Anja Wittkowski1, Philippa L Gardner2, Penny Bunton2, Dawn Edge2. 1. School of Psychological Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, United Kingdom. Electronic address: anja.wittkowski@manchester.ac.uk. 2. School of Psychological Sciences, University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, United Kingdom.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Research suggests that African women experience postnatal depression (PND) at a similar rate to that reported in developed countries. If PND is to be better understood in African populations, its risk factors need to be reliably identified. Studies in the developing world have found that risk factors are often culturally determined. This review aimed at improving our understanding of the culturally determined risk factors of PND within Sub-Saharan Africa by integrating evidence from quantitative and qualitative studies. METHODS: A mixed-method systematic review was employed. Nine quantitative and three qualitative studies were quality assessed, synthesised, and integrated. RESULTS: Quantitative studies indicated that stressful life events, cultural values and the African extended family system have an influential role in women's experience of PND. Qualitative studies described the impact of negative cultural perceptions of others and adhering to cultural traditions and values as contributing to the development and maintenance of PND. LIMITATIONS: The small number of studies is a limitation within the available body of research. Search strategies only included English language articles. CONCLUSIONS: Although some risk factors for postnatal depression were similar to those identified in studies in developed countries, important differences exist; most notably the influence of traditional African value systems, customs and antenatal exposure to extreme societal stress. The findings of this review are especially important for the development of a predictive model for PND within Sub-Saharan Africa and when working with migrant Sub-Saharan African mothers.
BACKGROUND: Research suggests that African women experience postnatal depression (PND) at a similar rate to that reported in developed countries. If PND is to be better understood in African populations, its risk factors need to be reliably identified. Studies in the developing world have found that risk factors are often culturally determined. This review aimed at improving our understanding of the culturally determined risk factors of PND within Sub-Saharan Africa by integrating evidence from quantitative and qualitative studies. METHODS: A mixed-method systematic review was employed. Nine quantitative and three qualitative studies were quality assessed, synthesised, and integrated. RESULTS: Quantitative studies indicated that stressful life events, cultural values and the African extended family system have an influential role in women's experience of PND. Qualitative studies described the impact of negative cultural perceptions of others and adhering to cultural traditions and values as contributing to the development and maintenance of PND. LIMITATIONS: The small number of studies is a limitation within the available body of research. Search strategies only included English language articles. CONCLUSIONS: Although some risk factors for postnatal depression were similar to those identified in studies in developed countries, important differences exist; most notably the influence of traditional African value systems, customs and antenatal exposure to extreme societal stress. The findings of this review are especially important for the development of a predictive model for PND within Sub-Saharan Africa and when working with migrant Sub-Saharan African mothers.
Authors: E E Haroz; M Ritchey; J K Bass; B A Kohrt; J Augustinavicius; L Michalopoulos; M D Burkey; P Bolton Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2016-12-22 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Ozge Sensoy Bahar; William Byansi; Apollo Kivumbi; Phionah Namatovu; Joshua Kiyingi; Fred M Ssewamala; Mary M McKay; Thabani Nyoni Journal: Fam Process Date: 2020-02-06