S Perlman1, D Shashar2, C Hoffmann3, O B Yosef4, R Achiron2, E Katorza2. 1. From the Antenatal Diagnostic Unit (S.P., D.S., R.A., E.K.) Sharoni5@yahoo.com. 2. From the Antenatal Diagnostic Unit (S.P., D.S., R.A., E.K.). 3. Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and Departments of Diagnostic Imaging (C.H.). 4. Pediatric Neurology (O.B.Y.), Chaim Sheba Medical Center, Tel HaShomer, Ramat Gan, Israel. (Affiliated with the Sackler School of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.).
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Accurate measurement of the lateral ventricles is of paramount importance in prenatal diagnosis. Possible conflicting classifications caused by their measurement in different sectional planes by sonography and MR imaging are frequently raised. The objective of our study was to evaluate the agreement between ultrasonography and MR imaging in the measurement of the lateral ventricle diameter in the customary sectional planes for each technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Measurement of both lateral ventricles was performed prospectively in 162 fetuses from 21 to 40 weeks of gestational age referred for evaluation due to increased risk for cerebral pathology. The mean gestational age for evaluation was 32 weeks. The measurements were performed in the customary plane for each technique: axial plane for sonography and coronal plane for MR imaging. RESULTS: The 2 techniques yielded results in substantial agreement by using intraclass correlation and κ coefficient score tests. When we assessed the clinical cutoff of 10 mm, the κ score was 0.94 for the narrower ventricle and 0.84 for the wider ventricle, expressing almost perfect agreement. The Bland-Altman plot did not show any trend regarding the actual width of the ventricle, gestational week, or interval between tests. Findings were independent for fetal position, sex, and indication for examination. CONCLUSIONS: Our study indicates excellent agreement between fetal brain ultrasonography and MR imaging as to the diagnosis of fetal ventriculomegaly in the customarily used sectional planes of each technique.
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Accurate measurement of the lateral ventricles is of paramount importance in prenatal diagnosis. Possible conflicting classifications caused by their measurement in different sectional planes by sonography and MR imaging are frequently raised. The objective of our study was to evaluate the agreement between ultrasonography and MR imaging in the measurement of the lateral ventricle diameter in the customary sectional planes for each technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Measurement of both lateral ventricles was performed prospectively in 162 fetuses from 21 to 40 weeks of gestational age referred for evaluation due to increased risk for cerebral pathology. The mean gestational age for evaluation was 32 weeks. The measurements were performed in the customary plane for each technique: axial plane for sonography and coronal plane for MR imaging. RESULTS: The 2 techniques yielded results in substantial agreement by using intraclass correlation and κ coefficient score tests. When we assessed the clinical cutoff of 10 mm, the κ score was 0.94 for the narrower ventricle and 0.84 for the wider ventricle, expressing almost perfect agreement. The Bland-Altman plot did not show any trend regarding the actual width of the ventricle, gestational week, or interval between tests. Findings were independent for fetal position, sex, and indication for examination. CONCLUSIONS: Our study indicates excellent agreement between fetal brain ultrasonography and MR imaging as to the diagnosis of fetal ventriculomegaly in the customarily used sectional planes of each technique.
Authors: N Girard; A Ozanne; K Chaumoitre; S Sigaudy; C Gire; M Dubuc; G Porcu; C d'Ercole; V Millet; A Potier; D Figarella-Branger; C Raybaud Journal: J Radiol Date: 2003-12