingam; Meghan R Perry; Stephen Ward; Stephen J Brett; Andrew Castello-Cortes; Michael D Brunner; Nicki Panoskaltsis
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  2006-08-14       Impact factor: 91.245

Review 2.  Translation of research evidence from animals to humans.

Authors:  Daniel G Hackam; Donald A Redelmeier
Journal:  JAMA       Date:  2006-10-11       Impact factor: 56.272

Review 3.  Matrix metalloproteinases as valid clinical targets.

Authors:  Barbara Fingleton
Journal:  Curr Pharm Des       Date:  2007       Impact factor: 3.116

4.  Immunotherapy at large: the road to personalized cancer vaccines.

Authors:  Robert H Vonderheide; Katherine L Nathanson
Journal:  Nat Med       Date:  2013-09       Impact factor: 53.440

Review 5.  Comparison of treatment effects between animal experiments and clinical trials: systematic review.

Authors:  Pablo Perel; Ian Roberts; Emily Sena; Philipa Wheble; Catherine Briscoe; Peter Sandercock; Malcolm Macleod; Luciano E Mignini; Pradeep Jayaram; Khalid S Khan
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2006-12-15

6.  Trial watch: phase III and submission failures: 2007-2010.

Authors:  John Arrowsmith
Journal:  Nat Rev Drug Discov       Date:  2011-02       Impact factor: 84.694

Review 7.  Predictive in vivo animal models and translation to clinical trials.

Authors:  Natalie Cook; Duncan I Jodrell; David A Tuveson
Journal:  Drug Discov Today       Date:  2012-03       Impact factor: 7.851

Review 8.  Trials, tribulations, and trends in tumor modeling in mice.

Authors:  JoAnn C L Schuh
Journal:  Toxicol Pathol       Date:  2004 Mar-Apr       Impact factor: 1.902

9.  Genomic responses in mouse models poorly mimic human inflammatory diseases.

Authors:  Junhee Seok; H Shaw Warren; Alex G Cuenca; Michael N Mindrinos; Henry V Baker; Weihong Xu; Daniel R Richards; Grace P McDonald-Smith; Hong Gao; Laura Hennessy; Celeste C Finnerty; Cecilia M López; Shari Honari; Ernest E Moore; Joseph P Minei; Joseph Cuschieri; Paul E Bankey; Jeffrey L Johnson; Jason Sperry; Avery B Nathens; Timothy R Billiar; Michael A West; Marc G Jeschke; Matthew B Klein; Richard L Gamelli; Nicole S Gibran; Bernard H Brownstein; Carol Miller-Graziano; Steve E Calvano; Philip H Mason; J Perren Cobb; Laurence G Rahme; Stephen F Lowry; Ronald V Maier; Lyle L Moldawer; David N Herndon; Ronald W Davis; Wenzhong Xiao; Ronald G Tompkins
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2013-02-11       Impact factor: 11.205

10.  TGN1412: From Discovery to Disaster.

Authors:  H Attarwala
Journal:  J Young Pharm       Date:  2010-07
View more
  336 in total

1.  Limitations in Translating Animal Studies to Humans in Cardiovascular Disease.

Authors:  Sean Lal; Amy Li; Cristobal Dos Remedios
Journal:  J Cardiovasc Transl Res       Date:  2016-01-15       Impact factor: 4.132

Review 2.  In Vitro Models to Study Human Lung Development, Disease and Homeostasis.

Authors:  Alyssa J Miller; Jason R Spence
Journal:  Physiology (Bethesda)       Date:  2017-05

3.  Pig Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell-Derived Neural Rosettes Parallel Human Differentiation Into Sensory Neural Subtypes.

Authors:  Robin L Webb; Amalia Gallegos-Cárdenas; Colette N Miller; Nicholas J Solomotis; Hong-Xiang Liu; Franklin D West; Steven L Stice
Journal:  Cell Reprogram       Date:  2017-03-07       Impact factor: 1.987

4.  Predictors of Success of Phase II Pediatric Oncology Clinical Trials.

Authors:  Laura Franshaw; Maria Tsoli; Jennifer Byrne; Chelsea Mayoh; Siva Sivarajasingam; Murray Norris; Glenn M Marshall; David S Ziegler
Journal:  Oncologist       Date:  2019-02-26

Review 5.  Transgenerational inheritance of metabolic disease.

Authors:  Rachel Stegemann; David A Buchner
Journal:  Semin Cell Dev Biol       Date:  2015-04-29       Impact factor: 7.727

6.  An in vivo model of functional and vascularized human brain organoids.

Authors:  Abed AlFatah Mansour; J Tiago Gonçalves; Cooper W Bloyd; Hao Li; Sarah Fernandes; Daphne Quang; Stephen Johnston; Sarah L Parylak; Xin Jin; Fred H Gage
Journal:  Nat Biotechnol       Date:  2018-04-16       Impact factor: 54.908

7.  Expansion of patient-derived circulating tumor cells from liquid biopsies using a CTC microfluidic culture device.

Authors:  Bee Luan Khoo; Gianluca Grenci; Ying Bena Lim; Soo Chin Lee; Jongyoon Han; Chwee Teck Lim
Journal:  Nat Protoc       Date:  2017-12-07       Impact factor: 13.491

Review 8.  Drug development for neurodevelopmental disorders: lessons learned from fragile X syndrome.

Authors:  Elizabeth M Berry-Kravis; Lothar Lindemann; Aia E Jønch; George Apostol; Mark F Bear; Randall L Carpenter; Jacqueline N Crawley; Aurore Curie; Vincent Des Portes; Farah Hossain; Fabrizio Gasparini; Baltazar Gomez-Mancilla; David Hessl; Eva Loth; Sebastian H Scharf; Paul P Wang; Florian Von Raison; Randi Hagerman; Will Spooren; Sébastien Jacquemont
Journal:  Nat Rev Drug Discov       Date:  2017-12-08       Impact factor: 84.694

9.  Laboratory mice born to wild mice have natural microbiota and model human immune responses.

Authors:  Jasmin Herz; Brian G Vassallo; Stephan P Rosshart; Ashli Hunter; Morgan K Wall; Jonathan H Badger; John A McCulloch; Dimitrios G Anastasakis; Aishe A Sarshad; Irina Leonardi; Nicholas Collins; Joshua A Blatter; Seong-Ji Han; Samira Tamoutounour; Svetlana Potapova; Mark B Foster St Claire; Wuxing Yuan; Shurjo K Sen; Matthew S Dreier; Benedikt Hild; Markus Hafner; David Wang; Iliyan D Iliev; Yasmine Belkaid; Giorgio Trinchieri; Barbara Rehermann
Journal:  Science       Date:  2019-08-01       Impact factor: 47.728

10.  Mechanically tunable coaxial electrospun models of YAP/TAZ mechanoresponse and IGF-1R activation in osteosarcoma.

Authors:  Eric R Molina; Letitia K Chim; Maria C Salazar; Shail M Mehta; Brian A Menegaz; Salah-Eddine Lamhamedi-Cherradi; Tejus Satish; Sana Mohiuddin; David McCall; Ana Maria Zaske; Branko Cuglievan; Alexander J Lazar; David W Scott; Jane K Grande-Allen; Joseph A Ludwig; Antonios G Mikos
Journal:  Acta Biomater       Date:  2019-09-19       Impact factor: 8.947

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.