BACKGROUND: Keratoplasty may induce major spherical refractive error related to abnormal corneal radius of curvature (CRC). METHODS: Two hundred and thirty-eight consecutive eyes of 238 patients with clear graft and at least one postoperative Orbscan examination performed after suture removal (average follow-up time, 86 months) were retrospectively analyzed. Anterior lamellar keratoplasties (ALK group, n = 119) and penetrating keratoplasties (PK group, n = 119) were matched for preoperative diagnosis and lens status. RESULTS: The average postoperative, suture-out, Orbscan 3-mm CRC was 7.17 mm with a wide 95 % confidence interval [6.26 mm; 8.37 mm]. It was 7.05 mm in the ALK group and 7.31 mm in the PK group (p < 0.01). In the ALK group, this figure was 7.00 mm for oversized grafts and 7.67 mm for non-oversized grafts (p < 0.001). CRC values were significantly lower for eyes with keratoconus (7.00 mm) or stromal scar after infectious keratitis (7.06 mm) compared with stromal scar after trauma (7.74 mm) or stromal dystrophies (8.17 mm). Values were significantly lower for big-bubble ALKs (6.92 mm) and manual dissection-ALKs (7.14 mm) compared with PKs (7.31 mm) and microkeratome-assisted ALKs (7.45 mm). The average Orbscan 3-mm SimK cylinder, irregularity, and refractive power symmetry index were, respectively, 4.7 D/4.8 D/1.9 D for ALKs and 5.2 D/4.8 D/1.8 D for PKs (p = 0.99). CONCLUSIONS: The CRC is lower after ALK compared with PK, and features important variability. In eyes with ALK, non-oversized grafts result in postoperative CRC close to normal values and corneal diseases associated with stromal thinning and DALK result in lower postoperative CRC.
BACKGROUND: Keratoplasty may induce major spherical refractive error related to abnormal corneal radius of curvature (CRC). METHODS: Two hundred and thirty-eight consecutive eyes of 238 patients with clear graft and at least one postoperative Orbscan examination performed after suture removal (average follow-up time, 86 months) were retrospectively analyzed. Anterior lamellar keratoplasties (ALK group, n = 119) and penetrating keratoplasties (PK group, n = 119) were matched for preoperative diagnosis and lens status. RESULTS: The average postoperative, suture-out, Orbscan 3-mm CRC was 7.17 mm with a wide 95 % confidence interval [6.26 mm; 8.37 mm]. It was 7.05 mm in the ALK group and 7.31 mm in the PK group (p < 0.01). In the ALK group, this figure was 7.00 mm for oversized grafts and 7.67 mm for non-oversized grafts (p < 0.001). CRC values were significantly lower for eyes with keratoconus (7.00 mm) or stromal scar after infectious keratitis (7.06 mm) compared with stromal scar after trauma (7.74 mm) or stromal dystrophies (8.17 mm). Values were significantly lower for big-bubble ALKs (6.92 mm) and manual dissection-ALKs (7.14 mm) compared with PKs (7.31 mm) and microkeratome-assisted ALKs (7.45 mm). The average Orbscan 3-mm SimK cylinder, irregularity, and refractive power symmetry index were, respectively, 4.7 D/4.8 D/1.9 D for ALKs and 5.2 D/4.8 D/1.8 D for PKs (p = 0.99). CONCLUSIONS: The CRC is lower after ALK compared with PK, and features important variability. In eyes with ALK, non-oversized grafts result in postoperative CRC close to normal values and corneal diseases associated with stromal thinning and DALK result in lower postoperative CRC.
Authors: William J Reinhart; David C Musch; Deborah S Jacobs; W Barry Lee; Stephen C Kaufman; Roni M Shtein Journal: Ophthalmology Date: 2011-01 Impact factor: 12.079